alexa Earthworm as Bioindicator of Soil Pollution Around Benghazi City, Libya

ISSN: 2161-0525

Journal of Environmental & Analytical Toxicology

  • Research Article   
  • J Environ Anal Toxicol 2013, Vol 3(6): 189
  • DOI: 10.4172/2161-0525.1000189

Earthworm as Bioindicator of Soil Pollution Around Benghazi City, Libya

Maher Haeba1*, Jan Kuta2, Zeyad K Arhouma3 and Heba MA Elwerfalli1
1Zoology Department, Science Faculty, Benghazi University, Benghazi, Libya
2Research Centre for Toxic Compounds in the Environment (RECETOX), Faculty of Science, Masaryk University, Kamenice, Czech Republic
3Biology Department, Education Faculty, Benghazi University, Ghemines, Libya
*Corresponding Author: Maher Haeba, Zoology Department, Science Faculty, Benghazi University, Benghazi, Libya, Email: [email protected]

Received Date: Jul 24, 2013 / Accepted Date: Aug 29, 2013 / Published Date: Aug 30, 2013


Pollution of terrestrial ecosystem is a serious environmental problem worldwide. Earthworm is considered as a domain soil organism. It has been recommended test species to evaluate soil contaminations in acute toxicity. Earthworm density and biomass are strongly influence by pollution. In this study, mortality, biomass, cocoon number of Eisenia fetida were examined during 14 days of exposure to series percentage (100, 75, 50, 25%) for each soil of (Bouatni, Hawari, Lowifia, and Jarotha) locations around Benghazi city, under control conditions. The locations soil was mixed with artificial soil to get the desired percentages. Mortality was recorded in Bouatni soil 100%. However, no mortality observed elsewhere. No cocoon numbers were account in all locations at 100, 75% as well as in Lowifia soil 50%. However, Cocoon numbers were significantly reduced in Bouatni, Hawari and Jarothaat50, 25% compared to control. Interestingly, earthworms body weight were increased significantly, in all locations soil (25, 50, 75%) compared to control earthworm. Our results had shown decreased in cocoon number which can lead to decline in earthworm populations and consequence to reduce soil fertility. This study was first investigation of contamination soils around Benghazi city by using biota as well as put more emphasis on using earthworm as bioindicator.

Keywords: Earthworm; Soil pollution; Ecosystem; Environmental


Benghazi (32_10¢N, 20_06¢E), the second largest city in Libya, is colonized by many soil invertebrates such as earthworms. Soil pollutions have enormously increased during the last decades due to the intensive use of pesticides and fertilizers in agriculture. The increase in soil pollution levels due to pesticides as well as heavy metals has endangered both the environment and human life [1]. It is becoming increasingly apparent that chemical analysis and the use of chemical-specific trigger values cannot take into account issues such as mixture toxicity and the environmental conditions determining chemical bioavailability. The best integrators of these complex effects are the exposed organisms themselves [2]. Among soil species, earthworms are ubiquitous, abundant, and important for soil processes. Earthworms form the largest part of the invertebrate biomass in most soils Lavelle and Spain, 2001), considered not only as a biofertilizer and composting agent but at the same time nature’s plough, aerator, moisture retainer, crusher, and biological agent [3]. It is able to modify soil physical properties [4], through mixing surface litter, casting, and burrowing activities. Earthworms are known to play a major role in the development and maintenance of soil structure, in the incorporation and breakdown of organic residues in the soil, and as a source of food for terrestrial organisms [5]. Assimilation of contaminated earthworm tissue by predators may lead to accumulation of toxic chemicals throughout the food chain. Their survival and behaviour in contaminated soils has implications for their use as biological indicators of soil health and as agents of soil restoration [1].

Earthworm is considered as a domain soil organism. It has been recommended test species to evaluate soil contaminations in acute toxicity. Earthworm density and biomass are strongly influence by contamination. Pollution of terrestrial ecosystem is a serious environmental problem worldwide. The potential hazards of environmental pollutants to soil invertebrates have been assessed in many years by the use of the 'earthworm acute toxicity test' [6]. This 14-day LC50 test using the earthworm Eiseniafetida has been important for risk assessment and regulation of new and existing chemicals [7]. The end point of the 'earthworm acute toxicity test' is mortality. However, mortality is unlikely to be either the most sensitive or ecologically relevant parameter for predicting effects on field populations. Reproductive and/or growth disturbances are far more likely to mediate population effects [8]. Reproduction is likely to be of particular important in ecotoxicological assessment because of its influence on population dynamics [9]. The aim of this study, to use earthworm as bioindicator to evaluate soil contamination around Benghazi city. Duration of the experiment was 14 days. However, along with mortality, the body weight and reproduction rate by cocoon production were considered.

Materials and Methods

Four stations located within the municipality of Benghazi were selected for the study (Figure 1). These stations were (1) Bouatni (2) Hawari (3) Lowifia and (4) Jarotha, they were categorized into four different habitats of earthworms. These were (i) Clayey loam soil, lemon, olive, guava and orange farm (stations 1). (ii) Silt clay soil, plain landscape with wild grasses and olive plants having medium-sized trees forming canopy (station 2). (iii) Loamy sand soil, rose and flower garden (station 3). (iv) Loamy sand soil, rose, flower garden pomegranate and olive plants having medium-sized trees forming canopy (station 4). Soil, were sampled during March 2013, and following certain steps a plot of 20 × 20 cm replicates ten times were measured within the survey site 10 × 10 m, of each station with two substations. A ditch of 10 cm deep was dug in the plot and the 100 g soil were taken from each and spread on a white plastic tray, and hand-sorted removing stones and road as they were found. The soil samples were air-dried and each sample was then placed in a mortar, and then sieved per 2 mm mesh to remove the rest of stones and pieces of macro-organic matter for routine analyses.


