Author/
year |
Participants/
level, Style |
Method |
Sample size/
duration |
Injury definition |
Outcomes: incidence/prevalence |
Outcomes: Severity (time loss in days) |
Intervention |
Limitation |
In-consistency |
In-directness |
Im-precision |
Publication bias |
Baker et.al.
[45] |
Contemporary students |
Retrospective survey |
57/ Sept 2006-June 2007 |
physical damage to the body or body part which prevented completion of one or more entire curriculum class |
75 injuries on total |
not reported |
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Scialom et.al. [46] |
professional contemporary |
retrospective survey |
30 |
"their most important injury" |
not indicated specifically |
not reported |
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Rietveld
[47] |
dancers and dance teachers>45years, all styles |
Retrospective medical records |
66/April 1993-March 1996 |
medical attention |
total 92 injuries, 1.4 injuries/dancer |
not reported |
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Pearson & Whitaker [48] |
ballet students |
Retrospective survey |
67 |
occurred or was first noticed during ballet practice |
36 dancers (55%) reported a relevant injury |
|
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Solomon et.al. (1995)
[49] |
professional ballet |
Retrospective |
70/1 year |
medical attention |
137 total (male: 58, female: 79) |
101 injuries classified as grade 1: less than a week away; 34 injuries grade 2: one week or more. |
self-insurance against medical costs |
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Solomon et.al.
[50] |
professional ballet |
retrospective |
70/year 1; 60/year 2;60/year 3 |
medical attention |
year 1:137; year 2:128; year 3:88 |
not indicated |
injury audit, in-house medical provision |
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Solomon et.al.
[51] |
professional ballet |
retrospective |
70/year 1; 60/year 2;60/year 3; 60/year 4; 59/year 5 |
medical attention |
year 1: 137; year 2:128; year 3:96; year 4:98; year 5: 101 |
|
injury audit, in-house medical provision |
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Nilsson et.al. [52] |
professional ballet |
retrospective/prospective cohort |
98 dancers/5 years |
medical attention |
0.6/1000hrs |
median full withdrawal 2.3 weeks |
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Pedersen & Wilmerding
[53] |
student and professional flamenco dancers |
retrospective survey |
80 dancers- injury data collected over lifetime of dance |
not explicit but injuries sustained during participation in flamenco |
50 injuries in total (20 to students, 30 to professionals) |
|
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Pedersen & Wilmerding
[53] |
student and professional flamenco dancers |
retrospective survey |
80 dancers- injury data collected over lifetime of dance |
not explicit but injuries sustained during participation in flamenco |
50 injuries in total (20 to students, 30 to professionals) |
|
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Ramel& Moritz
[54] |
professional ballet |
retrospective survey |
128/injury data collected in relation to last 12 months |
From the Nordic Questionnaire, "any trouble (ache, pain, discomfort)" |
121 dancers reported experiencing some trouble, 472 problems reported. |
168 problems prevented dancers doing their daily work. |
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Ramel et.al.
[55] |
professional ballet |
retrospective survey |
51 over 12 months |
From the Nordic Questionnaire, "any trouble (ache, pain, discomfort)" |
443 problems reported in 1995 (compared to 403 to the same 51 dancers in 1989) |
1995:132 injuries causing incapacity in last 12 months; 1989: 161 injuries causing incapacity in last 12 months |
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Evans et.al.
[56] |
professional Broadway dancers and actors |
retrospective survey |
318 over the duration of the Broadway production (166 dancers) |
self-reported |
for 166 dancers: 218 injuries in total |
|
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Quirk
[57] |
student and professional ballet |
retrospective medical records |
664/15 years |
medical attention |
2113 injuries |
|
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
No im-precision |
undetected |
Chmelar et.al.
[58] |
professional and student ballet and modern |
retrospective survey |
39 dancers/ |
taken from the questionnaire: "have you sustained any major injuries that have kept you away from dancing for more than 2 or 3 weeks; do you have any recurrent physical nuisances that interfere with but do not stop your dancing |
46 injuries |
|
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Bowling
[58] |
professional modern and ballet |
retrospective survey |
141 dancers/ 6 months recall |
self-reported injury |
118 dancers had at least one injury |
|
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Bronner& Brownstein
[59] |
professional Broadway dancers |
medical record review |
30 dancers/ 7 weeks |
time loss from performance |
40% injury rate; 1.0injuries/dancer |
82 missed and 35 partial performances |
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |
Nuneset.al.
[60] |
recreational ballet |
questionnaire |
31 dancers (12 non-Pointe, 19 Pointe) |
no explicit- reports painful sites |
mean number of painful sites reported. Non-Pointe: 1.3; Pointe 2.9 |
|
|
serious limitations |
No serious inconsistency |
no serious indirectness detected |
Im-precision |
undetected |