Reach Us +44 7482 874137
High Throughput Optical Biosensor for Monitoring Pb (II) Ions in Milk through Fluorescence based Microarray Approach | OMICS International
ISSN: 2155-6210
Journal of Biosensors & Bioelectronics

Like us on:

Make the best use of Scientific Research and information from our 700+ peer reviewed, Open Access Journals that operates with the help of 50,000+ Editorial Board Members and esteemed reviewers and 1000+ Scientific associations in Medical, Clinical, Pharmaceutical, Engineering, Technology and Management Fields.
Meet Inspiring Speakers and Experts at our 3000+ Global Conferenceseries Events with over 600+ Conferences, 1200+ Symposiums and 1200+ Workshops on Medical, Pharma, Engineering, Science, Technology and Business

High Throughput Optical Biosensor for Monitoring Pb (II) Ions in Milk through Fluorescence based Microarray Approach

Hardeep K1,2* and Verma N1

1Biosensor Technology Laboratory, Department of Biotechnology, Punjabi University, Patiala, Punjab, India

2Department of Biotechnology, Baba Farid College, Bathinda, Punjab, India

*Corresponding Author:
Hardeep K
Biosensor Technology Laboratory
Department of Biotechnology
Punjabi University, Patiala, Punjab
Tel: 91-9646-773958
E-mail: [email protected]

Received Date: March 14, 2015; Accepted Date: June 11, 2015; Published Date: June 21, 2015

Citation: Hardeep K, Verma N (2015) High Throughput Optical Biosensor for Monitoring Pb (II) Ions in Milk through Fluorescence based Microarray Approach. J Biosens Bioelectron 6:166. doi: 10.4172/2155-6210.1000166

Copyright: © 2015 Hardeep K, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Visit for more related articles at Journal of Biosensors & Bioelectronics


Milk is a bulk consumer product therefore it serves a versatile source of public exposure to contaminants. Among the various heavy metals, lead has been recognized as the leading environmental health threat and milk has been found mostly contaminated with high levels of Pb (II) ions. In present study an optical biosensor is developed employing Bacillus sphaericus (MTCC 5100) as biorecognition unit and the analysis is based on urease inhibition resulting in fluorescence change. Investigation was carried out by means of fluorescence dye (Rhodamine 6G) in hydrophobic environment with the heavy metal. The novelty of the method lies in the formula that is devised to detect equivalent Pb (II) ions in milk in the presence of Cd (II). Lowest detection limit achieved is 0.48 nM Pb (II) equivalents in spiked milk samples (permissible limit 96.6 nM). This is the first report on low level Pb (II) monitoring in milk through high throughput microarray biosensing.


Urease; Hydrosol-gel immobilization; Fluorescence; Microarray; Lead; Milk biosensor


Lead (Pb II) has gained the attention of all the health authorities and concerned departments due to its increasing contamination level and worldwide occurrence [1-3]. The permissible limit of lead has been reduced to 10 μgl-1 in drinking water and 20 μgl-1 in milk [4]. Recent reports have shown an overall increase of lead levels in milk, as a consequence, monitoring of lead becomes essential. Swarup [5] revealed that the lactating cows with a blood lead level (BLL) above 200 μgl-1 have significantly higher milk lead excretion than those below that level. So a simple and highly sensitive method is needed to check lead contamination in milk. As an analytical tool, biosensors hold the advantage of simplicity, portability, cost effectiveness and ability to analyze bio-available toxicity level of analyte over the conventional techniques.

Various approaches have been used by different researchers to develop biosensor for lead. Durrieu and Tran - Minh [6] reported inhibition of alkaline phosphatase in the presence of lead as a bioassay principle for the development of an optical algal biosensor. Kuswandi [7] employed fiber optic technology, to develop an optical Pb (II) biosensor. Urease activity based optical biosensor was developed by Tsai [8]. Later a multi analysis 50 spot array based optical biosensor was developed by Tsai and Doong [9], the sensor was based on basic principle of inhibition of urease and acetylcholinesterase by heavy metals. Both the enzymes were co – immobilized with FITC dextran in sol – gel matrix for multianalyte detection. The biosensor demonstrated detection range from 10 nM to 100 nM for Cd (II), Hg (II) and Cu (II), but no response was observed against Pb (II). Haron and Ray [10] developed a biosensor based on inhibition of urease and acetyl cholinesterase by Pb (II) and a detection limit of 4.83 nM was achieved using cyclotetrachromotropylene (CTCT) as an indicator. Gani et al. [11] constructed an optical biosensor by immobilizing urease and a pH indicator chlorophenol red in a PVC-sol-gel matrix for monitoring heavy metals in water samples. A liquid crystal (LC) based optical biosensor has also been developed [12]. In this case urease was immobilized on a UV – tailored nematic LC called 4 - cyano – 4’ – pentyl biphenyl (5CB). In the presence of heavy metal ion, the optical characteristic of LC remained unchanged in urea solution. Above discussed studies firmly elucidate that biosensors are promising tool for accurate real time monitoring of heavy metals in environmental samples. The present work is also focused on the development of a simple biosensor for fast and economical monitoring of Pb (II) ions in water and milk samples.

