Type of Catalyst |
Merits |
Demerits |
Homogeneous catalysts |
Alkaline type
(NaOH, KOH, CH3ONa, CH3OK) |
Less corrosive, high reaction rate |
Formation of saponified product, emulsion formation, high water and energy consumption, huge, high waste water discharges, high purification cost, feedstocks are limited to 0.5wt FFAs, not recycle |
Acid type
(H2SO4) |
Zero soap formation, the catalyst can be used to catalyze both esterification and transesterification simultaneously |
More waste as a result of neutralization, recycling difficulty, high purification cost, energy consuming, low reaction rates |
Heterogeneous catalysts |
Solid alkaline
(MgO, CaO, ZnO, KOH/NaY)
Solid acid types
(CaO/MgO, Al2O3-SnO, KOH/K2CO3, Al2O3-ZnO, Ca(NO3)2/Al2O3CaO/Al2O3, KOH/Al2O3, Al2O3/KI, Sr(NO3)2/ZnO, ZrO2/SO42-, TiO2/SO42-, ETS-10 zeolite, Zeolite HY, Zeolite X) |
Environmentally friendly, easily recycle, less discharges, less separation difficulty, high purity glycerol, lower cost of separation, insignificant leaching of CaO/Al2O3 |
Leaching effects, catalysts preparation is complicated and expense relatively slow rates |
Enzymes types
(Candida antarctica B lipase, Rhizomucormeihei lipase, candida rugosaPseuodonascepacia, M. meihei (Lypozyme), M. meihei(Lypozyme IM60),Aspergillus niger)
P. Fluorescens, R. Oryzae |
Zero saponification products nonpolluting, easily separable, lesser reparation cost, high purity glycerol and biodiesel products, environmentally benign
Simple glycerol recovery |
Catalysts inhibition by water
High cost of enzymes |
|