Received date: March 13, 2015; Accepted date: June 29, 2015; Published date: July 06, 2015
Citation: Azab SN, Kamel A, Abdelrhman SS (2015) Correlation between Anxiety Related Emotional Disorders and Language Development in Hearing-Impaired Egyptian Arabic Speaking Children. Commun Disord Deaf Stud Hearing Aids 3:137. doi:10.4172/2375-4427.1000137
Copyright: © 2015 Azab SN, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Communication Disorders, Deaf Studies & Hearing Aids
Background: Hearing is critical for normal development and acquisition of language and speech and Hearing impairment exists when there is diminished sensitivity to the sounds normally heard. Several studies have suggested that one out of every two to three school-aged children with any degree of hearing impairment have academic, social, and behavioral difficulties. Purpose: To compare the degree of hearing loss regarding the Anxiety Related Emotional Disorders of hearing-impaired children and then correlate this to language scale. Methods: 75 divided equally to three groups, mild, moderate and severe hearing impaired Egyptian Arabic speaking children aged between 6 to 8 years were included in this study and were subjected to psychometric evaluation, audiological assessment, Arabic language scale, and The Screen for Child Anxiety Related Emotional Disorders (SCARED) questionnaire (Arabic version). Results: Hearing-impaired children showed more language, emotion difficulties, and spent less time communicating than children with normal hearing. The lowest academic, social, and emotional scores were in severe hearing impaired group than in the other two groups. Conclusion: Even slight/mild hearing impairment can result in negative consequences in the psychological, social, and emotional and there is significant relationship between delayed language, anxiety, and child emotional related problems. Without appropriate interventions, these children are at risk of developing mental health disorders.
Hearing impairment; Psychological; Anxiety; Emotions; Language; Speech
Hearing, auditory perception, or audition is the ability to perceive sound by detecting vibrations changes in the pressure of the surrounding medium through time, through an organ such as the ear . Hearing is critical for normal development and acquisition of language and Speech . Hearing impairment exists when there is diminished sensitivity to the sounds normally heard . According to Smith, the term hearing impairment is usually reserved for people who have relative insensitivity to sound in the speech frequencies . The severity of a hearing impairment is categorized according to the increase in volume above the usual level necessary before the listener can detect it. Along the world approximately one child in 1,000 is hearing impaired from birth, and the number rises to about 1.6 per 1,000 in adolescents. The causes are hereditary in 30-39%, acquired in 19-30% and the cause remains unknown in 31-48% of children . Language plays a central role in development. It is not only the medium for social exchange, but aids in internalizing social norms and the development of behavioral control . Hearing impaired children do not acquire language and speech the same as normal hearing children because they cannot hear the language spoken around them. In normal language acquisition, auditory comprehension precedes the development of language . So children who have hearing impairment as they move into school are at risk of a raft of difficulties. Impacts of poor oral language skills go well beyond early literacy development and ‘school readiness’s to increasingly apparent associations with emotional, behavioral and social difficulties . Hearing impaired children can be viewed as being different from the majority because of their observable hearing aids, use of sign language, and/or their distinct speech production. Moreover, hearing impaired children's language problems and impaired socially skilled behaviors have been frequently reported. Refs [9,10] reports that school-aged children who are hearing impaired may be as much as five times more likely to suffer from emotional disturbance, defined as a pattern of behavior that deviates from the acceptable patterns of behavior in school that impact their ability to maintain normal social relationships. Questionnaires are frequently used in quantitative marketing research and social research. They are a valuable method of collecting a wide range of information from a large number of individuals, often referred to as respondents. Adequate questionnaire construction is critical to the success of a survey .
The aim of this work is to compare between the different degrees of hearing loss regarding the Anxiety Related Emotional Disorders of hearing-impaired children and then correlate the data to their language scale.
This research was conducted during the period between the months November 2013 and September 2014. The study protocol was approved by the Otolaryngology Department Council of Beni-Suif University. Consent to participate in this research was obtained from the subjects' parents before commencement of the study. This study was applied on 75 child, 53 males and 22 females. Their ages ranged from [72 m (6 years) to 93 m (7 years and 3 m)] with a mean (81.15 ± 5.53) diagnosed as hearing impairment. They were divided into three equal groups each one consists of 25 patients.
