Paper |
Data Source |
Time Period |
Total Pop. Group |
Total Pop. |
Pop. Sub-Group |
Pop. Number |
Mean Age (yrs) |
Staging |
p-value |
Treatment |
Survival/Mortality |
Busby et al.5 |
MD Anderson Cancer Center |
1990-2004 |
Non-urothelial UUT Tumors |
16 |
Squamous Cell Carcinoma UUT
Non-Squamous Cell Carcinoma of UUT |
12
4 |
---
--- |
Squamous Cell:
T2 (1 case)
T3 (7 cases)
T4 (4 cases)
All were N1 or Nx and M0 or Mx. All were Grade 2-3. |
--- |
Squamous Cell:
12/12 underwent surgical resection
1/12 underwent neoadjuvant chemo
11/12 underwent adjuvant or salvage chemo |
Squamous Cell:
7/12 passed from disease.
Median survival of 11.3 mos.
One year survival: 50%
All Patients (n=16):
9/16 passed from disease.
Median survival of 11.3 mos.
One year survival: 47% |
Holmang et al.16 |
Swedish Cancer Registry |
1971-1998 |
Malignant ureteral or renal pelvic tumor |
943 |
Squamous Cell Carcinoma (SCC)
vs.
Urothelial Carcinoma (UC) |
65
743 |
68.9 years
69.3 years |
SCC UC
pTa 0% 47%
pT1 2% 10%
pT2 2% 5%
pT3 65% 31%
pT4 29% 6%
pTx 3% 2% |
----
<0.01
0.02
<0.01
<0.01
0.37 |
Nephrouretctomy, Nephrectomy, or Resection: 89%
Post-op chemo 12%
Nephrouretctomy, Nephrectomy, or Resection 84%
Post-op chemo 9% |
SCC UA p-value
Alive 12% 14% 1
Died of Dis 19% 19% -----
Died from
Tumor 69% 67% 0.86
Months of post-op survival:
SCC: Mean 25 months
UC: Mean 40 months
p-value 0.07 |
Li et al.9 |
University of Hong Kong; Queen Mary Hospital |
1970-1985 |
Malignant tumors of the kidney |
144 |
Squamous Cell Carcinoma of the Renal Pelvis |
11 |
60 years |
All had local infiltration and regional lymph node involvement. |
--- |
Nephrectomy or nephrouretectomy: 7
Of surgical intervent:
Adjuvant radiation: 2
Adjuvant chemo and radiation: 1 |
Of patients without further post-surgical interventions: Mean one month survival (2 weeks – 2 mos)
Of those with post-surgical chemo/chemoradiation: Mean 12.5 months (1 week-6 yrs)
10/11 died from recurrent malign |
Korkes et al.15 |
School Med Sciences, Brazil |
1994-2004 |
All UUT Tumors |
33 |
Urothelial Tumors
Squamous Cell Carcinoma |
93.9%
6.1% |
65 ± 16 years |
Squamous Cell: All cases had pT3 pathological stage except one with pT4. |
--- |
All Patients:
Nephroureter-ectomy 65%; radical cystectomy 6%; distal ureterectomy only 16%; only nephrectomy 13%. |
All Patients (No SCC Subgroup):
10% Alive
30% Died to Other Causes
5% Died from Surgical Complicat.
55% Died from Malignancy |
Kinn18 |
Karolinska Hospital, Sweden |
1970-1972
|
Squamous and transitional cell carcinoma |
42 |
Squamous Cell Carcinoma
Transitional Cell Carcinoma |
15
27 |
Median: 69 years
Median: 58 years |
Squamous Cell Differentiation:
Well Diff: 5
Mod Diff: 6
Poor Diff: 4 |
--- |
Nephrectouretecomy
21/27 TCC; 8/15 SCC
Nephrectomy:
3/27 TCC; 4/15 SCC |
Squamous Cell Carcinoma:
1/15 had five year survival
Death 1 yr s/p nephrectomy: 67%
Transitional Cell Carcinoma:
10/18 had five year survival
Death 1 yr s/p nephrectomy: 22% |
Wagle et al.1 |
Roswell Park Memorial Institute, Buffalo, NY |
1942-1966 |
Renal tumors/ Renal pelvic tumor |
334/78 |
Squamous Cell Carcinoma |
12 |
67 years |
Squamous Cell:
Grade III: 3
Grade IV: 9 |
--- |
1/12 were inoperable and no further therapy
3/12 Nephrouretectomy
3/12 Nephrouretectomy
and radiation
3/12 Nephrouretectomy
and chemotherapy
1/12 Nephrouretectomy and chemoradiation |
Squamous Cell Carcinoma:
1 year survival: 33.3
2 and 5 year survival: 8.3
10 year survival: None |
Donnelly et al. |
Medical College of Virginia |
1965-1975 |
Renal pelvic carcinomas |
22 |
Squamous Cell Carcinoma
Transitional Cell Carcinoma |
9
13 |
64 years
|
--- |
--- |
--- |
Squamous Cell Carcinoma:
1/9 Alive after three years
1/9 Alive after two years
Disease specific mortality 77%
TCC:
1/13 at one year
2/13 at two years
1/13 at 4.5 years
1/13 at 7 years.
Disease specific mortality 46% |
The table above displays selected publications with relevant outcome charactersitics, reviewed for this publication. * Nephrouretctomy, Nephrectomy, or Resection. UTT; upper urinary tract. TCC; transitional cell carcinoma; SCC; squamous cell carcinoma