Figure 1: Location of study stations in Benghazi (up to down) (1) Bouatni, (2) Hawari (3) Lowifia, and (4) Jarotha.

The temperature of the soil (10 cm deep) was measured by a soil thermometer, relative humidity (%) on the soil surface by a hygrometer, and pH of the soil using a soil pH meter. The water content of the soil was calculated as the difference between the weights of the initial and oven-dried (55°C) soil, and expressed as a percentage. Selected heavy metals were determined in biota samples (microwave digestion with nitric acid and hydrogen peroxide). However, heavy metals in soils for “total” content with aqua-regia extraction (ISO 11466).

Earthworm of the species Eiseniafetida was maintained in the laboratory in culture medium according to OECD_222 [10]. Treated soils were mixed with different concentrations of the control soil (100, 75, 50, 25%). These experiments were started by adults with well-developed clitella, for 14 days exposure. The test endpoint were mortality, body weight as well as cocoon production.

Result and Discussion

The result put more emphasis on fact that the agriculture soils received a comparatively high input of anthropogenic heavy metals, possibly related to the use of agrochemicals and other soil amendments for the high annual crop production. Total concentration of heavy metals was always higher in soil collected from Buatany area compared to other. Heavy metals follow two orders, first order Zn>Cu>Pb>Cd inBuatany and Jarotha. Secondly, Zn >Pb>Cu >Cd in Hawari and Lowifia. The average concentrations of Cd, Cu, Pb, and Zn (expressed as mg kg-1 dry weight) were shown in Table 1. Selected Heavy metals concentrations were always higher in Buatany station than other, which were in different order in between. Heavy metals are strongly bound to soils rich in organic matter or clay [11]. Temperature was 22 ± 2, pH. was 7 ± 1, relative humidity was 70%. High mortality 93% was recorded in Bouatni soil 100%. However, no mortality observed elsewhere.

Stations Pb Cd Zn Cu
BUATANY 33.1 0.43 321.8 44.8
Hawari 19.6 0.26 52.3 12
Lowifia 17.6 0.2 87.7 16.1
Jarotha 13.5 0.2 115 15.3

Table 1: Show the mean of selected heavy metal concentrations (mg/Kg) in different soil stations around Benghazi city.

Body weight was significantly decreased in all soil from different locations at concentration (100%). At concentration 75 body weight was less than control group except 75% Jarotha was higher than control group. However, body weight was increased in all soil from different locations at concentrations (50 and 25%) compared to control (Figure 2) with no significant different.


Figure 2: Shown the change in body weight after 14 days at different concentration (100, 75, 50, 25%) of study stations around Benghazi (B) Bouatni, (H) Hawari (L) Lowifia, and (J) Jarotha.

Cocoon production was not recorded in treated soil (100%) in Bouatni, Lowifia, and Jarotha as well as in (75%) treated soil in Bouatni, and Jarotha. However, cocoon number in Hawari soil (100%) was four cocoons. Hawari and Lowifia soil (75%) the number of cocoon were 16 and 13 respectively that are significantly different with control group. In 50% treated soil, Hawari soil were the highest production (53 cocoon) followed by Lowifia and Bouatni (43, 42 respectively). The lowest cocoon production at 50% of treated soil were in Jarotha soil with (26 cocoon), all of them were significantly less production than control group. The cocoon production at 100, 75 and 50% of treated soil were always less than cocoon production in control group (72 Cocoon). However, the cocoon production at 25% of treated soil was almost higher than cocoon production in control group (72 Cocoon). In the 25% treated soil, Lowifia soil were the highest cocoon production (99 Cocoon) with significant different followed by Jarotha and Bouatni (82 and 76 Cocoon) respectively with no significant different with control. However, Howari 25% were shown cocoon production (47 Cocoon) which is significantly less than control group production (Figure 2). This study show high total concentration of heavy metal in Bouatni. Treated soil did not cause mortality in acute toxicity test 14 day exposure except in Bouatni 100%. However, it has clear effect on body weight and cocoon production which should be considered in such experiments. Such change in body weight and cocoon production leads to change in population dynamic.


Soil group at RECETOX, special thanks to Dr. Jakub Hofman at Masaryk University, Brno, Czech Republic.


Citation: Haeba M, Kuta J, Arhouma ZK, Elwerfalli HMA (2013) Earthworm as Bioindicator of Soil Pollution Around Benghazi City, Libya. J Environ Anal Toxicol 3:189. Doi: 10.4172/2161-0525.1000189

Copyright: © 2013 Haeba M, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language

Post Your Comment Citation
Share This Article
Relevant Topics
Article Usage
  • Total views: 13020
  • [From(publication date): 10-2013 - Jan 23, 2019]
  • Breakdown by view type
  • HTML page views: 9068
  • PDF downloads: 3952

Post your comment

captcha   Reload  Can't read the image? click here to refresh
Leave Your Message 24x7