Season Biofertilizertreatment*** 0% RR Inorganic fertilizer treatment** Mean
25% RR 50% RR 100% RR
Relative yield increase (%)*
2008/09 DS BG -1 0 -1 7 1
  BN 2 7 6 6 5
  BS 7 3 -6 8 3
  Control - - - - -
2009 WS BG 3 -1 23 10 9
  BN 13 21 19 20 18
  BS 5 9 12 24 13
  Control - - - - -
2010 WS BG 28 1 9 -3 8
  BN 24 7 20 2 12
  BS 17 2 7 0 6
  Control - - - - -
2010/11 DS BG 9 6 5 6 6
  BN 5 14 12 5 9
  BS 4 10 10 4 7
  Control - - - - -
* The relative yield increase was calculated for treatment means and in comparison to the control without biofertilizer use but within the same inorganic fertilizer treatment;
** RR: Recommended rate: 120-60-60 kg N-P2O5-K2O ha−1 in the DS; 90-30-30 kg N-P2O5-K2O ha−1 in the WS;
*** Biofertilizer treatments are described in detail in the text.
Table 5: Relative yield increase over the Control treatments with the same inorganic fertilizer rate for all biofertilizers tested, in all seasons and at both experimental sites.