Department of Mechanical Engineering, SLIET, India
Received Date: May 17, 2016; Accepted Date: May 31, 2016; Published Date: June 10, 2016
Citation: Chandra RK, Majid M, Arya HK, Sonkar A (2016) Improvement in Tensile Strength and Microstructural Properties of SAW Welded Low Alloy Steels by Addition of Titanium and Manganese in Agglomerated Flux. J Material Sci Eng 5:260. doi: 10.4172/2169-0022.1000260
Copyright: © 2016 Chandra RK, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Material Sciences & Engineering
The present work is an effort to study the effect of titanium and manganese powder addition in agglomerated flux, on the mechanical properties, of MS 1025 steel welds made by submerged arc welding. The effect of titanium and manganese powder addition on the agglomerated fluxes by varying the welding parameters like welding voltage and welding speed has been evaluated. Taguchi technique has been used for the design of experiments. The effects of flux, voltage and travel speed have been evaluated on the tensile strength and on the microstructure refining. The effect of all the input parameters on the output responses have been analyzed using the analysis of variance (ANOVA).
SAW; Tensile strength; Micro structure and various properties using Taguchi technique
Submerged arc welding is an arc welding process that uses an arc between a bare metal electrodes and the weld pool. The arc is maintained in a cavity of molten flux or slag which refines the weld metal and also protects it from atmospheric contamination [1-3]. Flux is the main ingredient on which the stability of the arc depends. The Unused flux can be extracted from left behind the welding head and subsequently recycled. The filler material is an uncoated, continuous wire electrode, applied to the joint together with a flow of granular flux, which is supplied from a flux hopper through a tube. The electrical resistance of the electrode should be as low as possible to facilitate welding at a high current, and so the welding current is supplied to the electrode through contacts very close to the arc and immediately above it. The current can be direct current with electrode positive (reverse polarity), with negative (straight polarity), or alternating current. The arc burns in a cavity which, apart from the arc itself, is filled with gas and metal vapors [4-6]. The size of the cavity in front of the arc is delineated by the scrap basic material and behind it by the molten weld.
Welding of 1.25Cr-0.5Mo steel with SiO2 and TiO2 based flux increases the heat input, lowers the yield strength and decreases the % elongation . Manganese fluxes give lower residuals of sulphurwhere as calcium silicate fluxes were responsible for removal of phosphorus . Because of small grain size and high angle grain boundaries acicular ferrite is desired microstructure in weld for high impact strength and ductility [8-10]. Low level of oxygen is desired in the weld metal for good impact strength . The effect of wire/flux combination on chemical composition, tensile strength and impact strength of weld metal were investigated and interpreted in terms of element transfer between the slag and weld metal [12-14]. Chemical composition of some flux were studied for microstructure and tensile strength in submerged arc welded metal and compared with those off commercial available flux . Non active flux enhance the formation of pearlite and ferrite in weld having the highest toughness and ductility where as active flux with Cr and Mo promoted the formation of acicular ferrite and fine carbide in the weld showing higher tensile strength and hardness . After literature study we find that very few efforts have been made to understand mechanical properties using Taguchi Technique and Very little work is made to improve the weld joint strength in single pass [15-17]. In this experiment we added titanium and manganese metal powder in 9%, 14% and 18% concentration of titanium and 1.4%, 1.7% and 2% manganese in AUTOMELT B31 flux and investigate its effect on the mechanical properties. The optimization of result has been done by using Taguchi’s Philosophy [18,19].
1025 mild steel is selected over other materials because of its distinct properties, cheaper cost and its Availability in the market.1025 plain carbon steel is used in the manufacturing of ships hulls Table 1.
Table 1: Chemical composition of base plate.
The agglomerated flux is prepared by the addition of the TiO2 and MnO2 powder in auto melt B- 31. Both the ingredients and Auto melt B-31 were crushed and wet mix in sodium silicate to form chemical bonding. Mixture is then passed through a 10 mesh screen to form small pallets (up to 2 mm diameter). The pellets of the flux were dried in air for 24 hours and then baked in the muffle furnace between 750°C (Figure 1 and Table 2).
