Reach Us +44 7482 874137
Bioengineering System for Prediction and Early Prenosological Diagnostics of Stomach Diseases based on Energy Characteristics of Bioactive Points with Fuzzy Logic
ISSN: 2155-6210
Journal of Biosensors & Bioelectronics

Like us on:

Make the best use of Scientific Research and information from our 700+ peer reviewed, Open Access Journals that operates with the help of 50,000+ Editorial Board Members and esteemed reviewers and 1000+ Scientific associations in Medical, Clinical, Pharmaceutical, Engineering, Technology and Management Fields.
Meet Inspiring Speakers and Experts at our 3000+ Global Conferenceseries Events with over 600+ Conferences, 1200+ Symposiums and 1200+ Workshops on Medical, Pharma, Engineering, Science, Technology and Business

Bioengineering System for Prediction and Early Prenosological Diagnostics of Stomach Diseases based on Energy Characteristics of Bioactive Points with Fuzzy Logic

Riad Taha Al-Kasasbeh1*, Nikolay Korenevskiy2*, Mahdi Alshamasin2 and Dmitry Klionskiy3

1Faculty of Biomedical Engineering, Kursk State Technical University, Russia

2Faculty of Engineering Technology, Al-Balqa Applied University, Jordan

3Saint Petersburg Electrotechnical University "LETI", Saint Petersburg, Russian Federation, Russia

*Corresponding Author:
Riad Taha Al-Kasasbeh
Faculty of Engineering Technology
Al-Balqa Applied University, Jordan
Tel: +962777787972
E-mail: [email protected]

Nikolay Korenevskiy
Faculty of Biomedical Engineering
Kursk State Technical University, Russia
Tel: +7(4712)50-39- 82
E-mail: [email protected]

Received Date: September 09, 2015; Accepted Date: October 02, 2015; Published Date: October 12, 2015

Citation: Al-Kasasbeh RT, Korenevskiy N, Alshamasin M, Klionskiy D (2015) Bioengineering System for Prediction and Early Prenosological Diagnostics of Stomach Diseases based on Energy Characteristics of Bioactive Points with Fuzzy Logic. J Biosens Bioelectron 6:182. doi:10.4172/2155-6210.1000182

Copyright: © 2015 Al-Kasasbeh RT, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Visit for more related articles at Journal of Biosensors & Bioelectronics


We apply mathematical models for the interaction of the internal and biologically active points of meridian structures. Amongst the diseases for which reflex diagnostics are effective are those of the stomach disease. It is shown that use of fuzzy logic decision-making yields good results for the prediction and early diagnosis of stomach diseases, depending on the reaction energy of biologically active points (acupuncture points). It is shown that good results for the prediction and early diagnosis of diseases from the reaction energy of biologically active points (acupuncture points) are obtained by using fuzzy logic decision-making. Analysis of resistances lower and higher than the nominal values allowed us to specify the prognostic and diagnostic models.


Acupuncture points; Fuzzy logic; Reflex diagnostics; Diagnostically important points (DIP); Confidence factors; Membership functions; Stomach diseases


Research conducted by scientists from several academic communities has shown that one possible approach to prediction and early detection of various diseases, including stomach diseases, is reflex diagnostics. This approach is based on measuring energetic characteristics of biologically active points (BAPs) [1-12].

One of the advantages of reflex diagnostic methods is the fact that the response of BAPs to the change in the internal structure of the human body occurs prior to the clinical presentation of a disease. This allows us to detect and treat diseases in their earliest stages and sometimes even avert diseases by taking certain preventive measures. At the same time medical, technical, and time-related costs for arranging research are significantly lower in comparison with traditional approaches [5,9,11,13,4-16].

Materials and Methods

One of the important tasks connected with generating decisionmaking rules is informative feature selection and, in particular, selecting informative BAPs.

Selecting informative BAPs will be more effective if we take into account the way information about the condition of internal structures on these BAPs is displayed. The aforementioned features of “displaying” information include the transmission of a large volume of information (multiple diagnoses, symptoms, and syndromes) to one BAP; cyclic changes of the energetic condition of BAPs during the day even for the normal meridian energy balance; a large amount of data, which has to be analyzed if a pathology is unknown in advance [1,2,6,17-20].