¨Present work lead to two innovations, first is the use of a fluorescent dye Rhodamine 6G (Rh -6G) as the pH indicator for Pb (II) monitoring and secondly the immobilization of the same in a hydrophobic sol gel environment to achieve a portable biosensor assembly with multiple sampling capability. Tetra-ethylorthosilicate (TEOS) has been used as the precursor for sol-gel matrix, which gets hydrolyzed with addition of water, and after condensation reaction lead to the formation of semi -solid Si – O – Si linkages. Due to the organic composition, the dye is easily soluble in protonated form in this matrix and its fluorescence intensity remains unaffected. The hydrolysis of urea by urease produces ammonia which is captured in the cross linked sol-gel matrix along with Rhodamine 6G. This association of ammonia and Rhodamine 6G creates the perfect circumstances for deprotonation of the later and formation of ammonium ions with decrease in the fluorescence [13].

Rh 6G - H+ + NH3→Rh 6G + NH4+

The bioassay characterization was based on the well known inhibition phenomenon of urease enzyme by the heavy metal. The ammonia produced from urea hydrolysis (catalyzed by urease) was subjected to the dye and the fluorescence was checked before and after the reaction. The inhibition of urease in the cell was detected by increase in fluorescence as compared to control, as in the presence of heavy metal less ammonia was produced which caused less amount of dye deprotonation.

Materials and Methods

Rhodamine 6G solutions was purchased from Sigma–Aldrich (ST. LOUIS, MO, USA). Reagents like ethanol, Tetra–ethylorthosilicate (TEOS), NaOH were purchased from Merk and HIMEDIA, Mumbai, India. Standard solutions of Pb (II) and Cd (II) were purchased from MERCK KGAA, Germany and stored in plastic bottles at 4°C after dilutions.

The optical biosensor for lead was constructed using urease producing B. sphaericus whole cells which were found to be sensitive against lead upto nanomolar levels [14]. Concentration of Rhodamine 6G was optimized to get the most favorable fluorescence for the analysis. Whole cells of B. sphaericus were immobilized with hydrosolgel method in the micro well plate [15]. A mixture of 530 μl ethanol, 50 μl TEOS, 10 μl NaOH (5 mM), 80 μl Rh-6G dye, 10 μl B. sphaericus whole cells (0.14 U) was prepared and incubated at 4°C for 1 hr. 20 μl of the mixture was then poured in each well followed by 20 μl of Pb (II) and 2M urea solution each for lead analysis. The fluorescence was read at the zero time after addition of all reagents and after 10 min incubation at 37°C. The direct immobilization of B. sphaericus needed the selection of wells with same initial fluorescence. To overcome this problem a slight modification of the above method was made, in which the hydrosol gel mixture [530 μl ethanol, 50 μl TEOS, 10 μl NaOH (5 mM), 152 μl Rh-6G (1.22 μM), 10 μl B. sphaericus whole cells (0.14 U)] was taken in a tube and kept at 4°C for 1 hr. The dye content was increased because the overall volume in this method was much more than the previous method. Then 1 ml lead (1-10 ng ml-1) and 1 ml urea (2 M) were added to the mixture and half of the reaction mixture was taken out to take zero time reading and the next half given 10 min incubation at 37°C after which its fluorescence was read. 20 μl from each tube was taken in wells for fluorescence read and a number of samples were possible at the same time in a 48 well microwell plate. The optimized method was used to check lead contamination in water, spiked milk samples and unknown milk samples from rural, urban and industrial areas. All the experiments were conducted in triplicates and standard deviation was applied to all results to obtain error bars.

