Efficacy and Safety of a New Topical Hair Loss-Lotion Containing Oleanolic Acid, Apigenin, Biotinyl Tripeptide-1, Diaminopyrimidine Oxide, Adenosine, Biotin and Ginkgo biloba in Patients with Androgenetic Alopecia and Telogen effluvium: A Six-month Open-Label Prospective Clinical Study
Received Date: Mar 02, 2018 / Accepted Date: Mar 27, 2018 / Published Date: Apr 02, 2018
Objective: The causes of hair loss are multifactorial; therefore, there are multiple potential targets for treatment, and a combination of different active ingredients can be helpful in managing the condition. Androgenetic alopecia and telogen effluvium comprise two of the main types of hair loss, and differ in their pathophysiology. The objective of the study was to evaluate, in male and female individuals with androgenetic alopecia and telogen effluvium, the safety and efficacy of a new hair loss lotion containing a combination of cosmetic ingredients: oleanolic acid, apigenin, biotinyl tripeptide-1, 2-4diamino pyrimidine-3-oxide, adenosine, Ginkgo biloba, and biotin.
Methods: 56 patients with androgenetic alopecia (AGA) or telogen effluvium (TE) completed the study. For 6 months, the product was applied once-daily before bed and left on overnight. Efficacy and safety assessments took place at baseline, 3 months and 6 months. Efficacy was assessed in three ways: phototrichogram to count the total number of hairs and number and of hairs in telogen and anagen, visual clinical assessment by a dermatologist using a 7 point scale that evaluated hair volume/thickness, scalp coverage and overall hair appearance, and patient opinion questionnaire on the effects and additional qualities of the product.
Results: In the whole study sample, the total number of hairs and number of anagen hairs increased significantly (p<0.05). In the subgroup with TE, there was a significant increase in total hairs, and in the AGA subgroup there was a significant increase in total hairs and anagen hairs. On visual clinical assessment, 35.7% of participants were evaluated as having thicker, more voluminous hair, 37.5% had improved general hair appearance and 39.3% had improved scalp coverage. On patient questionnaire, participants reported a reduction in hair loss (79%), increased confidence regarding their hair (86%) and that their hair problem was less visible (79%). The product was rated positively by 100% of participants for texture, smell, and hair condition. There were no adverse events.
Conclusion: This lotion enriched with a mixture of oleanolic acid, apigenin, biotinyl tripeptide-1, 2-4 diamino pyrimidine-3-oxide, adenosine, Ginkgo biloba, and biotin is safe and effective as a topical hair-loss treatment, as proven by the statistically significant increase in total hair fibers and anagen hairs, the increased thickness and scalp coverage on dermatological assessment, and patient self-assessment.
Keywords: Hair loss; Alopecia, Telogen effluvium; Androgenetic alopecia; Topical treatment; Oleanolic acid; Apigenin; Biotinyl tripeptide-1; Diaminopyrimidine oxide; Adenosine; Biotin
As patients and dermatologists will testify, the aesthetic effects of dermato-trichological conditions are often the most devastating. For many men and women, having a full head of hair represents physical attractiveness and youthfulness, and hair loss can have significant negative effects on self-esteem and quality of life [1,2]. Androgenetic alopecia (AGA) and telogen effluvium (TE) are two of the most common causes of hair loss in men and women, with differing pathophysiologies but similar symptoms. To date only two therapeutic drugs have been approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the European Medicines Agency (EMA) for the treatment of AGA: oral finasteride and topical minoxidil 2% and 5%.