Such features of information transmitted to BAPs impede the selection of informative points in the case of applying traditional methods adopted in the information theory and in the theory of pattern recognition.

Due to the existing peculiarities of representing information about the condition of the human body on BAPs, various methods and algorithms have been suggested [5,15,18].

These methods and algorithms are intended to search for special combinations of BAPs. The analysis of such combinations makes it possible to confirm the diagnosis in question or to refute the diagnosis reflected in BAPs according to reference data, when the disease has not affected a person. The combinations described above are called “diagnostically important points” (DIPs) [5,6,18].

Special research on prediction, early and differential diagnostics of cardiovascular system diseases, diseases of the digestive tract, nervous system diseases, musculoskeletal system diseases, diseases of the respiratory system, etc. has shown that the use of DIPs, in combination with other informative features, enables us to obtain decision rules providing high-quality classification [5,17,21-23].

Multiple investigations by scientists have demonstrated that projective zones and, in particular, BAPs are capable of accumulating and radiating different types of energy: thermal energy, electric energy, electromagnetic energy, etc. The amount of this energy can be determined using both electric and non-electric parameters [2-6,8,9,11-13,23,24].

When selecting parameters that characterize the energetic condition of BAPs we relied upon the accumulated experience and results of our own research. These results made it clear that from the point of view of instrumental resources, manufacturability, and reliability of what we have found, the most suitable parameters are the magnitudes of BAP electric resistance, measured in alternating current with a frequency of 1 kHz and a current strength not exceeding 10 mA. [5,9,14-16,18].

We can find highly informative interval estimates of electric resistances ΔRj,k with the indicated upper and lower bounds of resistances for interval k and point j [5,9,14-16,18]. The works mentioned above also say that relative deviations of the current values of resistances Rj from their nominal values Rjnom are very informative from a medical point of view. These relative deviations are calculated by the following formula:


When solving particular tasks with representative samples, it was established that if we fix measurement modes, sizes, and locations of electrodes and provide identical conditions for measuring both nominal and diagnostic values of electric resistances of BAPs, we will see that when changing the functional or health condition of an examined patient for the set of DIPs, it is possible to observe significant p<0.1 deviations of the measured characteristics from their nominal values [4,5,12-16,17-21,23].

The early (prenosological) stage of diseases is characterized by a decrease in DIP resistances of 20-30%. Mild and moderate degrees of severity lead to a decrease in resistance of 30-60%. The acute phase is distinguished by a decrease in resistance of more than 60% from the initial values. Severe forms of diseases connected with protracted processes are known to have more than 50% increases in the resistance of BAPs in comparison with their initial values. This, both increases and decreases have diagnostic and predictive significance.

Furthermore, it was established that in most cases the quality of diagnosis improves if, in addition to DIPs, other highly informative points connected with the diseases in question are used. As a rule these additional points are indicated by experienced experts, but they can also be found during statistical research, for example, using the Kullback technique [25].

According to the technique adopted in the decision-making theory, after selecting informative features (lists of informative BAPs including DIPs) we need to deal with the problem of choosing adequate mathematical techniques and generating the corresponding decision rules.

The experience of solving various prediction and diagnostic problems with the use of information about the energetic condition of projective zones and, in particular, BAPs has shown that the measurable indices are fuzzy and incomplete for the problem being discussed. Classes employed for decision-making (especially for prediction and early diagnostics) have fuzzy boundaries with overlapping areas, which migrate from one class to another [6,19,23,26,27].

According to the recommendations [5,22,25-33] for generating decision rules it is reasonable to apply decision-making based on fuzzy logic.

The experience of using fuzzy logic for decision-making in medicine, psychology, ecology, and a number of other knowledge domains has confirmed that two areas of fuzzy logic have now become the most popular. These areas are briefly described below.

The first area is based on the fuzzy set theory, when sets are represented by certain membership functions μA(x) for fuzzy set A. The idea behind the construction of fuzzy sets is expounded in the works by Zade [28,30-33,34].

The second area uses special confidence coefficients ωi for hypotheses (predictions, diagnoses, etc.). These coefficients are obtained and calculated with the help of the algorithm suggested by Shortlif [26,30].

