Drexel University College of Medicine Institutional Review Board, USA
Received date: February 01, 2016; Accepted date: March 25, 2016; Published date: March 31, 2016
Citation: Allen HB, Warner AC, Joshi SG (2016) Eczema: A Proposed Reclassification Based on the Signature Pathology Finding of Occluded Sweat Ducts. J Clin Exp Dermatol Res 7:344. doi: 10.4172/2155-9554.1000344
Copyright: © 2016 Allen HB, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Clinical & Experimental Dermatology Research
Occluded sweat ducts are the hallmark of miliaria. The occlusions were thought to be due to biofilm or “slime” producing Staphylococcus epidermidis. Sulzberger first saw occluded ducts in eczema and 60 years later, these were rediscovered and shown to be due to many different species of staphylococci, including S. aureus, epidermidis, tenuis and many others. These occlusions also trigger the activation of the innate immune system, and this, while trying to attack and destroy the staphylococcal organisms, begins the cascade of events leading to the signs and symptoms of the many various forms of eczema. We propose a classification of these diseases as atopic eczema, seborrheic eczema, and others to unify these lesions with occluded ducts. Further, we propose a treatment protocol that addresses both the genetic and environmental “hits” in this classical “double-hit” disease.
Diseases in the past have been descriptively named or named for their first or most important observers, or for their pathology. Examples of those would be erythema multiforme for descriptive, Alzheimer’s disease for name based, and angiolymphoid hyperplasia with eosinophilia for pathology based. We propose that the diseases which have occluded sweat ducts as part of their pathology be included under the broad heading of eczema. For instance, atopic dermatitis would be atopic eczema and Meyerson’s nevus would be nevoid eczema. These would tie together all these diseases which have occluded ducts in their pathology as well as itching as their main symptom.
Recently, sixty years after the original observation, the pathology of eczema was shown to have occluded eccrine sweat ducts in addition to the characteristic spongiotic dermatitis . These ductal occlusions consisted of biofilms made by cutaneous, normal flora staphylococci, all of which contained a gene to make biofilms;  and, similar to miliaria (the prototypical ductal occlusion disease), these biofilms triggered both the clinical symptoms and the subsequent pathological findings of the disease . The occluded ducts can be visualized on routine staining and documented as biofilms by periodic acid Schiff and Congo red stains. (Figure 1). The bacteria can be seen with gram stain and can be recovered by routine cultures.
The biofilms themselves consisted of extracellular polysaccharides enclosing DNA, staphylococcal organisms, water channels, and amyloid fibers . The staphylococci produce these biofilms in response to the salt and water present in the sweat ducts . The “curli” fibers associated with the amyloid attract activated Toll-like receptor 2 (TLR2) initiates the MyD88 pathway in an attempt to destroy the gram positive staphylococci . TLR 2 also activates the PAR 2 (proteinase activated receptor 2) pathway that leads to the initial symptom of pruritus in the disease [7,8]. The MyD88 pathway generates NFκB and TNFα, and TNFα is the strongest stimulant for producing spongiosis .
Eczema has been called the “itch” that rashes,  and all the foregoing (occluded ducts, biofilms, and TLR2) lead to that “itch”. Recent work suggests that once the basement membrane is breached, the adaptive immune system (especially IL 31) enters the picture and creates even more intense itching . Consequently, both arms of the immune system are involved in this autoimmune disease: the innate arm is first and begins in the epidermis, and the adaptive is second and begins in the dermis.
Eczema has been postulated to be a double-hit phenomenon with the filaggrin gene (or other genes yielding a defective stratum corneum ) representing the genetic component and the biofilmproducing staphylococci the environmental hit .
Many different presentations of eczema exist and sometimes overlap. The traditional, largely age dependent atopic dermatitis presentations of facial extensor, flexural, and nummular all show occluded ducts and activation of the innate immune system. Similarly, dyshidrotic eczema, and the recently described lichen planus-like eczema also show those signature findings [12,13].
Surprisingly, seborrheic dermatitis, axillary granular parakeratosis, and tinea pedis have shown occluded ducts with the biofilm generated by staphylococci and TLR2 activation . The main difference in these diseases, when compared to atopic dermatitis, was the stratum corneum was rendered defective not by a gene as in the more familiar presentations of eczema, but by yeasts in seborrheic dermatitis, granules in granular parakeratosis, and dermatophytes in tinea pedis .
Occluded ducts are also a feature of Meyerson’s nevus and Doucas Kapetanakis pigmented purpuric dermatosis . Meyerson’s nevus is a melanocytic nevus with a halo of eczema surrounding it. Doucas Kapetanakis disease is pigmented purpuric dermatosis combined with eczema. It is also known as “itching” purpura. Both these disease are supposed to have eczema as a component of their pathogenesis, and, in fact, they both display the ductal occlusions that now, more fully, define the disease.
It was Sulzberger in 1947 who saw the occluded duct in eczema , and it was he who championed calling eczema atopic dermatitis . He did this in an attempt to simplify the diagnosis because of the multiplicity of names extant at that time. It is therefore with some trepidation that we propose the following for all the diseases listed in Table 1 with occluded eccrine sweat ducts as the underlying pathological finding of each.
|Atopic eczema||facial extensor and flexural|
|Nummular eczema||coin-shaped lesions|
|Dyshidrotic eczema||hands and feet|
|Lichen planus-like eczema||purple papular rash|
|Seborrheic eczema||face and scalp|
|Granular parakeratotic eczema||axillae (and other sites)|
|Juvenile plantar eczema||childhood foot disease|
|Pigmented purpuric eczema||DoucasKepetanakis|
|Nevoid eczema||Meyerson’s nevus|
Table 1: Showing occluded eccrine sweat ducts as the underlying pathological finding of each.
Pityriasis alba could possibly be included as facial eczema but most already consider it associated with eczema. It has its own distinctive clinical presentation and in unlikely to be mistakenly identified.
Regarding the genetic “hit” in the double-hit phenomenon: with care taken to treat the stratum corneum very kindly, the treatment with topical corticoids is more easily and more rapidly effective . The subsequent prevention of the disease with exceedingly gentle skin care (minimal to no soap, no scrubbing, less frequent bathing, and more moisturizing) is remarkable. All caregivers have to be involved with this approach, but it is apparent this is most beneficial . Those that eschew this approach very frequently have continuing troublesome disease. Also, of note, is this is a way to counteract the impact of the “genetic” side of the disease, which is a “rare” opportunity indeed. Bleach baths, or the use of bleach containing gel, may be considered along with the aforementioned. Bleach is a biofilm dispersing agent which also is capable of killing planktonic (free floating) microbes . Petrolatum itself, previously thought to be inert, has recently been shown to have antimicrobial capability .
The addition of oral antibiotics is fraught with difficulty because all the staphylococci are multidrug resistant and 60% are MRSA or MRSE . Other antibacterial substances such as silver as in silver sulfadiazine, iodinated compounds, and zinc containing products may also have a place in the topical therapeutic armamentarium. The administration of antimetabolites, or immunosuppressives, or biologics would only be considered as a last resort .
We have presented a modest reclassification of eczema based on the signature pathology of occluded sweat ducts. We have also included some therapeutic maneuvers to counteract this pathology and lead both to clinical improvement and prevention of this disease in all its forms.