As lead and cadmium are the main contaminating metals found in milk [1,3,16,17] lead analysis in the presence of cadmium was optimized in water system and then applied to spiked and unknown milk samples. For cadmium detection B. badius was used as the sensing element as it was found to be sensitive against cadmium up to 0.1 ng ml-1 [18] and is not sensitive to lead up to microgram levels. This fact helped to check the cadmium concentration in the sample without any interference by lead. The fluorescent dye Acridine orange (Ex at 502 nm and Em at 526 nm) working on the same principle as Rhodamine- 6G (Ex=526 nm, Em=555 nm) was used for the signal transduction. The Acridine orange and Rhodamine- 6G has been used as they have different emission wavelengths and hence can be used for simultaneous detection of lead and cadmium in the same well. For simultaneous detection of both the metals, composition of hydrosol- gel mixture was modified to 500 μl ethanol, 50 μl TEOS, 10 μl NaOH (5 mM), 152 μl Rh- 6G (1.22 μM), 45 μl Acridine orange, 10 μl B. sphaericus whole cells (0.14 U) and 10 μl B. badius whole cells (0.29 U). The system was first optimized for water samples and then applied to milk samples. The hydrosol- gel mixture was incubated at 4°C for 1 hr, then 0.5 ml each of lead and cadmium (1- 20 ng ml-1) was added along with 1 ml urea (2M). Further analysis was made as in previously mentioned protocol and according to the lead and cadmium detection limits achieved in a single well, standards for both individual and simultaneous detection were prepared and applied to device a formula to unknown milk samples.


The results obtained were statistically verified to achieve minimum error level and precise detection limit. All the results are presented with error bars that depict the standard deviation range. To develop an optical microarray based biosensor for multiple sample analysis, Rhodamine -6G (Ex=526, Em=555) was used as the indicator dye. The dye was optimized for linear concentration response in the microwell plate. A volume of 80 μl of 1.22 μM dye in a total of 680 μl sol gel mixture was found most appropriate according to the linear curve (Figure 1) after which the intensity of fluorescence reached pseudozero order stage. Pb (II) was analyzed by setting the Rhodamine immobilized hydrosolgel directly into the microarray plate and then adding different lead concentrations in the wells with same initial fluorescence. Rhodamine was completely soluble in the sol-gel mixture. An initial drop in Rhodamine fluorescence in the control assay (not containing Pb II), followed by increase with consecutive addition of lead, as expected from the Pb (II) bioassay principle was observed. Whole cells of B. sphaericus were used as the sensing component with enzyme activity 14.97 ± 2.01 IU (250 ml broth). The lead inhibition effect was found to be logarithmic in this case and the linear range of detection was found to be 4.83 nM–4.83 μM Pb (II) equivalents. The lower limit of detection in this method was 4.83 nM Pb (II) equivalents.


Figure 1: Fluorescence response of 1.22 μM Rhodamine 6G dye at various volume levels in the detection vial containing 680 μl sol – gel mixture.

Although this method was sensitive, it had the disadvantage of selection of wells with same fluorescence intensity and many unutilised wells, hence wastage of biomass and reagents. To combat this problem, a modificaion in the protocol was made. This method provided repeatability of the results and linear range of lead detection achieved was 0.48-9.66 nM Pb (II) equivalents with lowest detection limit of 0.48 nM Pb (II) equivalents (Figure 2, results are presented as logarithmic relationship of cadmium with enzyme activity, standard deviation was applied to triplicate experiments)).


Figure 2: Logrithmic relationship of lead concentration with enzyme activity. The Linear range of detection achieved was 0.48-9.66 nM Pb in modified microarray method (result obtained by applying standard deviation to triplicate experiments).

Owing to the repeatibility and lower limit of detection of lead, this method was further applied for lead analysis on spiked milk samples. In case of spiked milk samples (1 ml volume used) the linear range of detection was from 0.48-48.3 nM Pb (II) equivalents in a logarithmic pattern with lowest limit of detection 0.48 nM Pb (II) equivalents. To apply the developed method to unknown samples and showcase the fluorescence difference in water and milk matrix, fluorescence of different Pb (II) concentrations was compared in water and milk system as shown in Table 1.

Lead Concentration (nanomoles) Fluorescence in water system Fluorescence in spiked milk sample (10 μl) Fluorescence difference
Control 0.502 0.641 0.139
4.8 X 10-4 0.525 0.654 0.129
2.4 X 10-3 0.534 0.653 0.119
4.8 X 10-3 0.547 0.667 0.120
9.7 X 10-3 0.553 0.671 0.119
2.4 X 10-2 0.581 0.683 0.102

Table 1: Comparison of fluorescence in water and spiked milk samples.