In this paper both approaches are employed, but unlike the traditional fuzzy logic of decision-making developed by Zade and relying upon concepts and laws of fuzzy sets, in the present paper we use the concept “membership function” μωl for the investigated classes of conditions ωi . These classes are continuous areas of a multi-dimensional feature space. The construction of fuzzy decision rules for the multidimensional feature space X= (x1,…,xi,…xn) is performed on the basis of aggregate operations. These operations are chosen depending on the structure of data used in an experiment. For the purpose of exploring the structure of multidimensional data and forming recommendations for choosing the type and parameters of membership functions, exploratory analysis is needed [5,18,19,24,28]. This analysis is also indispensable for finding ways of unifying these recommendations.

Several items can be clarified and discovered during the exploratory analysis. Among them are the possibility and reasonability of solving the recognition problem on the basis of its geometrical interpretation; the possibility of linear or piecewise-linear division of classes, existence of nested class structures of the type “ball in a ball”, “ball in a cup”, “ellipsoid in a ball”; existence of class overlapping areas, different types of areas and their structure, etc. [5,20,24,28].

Knowing various characteristics of class structure allows us to select the type of basic variables and characteristics of membership functions in a reasonable way; to obtain partial decision rules for subspaces belonging to the information feature space; to construct the final decision rule from partial decision rules, thus providing the required classification quality. It is important to emphasize that all the operations mentioned above are performed in a scientifically substantiated way due to the availability of class characteristics. The description of the general method needed for generating heterogeneous fuzzy decision rules on the basis of the exploratory analysis is provided in [5,20,24,28]. This method was developed for dealing with the problems of prediction and medical diagnostics.

In order to unify the synthesis of decision rules for diagnostic and prediction problems, the diagnostic problem is considered in this paper as a classification problem with two classes: the examined patient will not become ill in the next T years (class ω0); the examined patient will become ill in the next T years (class ωl).

When choosing informative BAPs and other indices, it is recommended to pay attention to those whose registration increases the confidence in hypothesis ωl (illness) being investigated. According to the recommendations given in [5,26,28] it is reasonable to select the storage iterative formula of E. Shortlif in its two modifications. This formula will be used as a basic one for calculating decision confidence on the basis of hypothesis ωl :

Equation (1)

Equation (2)

Where Equation is the confidence coefficient for hypothesis ωl on condition that i informative features have already been involved in hypothesis testing; Equation is the confidence coefficient in diagnosis (prediction) Equationωl when only one feature xi+1 is used; is the membership function for class Equation with a basic variable with number Equation.

If experts have chosen interval estimates (resistance ranges) ΔRj,k (j is the number of BAP, k is the number of the range ΔR) as the original information, formula (1) will be converted into the expression:

Equation (3)

If preference is given to membership functions for hypotheses Equation ωl, formula (2) will be modified:

Equation (4)

It was shown that due to the specific information represented by each BAP [15,16,31], hypothesis Equation can be confirmed with a large extent of confidence if and only if for all the points from the DIP list, their energetic characteristics (e.g., resistances) exceed the limits established. In other words, Equationexceeds the limit Equation. This means that the onset of diagnostics using rule (2) must be carried out only under the following condition:

If [for all points Yjlonging to DIPs for class Equation resistance Equationexceeds the selected threshold Equation] Then [it is necessary to determine the confidence in the diagnosis (prediction) Equation] Otherwise [confidence in diagnosis (hypothesis) Equation is equal to zero]. (5)

Joining expression (4) with condition (5) we obtain the basic formula for determining confidence coefficients in the investigated diseases Equation according to the response of BAPs:

If Equation Then


Otherwise Equation (6),

Where ∀ is the universal quantifier, Expression (3) can be modified in a similar way.

The technical means used for registering BAP resistance was a special computer device, which exchanges data with a personal computer using the Bluetooth channel. The device operates in two modes: search mode for a point with acoustic, light, and graphical registration of BAPs and measurement mode on a frequency of 1 kHz with a current strength of 5 uA.

In order to estimate the influence of physiological changes caused by stomach diseases upon the electrical resistance of BAPs connected with the investigated class of diseases, a special type of supervision was arranged. The supervision of patients, which lasted for three years, was organized in hospitals located in the town of Kursk (Russian Federation). During the supervision, the resistance of the selected BAPs was measured.

