|
Technology |
Rate of Infection |
Rate of Hemorrhage |
Technical Errors |
Comparison of parenchymal & ventricular ICP recordings |
Zero Drift |
Camino ICP Monitor |
Fiber optic |
8.5%174.75%23 |
2.50% (0.66% clinical significant)17 1.1%23` |
4.5%17 10%18 3.14%23 |
0.946* (180 paired data points)19 59.3% within ±2 mm Hg and 97% within ±5 mmHg20 |
Mean 7.3 ± 5.1 mmHg (range −17 to 21 mmHg)17 Mean −0.67 mmHg (range −13 to 22 mmHg)18 Mean 0.4 ± 0.57 mmHg (maximum 12 mmHg)30 |
Codman MicroSensor |
Strain gauge |
0%44 0%24 |
0%23 ∼0.3% (0% clinical significant)24 |
n/a |
Mean difference 0.7mm Hg24 Mean difference 0.3mmHg (range -6.7 to 7.1mmHg) (1,527 paired data points)26 |
Mean 0.9 ± 0.2 mmHg (range −5 to 4 mmHg)24 Mean 0.1 ± 1.6 mmHg/100 hours of monitoring26 Mean 2.0 mmHg (range −6 to 15 mmHg)25 |
RaumedicNeurovent-P ICP sensor |
Strain gauge |
0%29 |
2.02% (0% clinical significant)29 1%30 |
5%30 |
n/a |
Mean 0.8 ± 2.2 mmHg (range −4 to +8 mmHg)29 Mean 0.2 ± 0.41 mmHg (maximum 3mmHg)30 |
Pressio |
Strain gauge |
n/a |
n/a |
n/a |
Mean difference -0.6mmHg (range -8.1 to 6.9mmHg) (1,562 paired data points)26 |
Mean −0.7 ± 1.6 mmHg/100 hours of monitoring26 |
Spiegelberg |
Pneumatic |
0%31 |
0%31 |
3.45%31 |
99.6% within +/13mmHg and 91.3% within +/12mmHg (15104 paired data points)31 |
Mean<±2mmHg31 |
Hummingbird Synergy Duo |
Pneumatic |
4%32 |
10%32 |
n/a |
95% within +/-12mmHg (1.5million paired data points)33 |
|