Group A (mild hearing impairment) consisted of 16 males and 9 females with age range (72 m-93 m) with a mean (80.08 ± 5.83).
Group B (moderate hearing impairment) consisted of 19 males and 6 females with age range (72 m-90 m) with a mean( 82.96 ± 5.22).
Group C (severe hearing impairment) consisted of 18 males and 7 females with age range (72 m-90 m) with a mean( 80.40 ± 5.29). The subjects were randomly selected from a group of typically developing Egyptian children in Nurseries and schools in Beni-Suef city area. All children were coming from Families of moderate socio-economic status. They were all reported to be free from profound hearing impairment (>90 db) or those with cochlear implantation, hearing impairment with other psychological disorder (Autism, ADHD), neurological or physical handicap e.g. BDMH (brain damage motor handicap) and serious medical/chronic problems.
The children were diagnosed as sensorineural or conductive hearing loss: (Mild-moderate-moderate to severe and severe), all the children were fitted with either unilateral or bilateral hearing aids (according to their audiological needs) with regular use and follow up and with minimum two years ago. Arabic spoken as a primary language (monolingual Arabic-speaking family, where Arabic is the primary language) and regular use of satisfactory hearing aids and language rehabilitation sessions twice 20 minutes per week for minimum one year.
All children were subjected to the following protocol of assessment:
Audiological assessment: Many formal audiologic testing to determine the type and etiology of hearing loss and the optimal treatment plan, such as, e.g. Auditory Brainstem Response (ABR) and Pure Tone Audiometry to measure the degree of hearing impairment then classify them accordingly to mild 20-40 dB, moderate 41-70 dB and sever 71-95 dB.
Psychometric and cognitive assessment by Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales Fourth Edition (SB: FE): .
Language assessment by Language scales .
Screen for Child Anxiety Related Emotional Disorders (SCARED): The Questionnaire was translated to Arabic language and back-translated by two of the psychiatric staff.Then pilot study was done for checking and be sure of its reliability although it is already applied on normal hearer attending to psychiatry department faculty of medicine Beni-Sweif University, so, there was no mandatory need for control group. The SCARED has 41 sentences describing various feelings and behaviors possibly associated with anxiety symptoms . The SCARED was chosen to measure the children for anxiety disorder SCARED could significantly discriminate between anxious and depressed children. Items that can be grouped into five subscales. Four of these subscales measure anxiety disorder symptoms as conceptualized in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders DSM-IV-TR: panic disorder, generalized anxiety disorder, separation anxiety disorder, and social anxiety. The SCARED questionnaire in this study rated each symptom on a 3-point scale: 0 (no), 1 (sometimes), or 2 (yes).The subscales of the questionnaire are: panic disorder (13 items), generalized anxiety disorder (9 items), separation anxiety disorder (8 items), and social anxiety (4 items), and school anxiety (4 items). A total score of ≥ 25 may indicate the presence of an Anxiety Disorder. Scores higher that 30 are more specific.
A score of 7 for items 1, 6, 9, 12, 15, 18, 19, 22, 24, 27, 30, 34, 38 may indicate Panic Disorder or Significant Somatic Symptoms.
A score of 9 for items 5, 7, 14, 21, 23, 28, 33, 35, 37 may indicate Generalized Anxiety Disorder.
A score of 5 for items 4, 8, 13, 16, 20, 25, 29, 31 may indicate Separation Anxiety Disorder.
A score of 8 for items 3, 10, 26, 32, 39, 40, 41 may indicate Social Anxiety Disorder.
A score of 3 for items 2, 11, 17, 36 may indicate Significant School Avoidance.