The patients participating in the study had to undergo an examination of stomach conditions. The patients’ complaints were documented and when there were certain indications, fibrogastroduodenoscopy was performed. Those whose stomach pathology was not corroborated were assigned to class “healthy” (ω0). Patients whose pathology was not confirmed during the initial visit, but who developed gastritis or ulcer in the next three years, were assigned to class ωR – high risk of stomach diseases (prediction of stomach diseases). Patients who had early signs of gastritis or ulcer during the initial visit were assigned to class ωP. Using this technique training samples were formed containing 100 persons for each class. In This work it was established that decreasing and increasing the resistances of biologically active points relative to their nominal values has different influence on the decision-making process in stomach disease prediction problem. Analysis of resistances lower and higher than the nominal values allowed us to specify the prognostic and diagnostic models.


The age of the examined patients varied from 18 to 70 years. The total number of men and women was the same (50 persons in each group). The analysis of the well-known meridians atlas showed that stomach diseases were connected with stomach meridian points, spleen-pancreas meridian points, bladder meridian points, etc. It is rather problematic to use all these points in practice and there is usually no medical need for doing this. For this reason after analyzing the whole list of points, it is reasonable to confine ourselves to the set of points applied in practice. In order to form this set we can use the opinion of experienced reflexologists and the availability of points selected for mining knowledge on the informativity of the explored BAPs. This informativity is calculated by techniques adopted in statistical analysis (e.g., Kullback statistical method [25]. The choice of informative BAPs with the subsequent synthesis of decision rules is made on the basis of the following technique. For a training set for all the extracted classes (ω0 , ωR , ωP ) the average values of resistances were determined with the estimation of reliable differences between classes P0P , P0R. The points for which the reliable difference did not exceed 0.05 remained as candidates for becoming informative. Table 1 illustrates the prognostic and diagnostic possibilities of points Е19, Е21, Е22, Е25, Е36.

Class Point
Е19 Е21 Е22 Е25 Е36
Equation 100 100 90 100 120
Equation 61 65 72 63 83
205 189 131 223 284
Equation 58 49 81 54 72
311 293 155 324 392
Equation 0,05 0,05 0,10 0,05 0,01
Equation 0,01 0,01 0,05 0,01 0,001

Table 1: average values of informative point resistances. The points are connected with stomach diseases.

This result coincides with those obtained in works [5,14,18,34] concerning interconnections between stomach diseases, meridian BAPs and auricular points. The only difference is that the extension of the research area in this paper helped us to reveal two trends in the resistance change of BAPs concerning the nominal value RjHOM (persons from class ω0). Some patients from classes’ ωR and ωP are distinguished by reliable (P<0.05) decrease in BAP resistance relative to Rjnom (except for point Е22), which is characteristic of acute inflammatory processes according to previous research. Another category of patients had a reliable (P>0.05) increase in BAP resistance, which implies chronic protracted processes.

The crossover studies which have been conducted have shown that stable deviations in the resistance of informative BAPs from nominal values in both directions mean high probability (P<0.05) of emergence and development of the investigated digestive system diseases. In order to gain this probability we must isolate the groups with decreasing (upper values of the corresponding lines of classes’ Equation in Table 1) and increasing (lower values of the corresponding lines of classes’ Equation in Table 1) resistance values in a training set relative to Rjnom.

In view of the recommendations given, [9,18,21] at the second stage of the research the resistance scales of BAPs were divided into 12 intervals with numbers k, for which diagnostic coefficients were calculated [10,25]:

Equation, (7)

Where Equation is the frequency of the k-th gradation of the j-th point in class ω0 (healthy); Equation is the frequency of the k-th gradation of the j-th point in class ωR (prediction of stomach disease).

Informativity of the k-th gradation of the j-th point Equation was determined with the use of the Kullback criterion [25]:

Equation. (8)

Informativity of the whole scale can be found by the expression

Equation (9)

In Table 2 there are results of diagnostic coefficient calculation, informativity for gradations and points for classes ω0 and ωR in general.