Table 2:Chemical composition of auto melt B31.
Taguchi method analysis
In Taguchi method first optimal parameters were determined by using L9 orthogonal array. L9 means that it will investigate for 3 levels and 3 factors on qualitative index for each factor. Table 3 gives the levels and factors which are employed for welding the samples. Table 4 gives the experimental data that is taken for analysis .
|Parameter||% age composition of TiO2||% age composition of MnO2|
Table 3: Levels and factors used in design.
|Sample no.||%age composition of TiO2||% age composition of MnO2|
Table 4: Design of taguchi orthogonal array.
In this study L 9 was chosen as the preferred array, 18 plates were cut to size of dimension 150 × 120 × 14 mm for experiment because four plates were required for welding in each trial. Edge preparation was completed on each of the 18 plates as per the requirement of 9 trial condition given by Taguchi orthogonal array. The edge preparation of 45 degree was made on 120 mm side Edge preparation was done on shaper. Groove between two plates. After edge preparation, the plates were tacked through manual arc welding to avoid misalignment. Following tests are carried out in the present study to study mechanical properties.
a) Tensile strength test
b) Micro structural study
Table 5 shows percentage composition of TiO2 and MnO2.
|Percentage composition of TiO2||Percentage Composition of MnO2||Tensile Strength(MPa)||S/N ratio of tensile strength|
Table 5: Shows percentage composition of TiO2 and MnO2.
Analysis of tensile strength
Tensile strength analysis done here is dependable variable on two factors:
1. Percentage composition of TiO2
2. Percentage composition of MnO2
Analysis of variance for S/N ratios for tensile strength calculated from software is given in Table 6. Since the p -value in the Table 6 is less than 0.05; there is a statistically significant relationship between the variables at the 95.0% confidence level. From the Table 6 it can be easily figure out that percentage composition of MnO2 are most significant.
|Parameter||Degree of freedom(DF)||Sum of square(SS)||Mean square(MS)||F–value||P–value|
|Percentage composition of TiO2||2||6291||3145.4||7.37||0.046|
|%age composition of MnO2||2||36692||18314||42.91||0.002|
Table 6:Analysis of variance for S/N ratios for tensile strength.
The main effect of MnO2 is to increase ductility of the weld metal and slight loss in the tensile strength which is overcome by TiO2 so nominal is better option is selected from Taguchi design and accordingly response for signal to noise ratio is generated. It was found that level-3 of Percentage composition of TiO2 and level-3 of e composition of MnO2 gives the optimum values .
In response Table 7 Delta value indicates the variability of factors. Table 7 shows that percentage composition of MnO2 has highest variability. Also rank of parameters in response Table 7 indicates the order at which the parameters influence the quality characteristics. So MnO2 has greatest influence on the Tensile strength of the weld.
|Level||Percentage composition of TiO2||Percentage composition of MnO2|
Table 7:Response for signal to noise ratios: nominal is better.
Tensile strength = 20 + 3.63 % composition of TiO2+ 197.8% composition of MnO2. Table 8 shows the model summary.
Table 8: Model summary.
Main effects for S/N ratios
Figure 2 shows main effect plots for S/N ratio of tensile strength.
Microstructures analysis of various specimens was done with an optical microscope of magnification up to 100 X to compare microstructure of the welded samples. Images were taken that are shown in Figure 4-7. All the welded samples show a microstructure composed of acicular ferrite. It is conforming that Ti containing white inclusions in the sub arc weld metals plays a very important role The term interaction expressed by inserting “x” mark between the two interacting factors is used to explain a condition in which the influence of one factor upon the result, is dependent on the condition of the other [22- 24]. The two factors A & B are said to interact written as (A×B) when the effects of changes in the levels of A, determines the influence of B and vice versa. If there is absolutely no interaction, these lines would be parallel. Figure 3 shows the interaction plots for S/N ratio. The interaction plot for the tensile strength shows that the tensile strength is improved at the less amount of percentage of TiO2 and then it becomes reduced due to the quasi cleavage fracture occurring in the microstructure to overcome this issue we add the manganese in the weld metal to improve the tensile strength it becomes highest at the moderate value of manganese .
