| |
Method |
STEMLIS |
Classical Method |
| |
|
MSE |
HSR |
IDEP |
MSE |
HSR |
IDEP |
| 26x44 (5x5 window) |
Test1
( pattern recognition) |
817.9 |
0.831 |
144.0 |
793.1 |
0.815 |
111.0 |
Test2
(contrast discrimination) |
2171.8 |
0.448 |
220.0 |
2923.9 |
0.437 |
209.0 |
| Test3 (text reading) |
1858.5 |
0.888 |
317.0 |
2370.4 |
0.856 |
323.0 |
| Test4 (object counting) |
1259.8 |
0.731 |
141.0 |
3102.8 |
0.634 |
120.0 |
| Mean |
1527.0 |
0.722 |
205.5 |
2297.6 |
0.691 |
190.8 |
| 43x73 (3x3 window) |
Test1
( pattern recognition) |
587.8 |
0.915 |
287.0 |
1124.3 |
0.877 |
239.0 |
Test2
(contrast discrimination) |
1104.1 |
0.497 |
223.0 |
1794.8 |
0.456 |
166.0 |
Test3
(text reading) |
1700.0 |
0.923 |
711.0 |
1918.7 |
0.922 |
796.0 |
Test4
(object counting) |
945.6 |
0.729 |
156.0 |
1875.7 |
0.714 |
282.0 |
| Mean |
1084.4 |
0.766 |
344.3 |
1678.4 |
0.742 |
370.8 |
| 130x220 (no window) |
Test1
( pattern recognition) |
546.7 |
0.974 |
2837.0 |
527.3 |
0.943 |
3070.0 |
Test2
(contrast discrimination) |
614.1 |
0.510 |
624.0 |
835.5 |
0.477 |
2011.0 |
Test3
(text reading) |
1311.6 |
0.820 |
4582.0 |
1116.3 |
0.817 |
4860.0 |
Test4
(object counting) |
443.6 |
0.701 |
1513.0 |
1503.8 |
0.696 |
1032.0 |
| Mean |
729.0 |
0.751 |
2389.0 |
995.72 |
0.733 |
2743.3 |
| Overall results |
1113.5 |
0.746 |
976.6 |
1657.21 |
0.722 |
1101.6 |