Point Range (kOhm) Equation Equation Equation
1 2 3 4 5
Е19 >500 -4 0,8 25
400...500 0,9 0,05
300...399 4 0,8
200...299 6 1,8
100...199 16 7,5
90...99 16 7,5
80...89 10 4
70...79 5 1,25
60...69 2 0,2
50...59 -1 0,05
<50 -4 0,8
Е21 >500 -6 1,2 18
400...500 -1 0,05
300...399 0,9 0,05
200...299 4 0,8
100...199 13 5,8
90...99 13 5,8
80...89 6 1,8
70...79 3 0,45
60...69 0 0
50...59 -4 0,8
<50 -6 1,2
Е22 >500 -4 0,8 4,85
400...500 -2 0,2
300...399 0 0
200...299 2 0,2
100...199 6 1,2
90...99 6 1,2
80...89 2 0,2
70...79 0,9 0,05
60...69 0 0
50...59 -2 0,2
<50 -4 0,8
  >500 -6 1,2  
400...500 -2 0,2
300...399 0 0
200...299 2 0,2
Е25 100...199 16 7,5 21
90...99 16 7,5
80...89 4 0,8
70...79 0,9 0,05
60...69 -2 0,2
50...59 -5 1,25
<50 -7 2,45
Е36 >500 -7 2,45 25
400...500 -4 0,8
300...399 0,8 0,05
200...299 2 0,2
100...199 17 8
90...99 16 7,5
80...89 3 0,45
70...79 0 0
60...69 -3 0,45
50...59 -6 1,2
<50 -9 3,6

Table 2: Informative BAPs used for predicting the investigated classes of stomach diseases.

In view of low informativity, point Е22 was excluded from the list of informative BAPs.

For the rest of the points, experts had to transform the values of diagnostic coefficients into the values of confidence coefficients Equation. This transformation should occur under the following conditions:

1) Class ωR has negative values of ;

2) Maximal values of confidence coefficients do not exceed the confidence level (which is less than 1) for the points being used;

3) Zero value of a diagnostic coefficient corresponds to same confidence levels for classes’ ω0 and ωR;

4) Maximal positive values of Equation that exceed the threshold values of these coefficients conform to zero values of the corresponding confidence coefficients.

For the conditions listed above, the table of confidence levels was formed at the expert level. The table is intended for predicting the investigated stomach diseases (Table 3). The elements of this table are partial confidence coefficients Equation for a prognostic formula like, for example, formula (3).

Class BAP Resistance ranges, kOhm
>500 400...
ω Е*19 0,6 0,5 0,35 0,2 0 0 0,2 0,3 0,45 0,55 0,6
Е*21 0,65 0,6 0,5 0,25 0 0 0,2 0,35 0,5 0,6 0,65
Е*25 0,65 0,6 0,5 0,25 0 0 0,25 0,5 0,6 0,65 0,7
Е36 0,7 0,6 0,45 0,2 0 0 0,25 0,5 0,65 0,8 0,9

Table 3: Partial confidence coefficients for the prediction of stomach diseases.

When forming this table, experts took into consideration the values of diagnostic thresholds for classes’ ω0 and ωR. The thresholds were calculated relative to Equation according to the following formulas [17]:


Where α is the allowable percentage of errors of the first kind when hypothesis ω0 is taken for hypothesis ωR ; β is the allowable percentage of errors of the second kind when hypothesis ωR is taken for hypothesis ω0.

Having taken α = β = 0.95 the threshold values ± 13 were obtained.

The location of the points selected for the prediction of stomach diseases is shown in Figure 1.


Figure 1: Location of the selected points on the stomach meridian.

The lists of DIPs for the “inclusion” of a fuzzy prognostic decision rule are formed according to the recommendations given in works [5,18]. Following these recommendations taken from the well-known meridian atlases, for example [35], all the cases connected with the selected points X0 are considered – stomach ulcer, acute and chronic gastritis.

E21- a typical point: Х1- diarrhea; Х2- spastic pain in the gut; Х3- loss of appetite.

E22- a typical point: Х1;Х3; - as above; Х4- pain and rumbling in the stomach; Х5- pain around the navel; Х6- violation of the peristaltic intestine; Х7- asthma.

E19- a typical point: Х3; - as above; Х8- liver disease; Х9- lung disease; Х10- pain in epigastric areas; Х11- vomiting; Х12- coughing, shortness of breath; Х13- pain in the chest and back; Х14- bronchial and cordial asthma.