Micro-structural analyses: for heterogeneous nucleation of acicular ferrite. Figure 7 shows the microscopic magnification graphs of the welded steels corresponding to the fluxes with different percentage composition of TiO2. The microstructure of the weld metal for each flux consisted mainly of equiaxed ferrite and acicular ferrite. Some small pearlite colonies were also observed in the welds. The micro constituent’s volume percentage, as well as mean radius of equiaxial ferrite and mean length of acicular determined by means of quantitative metallographic. The lowest and highest volume percentages of acicular ferrite corresponded to the weld with 9% and 18 % of TiO2 fluxes respectively.
The chemical composition of the weld metal is obtained from the spectroscopy of the weld joints and the specimen of the spectroscopy (Figure 8 and Table 9).
|% age composition||C%||Si%||Mn%||Cr%||Mo%||Ni%||Cu%||Al%||S%||Ti%|
|F3 (9, 2%)||0.125||0.2048||1.0745||0.0889||0.0034||0.0327||0.0957||0.0121||0.0254||0.0092|
|F6 (13.5, 2%)||0.14||0.1961||1.0312||0.0773||0.0023||0.0247||0.1126||0.0148||0.0277||0.0165|
|F7 (18, 1.4%)||0.125||0.1611||0.9461||0.088||0.0034||0.0327||0.0957||0.0121||0.0254||0.0092|
|F8 (18, 1.7%)||0.133||0.1675||1.0074||0.0932||0.0025||0.0215||0.1135||0.0131||0.0327||0.0125|
|F9 (18, 2%)||0.146||0.2351||1.0754||0.0945||0.005||0.0412||0.0878||0.0199||0.0212||0.0178|
Table 9: Chemical composition of the base metal and weld metals.
The present study was carried out to study the effect of titanium and manganese addition in submerged arc welding flux on the mechanical properties of AISI 1025 welds by keeping all other variables constant like current, speed and arc voltage. The tensile strength value is maximum (529Mpa) at flux composition having titanium 13.5% and 2% manganese at 400 A and 27 V. As a result of increasing the titanium content in the flux, the amount of acicular ferrite was increased in the weld metal. With the further addition of titanium, the microstructure the weld has changed from a mixture of ferrite, grainboundary ferrite to a mixture of acicular ferrite, bainite and ferrite with M/A micro-constituents. The higher percentage of titanium in weld metal encouraged formation of hard phases in the weld microstructure which increases the micro hardness of the weld. The increase in the titanium content in the fluxes improved the ductility and toughness of the weld due to the formation of white inclusions in the sub-arc weld metal and heterogeneous nucleation of acicular ferrite but tensile strength is slightly loss which was overcome by the addition of the moderate % age of manganese in the flux, it refines the microstructure and micro constituent in the flux. The micro structural refining improved the impact strength properties of the weld but the hardening effect produced by the manganese reduced the toughness which is overcoming by % age composition of titanium improves the toughness of the weld. From the spectroscopy of each weld it is found that the carbon percentage in weld is reduced due to use of low carbon electrode for welding the plates. Also the percentage composition of titanium and manganese is increased in the weld when compared with the base metal of each weld.
From the results it concluded that the titanium addition and manganese addition in the flux helped to refine the micro structure of the weld moreover it improves the mechanical properties like tensile strength which is necessary objective of the research work.
I would like to express a deep sense of gratitude and thanks profusely to my esteemed guide Mr. Mohd. Majid, Assistant professor and Mr. H.K. Arya, Assistant Professor Department of Mechanical Engineering, SLIET Longowal, for his exceptional patience , for all kind of help and for being there to encourage me all the times. His enthusiasm and optimism made this experience both rewarding and enjoyable. Thank you for all what you have done for me and for providing me with valuable feedback in my research which made it stronger and more valuable. I humbly express my thanks to Dr. Kulwant Singh (HOD), Department of Mechanical Engineering and Technology, SLIET, for his concern at every step of my project and providing me necessary facilities.
Make the best use of Scientific Research and information from our 700 + peer reviewed, Open Access Journals