Systemic treatments or surgical options may be unsuitable or undesirable due to potential side effects, expense, or invasiveness . Topical drugs and cosmetics can provide a safe alternative or adjuvant to systemic drug treatment, reducing the potential side effects. In hair cosmetics, one of the keys to successful treatment is finding the most effective combination of actives and taking advantage of their different mechanisms of action. The right combination, targeting the multifactorial causes of hair loss, can improve penetration and achieve faster results. Amongst the newest actives is the combination of oleanolic acid, apigenin, and biotinyl tripeptide-1; this combination of actives improves cellular metabolism and microcirculation, and inhibits 5α-reductase [4,5]. Diaminopyrimidine oxide is a compound chemically related to minoxidil that works against perifollicular fibrosis [6,7]. Adenosine promotes expression of several growth factors  biotin is a vitamin used frequently in hair and nail disease that assists in numerous metabolic reactions involved in fatty acid synthesis  and Ginkgo biloba is a potent antioxidant with anti-inflammatory properties  and improves microcirculation . Besides the clinical effects of such treatments, it is also important that they be pleasant to use in terms of additional effects on the condition of the hair and the cosmetic properties: patients are unlikely to adhere to unpleasant treatments.
We studied the effects of a topical lotion containing a combination of oleanolic acid, apigenin and biotinyl tripeptide-1, diaminopyrimidine oxide, adenosine, biotin, and Ginkgo biloba for the treatment of telogen effluvium and androgenetic alopecia.
Participants: The study included 56 male and female patients aged 25-50 years. Diagnosed by a dermatologist with as having androgenetic alopecia or telogen effluvium by a dermatologist (Figure 1). Severity of hair loss was assessed in patients with androgenetic alopecia using the Hamilton scale for men and the Ludwig scale for women; severity of telogen effluvium was not assessed. Participants were otherwise healthy, with healthy skin at the test region and no history of allergy or atopy, and who washed their hair at least three times per week. The study excluded individuals using hair extensions, or hair straightening within 3 months prior to the study, as well as those with any immunodeficiency, those using systemic or topical steroids or retinoids, and pregnant or breastfeeding women. None of the participants were taking conventional or alternative treatments for hair loss, including 5-reductase inhibitors, minoxidil, or nutritional supplements. All participants provided signed informed consent. The study was conducted in accordance with Brazilian legislation, following Brazilian resolution No. 466/2012, adhering to good clinical practice guidelines (ICH E6 R1 (CPMP/ICH/135/95)) and the Declaration of Helsinki and its successive updates. The internal ethics committee at the research institution (IPclin Instituto de Pesquisa Integrada Ltda. Jundiai, Brazil) approved the study.
To simulate normal use, participants applied the product to their scalp at home, in accordance with the product’s instructions for use: the product was applied once per day, before bed, and left on overnight. During the study, participants were instructed to not use any hair treatments that could affect hair loss, and not to change their usual hair hygiene habits, diet, exercise routine, or contraceptive method. Anti-inflammatories, antihistamines, immunosuppressive and retinoids were prohibited during the study.
A medical assessment for adverse events was performed at D0, D90 and D180. A dermatologist assessed for erythema, edema, vesicles, papules, macules, crust, dryness, and dyschromia, and participants were questioned about any feelings of discomfort, such as burning or stinging.
Efficacy assessment involved three methods: digital phototrichogram, visual clinical assessment by a dermatologist, and patient questionnaire. For phototrichogram assessment, each patient had a 2 cm2 area of scalp shaved to leave a maximum of 1 mm hair length, and the central 1 cm2 was assessed.
The same area was shaved at D0, D30, D90, D120, D150 and D180. This avoided excessive hair growth so the same area could be assessed by phototrichogram at all experimental times. Images were taken using the computerized trichogram Tricho Scan (Dermoscan GmbH, Regensburg, Germany) within a maximum of 2 D after shaving, at D2, D92 and D182 (Figure 2). If this time was exceeded, the participant had their hair shaved again with a corresponding new phototrichogram image taken 48 h later.
The TrichoScan device obtains images of the shaved area on the scalp, and the software counts the number of hair fibers in each phase of the hair growth cycle, thus enabling the acquisition of a quantitative data concerning hair growth improvement during treatment. The data obtained with the equipment was: total number of fibers, percentage of hairs in anagen (hair growth phase), and percentage of hairs in telogen (death phase). With these data we were able to calculate the absolute number of anagen and telogen hairs. Statistical analysis was performed with a paired t-test to compare before and after data for each parameter measured on trichogram.
