Minori Nishiguchi*, Hideyuki Nushida, Noriyuki Okudaira and Hajime Nishio
Department of Legal Medicine, Hyogo College of Medicine, Nishinomiya, Hyogo, Japan
Received date: October 15, 2014; Accepted date: December 06, 2014; Published date: December 10, 2014
Citation: Nishiguchi M, Nushida H, Okudaira N, Nishio H (2015) An Autopsy Case of Fatal Methemoglobinemia due to Ingestion of Sodium Nitrite. J Forensic Res 6:262. doi: 10.4172/2157-7145.1000262
Copyright: © 2015 Minori Nishiguchi. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Forensic Research
We herein present an autopsy case of fatal methemoglobinemia due to suicidal ingestion of sodium nitrite. A man in his 30s who had exhibited mild depression was found dead in his house. A glass containing a white turbid solution and a suicide note were found on the table near the decedent. At autopsy, the lividity of the face and back was greenish gray, and the blood was tinted a chocolate brown color. Toxicological analysis of nitrite and nitrate using a colorimetric method showed that the nitrite concentrations were <0.05 and 0.09 μg/mL and that the nitrate concentrations were 71.69 and 83.48 μg/mL in the heart and femoral blood, respectively. Biochemical analysis after death showed that the level of methemoglobin was 83.4% by spectrophotometry. We conclude that the cause of death was severe methemoglobinemia following acute poisoning induced by sodium nitrite ingestion, although the blood nitrite concentration did not reach the fatal level.
Nitrite; Nitrate; Fatal methemoglobinemia; Overdose; Toxicology
Sodium nitrite has long been used as a color enhancer in cured meats and fishes, a preservative, and an antimicrobial agent worldwide [1,2]. Other, and is also used as an industrial chemical and therapeutic agent. Poisoning by sodium nitrite is an unexpected accident in many cases. In North American and European countries, where large amounts of sodium nitrite are added to food, many cases of methemoglobinemia caused by accidental ingestion or inhalation of nitrites have been reported [1-5]. In contrast, few cases of fatal poisoning by nitrites in food have been reported in Japan [6,7]. Small amounts of nitrite, as food additives, ingestion are not associated with poisoning symptoms, whereas acute exposure to excessive dosages may be associated with lethal symptoms such as methemoglobinemia.
Severe methemoglobinemia is caused by exposure to therapeutic agents and chemicals such as nitrogen oxide [3,8,9] and chlorates [10-12], which oxidize hemoglobin into methemoglobin. Oxidizing drugs such as nitrites oxidize the Fe2+ of the hemoglobin to Fe3+ and convert hemoglobin to methemoglobin, which loses its ability to bind and transport oxygen. The methemoglobin level in humans is normally <1%; levels of >70% can cause lethal tissue hypoxia [7,13,14].
In most fatal cases of severe methemoglobinemia secondary to sodium nitrite ingestion, the serum nitrite concentration exceeds the lethal level. However, there is not the report of the deceased who died of fatal methemoglobinemia although the serum nitrite concentration did not reach the lethal level. We herein report an autopsy case of fatal poisoning by suicidal ingestion of a large amount of sodium nitrite in the form of a chemical food additive; death occurred despite the fact that the blood nitrite concentration was lower than the lethal level. Biochemical analysis showed high levels of methemoglobin in the blood.
A man in his 30s who had worked in a ham-processing factory was found dead in the left lateral position in his living room. He had vomited a large amount of stomach contents. A glass containing a white turbid solution and a suicide note were found on the table near the decedent. A plastic bag containing approximately 120 g of a white powder was found in the drawer of a chest in the living room. He had a medical history of mild depression, hypertension, and diabetes. He had attempted suicide a few months previously. To clarify the cause of death, a forensic autopsy was performed approximately 24 h after his death.
The decedent was 175 cm tall and weighed 121.0 kg. The lividity of the face and back was greenish gray. External findings were unremarkable. Internally, however, both lungs (left, 475 g; right, 555 g) were slightly edematous. No bronchial foreign body was observed. The heart (615 g) contained approximately 650 mL of chocolate-brown colored blood and exhibited slight myocardial fibrosis and calcification. The coronary artery showed no abnormal findings, including stenosis. The brain (1570 g) showed no macroscopic abnormalities. Nitrite in blood samples is unstable at room temperature and is readily oxidized to nitrate . Postmortem heart blood, femoral blood, and urine specimens were collected during autopsy and kept at -80°C [16,17] for toxicological examination.
