Method |
Mechanism |
Additional information |
Limitations |
Assays |
Enrichment of differences in Methylation |
Bisulfite conversion |
Converts unmethylated cytosines to uracil (and eventually thymine following PCR amplification), while leaving methylated cytosines unconverted. |
PCR product may be analyzed by direct sequencing or mass spectrometry to quantify cytosine methylation |
-Conversion needs to be complete for accurate results.
-Labor intensive & high cost prohibits genome-wide application. Partially overcome by combining with MS-PCR, microarrays & high-throughput sequencing. |
Pyrosequencing
MassARRAY |
Methylation-Sensitive Restriction Digestion Assays |
Uses restriction enzyme that identifies methylated DNA. |
Often used in initial genome-wide screening |
Limited to the analysis of CpG sites located within the enzyme recognition site |
HELP, McrBC |
Immunoprecipitation-Based Enrichment Assays |
Uses antibodies that recognize methylated CpG to enrich methylated DNA |
In combination with DNA microarrays (ChIP-chip) & massively parallel sequencing (ChIP-Seq), has made genome-wide analysis easier |
Lack of specificity in low CpG-dense regions due to noise |
MeDip |
Analysis of Methylation |
High Throughput Interrogation |
Bead arrays |
Uses two primers each recognizing methylated Vs unmethylated cytosine |
|
Provides less coverage than other array-based methods |
Illumina |
Short oligonucleotide arrays |
Millions of 25-mer probes per chip in a tiling design |
Good specificity |
Decreased sensitivity, noise |
Affymetrix |
Long oligonucleotide arrays |
60-mer probes, can analyze test and control DNA on the same array |
Better balance between sensitivity, specificity and noise |
|
Nimblegen, Agilent |
Massively Parallel sequencing |
Involves direct sequencing of enriched DNA |
-Best-possible resolution and quantitative methylation information (using bisulfite converted DNA)
-Data can be re-analyzed if needed |
|
Fluorescent nucleotide-based system (Illumina), MethylC-seq, SMRT (Pacific Biosciences) |