Bassam H Mahboub, FatehRahman SMA Shendi*, Basil Kh Safarini, Mostafa H AbdulAziz, Gamal M Mustafa and Vijayshree Prakash
Department of Internal Medicine, Pulmonary Unit, Rashid Hospital – Dubai Health Authority, UAE
Received date: December 27, 2012; Accepted date: April 19, 2013; Published date: April 22, 2013
Citation: Mahboub BH, SMA Shendi FR, Safarini BK, AbdulAziz MH, Mustafa GM, et al. (2013) Cost of Asthma in Dubai, United Arab Emirates (UAE). J Pulmon Resp Med 3:146. doi: 10.4172/2161-105X.1000146
Copyright: © 2013 Mahboub BH, et al. This is an open-access article distributedunder the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Pulmonary & Respiratory Medicine
Background and Objectives: Asthma is one of the chronic respiratory diseases affecting both genders and all ages across the globe. The treatment and control of asthma imposes significant economic burden on patients as well as the healthcare system. Patients also report absenteeism from school/work and poor quality of life. There are very few studies evaluating the cost of asthma in UAE. The objective of this study is to evaluate the cost of asthma in Dubai region of United Arab Emirates.
Material and Methods: Asthma prevalence and unit cost estimates were applied to the population of Dubai aged 5 years and above, based on the figures from the Dubai Statistic Center 2009 census. The asthma treatment profiles of the patients in Dubai as well as the days absent from school/work and quality of life data were obtained from the Asthma Insights and Reality for the Gulf and Near East (AIRGNE) study. The cost of drugs was procured from the purchase department of Dubai Health Authority (DHA) and cost of out-patient visits as well as hospital stay and emergency visits was also provided by the DHA. The cost of asthma in this study is the direct cost of drugs, hospital stay and visits as out-patient and ER visits, along with supplementary costs in terms of days lost from work or school.
Results: The total direct cost of asthma in Dubai was about 88 million Dirhams (AED 87,917,202). The maximum contribution to this was from expenditure on out-patient visits (37% - AED 32,217,143), followed by that on hospital stays (23% - AED 23,587,008). The cost on medication and ER visits represented 20% and 16% of the direct cost respectively. Absenteeism from school was reported by 50% of asthmatic children, asthmatics also reported an average loss of 4 days of work per year due to asthma.
Conclusion: There is a huge economic burden on the patients and healthcare services due to asthma. Taking into account the considerable expenditure on the out-patient visits, ER visits and hospital stay, efforts must be directed towards improved asthma control and patient education about their disease.
Asthma is a chronic respiratory disease characterized by chest tightness, wheezing, cough and shortness of breath. Approximately 300 million people around the globe suffer from asthma. It affects all ages and both genders; the prevalence varying between 1-18% in different countries across the world  .There is also a changing prevalence in countries over the past few years, which may be attributed to the change in awareness and diagnostic practices for asthma .
In the Middle East as well, there is inter and intra-regional variability in asthma prevalence. In Saudi Arabia, the prevalence was reported to be 23.6% , in Qatar it was 19.8%  while that in Oman the prevalence varied between 7.8% to 17.3% in different regions . A study from the Al Ain region of UAE shows asthma prevalence of 13% using the ISAAC questionnaire , while another based on the ECRHS questionnaire shows a range of 8 – 10% across UAE . Despite this diversity in prevalence worldwide, there is a trend towards increase in diagnosed asthma, so much so that the prevalence has almost doubled in Europe over the past decade.
Asthma affects the quality of life adversely and adds to the economic burden of the patients and healthcare system. The expenditure on asthma control medication is not the only cost. Hospital visits including outpatient consultations, inpatient stay for disease control and absenteeism from work or schoolimpose additional cost. The AIRGNE data reports sickness absenteeism due to asthma in 30% adult and 52% of children suffering from asthma per year .