Quantification of the nitrite and nitrate concentrations in the heart and femoral blood were measured by a previously described colorimetric method [18,19] at the Forensic Science Research Center (Tokyo, Japan). Qualitative analysis of the white powder, vomited stomach contents, and glass of white turbid solution was performed by the Forensic Science Laboratory of Hyogo Prefectural Police Headquarters (Hyogo, Japan). Methemoglobinemia was measured with a portable oximeter (AVOXimeter 4000; A-VOX Systems, International Technidyne Corporation, NJ, USA) that was able to measure carboxyhemoglobin, oxyhemoglobin, and total hemoglobin. This oximeter measures the levels of these three types of hemoglobin by simultaneously monitoring seven wavelengths (488, 520, 560, 585, 597, 622, and 672 nm) . The blood and urine samples were analyzed for ethanol by headspace gas chromatography (AutoSystem XL; PerkinElmer, Waltham, MA, USA). All organic compounds except the ionization materials were measured with a gas chromatograph–mass spectrometer (GCMS-QP2010; GC Solution system, Shimadzu, Kyoto, Japan) following liquid–liquid phase extraction with EXtrelut NT3 columns (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany).
The results of the toxicological analysis of this case are presented in Table 1. Nitrite and nitrate was detected in heart and femoral blood, and the nitrite in neither blood sample reached lethal levels. Sodium nitrite was detected in the plastic bag containing white powder, vomited stomach contents, and glass of white turbid solution. Biochemical analysis showed that the methemoglobin level in the heart blood was 83.4% using the oximeter by spectrophotometry. No ethanol was detected in the blood or urine. Drug screening results using the Triage® Drugs of Abuse Panel (Biosite Diagnostic Inc., San Diego, CA, USA) were negative.
Table 1: Nitrite and nitrate concentrations in blood samples
Nitrite is used to maintain the bright pink color of meat and suppresses the growth of microorganisms. It is a powerful drug; the median lethal dose of oral sodium nitrite is 71 mg/kg of body weight in humans. Nitrite as therapeutic agent and chemical oxidizes Fe2+ of hemoglobin to Fe3+ and produces methemoglobin, in turn promoting the process of methemoglobin production . Methemoglobin is originally produced in the body from hemoglobin by auto-oxidation. However, NADH- and NADPH-methemoglobin reductase catalyze the process that reduces methemoglobin to hemoglobin and maintains the methemoglobin concentration at <1% [7,13,14]. After a large quantity of ingested nitrite or exposure to nitrite, the methemoglobin level increases to exceed the reduction ability of reductase. Methemoglobin is not capable of binding and transporting oxygen. Additionally, methemoglobinemia strengthens the bond between oxygen and the hemoglobin and decreases the oxygen supply in the tissues, resulting in a leftward shift of the oxygen dissociation curve. The decreased oxygen supply may cause a headache, cyanosis, breathing disorders, and death. The lethal blood methemoglobin level is generally >70% [7,9,13].
Serum nitrite levels in previous reports of death following accidental or intentional ingestion of nitrite have showed levels of 0.55 to 13 µg/mL [9,21]. A high methemoglobin level was detected in these cases, and the cause of death was methemoglobinemia. In the present case, the nitrite concentrations in the heart and femoral blood are presented in Table 1; they were lower than those previously reported. However, the ingestion of a large amount of nitrite causes death by induced methemoglobinemia in a very short time . In addition, in some deaths due to sodium nitrite, the drug has been detected in gastric contents but not in other body fluids or tissues . Therefore, if the presence of nitrite is suspected in the blood, determination of the methemoglobin level may be more important than the nitrite or nitrate level. In the present case, the level of methemoglobin was 83.4%, which is higher than previously reported fatal levels [6,7,8,21].
In this case, the concentrations of nitrate (71.69 and 83.48 µg/mL in the heart and femoral blood, respectively) were higher than those of nitrite (Table 1). Nitrite is converted to nitrate, which is incapable of oxidizing hemoglobin to methemoglobin in the body. The accidental ingestion of 75 g of sodium nitrate by one man resulted in gastrointestinal symptoms, but his methemoglobin levels were normal and he made an uneventful recovery .
In summary, we have presented the results of a postmortem examination of the heart and femoral blood after ingestion of sodium nitrite, which may have been obtained from the ham-processing factory where the deceased worked. This case of death of severe methemoglobinemia following acute poisoning by sodium nitrite is infrequency; the serum nitrite concentration dose did not reach the fatal level.
This study was supported in part by the Forensic Science Research Center and the Forensic Science Laboratory of Hyogo Prefectural Police Headquarters.