For the visual clinical assessment, a dermatologist assessed each patient’s hair and scalp on D0, D90, and D180 for three aspects: hair volume/thickness, general hair appearance, and scalp coverage. Each aspect was assessed on a 7 point scale ranging from -3 (very thin or very bad) to 3 (very thick or very good).
Patient questionnaires were completed at D90 and D180. Participants assessed the product’s effects and cosmetic qualities via closed questions and a 4-point agree/disagree scale (1=agree completely, 2=agree somewhat, 3=disagree somewhat, 4=disagree completely), and yes/no questions on satisfaction: whether they would buy the product and whether they would recommend it.
Eighty participants were enrolled in the study; 56 completed the study and were included in the analysis (Figure 1). Of those who completed the study, twenty-four had telogen effluvium (TE), and 32 had androgenetic alopecia (AGA). The mean age was 35.6 years. (min 25-max 50). Patient demographics are shown in (Table 1). Of the 24 dropouts, 22 did not return for the day 90 visit, so only baseline data was available; two patients did not return for the day 180 visits. Only patients with complete data were included in the analysis. All patient dropouts were reported as being for personal reasons and further follow-up was not performed.
|Whole study||N = 56|
|Age, y||35.6 (min 25-max 50)|
|Female, No. (%)||30 (53.6)|
|Telogen effluvium||24 (42.9%)|
|Female||20 (83.3% of TE)|
|Male||4 (16.7% of TE)|
|Androgenetic alopecia||32 (57.1%)|
|Female||10 (31.3% of AGA)|
|Male||22 (68.8% of AGA)|
|Ludwig scale (women)|
|Hamilton scale (men)|
Table 1: Baseline characteristics of the participants who completed the study.
None of the participants reported discomfort and no adverse reactions were detected on examination at D90 and D180.
On phototrichogram analysis, in the study sample as a whole (AGA plus TE), there was a statistically significant increase (p<0.05) in the number of anagen hairs and the total number of hairs after 90 and 180 days of treatment (mean 183 hairs per 1 cm2 test area at D0, 191 at D90, and 194 at D180). As a percentage improvement, there was a median 5% (range, -23% to 81%) increase in total number of hairs and median 9% (range, -20% to 56%) increase in number of anagen hairs. When extrapolated from the test area to the whole scalp area (taken to be 500 cm2)  this increase represented 5598.2 more hairs per patient at the end of the study. When analyzed according to etiology, in patients with androgenetic alopecia, there was a statistically significant increase in the number of anagen hairs as well as in the total number of hair fibers after 90 and 180 days of treatment (p<0.05).
In patients with telogen effluvium, there was a statistically significant increase only in the number of anagen hairs after 90 and 180 days of treatment (Table 2) contains numerical phototrichogram data on total hair number and number of anagen hairs, which were the statistically significant parameters.
|Whole study sample||Total number of hair fibers|
|Number of anagen hair fibers|
|Telogen effluvium||Number of anagen hair fibers|
|Androgenetic alopecia||Total number of hair fibers|
|Number of anagen hair fibers|
Table 2: Phototrichogram data for statistically significant parameters: total number of hair fibers and number of hairs in anagen. Data for the whole study sample and by etiology at D90 and D180 of treatment, N=number of patients in sample; SD=standard deviation.
On clinical assessment by the dermatologist, in the whole study sample, after 90 D of product use, 23.2% of the participants had thicker, more voluminous hair; 25.0% had improved general hair appearance and 35.7% had improved scalp coverage. After 180 D of product use, 35.7% had thicker, more voluminous hair; 37.5% had improved general hair appearance and 39.3% had improved scalp coverage. When assessed according to etiology, patients with androgenetic alopecia had more striking results than those with telogen effluvium: at D90, 25.0% had thicker hair (vs. 20.8% for TE), 31.3% had improved general appearance of hair (16.7% for TE), and 43.8% had improved scalp coverage (25.0% for TE). At D180, 46.9% had thicker hair (vs. 20.8% in TE), 50.0% had improved general appearance (20.8% in TE), and 50% had improved scalp coverage (25.0% in TE).
