Methods

Features and Advantages

Disadvantages

Sodium hydroxide (NaOH)

remove lignin, low temperature and pressure,

inhibitory, long pretreatment time, expensive chemical, complex recovery process

Lime

the least expensive alkali; safe to handle; can be simply recovered

inhibitory, long residence time, neutralization or washing process required

Ammonia fiber expansion (AFEX)

low enzyme requirement, minimized degradation products, high solids loadings

formation of oligomeric form of hemicellulose degradation products

 

Ammonia recycle percolation (ARP)

high efficiency for delignification,

low solids loadings

Hot-water

low cost, less inhibition, low corrosion, less residues, high simplicity

high temperature, particle size reduction required to obtain high yield

Dilute sulfuric acid

high yield

inhibitory, causticity reagent, acid neutralization required

SO2-catalyzed steam explosion

high solids loadings, rapid penetration of biomass

highly toxic, inhibitory

Concentrated acid hydrolysis

high yield

slow rate of conversion, acid recovery systems required

Ionic liquid

effective at solvating cellulose, minimal environmental impact

high cost, induction of cellulase inactivation; effective regeneration; causticity and toxicity of ILs; selection of stable ILs

Lewis acid

lower corrosion to equipment, lower enzyme demands

overall efficiency needs to be improved, the effect of Lewis acid residues on the downstream processing need to be evaluated

Table 1: Simple comparison of different pretreatments.