The data was collected, coded and entered to computer. The data was analyzed with the program (SPSS) statistical package for social science version 16 under windows 7. Statistical tests used in this thesis were: description of qualitative variables by frequency and percentage, description of quantitative variables in the form of mean and standard deviation (mean ± SD) and Chi-square (x2) test was used for comparison of qualitative variables with each other. Comparison between quantitative variables was carried by using Student t-test of two independent samples while ANOVA test was used for more than two independent samples. The differences were considered significant if p<0.05. Spearman-rho method was used to test correlation between numerical variables (r > 0.3=no correlation, r=0.3-0.5=fair correlation, r=0.5-0.1=good correlation).
Sex and age distribution for each group regarding mean and SD show no significant difference. Table 1 shows that there is significant difference between the three groups A, B and C (mild, moderate and sever hearing impairment) as regard the total language age.
|Item||Groups||N||Mean||Std. Deviation||P value and sig.|
|Total language age||A||25||58.08||7.5||0.001 (S)|
|Total language age||A||25||58.08||7.5||0.0001(S)|
|Total language age||B||25||50.56||7.927||0.0001(S)|
Table 1: Significant difference between the three groups A, B and C (mild, moderate and severe hearing impairment) as regard the total language age.
Also, there is significant difference between the three groups A, B and C (mild moderate and sever hearing impairment) as regard the IQ (Table 2).
|Item||Groups||N||Mean||Std. Deviation||Pvalue and sig.|
Table 2: Significant difference between the three groups A, B and C (mild, moderate and sever hearing impairment) as regard the IQ scores.
Figure 1 shows the subtypes of Child Anxiety Related Emotional Disorders (SCARED) test regard no. and % shows significant difference between the three groups A, B and C (mild, moderate and severe HI) in generalized and social disorders (p=0.0001).
Figure 1: Subtypes of anxiety test regard no. and % shows significant difference between the three groups A, B and C (mild, moderate and sever hearing impairment) in generalized and social disorders (Value=0.0001) and there was no significant difference between the three groups in panic (Value=0.353), separation and school avoidance disorders (Value=0.191)
There was no significant difference between the three groups in panic (p=0.353), separation and school avoidance disorders (p=0.191).
Figure 2 shows significant positive correlation between all children chronological ages (the three groups A, B and C) and their total language ages (R=0.0288).
Figure 3 shows highly significant positive correlation between IQ scores of all children (the three groups A, B and C) and their total language ages (R=0.716).
Figure 4 shows negative correlation between total language ages and Child Anxiety Related Emotional Disorders (SCARED) (R=-0.197).
Figure 5 shows significant negative correlation between anxiety scores and IQ total scores (R=0.422) of all children (the three groups A, B and C).
Hearing is critical for normal development and acquisition of language and speech. Hearing impairment in children may affect the development of behavior and language and can cause work related difficulties for adults . Hearing loss brings with it some emotions and psychological problems before acceptance of the loss. These emotions can include denial and anger, as well as a sense of isolation . All children with different degrees of hearing impairment had delayed language development and this can be explained by the interference of hearing impairment with the child detection and recognition of speech as well as the development of auditory skills that are prerequisites of the development of receptive and expressive language skills, as well as speech intelligibility . Such auditory skills include detection, discrimination, recognition, comprehension, and attention and in turn, a delay in the early development of these auditory skills caused by hearing loss negatively impacts child's ability to learn and use an auditory-oral language system . Strong positive associations between the degree of hearing impairment and language skills were proved and mild hearing impaired children had better receptive and expressive language than the other two groups. So there total language ages were highest than the other two groups.
These results were also found by Halliday and Bishop  who discovered that even subtle deficits in sound processing can lead to marked impairments in language development and severe hearing impairment in childhood often leads to marked delays and deficits in the acquisition of spoken and written language. However, children with mild hearing impairment usually attend regular schools and communicate with the others and when these children receive hearing aids, they usually find that school is easier and their school performance improves. But the other two groups entail not only lowered hearing thresholds, but also distortion of sounds, and this means that language input is partial and degraded in spite of the significant positive correlation between the children chronological ages and their total language ages, the older the child age, the higher the speech perception abilities whatever the degree of hearing impairment and the higher its ability to learn .