E25- a signal point of the meridian of the colon: Х1, Х5, Х7, Х11; - as above; Х15- dysentery; Х16- constipation; Х17- cholecystitis; Х18- conversion disorder; Х19- endothermy.

E36- a point with a wide spectrum of action: Х1,Х11,Х16; - as above; Х20- pain in epigastric areas;Х21- bloating; Х22- enteritis; Х23- pain in the knee joint and shin; Х24- eye diseases; Х25- fever; Х26- enuresis; Х27- arterial hypertensia; Х28- asthenic condition [5] (Table 4).

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
E19 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
E21 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
E25 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
E36 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

Table 4: Binary table of connections concerning stomach diseases.

The analysis of this table shows that three points E19, E21 and E25 provide the exclusion of all the interfering factors because the product of the columns for these points is equal to zero. These points are available for measuring and are recommended as DIPs. Point E21 has been excluded by experts as uninformative. It has been suggested that point E36 be used as an additional feature because of its high informativity (Figure 1).

Owing to the list of DIPs we have obtained and the calculation results given in Tables 2 and 3, formula (6) can be modified the following way:

If Equation

Equation Then


Otherwise Equation (10)

Where, Equation

As a result of mathematical modeling it was established that for maximal values of partial confidence coefficients, the final confidence in the prediction of the onset of stomach diseases defined by formula (10) exceeds 0.95.

For the most frequent values of resistance on condition of the stable deviation of BAPs resistance from nominal values (“range” 90 kOhm, 200 kOhm) the value Equation exceeds 0.85.

A peculiarity of the energetic characteristics of BAPs and a number of other informative features is the fact that they can change under the influence of one-time, relatively short, perturbing internal and external impacts. After that, if the organism has sufficient adaptation potential, all the features can return to the range of allowable values or stay beyond the scope of the values considered to be normal for a rather long period of time (week, month, year, etc.).

The first case more rarely indicates abnormal deviation of a human body condition, while the second case usually means a high risk of the emergence and development of new diseases, or the diseases that have already affected a person. The longer the time period, in which we can observe the deviation of energetic characteristics from their nominal values, the more confidently we can speak about hypothesis Equation.

It is possible to take into account the duration of energetic characteristic deviation of BAPs from the corresponding nominal values. For this purpose we need formulas for calculating confidence coefficients in hypotheses Equation. It is also necessary to introduce different confidence levels. For example, the first confidence level with its partial decision rules can be linked with conclusions drawn as a result of onetime measurements; the second confidence level can be linked with the results obtained in the presence of a stable trend in measurable parameters exceeding nominal values during the week; the third level exceeding nominal values during two weeks, the fourth one month, etc.

Multiple methods are suitable for estimating the time when electrical characteristics of BAPs are kept beyond the nominal values.

For example, the confidence coefficient for different confidence levels r can be determined by multiplying the confidence coefficient for the first confidence level Equation by the weight coefficient Equation, which depends on the outcome value of the measured resistance Rj beyond the nominal values Dj and the time Equation during which Rj is kept beyond the nominal value. The corrected confidence coefficient is determined by the expression:

Equation (11)

When choosing the values Equation, it is necessary to remember that


Another method is to introduce, in addition to Equation, a membership function Equation for clarifying the term “critical time of a feature location beyond nominal values”. The current value of this function calculated for a particular time during which we can observe the deviation of the resistance Rj from the nominal value can be used for correcting the corresponding confidence coefficient. The improved confidence coefficient can be calculated by the formula:

Equation (12)

In this expression we can see the growth of confidence in Equation with the increasing duration of the BAP energetic characteristic deviation with number j from its nominal value with Equation tending to some upper bound. This bound does not exceed 1 according to the law determined by the parameters of the corresponding membership functions.

The given values of the confidence coefficients were obtained after expert evaluation and mathematical modeling. For a more objective evaluation of a decision-making quality, testing sets were formed and several quality indices were calculated. These indices comprise diagnostic sensitivity, diagnostic specificity, prognostic significance of positive and negative results.

Concerning stomach disease prediction, patients from the emergency hospital in Kursk (Russian Federation) were supervised. At the beginning of the research all the examined patients had to have the resistance of points E19, E21, E25, and E36 measured. The testing sets were obtained the following way. Those patients who were not suffering from stomach diseases were assigned to class ωR. For each class, 100 persons were selected. After one year of medical supervision the accuracy of rule (10) was tested for threshold Equation. The prognostic quality indices were calculated. Finally, using information about classification errors it was established that

PZ+ = n1/(n1+n2)=0,86; PZ– = n3/(n4+n3)=0,82.

