Year |
Author |
Predictor |
Data |
AUC |
SES(%) |
SPE(%) |
1991 |
Martin et al. [50] |
MF |
7 patients |
/ |
/ |
/ |
1996 |
Brown et al. [44] |
Combination of PF and FC in certain ranges |
55 patients with OHCA |
/ |
100 |
47.1 |
2000 |
Eftestol et al. [46] |
Combination of FC and PF |
156 patients with OHCA (total 868 shocks:87 had caused ROSC and 781 had failed to cause ROSC ) |
/ |
92 ± 2 |
42 ± 1 |
2001 |
Strohmenger et al. [69] |
DF |
89 patients with OHCA |
/ |
92 |
42 |
2001 |
Eftestøl et al. [43] |
Combination of CF and the energy |
156 patients with OHCA (total 883 shocks:87 had caused ROSC and 781 had failed to cause ROSC ) |
/ |
91 ± 3 |
36 ± 4 |
2001 |
Hamprecht et al. [36] |
DF |
54 patients with OHCA (artefact-free ventricular fibrillation episodes, 28 return to ROSC) |
/ |
59 |
52 |
2004 |
Jekova et al. [70] |
Energy between 2 and 7 Hz |
more than 700 out-of-hospital fibrillation cases |
/ |
61.8 |
79.6 |
2004 |
Young et al. [51] |
AMSA |
46 patients with OHCA |
/ |
91 |
94 |
2004 |
Watson et al. [54] |
Entropy measure based on Morlet wavelet |
87 success shock and 781 unsuccess shock |
/ |
91 ± 2 |
60 ± 6 |
2005 |
Watson et al. [49] |
COP based on a tunable Morlet wavelet |
110 patients with OHCA |
/ |
97 ± 2 |
63 ± 4 |
2006 |
Watson et al. [71] |
COP based on CWT |
110 patients with OHCA |
/ |
95 ± 4 |
66 ± 4 |
2007 |
Neurauter et al. [38] |
MdS |
197 patients with in-hospital and out-of-hospital CA |
0.848 |
95.2 |
52.6 |
2007 |
Jagric et al. [61] |
Irregularity |
120 recordings of VF |
/ |
/ |
/ |
2008 |
Gundersen et al. [47] |
COP |
86 patients with OHCA |
0.877 |
/ |
/ |
2008 |
Box et al. [55] |
COP based on wavelet transform |
54 patients with OHCA |
/ |
100 |
60 |
2008 |
Sherman et al. [62] |
LAC |
158 patients with OHCA |
0.77 |
|
|
2008 |
Ristagno et al. [72] |
AMSA |
90 patients with OHCA |
/ |
91 |
97 |
2008 |
Neurauter et al. [73] |
MdS(10-22Hz) |
192 patients with in-hospital and out-of-hospital CA |
0.863 |
95.2 |
49.7 |
2012 |
Nakagawa et al. [74] |
AMSA |
83 patients with OHCA |
/ |
94 |
59 |
2012 |
Shandilya et al. [28] |
Feature based on complex wavelet transform |
57 patients (34 successful and 56 unsuccessful defibrillations)
ECG signals without addition of the PetCO2 signal |
0.850 |
90 |
78.6 |
With addition of the PetCO2 signal |
0.938 |
/ |
/ |
SES, sensitivity; SPE, specificity; “/ ” denotes the corresponding values were not reported.