Children intelligence quotient (IQ) scores and their determinants are generally considered predictors of eventual school performance, quality of life, and psychiatric morbidity. Focusing on the relationships between the cognitive assessment (IQ) and the three groups of the study, it will be found that IQ scores range between below average and dull average in hearing impaired children whatever the degree of hearing impairment with strong positive associations between the IQ score and the degree of hearing impairment as mild hearing impaired children have higher IQ than the other two group which is in agreement with Welch D, Dawes PJ (2007) who discovered that even slight to mild hearing loss (<30 db) has been documented to have life-long effects.
Among children with losses <15 db HL i.e., whose hearing is considered normal, some research has found that slight fluctuations in auditory perception affect neurocognitive outcomes . Children with severe hearing impairment may have a higher frequency of poor cognitive and academic performance when compared with children with mild or even moderate hearing impairment. Also the descriptive analysis shows highly significant positive correlation between cognitive assessment (IQ) and total language ages in the hearing impaired children, the higher the language age the higher the IQ score. As primary reasons why students with hearing deficits perform, on average, lower than their peers on cognitive assessments such as IQ tests, language and communication skills of these hearing impaired children are often delayed due to their disability and these students’ language skills and reading level are lower than average, which may also affect cognitive skills which was proved by Gallaudet Research Institute (2003) who proved that an estimated 40% of children with hearing loss have additional impairments that affect education and adaptive development and children with hearing impairment may have a higher frequency of language problem and had signiﬁcantly lower intelligence coefficients when compared with children with normal hearing .
The descriptive analysis shows that hearing impaired children - whatever the degree of hearing impairment fell lonely event if they are mild hearing impaired without significant different between the three groups because children feel that they are different from their peers and start to avoid them. Also limited access to services and exclusion from communication can have a significant impact on everyday life, causing feelings of loneliness, isolation. So, even slight/mild hearing impairment can result in negative consequences for the bio psychosocial development of children who often report feeling lonely, without friends and unhappy in school . Anxiety is a normal human emotion that everyone experiences at times. Many people feel anxious, or nervous, when faced with a problem at work, before taking a test, or making an important decision. Anxiety disorders, however, are different; they can cause such distress that it interferes with a person's ability to lead a normal life . Hearing impaired children with anxiety disorders had an increased physical and psychological reaction to stress. Their reaction to danger, even if it is a small one, is quicker and stronger . Research question investigated the feeling of anxiety in hearing impaired children and the analysis shows that the three groups has different degrees of anxiety feeling and each group shows number of children with anxiety. Mild hearing impaired children have less anxiety feeling than the other two groups. Mild hearing impaired children have less disability and better communication than the other two groups which lead to less stress and anxiety disorder so the results is expected. Knutson et al.  found that the risk for clinically significant emotional distress and anxiety disorder (generalized anxiety disorder, social, separation, school avoidant disorder, and panic disorder; each has its own characteristics and symptoms) was two to four times higher among persons with hearing impairment than among persons with normal hearing. These results were also founded by Castrogiovanni  who found that school-aged children with any degree of hearing impairment have academic, social, emotional and behavioral difficulties because hearing impaired children, even with a minor degree, often miss information during play and are a target for bullying (person who is curl to other).
Strong negative correlation between language and cognitive scale with anxiety disorder is expected that hearing impaired children, who experience significant disruptions in auditory input, are likely to show delays not only in the production of oral language but in other important aspects of development such as anxiety, emotion and behavioral control. With regard to socio-emotional aspects, Zandberg  studies have reported that hearing impaired children encounter difficulties acquiring spoken language, which often affects their communication abilities and social development. In turn, the children’s friendship relations and social feelings and mild hearing impaired children have better language and cognitive scale than moderate or severe ones and the more the affected the child with hearing impairment the more the behavior problem and anxiety disorder or even other psychological interruptions. In addition to a small samples size, the limitations differed across a variety of factors such as duration of deafness, previous degree of benefit from hearing aids, mode of communication, device settings, and age.
Children with hearing impairment-whatever its degree-face multiple concurrent health, developmental, communicative and exhibit anxiety and emotional problems when they do not understand what is going on around them. Without appropriate interventions, these children are at risk of developing mental health disorders.