In the latter expressions n1 is the number of sick persons who have been classified correctly by a decision rule; n2 is the number of healthy persons who have been classified by a decision rule as sick; n3 is the number of healthy persons who have been classified correctly by a decision rule; n4is the number of sick persons who have been classified by a decision rule as healthy persons.

When modifying expression (10) due to time amendments (expression 11) the value PZ+ is increased to 0.92; the value PZ- is increased to 0.87.

Thus, it was concluded and statistically proven that BAPs E19, E21, E25, and E36 can be used in practical medicine for stomach disease prediction.

The points selected for prediction were investigated as informative features for diagnosing early stomach diseases (class ωp). As in prediction tasks, the points under concern were used for determining diagnostic coefficients Equation and Kullback informativity. The analysis of the results made it clear that unlike the prediction problem, diagnostic coefficients almost linearly and uniformly increase with the deviation of the investigated resistances of BAS from the nominal values provided in Table 1. For this reason and also due to the results obtained during the creation of fuzzy diagnostic decision rules for other diseases (described in [5,14-16,18-21,23]), we decided to choose membership functions for classes ωR and ωp(with basic variables δRj ) as the basic elements of decision rules.

To determine the type and parameters of membership functions Equation according to the recommendations, [6] histograms for classes ω0 and ωP were constructed (using scale δRj ). The example of histograms for classes ω0 and ωP is given in Figure 2.


Figure 2: Histogram for classes ω0 and ωp using the scale δRÅ19.

When proceeding from histogram images for classes to the corresponding membership functions, it was taken into account that the magnitude of a histogram reflects the relative frequency of different values δRj in class ω. The value Equation reflects the confidence in hypothesis ωP for each value of j.

Furthermore, it is necessary to remember that when including Equation in a decision rule for checking hypothesis ωP, the general confidence should not exceed a confidence value produced by experts for the investigated problem if only electrical characteristics of BAPs are used as informative features.

The algorithm operates according to the modified expression (6):


Then Equation

Otherwise Equation (13)

Where Equation

The plots of the corresponding membership functions found by experts are shown in Figure 3 [5,6].


Figure 3: Plots of the membership functions: а) μωpEquation with a basic variable δRE19; б) Equation with a basic variable δRE21; B) Equation with a basic variable δRE25;г) Equation for the class «early stage of stomach diseases» (class ωp).

These plots correspond to the following analytical expressions:





By means of mathematical modeling it was found that for maximal values of all the membership functions the value of the confidence coefficient determined by expression (13) reaches 0.9 for the most frequent values of BAP resistances Equation

For statistical evaluation of the decision rule quality two testing sets were formed: ω0 is the class of persons who do not have stomach diseases; ωP is the class of persons who have an early stage of stomach diseases. Patients were diagnosed with the use of traditional methods of examination (fibrogastroduodenoscopy), without considering electrical characteristics of BAPs.

As a result of checking for the threshold CCThr = 0,5 the following results were found: DSen = n1/nP = 0,91; DSpec = n1/n0= 0,89, where nP = n0 = 100 is the number of people in a testing set in classes ω0and ωP respectively [5].

When using correcting time amendments (rule (11)) the indices of diagnostic sensitivity and specificity exceed 0.95.

The outcome of the research can be summarized as follows: first, a rather good coincidence between expert evaluation, mathematical modeling, and statistical tests was shown; second, when the corresponding quality indices are rather high, it is possible to recommend the results from the paper for further investigation and application [5].


In contemporary medical practice there is a growing interest in traditional oriental methods of reflexodiagnostics and relexotherapy based upon the teaching about meridian energy balance of the body.

However, the fact that a large number of reflexotherapists use a traditional oriental conceptual apparatus, which does not coincide with contemporary medical terminology of anatomy, physiology, and biophysics diminishes medical confidence in this area of medical practice.