The direct annual cost of asthma in Europe was estimated to be Euro 7.9 billion , while that in USA was USD 37.2 billion . Another study in USA found the total incremental cost of asthma, including the indirect cost was USD 56 billion in 2007 .
The studies evaluating the cost of asthma from Middle East are very few, there are none from UAE. This study is thus aimed to estimate the expenditure for asthma treatment in Dubai. This includes the cost of asthma medication, out-patient visits, in-patient treatment and emergency visits. This can provide an insight for better management of asthma.
The population of Dubai for age above 5 years was obtained based on the figures from the Dubai Statistic Center 2009 census. The data for drug use and cost of drug use was provided by the Dubai Health Authority (DHA) Purchasing Department. The treatment profiles were taken from the AIRGNE study . The prevalence of asthma in Dubai was estimated using the Modified Delphi technique. This technique was used to gather consensus estimates of this data due to a lack of availability of unit costs of asthma treatment. One of the main advantages of using the Delphi technique is its ability to obtain expert knowledge from each participant without influence from other participants as opposed to a face-to-face group panel approach .
The Delphi panel methodology consisted of consensus consultations with seven leading physicians in asthma treatment in the UAE. Data was collected in two rounds from the panel were conducted to determine these estimates. In round 1, a summary of the best currently available data on asthma prevalence and unit costs of asthma treatment were provided to each of the panel members. Treatment costs included outpatient, Emergency Room (ER) visit, and inpatient costs for both adults and children. Each panel member provided their own expert estimates individually, including upper and lower estimates in addition to a “best” estimate. An average of the round 1 combined estimate from the panel members was calculated for each data input, and then used in round 2.
During round 2, the panelists were given these mean values to consider, and were given the opportunity to amend their round 1 estimates where they thought is appropriate to do so. These revised estimates for prevalence and costs (for both adults and children) generated in this second round were used in the main calculations of the current study.
For the arriving at the estimated prevalence, the panel members were asked to give three estimates of prevalence for both adults and children. The three estimates were for the lowest level of asthma prevalence (unlikely to be lower than this), the upper level of asthma prevalence (unlikely to be higher than this) and the best estimate (most likely).
The asthma prevalence determined in round 2 of the Delphi exercise was applied to the population of Dubai aged 5 and above. The product of percentage of patients being treated for asthma as reported in the AIRGNE study and the estimates from round 2 was then obtained to determine the total number of asthma patients managed in healthcare facilities.
The total outpatient cost was determined by multiplying the total number of asthma patients treated and the average number of annual out-patient visits as per the AIRGNE study .
Similarly, the ER visit and the total in-patient treatment expenditure was calculated by first multiplying the percentage of asthma suffers visiting ER as reported by the AIRGNE study by the total number of asthma patients being treated, then multiplying the product by the average number of ER visits per year in the AIRGNE study. The total number of annual ER visits thus obtained was then used to calculate the total cost of ER visits using the estimate obtained from the Delphi round 2 estimate of unit cost of ER visit. The total expenditure on the in-patient stay was calculated in a similar fashion.
To estimate the total direct treatment cost, it was assumed that the total direct cost of asthma was the sum of the out-patient costs, inpatient costs, cost of ER visits and the asthma medication cost.
A sensitivity analysis to the results from the Delphi panel was done based on the lowest 50% of values collected in round 1 Delphi.
The supplementary cost was assumed to be due to loss of work/ school-days due to asthma and poor quality of life. Data from the AIRGNE II was used for these assessments.
The estimated asthma prevalence for the resident population of Dubai as estimated by the Delphi technique was 13.6% in adults and 19.2% in children (Table 1).
|Delphi round 1 and 2||Asthma Prevalence %|
|Upper estimate||Best estimate mean||Lower estimate|
|Round 1 estimate||40%||50%||14%||21%||6%||11%|
|Round 2 revised||13.6%||19.2%|
Table 1: Estimated Asthma prevalence for Dubai.