On participant self-assessment questionnaire the product was rated highly both for efficacy and cosmetic qualities. At D180, 79% of participants said their hair problem was less visible, 84% said hair growth had increased, 79% reported reduced hair loss, 79% said their hair was stronger, 86% were more confident about their hair, 86% were satisfied with the results, 86% would recommend the product, and 86% said they would buy the product regardless of the price. In general, in the group with androgenetic alopecia, these percentages were slightly higher than in those with telogen effluvium. Full results broken down by question, timing, and alopecia etiology are given in (Table 3). Cosmetically, the product was rated very highly: 100% of participants judged it as having a non-greasy, non-sticky texture and pleasant smell. This was regardless of etiology, i.e. 100% in both groups.
|Question/statement||% of participants in agreement|
|Whole sample||Androgenetic alopecia||Telogen effluvium|
|The product is pleasant||100||100||100||100||100||100|
|The texture of the product is nice||100||100||100||100||100||100|
|The product has a pleasant smell||100||100||100||100||100||100|
|The product is non-greasy||100||100||100||100||100||100|
|The product is non-sticky||100||100||100||100||100||100|
|The product makes my hair problem less visible||77||79||78||81||75||75|
|The product makes my hair more voluminous||57||59||59||63||54||54|
|The product makes my hair grow||82||84||84||88||79||79|
|Hair loss was reduced||79||79||78||78||79||79|
|My hair is thicker||48||48||50||50||46||46|
|My hair is stronger||79||79||81||81||75||75|
|New hairs grow faster than before||79||79||78||78||79||79|
|The appearance of hair loss is reduced||54||54||56||56||50||50|
|The product helps regulate excess oily hair||59||61||59||63||58||58|
|My hair looks healthier||82||82||84||84||79||79|
|My hair is more manageable and easier to comb||55||57||56||59||54||54|
|Within a month of using the product my hair is already improving||50||50||53||53||46||46|
|At the end of the treatment my hair has improved||82||86||84||88||79||83|
|This product makes me more confident about my hair||82||86||84||88||79||83|
|I would prefer to use this product instead of a costly hair transplant||77||77||78||78||75||75|
|Since using the product I am less worried about hair loss||71||71||75||75||67||67|
|I feel my image has improved||82||84||84||84||79||83|
|I feel more confident about my image||82||82||84||84||79||79|
|Are you satisfied with the results?||82||86||84||87.5||79||83|
|Would you recommend this product||82||86||84||87.5||79||83|
|Would you buy this product regardless of the price?||82||86||84||87.5||79||83|
Table 3: Results of participant questionnaires on efficacy and cosmetic qualities of the product at day 90 and day 180.
The results show that normal use of this product resulted in a significant increase in the total number of hair fibers and number of anagen hairs in patients with AGA and an increase in the number of anagen hairs in patients with TE. On assessment by a dermatologist, 39% of participants had visibly improved scalp coverage at the end of the study. The majority of patients found the product to be effective and wished to continue using it.
The existing scientific literature contains evidence on the efficacy and mechanism of action of some of the individual ingredients in this product. The key ingredients in this product are oleanolic acid, apigenin, biotinyl tripepdide-1, diaminopyrimidine, and adenosine, biotin, and Ginkgo biloba. As briefly mentioned above, the combination of oleanolic acid, apigenin, and biotinyl tripepdide-1 acts against the principal causes of hair loss, namely poor scalp microcirculation, follicle ageing, and follicle atrophy caused by dihydrotestosterone. Previous studies in the literature have shown that biotinyl-GHK (a member of the matrikine family) improves cellular metabolism . While apigenin, a citrus flavonoid improves microcirculation  and oleanolic acid inhibits DHT (dihydrotestosterone)  via 5-alpha reductase inhibition. This study adds clinical evidence on the efficacy of this particular combination of ingredients in normal use conditions (Table 4). summarizes the known mechanism of action of each of the actives in this product.
