| Resin |
Solution |
Period |
| Inital |
12 hours |
24 hours |
36 hours |
60 hours |
| Adoro |
Saliva |
43.00 (3.13) Aa |
40.06 (4.00) Aab |
37.36 (5.62) Aab |
37.13 (4.62) Aab |
35.82 (4.60) Ab |
| |
Listerine |
43.20 (2.88) Aa |
34.80 (4.34) Ab |
33.39 (4.30) Ab |
32.02 (2.56) Ab |
29.76 (2.30) Ab |
| |
Oral-B |
42.62 (0.91) Aa |
39.03 (4.38) Aab |
36.04 (4.60) Ab |
35.06 (5.07) Ab |
33.65 (5.76) Ab |
| |
Plax |
42.87 (1.54) Aa |
36.63 (3.34) Ab |
33.71 (2.99) Abc |
31.10 (2.42) Abc |
30.14 (1.72) Ac |
| |
Periogard |
42.71 (1.31) Aa |
37.61 (3.73) Aab |
34.88 (2.92) Ab |
34.25 (2.73) Ab |
31.63 (3.28) Ab |
| Resilab |
Saliva |
42.08 (3.57) Aa |
36.60 (5.28) Aab |
35.87 (5.03) Ab |
33.82 (4.23) Ab |
31.08 (3.63) Ab |
| |
Listerine |
42.54 (3.88) Aa |
31.63 (5.36) Ab |
30.53 (4.41) Ab |
28.06 (3.77) Abc |
24.33 (4.31) Bc |
| |
Oral-B |
41.97 (2.25) Aa |
34.04 (3.20) Ab |
33.05 (3.45) Ab |
31.39 (2.95) Ab |
28.43 (4.20) ABb |
| |
Plax |
43.76 (3.84) Aa |
35.07 (4.75) Ab |
33.90 (4.59) Ab |
32.33 (3.80) Ab |
30.00 (3.65) ABb |
| |
Periogard |
42.30 (3.45) Aa |
33.29 (3.52) Ab |
32.52 (3.34) Ab |
31.11 (3.09) Ab |
30.71 (3.34) Ab |
| Cristobol |
Saliva |
48.82 (1.97) Aa |
47.79 (2.21) Aa |
45.89 (1.56) Aab |
43.06 (1.87) Aab |
40.31 (1.01) Ab |
| |
Listerine |
48.16 (2.49) Aa |
41.98 (1.38) Ab |
38.34 (1.32) Bbc |
36.79 (1.17) Bbc |
32.94 (0.91) Bc |
| |
Oral-B |
48.72 (2.29) Aab |
47.00 (2.39) Aa |
41.22 (1.77) ABac |
39.12 (1.19) Abc |
36.35 (1.12) Abc |
| |
Plax |
48.08 (0.92) Aa |
46.93 (0.54) Aab |
45.19 (1.86) Aab |
41.33 (2.96) ABb |
38.95 (2.78)ABbc |
| |
Periogard |
49.18 (3.18) Aa |
44.38 (2.11) Aab |
42.83 (1.93) ABb |
39.89 (3.10) ABb |
37.15 (3.40)ABbc |
| Sinfony |
Saliva |
21.15 (3.79) Aa |
19.66 (6.45) Aab |
17.73 (5.58) Aab |
14.72 (5.10) Ab |
12.95 (4.74) Abc |
| |
Listerine |
19.97 (1.46) Aa |
7.51 (1.87) BCb |
6.71 (1.23) BCb |
6.83 (1.42) Bb |
5.37 (1.06) Bb |
| |
Oral-B |
20.12 (0.75) Aa |
14.76 (0.90) ACab |
14.02 (1.28) ACab |
12.40 (0.88) ABb |
11.37 (0.69) ABb |
| |
Plax |
19.86 (2.14) Aa |
13.73 (4.86) ACb |
13.51 (4.11) ACb |
12.55 (3.89) ABb |
11.25 (3.04) ABb |
| |
Periogard |
20.52 (1.22) Aa |
11.29 (1.57) Cb |
10.56 (1.22) Cb |
10.39 (0.91) ABb |
9.62 (0.48) ABb |
| Epricord |
Saliva |
38.96 (0.82) Aa |
34.95 (1.62) Aa |
34.10 (3.10) Aa |
33.61 (2.53) Aa |
33.25 (2.38) Aa |
| |
Listerine |
40.88 (1.85) Aa |
33.03 (3.02) Ab |
31.43 (2.50) Ab |
30.46 (3.62) Ab |
28.55 (2.13) Ab |
| |
Oral-B |
40.17 (1.83) Aa |
33.65 (1.49) Ab |
30.82 (1.99) Abc |
29.46 (1.84) Abc |
27.27 (1.76) Ac |
| |
Plax |
40.88 (1.89) Aa |
33.45 (2.74) Ab |
30.32 (2.75) Ab |
28.80 (2.67) Ab |
27.84 (3.00) Ab |
| |
Periogard |
40.84 (1.63) Aa |
35.07 (3.44) Aab |
32.35 (2.31) Ab |
30.74 (2.87) Ab |
29.75 (4.22) Ab |
Means followed by the same uppercase letter in the column (comparison of each resin brand) and the same lowercase letter in the line does not differ to 5% level of
significance (P<.05) in Tukey’s test. |
