Benchmark |
Benchmark Corpus |
InfoCodex Corpus |
Precision |
Recall |
I2E raw |
PubMed |
PubMed |
(exact) |
(exact) |
<1% obesity |
5% obesity |
3-5% diabetes |
9-11% diabetes |
3-7% MDOB |
7% MDOB |
I2E normalized |
PubMed |
PubMed |
(exact) |
(exact) |
3-7% MDOB |
3-7% MDOB |
I2E manual |
PubMed |
PubMed |
1-5% obesity |
9-33% obesity |
3-11% diabetes |
9-31% diabetes |
3-26% MDOB |
4-15% MDOB |
UMLS + GO + OMIM |
UMLS + GO + OMIM |
PubMed |
1-4% |
3-22% |
1-8% (unary) |
4-35% (unary) |
Thomson Reuters |
Thomson Reuters |
PubMed |
7-36% obesity |
36% obesity |
18% DM2 |
9-49% DM2 |
22% DM1 |
25% DI |
TGI |
TGI |
PubMed |
0-5% obesity |
(exact) 2.5% |
0-4% diabetes |
1-14% MDOB |
I2E manual |
PubMed |
ClinicalTrials.gov |
(preferred terms) 27-59% |
(preferred terms) 3-7% |
UMLS + GO + OMIM |
UMLS + GO + OMIM |
ClinicalTrials.gov |
(preferred terms) 1-2% |
(preferred terms) <1% |
I2E manual |
PubMed |
Merck internal |
(preferred terms) 8-14% |
(preferred terms) 1-2% |
UMLS + GO + OMIM |
UMLS + GO + OMIM |
Merck internal |
(preferred terms) <1% |
(preferred terms) <1% |
|