The estimated adult expenditure was AED 722 as the unit cost of hospitalization, while for a child it was AED 652 (Table 2).
|Mean cost in Dubai||Cost visit or per day in DH|
|Outpatient||Emergency visit||Inpatient adult||Inpatient child|
|Round 1 average||225||565||633||560|
|Round 2 revised||261||547||722||652|
Table 2: Cost per hospital visit in Government healthcare facilities in Dubai.
According to the AIRGNE II data, 22% of Dubai residents regularly use DHA facilities as their primary source of asthma management (Table 3).
|Dubai||Adult 15+||Children 5+|
|Sub-total number of asthma sufferers||212,587||26,228|
|% regularly using DHA facilities (AIRGENE II)||20.0%||38.1%|
|Total number of asthma sufferers using DHA||42,517||9,993|
Table 3: Estimated asthma sufferers using DHA facilities.
The Out-patient visits accounted for the highest expenditure in the total direct cost for asthma, costing AED 22 945 342 for adults and AED 9 271 801 for children, the total expenditure being AED 32 217 143 (Table 4).
|Dubai||Adults 15+||Children 5+|
|Asthma sufferers using DHA facilities||42,517||9,993|
|% sufferers hospitalised in past year||28%||38%|
|Total number of sufferers hospitalised||11,777||3,747|
|Number of nights per patient in 12m||2.4||1.3|
|Total number of nights hospitalized.a.||28,266||4,871|
|Unit cost of an inpatient day/night DH||722||652|
|Total cost of inpatient stays with DHA||20,412,442||3,174,566|
Table 4: Estimated total cost of in-patient treatment for asthma in Dubai - DHA
This was followed by the cost of hospital stay due to asthma amounted to AED 23 587 008, that for adults being AED 20 412 442 and for children being AED 3 174 566 (Table 5). Huge amount was also spent on emergency visits, a total of AED 17 543 414, 44% of adult and 38% of children with asthma visiting the ER in the past one year. Total number of ER visits per year for adults was 18,878 while that for children it was 3747 (Table 6).
|Dubai||Adults 15+||Children 5+|
|Total asthma sufferers using DHA facilities||42,517||9,993|
|% needing outpatient treatment in a year||67%||75%|
|Total sufferers using DHA outpatient dept||28,359||7,495|
|Outpatient visit per patient per year||3.1||4.7|
|Total number of outpatient visits per year||87,913||35,524|
|Unit cost of an outpatient visit DH||261||261|
|Total cost of outpatient visits (DHA) DH||22,945,342||9,271,801|
Table 5: Estimated total cost of out-patient visits for asthma in Dubai - DHA facilities.
|Dubai||Adults 15+||Children 5+|
|Total asthma sufferers using DHA||42,517||9,993|
|% making emergency visit in past year||44%||38%|
|Total number of ER visits||18,878||3,747|
|Average number of visits per patient per year||1.5||1.0|
|Total number of visits per year||28,317||3,747|
|Unit cost of an emergency visit DH||547||547|
|Total cost of emergency visits to DHA||15,493,131||2,050,283|
Table 6: Estimated total cost of Emergency Visits for asthma in Dubai - DHA facilities.
The estimated total direct expenditure due to asthma in DHA facilities was AED 87,917,202, of which medication cost was AED 14 569 637 (Table 7). The proportions of the total direct cost of asthma are shown in Graph 1.
|‘Core’ treatment cost in DHA facilities||Adults 15+||Child 5 to 14||Totals|
|Cost of outpatient visits||22,945,342||9,271,801||32,217,143|
|Cost of emergency visits||15,493,131||2,050,283||17,543,414|
|Cost of inpatient stays||20,412,442||3,174,566||23,587,008|
|Total non drug cost||58,850,915||14,496,650||73,347,565|
|Cost of medicines (DHA 2009) DH||14,569,637|
|Total direct cost of treatment (DH)||87,917,202|
Table 7: Estimated total direct cost for asthma in Dubai - DHA facilities.
|AIRGNE I : Dubai (N= 68)||total Dubai||adult Dubai||child Dubai||Controlled ACT>20|
|missed day at work or school||21%||14%||50%||14%|
|Figures for Europe (AIRE)||17%||43%|
Table 8: Work-days lost due to asthma: calculation in working male population of Dubai.
