|
Study
|
ALK+ (N)/Total (N)
|
Efficacy
|
|
Studies with no control or adjustment for confounding factors
|
|
Shaw et al. [15]
|
17 ALK+ /96
never/light smokers, stage IV
|
Median OS:
• 20 months in ALK+a
• 32 months in EGFR mu (p = 0.468 vs.ALK+)
• 16 months in ALK−/EGFR WT (p = 0.152 vs.ALK+)
|
|
Shaw et al. [2]
|
36 ALK+/356
advanced
|
Median OS:
• 20 months in ALK+
• 15 months in ALK−/EGFR WT (p = 0.244 vs.ALK+)
|
|
Takeda et al. [16]
|
18 ALK+/200
advanced non squamous cases
|
Median OS† :
• 15.7 months in ALK+
• 24.8 months in EGFR mu (p = 0.135 vs. ALK+)
• 15.2 months in ALK−/EGFR WT (p = 0.591 vs. ALK+)
|
|
Wang et al. [17]
|
9 ALK+/113
stage IV
|
Median OS:
• 19.27 months in ALK+
• 23.13 months in EGFR mu
• 18.93 months in ALK−/EGFR WT (p = 0.481 vs. ALK+ and EGFR mu)
|
|
Hayashi et al. [18]
|
3 ALK+/37
locally advanced
adeno cases
|
Median OS:
• 7.7 months in ALK+
• 67.5 months in EGFR mu
• 42.6 months in ALK−/EGFR WT (p = 0.007 vs. ALK+)
|
|
Martinez et al. [8]
|
7 ALK+/99
Non squamous ,all stages
|
Median OS:
• not reached in ALK+b
• 15.7 months in EGFR mu
• 4.5 months in ALK−/EGFR WT (p =0.103 vs. ALK+)
|
|
Paik et al. [19]
|
28 ALK+/735
stage I-III
|
Median OS:
• 97.7 months in ALK+
• 78.9 months in ALK− (p = 0.10 vs. ALK+)
|
|
Fukui et al. [20]
|
28 ALK+/720
Adeno resected cases,
all stages
|
5-year OS rate:
• 81% in ALK+
• 77% in ALK− (p = 0.76 vs. ALK+)
|
|
Studies with control or adjustment for confounding factors
|
|
Lee et al. [6]
|
23 ALK+ /262
non-squamous EGFR WT or TKI non-responders,
stage IIIb–IVb
|
Median OS:
• 12.23 months in ALK+
• 29.63 months in EGFR mu (p = 0.001 vs. ALK+)
• 19.33 months in WT/WT (p = 0.127 vs. ALK+)
|
|
Yang et al. [4]
|
22 ALK+/296never-smoker, adenocasesc
9=stage I/II
7=stage III
6=stage IV
|
DFS not reported in either ALK+ or ALK− groups
(2-fold greater risk of progression or recurrence within 5 yrs of diagnosis reported in ALK+ vs.ALK− cases, p=0.004)
|
|
Kim et al. [5]
|
13 ALK+/229
never-smokers, all stagesd |
Median OS:
• 14.3 months in ALK+
• 37.2 months in EGFR mu (p = 0.001 vs. ALK+)
• 33.3 months in ALK−/EGFR WT/KRAS WT (p = 0.016 vs. ALK+)
|
|
Wu et al. [21]
|
39 ALK+/116
adeno cases, stage IVe |
Median OS:
• 14.7 months in ALK+
• 10.3 months in ALK−/EGFR WT (p = 0.011 vs. ALK+)
|