|Active||Mechanism of action|
|Oleanolic acid||Improves cellular metabolism, stimulates hair matrix cell proliferation |
|Apigenin||Stimulates microcirculation |
|Biotinyl tripeptide-1||Inhibits 5α-reductase |
|Diaminopyrimidine oxide||Inhibits perifollicular fibrosis, similar mechanism of action to minoxidil [6,7]|
|Adenosine||Promotes expression of several growth factors, stimulates growth of dermal papilla, lengthens anagen |
|Biotin||Vitamin that assists in numerous metabolic reactions involved in fatty acid synthesis |
|Ginkgo biloba||Antioxidant+anti-inflammatory. Improves microcirculation [10,11]|
Table 4: Active ingredients in the product studied and their mechanism of action against hair loss.
In 2008, a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled study of 30 women with female pattern hair loss found that twice-daily use of adenosine lotion for 12 months improved hair growth and thickness in women  as assessed on dermatological clinical examination and phototrichogram. In the intervention group, there was a significant increase in anagen hair growth and hair thickness, superior to placebo, but no significant difference in anagen hair ratio. Our study results differ slightly from those of Oura et al, in that we found increased anagen hair number; however, we did not directly measure growth rate or individual hair fiber thickness. More recently, a 2015 study from Japan concluded that topical adenosine increases the proportion of thick hair in Caucasian men with androgenetic alopecia . In that study, individual hair fiber thickness was assessed and found to increase significantly, but on dermatologist assessment of overall hair appearance there was no significant difference between the intervention group and placebo group. In our study, dermatologist assessment found that 35.7% of participants had some improvement in hair thickness appearance at the end of the study, although our study design did not include a control group. This could be an area for further study, to compare this product against a placebo.
In addition to the direct effects of adenosine on hair growth, it has also been demonstrated to mediate the effects of minoxidil against hair loss. A 2001 study in dermal papilla cells found that adenosine triggered intracellular signal transduction, thus increasing minoxidil’s effect on hair growth . This concept of synergistic interaction is of great importance when trying to establish the optimal combination of ingredients. In this study we have demonstrated that the combination of ingredients in the product tested is clinically effective against hair loss.
The strengths of this study are that it assessed clinical effects in multiple ways: the objective and validated phototrichogram assessment  the clinical impression according to the dermatologist, and patient opinion, which although subjective by definition, is fundamentally important to any medical or cosmetic treatment. The patient questionnaire was a commonly-used questionnaire for subjective evaluation of cosmetic products, but is not a validated questionnaire, and as such, constitutes a weakness of the study. The study could have been further improved by use of a control group and blinding. Collecting information on time since diagnosis, and time since last pregnancy (if applicable) would provide more complete data (pregnancy was an exclusion criteria). Future studies, looking at female patients in particular, in which systematic treatment is limited due to side effects, would be an interesting focus. A larger sample size would make the data from such studies more robust.
Once-daily use of this product for 6-12 months is effective and safe as a topical hair-loss treatment, as demonstrated by increased total and anagen hairs, increased overall thickness and scalp coverage, and patient-reported reduction in hair-loss. This lotion would be suitable for use as an adjuvant to systemic treatments or in patients who are not suitable for or decline systemic or invasive treatments.
Medical writing assistance was provided by J. Marshall.
Conflicts of interest
A Garre, G Martinez, and C Trullas are employees of ISDIN, who sponsored the study. J Piquero is an external medical advisor to ISDIN.
- Alfonso M, Richter-Appelt H, Tosti A, Viera M, Garcia M (2005) The psychosocial Impact of hair loss among men: a multinational European study. Curr Med Res Opin 21: 1829-1836.
- Cash T, Price V, Savin R (1993) Psychological effects of androgenetic alopecia on women: comparisons with balding men and with female control subjects. J Am Acad Dermatol 29: 568-575.