Another obstacle in the way of a wider and more effective use of reflexodiagnostics and reflexotherapy techniques is the lack of well-developed theoretical fundamentals that reveal the interaction mechanism of internal organs with meridian structures located on the surface of a human body. This problem dramatically decreases the potential capabilities of acupuncture. Furthermore, by using theoretical uncertainty, a great number of practicing reflexotherapists are known to exaggerate the potential of acupuncture, which leads to partial errors and discredits the corresponding approach to diagnostics and treatment.

The problems specified in the paper, as well as a number of other problems of acupuncture are eliminated to a large extent due to the research results obtained by the team of authors in Russia, Germany, and Jordan. All this prolonged and laborious work was made possible thanks to the financial support provided by the DFG fund. During the research several new mathematical models were offered. These models reflect the interaction between internal organs and BAPs of meridian structures: table models, models on the basis of the graph theory, models obtained by the automatic control theory methods, and multilevel models.

Analysis of the models mentioned above allowed us to specify the range of diseases for which reflexodiagnostics and reflexotherapy are the most effective methods. Computer implementation of such models provides precise solution of prediction tasks and helps experts achieve an early diagnosis of fundamental diseases, combined diseases, and coexistent diseases, when clinical manifestations are almost unobservable or undetectable by other techniques. When the diagnosis has already been established, the analysis of meridian models enables us to specify the degree of severity, prediction of the exacerbation and possible outcome of a disease. At the stage of reflexotherapy, the analysis of energy imbalance of meridian models makes it possible to construct rational schemes of impact on BAPs excluding harmful side effects on different organs and systems, which are in complex hierarchical interaction with an impact point.

A rather large number of prediction and diagnostic tasks, which are solved on the basis of information about the energetic condition of projective zones and, in particular, BAPs, showed that the measurable indices are fuzzy and incomplete for the problems under consideration. Classes used for decision-making (especially for prediction and early diagnostics) have fuzzy boundaries with overlapping areas, which migrate from one class to another. In these conditions for the purpose of creating the corresponding decision rules, it is reasonable to use the fuzzy logic theory of decision-making, when energetic characteristics of BAPs used for decision-making for class ωl are represented by membership functions or partial confidence coefficients relative to the considered hypothesis ωl.

In this paper we have shown that the best quality of decisionmaking is provided if the synthesis of fuzzy decision rules is carried out according to exploratory analysis intended for studying various features of data. Then these features contribute to the choice of the form and parameters of partial decision rules (membership functions of Zade and confidence coefficients of E. Shortlif) and the methods of transformation in final decision-making rules.

By means of numerous investigations it was shown that projective zone and, in particular, BAPs are capable of accumulating and radiating different types of energy: thermal, electrical, electromagnetic, etc. The amount of this energy can be determined via electrical and non-electrical parameters.

By choosing parameters characterizing the energetic condition of BAPs we proceeded from the experience we have gained and our own findings. They indicated that from the point of view of instrumental errors, manufacturability, and reliability of the results, the most suitable parameters are electrical resistances of BAPs measured in alternating current of low frequency.

This paper contains information about the way the prediction problem can be solved and how it is possible to deal with the need for early diagnosis of stomach diseases using the suggested information processing techniques. Checking on testing sets with 100 persons for each class formed by highly-qualified experts showed that the diagnostic effectiveness of the solution exceeds 0.85. Such a result permits us to recommend the decision rules we have developed for practical application. Furthermore, with the use of the suggested models and techniques of constructing fuzzy decision rules, the following problems have been solved: prediction, diagnosis, and prophylaxis of various diseases that affect the respiratory system, the digestive system, the skin, etc. In all these cases it was shown that for minimal resources of hardware and time, there was an increase in the effectiveness of decisions in the case of observing sick patients with the corresponding pathology. This increase is the reason we can recommend the results for medical practice in decision-making support systems.

After testing the specified models on testing sets it was established that the prediction quality increased by 5% and early diagnostics by 4% in comparison with the previously published author’s works [1-5].


We would like to thank Al-Balqa' Applied University for their support, DFG Germany for the initial data, South West State University, Russia, for clinical tests and The Higher Council for Science and Technology, Jordan for their logistic aid.


Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language
Post your comment

Share This Article

Article Usage

  • Total views: 12910
  • [From(publication date):
    December-2015 - Jan 28, 2020]
  • Breakdown by view type
  • HTML page views : 9046
  • PDF downloads : 3864