The detection of lead and cadmium simultaneously was made possible by using two urease producing strains, B. sphaericus and B. sphaericus respectively. Two different fluorescent dyes Rhodamine 6G (Ex=526 nm, Em=555 nm) and Acridine orange (Ex=493 nm, Em=535 nm) with different emission wavelengths (Figure 3) were selected for this purpose. Also there was an advantage that B. badius urease is insensitive to lead at nanomolar levels and demonstrate inhibition only at micromolar range [18], whereas B. sphaericus is sensitive to lead at nanomolar levels. So lead does not interfere in cadmium detection by B. badius and the fluorescence read against Acridine orange corresponds to cadmium effect only, but the fluorescence read using B. sphaericus is the cumulative effect of lead and cadmium. Regarding the cytotoxicity of heavy metal ions against Bacillus sp, it needs to be mentioned that it’s been preinvestigated by authors that Pb (II) and Cd (II) ions demonstrate variable range of response against Bacillus sp [14,18]. The Bacillus sphaericus employed in the present study has also been reported to illustrate response against other heavy metals such as Nickel [19] and copper [20]. The effect of lead and cadmium on Bacillus species has been tested by other workers also. Bacillus sphaericus has been employed as bioaccumulator of lead ions in a study [21]. A Diaion SP–850 resin loaded with B. sphaericus was experimented to preconcentrate and separate the metal ions from liquid and solid samples in the detection range of 0.2020-0.75 μgL-1 and 2.5- 9.4 ng g-1 respectively. Owing to higher bioaccumulation capacity of Bacillus sp, an endophytic strain Bacillus sp. MN3-4, isolated from the roots of Alnus firma plant is reported [22]. Lead was accounted to be extracellularly sequestered by the microbe that confirmed a higher degree of toxicity tolerance of Bacillus sp. against lead ions. The linear range of detection of cadmium was obtained in the range of 0.5–24 nM for water and spiked milk samples as depicted in Figure 4 (results are presented as logarithmic relationship of cadmium with enzyme activity; standard deviation was applied to triplicate experiments). The viability of both the Bacillus strains has been reported in author’s previous research work [14,18] that revealed a storage stability of approximately two months in sol- gel hydrophobic environment


Figure 3: Emission Spectra od Rhodamine 6G at Emission wavelenth Ex 555 nm and Acridine Orange Ex 535 nm, without any biological component in the assay.


Figure 4: Logrithmic relationship of Cadmium (0.5-24 nM) with enzyme activity, in spiked milk sample with acridine orange as the sensing dye (result obtained by applying standard deviation to triplicate experiments).

The reliability of the developed method and the formulas was checked by carrying out lead and cadmium analysis in unknown samples and then again after spiking of the samples with known concentration of lead and cadmium. All the samples were analyzed in triplicates and the devised formula was applied to the fluorescence read to detect lead and cadmium contamination. For this purpose three unknown samples D4, D19, D20 (which were detected negative for both Pb (II) and Cd (II) earlier) were spiked with 5 ng lead and cadmium each (Table 2). It was observed that the levels of Pb (II) and Cd (II) added and detected by the developed method were close enough to validate the method. Applying the same method to 60 milk samples from rural, urban and industrial areas of Punjab, India, three from the industrial area were found to be contaminated. One had a lead contagion of 5.9 μM and cadmium 14 nM, other was contaminated with 6 μM of lead only and the last one was found to be highly contaminated with cadmium only (87.4 nM).

Sample Pb2+ and Cd2+
Added (ng)
Lead found (ng) Cadmium found (ng)
Sample D4 5 4.64 ± 0.33 4.69 ± 0.38
Sample D19 5 4.88 ± 0.26 5.01 ± 0.17
Sample D20 5 5.3 ± 0.10 4.77 ± 0.19

Table 2: Reliability studies of the Optical Biosensor.


The detection limit achieved in the developed biosensor (based on enzyme inhibition phenomenon) is far below the limits obtained till now and is under the permissible limit of lead in milk (96.6 nM or 20 ng ml-1). No optical study based on enzyme activity has been done so far for lead contamination in milk. From the above shown data it is very evident that the developed method is suitable for lead analysis in milk samples with a very low detection limit. The obtained limit of detection in milk has not been reported by any other worker yet and the developed method surpasses the need of any pretreatment of the milk samples. It was observed that the complex matrix of milk imparts some increase in fluorescence of the dye as compared to water system. So, to detect that interference due to milk and to apply the developed method to unknown milk samples taking water as reference, the analysis of lead in water and spiked milk samples was carried out and the fluorescence read at different lead concentrations with control samples were compared. As shown in Table 1, it was observed that the difference in fluorescence of spiked milk and water samples were following a regular pattern and indicated an average fluorescence difference of 0.12. So it could be suggested that the effect of milk on fluorescence is corresponding to 0.12 units in present study, and should be considered at the time of lead determination in unknown milk samples.