- Sonthalia S, Daulatabad D, Tosti A (2016) Hair Restoration in Androgenetic Alopecia: Looking Beyond Minoxidil, Finasteride and Hair Transplantation. J Cosmo Trichol 2: 105.
- Liu B, Chen X, Yi H, Han L, Ji B, et al. (2017) β-Catenin is involved in oleanolic acid-dependent promotion of proliferation in human hair matrix cells in an in vitro organ culture model. Fitoterapia 121: 136-140.
- Mastantuono T, Battiloro L, Sabatino L, Chiurazzi M, Di Maro M, et al. (2015) Effects of Citrus Flavonoids Against Microvascular Damage Induced by Hypoperfusion and Reperfusion in Rat Pial Circulation. Microcirculation 22: 378-390.
- Mahe Y, Buan B, Bernard BA (1996) A minoxidil-related compound lacking a C6 Substitution still exhibits strong anti-lysyl hydroxylase activity in vitro. Skin Pharmacol 9: 177-183.
- Rossi A, Cantisani C, Melis L, Iorio A, Scali E, et al. (2012) Minoxidil use in dermatology, side effects and recent patents. Recent Pat Inflamm Allergy Drug Discov 6: 130-136.
- Hwang K, Hwang Y, Lee M, Kim N, Roh S, et al. (2012) Adenosine stimulates growth of dermal papilla and lengthens the anagen phase by increasing the cysteine level via fibroblast growth factors 2 and 7 in an organ culture of mouse vibrissae hair Follicles. Int J Mol Med 29: 195-201.
- Trueb RM (2016) Serum Biotin Levels in Women Complaining of Hair Loss. Int J Trichology 8: 73-77.
- Li Y, Wu Y, Yao X, Hao F, Yu C, et al. (2017) Ginkgolide A Ameliorates LPS-Induced Inflammatory Responses In Vitro and In Vivo. Int J Mol Sci 18: 794.
- Yoshikawa T, Naito Y, Kondo M (1999) Ginkgo biloba leaf extract: review of biological Actions and clinical applications. Antioxid Redox Signal 1: 469-480.
- Robins CR (2012) Chemical and Physical Behavior of Human Hair (5th Ed).
- Pickart L, Vasquez J, Margolina A (2015) GHK Peptide as a Natural Modulator of Multiple Cellular Pathways in Skin Regeneration. BioMed Res Int.
- Oura H, Iino M, Nakazawa Y, Tajima M, Ideta R, et al. (2008) Adenosine Increases anagen hair growth and thick hairs in Japanese women with female pattern Hair loss: a pilot, double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial. J Dermatol 35: 763-767.
- Iwabuchi T, Ideta R, Ehama R, Yamanishi H, Iino M, et al. (2016) Topical adenosine increases the proportion of thick hair in Caucasian men with androgenetic alopecia. J Dermatol 43: 567-570.
- Li M, Marubayashi A, Nakaya Y, Fukui K, Arase S (2001) Minoxidil-induced hair growth is mediated by adenosine in cultured dermal papilla cells: possible involvement of sulfonylurea receptor 2B as a target of minoxidil. J Invest Dermatol 117: 1594-1600.
- Hoffmann R (2003) Trichoscan: a novel tool for the analysis of hair growth in vivo. J Investig Dermatol Symp Proc 8: 109-115.
Citation: Garre A, Piquero J, Trullas C, Martinez G (2018) Efficacy and Safety of a New Topical Hair Loss-Lotion Containing Oleanolic Acid, Apigenin, Biotinyl Tripeptide-1, Diaminopyrimidine Oxide, Adenosine, Biotin and Ginkgo biloba in Patients with Androgenetic Alopecia and Telogen effluvium: A Six-month Open-Label Prospective Clinical Study. J Cosmo Trichol 4:1000132. DOI: 10.4172/2471-9323.1000132
Copyright: ©2018 Garre A, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language
Share This Article
- Total views: 1197
- [From(publication date): 0-2018 - Dec 16, 2018]
- Breakdown by view type
- HTML page views: 1154
- PDF downloads: 43