The indirect cost of asthma due to loss of days of work/school and poor quality of life is difficult to calculate in terms of revenue. The number of days of work lost due to asthma may reflect in loss of wages, thereby leading to monetary loss.
Based on the AIRGNE II data, 19% of asthmatics in Dubai reported their asthma related limitation in activity affected their participation in sports and recreational activities a lot, while 44% reported some effect on sports and recreational activities. Physical exertion was somewhat limited for 40% while for 23%, there was some correlation between their limitation in physical activity and choice of career. The extend of limitation of such activities that is due-to asthma is shown in Graph 2.
Leave from work / school was reported by 21% of asthmatics in Dubai according to the AIRGNE II study. Sickness absenteeism due to asthma was reported by 14% adults and 50% of school going children suffering from asthma. The average loss of days due to asthma was 4 per year.
Applying the estimated prevalence of asthma of 13.6 % obtained by the Delphi technique to the population of working males (age 20-65 years) in Dubai according to the 2009 census, there is a loss of about 79000 work-days annually due to asthma.
The high cost of asthma in Dubai is an economic burden on the healthcare system. The estimated total direct cost of treatment for asthma was AED 87, 917, 202 (approximately 88 million Dirhams). The highest cost was related to the out-patient visits representing 37% of the total cost (AED 32,217,143), followed by expenditure on hospital stay due to asthma (23%) and ER visits (20%). This expenditure (AED 73,347,565) was much higher than that on asthma medication (AED 14,569,637) which made up to 16% of the total direct cost.
The high financial burden is attributable to poor asthma control as evident by the high percentage of ER visits by asthmatics in the year preceding the study. This percent (44%) is substantially high than in Europe, where only 10% of asthma sufferers needed to visit the ER. In addition, only 6% needed overnight hospitalization in Europe while in Dubai the percent was much higher (28% in adults and 38% in children) [8,13].
In Europe, the cost for out-patient care was 48%, drug cost was 46% and in-patient care cost was 6% , the largest portion of the total direct cost of asthma in US was expenditure on prescription medication and physician office visits – about 38% of the total incremental expenditure for asthma in children and 49% in adults .
The data from Dubai for sickness absenteeism due to asthma is close to that reported from Europe (14% adults and 50% children in Dubai & 17.1% adults and 42.7% children in Europe).This may result into loss of wages, thus an indirect cost due to asthma.
In the sensitivity analysis, the ‘best estimate’ mean values from the Delphi exercise were replaced with mean values taken only from the ‘lower estimate’. That meant we used asthma prevalence figures of 9% for adults and 15% for children. Although the effect of this change was to decrease the figure for the overall cost of asthma, the conclusions remained the same: that the main cost elements relating to asthma treatment in the DHA are those of emergency treatment, in patient treatment, and unscheduled outpatient treatment. These cost elements reflect poorly controlled asthma and it follows that the prime focus should be on improving control of asthma and not on reducing drug costs.
There are certain drawbacks of this study. These figures are estimates in cost and prevalence based on individual judgment although the reliability of the estimates is increased due to use of two rounds of estimates and sensitivity analysis.
Furthermore, the population in Dubai is a heterogeneous group of local Arab and expatriate people. The figures in this study are thus the best that could be represented.
Expenditure due to asthma is a substantial burden on the healthcare system. The cost of asthma for hospital stay, out-patient visits and Emergency visits is considerably higher than that of the medication cost. The efforts should hence be directed towards achieving better asthma control by means of patient education and disease awareness.