As per the earlier reports, Lee and Lee [23] developed a conductometric biosensor based on sol-gel immobilized urease and obtained a detection limit of 0.9 mM for lead in drinking water. Later Tsai [8] used FITC- dextran as fluorescent dye to develop urease based optical biosensor for heavy metals and achieved a detection limit of 0.1 mM. Kuswandi [7] obtained a detection limit of 1 X 10-2 mM lead in 6 min response time using immobilized urease on an optical fiber. Then a sol-gel immobilized urease conductometric biosensor was developed by Illangovan et al. [15] and a percentage inhibition of 35% was observed with 1 mM lead. A very low detection limit of 4.83 nM was achieved using cyclotetrachronotropylene (CTCT) as an indicator by Haron and Ray [10]. None of the above reports furnished any details about interfering ions. The present work has the advantage of simplicity and multiple sampling along with lower limit of detection as compared to the existing ones. Also the distinction between lead and cadmium response through the selection of different Bacillus strains and fluorescent dyes is an extra advantage of reported method.

The present method is also first of its kind to detect Pb (II) and Cd (II) simultaneously in milk. Haron and Ray [10] reported an optical biosensor for monitoring Pb (II) and Cd (II) in water samples based on inhibition of urease and acetylcholinesterase and achieved a detection limit of 1 ng ml-1 whereas the present work could detect upto 0.1 ng ml-1 Pb (II) ions in milk samples. For simultaneous detection of lead and cadmium in unknown samples, standard curves for water and spiked milk samples were utilized. According to the standard curve of cadmium effect on urease, its concentration could be deduced from the change in fluorescence pattern corresponding to Cd (II). Taking that concentration as reference the respective fluorescence fraction of Cd (II) was subtracted from the fluorescence read with B. sphaericus to get the lead contamination level. As per the standards of spiked lead samples and cadmium interference values, two formulas for quantitative analysis of lead was devised which could be directly applied on unknown samples.

Where, A=Fluorescence read for the sample (corresponding to Pb II)

M1=Milk factor with Rhodamine dye,

F1=Fluorescence read of Rhodamine G

B1=Pb (II) Standard/Fluorescence of that standard sample

To detect lead in the presence of cadmium a formula was devised for cadmium detection and then the fluorescence factor (interference factor) according to that cadmium concentration was subtracted from Rhodamine 6G fluorescence to detect lead contamination.

X nanomoles of Pb (II)=[{[A–M1)–F3]–C} × B1

Where, A=Fluorescence read for the sample (corresponding to Pb II ),

M1=Milk factor,

F3=Florescence read of combined dyes rhodamine and acridine orange,

C=Cadmium conc. calculated from standard curve using dye acridin orange,

B1=Pb (II) Standard/Fluorescence of that standard sample

Present work has resulted in development of an enzyme inhibition based microarray optical biosensor for monitoring lead equivalents in milk simultaneously with cadmium.


Finally it is concluded that, a reliable and cost effective lead detecting whole cell based optical biosensor has been developed for application in milk, based on urease inhibition. Microarray approach has been used to analyse multiple samples at the same time. The detection limit achieved is 0.48 nM of Pb (II) equivalents in milk which is far below the permissible level (96.6 nM). The reliability and application of the developed biosensor for lead monitoring in milk samples is checked and found to be a competent method for analysis. Present work is also first endeavor of its kind capable of detecting cadmium and lead simultaneously through different strains of urease producing Bacillus sps. The study has resulted in a fluorescence based formula for Pb (II) and Cd (II) detection in unknown milk samples without any pretreatment requirement. Exploitation of Rhodamine -6G as the fluorescent indicator and the nature of its fluorescence change in the hydrophobic environment of sol-gel matrix provided the advantage of lower limit detection. The developed biosensor could be easily converted into a simple kit based assay for commercial purpose.

Acknowledgement. The authors are thankful to ICAR (NAIP), New Delhi, India for the research grant C4/C10125/2008 supporting this work.

Conflict of Interest

Dr Hardeep Kaur and Dr Neelam Verma declare that they have no conflict of interest.


Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language
Post your comment

Share This Article

Article Usage

  • Total views: 12355
  • [From(publication date):
    June-2015 - Feb 18, 2020]
  • Breakdown by view type
  • HTML page views : 8544
  • PDF downloads : 3811