Malignant Tension Hydrothorax with Mediastinal Shifting: Emergency Decompression of a Rare and Potentially Lethal Respiratory Condition
Received Date: Mar 24, 2018 / Accepted Date: Apr 06, 2018 / Published Date: Apr 10, 2018
Introduction: A Tension Hydrothorax is defined as a massive pleural effusion presenting with hemodynamic abnormalities secondary to mediastinal compression. In these patients the pleural volume increases the intrathoracic pressure to the point of compromising diastolic filling and cardiac output simulating a cardiac tamponade physiology. This is an uncommon yet potentially fatal medical emergency that if left untreated may lead to cardiac arrest. Early detection and rapid intervention of these patients prevents cardiorespiratory collapse.
Case presentation: We present a two-case report of patients presenting with a malignant tension hydrothorax managed in the emergency room with ultrasound-guided decompression thoracentesis and the other patient with tube thoracostomy.
Conclusion: Although these life-saving decompressive interventions appear simple, not having proper training is an independent factor for chest tube and thoracentesis complications. Courses and simulation training can benefit physicians to minimize potential complications when managing emergency conditions and pathologies such as a Tension hydrothorax which continues to be a medical challenge. Whether thoracentesis or thoracostomy is superior in managing this condition remains in debate and a clinical dilemma.
Keywords: Tension hydrothorax; Pleural effusion; Thoracostomy; Thoracentesis
A pleural effusion is the excess pleural fluid within the pleural cavity defined as >15 cc and generally considered to be significant above 500 cc. Normal volume is approximately 0.1 to 0.3 ml/kg, produced at 0.01 ml/kg/h from parietal capillaries and removed by parietal lymphatics at 0.28 ml/kg/h. When normal pleural physiology is impaired, pleural fluid accumulates; this happens through transudate mechanisms such as increased hydrostatic pressure seen in heart failure or decreased oncotic pressure seen in liver failure. Transudate effusions are more likely to be bilateral and chest tubes are usually not needed. Exudate mechanisms however occur through inflammatory and infectious processes such as pneumonia, obstructive processes as in neoplasms or trauma. Exudate effusions are usually unilateral and some may eventually need a chest tube. When massive, pleural effusions can cause significant cardiopulmonary and hemodynamic compromise secondary to mediastinal compression manifesting as tamponade physiology known as a tension hydrothorax. This is due to the pleural fluid volume causing an increase in intrathoracic pressure leading to an inadequate diastolic filling and cardiac output simulating a cardiac tamponade. The exact incidence of this rare condition is unknown, however it is a potentially fatal medical emergency, that if unrecognized early may progress to cardiac arrest [1-10]. Although thoracentesis is the initial approach to most pleural effusions, patient stabilization takes priority in these patients because of the level of hemodynamic and respiratory insult; therefore chest tube decompression may be required in some patients depending on the clinical presentation, suspected etiology and physician preference and training. The criteria for placing a chest tube in massive pleural effusions include associated pneumothorax or hemothorax, respiratory and hemodynamic instability, and grade III-V parapneumonic effusions. There are no absolute contraindications for chest tube placement except refusal by the patient or adherence of the lung to the chest wall. History of pleurodesis may also predict better results with thoracentesis. Relative contraindications include coagulopathies, loculations and large tumors masquerading as effusions. Here we report two cases of patients presenting with a tension hydrothorax, one managed with ultrasound-guided thoracentesis and another with a chest tube [11-19].
A 43-year-old male patient presents to the ER with a clinical picture of acute progressive respiratory difficulty during the last 4 days. On admission, there was severe dyspnea with significant use of accessory respiratory muscles, tachycardia (113 bpm), less than normal pulse oximeter (88% SaO2), blood pressure of (89/48 mmHg), absent right pulmonary breath sounds and dullness to percussion. Neither jugular ingurgitation nor muffled heart sounds were present. The patient’s initial chest X-ray showed a massive unilateral right pleural effusion along with tracheal and mediastinal deviation to the opposite hemithorax (Figure 1). Considering the pleural fluid volume, respiratory insult and hemodynamic compromise, a chest tube was inserted using standard Royal College of Surgeons’ and ATLS recommendations; chest tube placed in the 5th intercostal space with anterior axillary line revealed a serosanguinous odorless fluid under pressure. The chest tube was connected to a pleural drainage system without suction and clamped at 1400 cc immediate drainage. Post-thoracostomy chest X-ray confirmed appropriate chest tube position as well as mediastinal and tracheal realignment (Figure 2). Immediately following drainage, the patient’s respiratory pattern, hemodynamics and adequate oxygenation were restored and attained. Pleural fluid analysis showed a malignantexudate effusion, with a negative gram stain and bacterial culture. Follow-up chest X-ray showed a right lung mass not initially visible due to the effusion volume.
A 29-year-old female patient with a clinical history of bilateral metastatic breast cancer treated with chemotherapy and radiotherapy presents to the ER with a clinical picture of 1 week consisting of severe dyspnea, left pleuritic pain and significant use of accessory respiratory muscles. On admission she had a blood pressure of (119/60 mmHg) heart rate of (122 bpm) a respiratory rate of (24 rpm) and O2 saturation of 87%. Physical exam revealed absent left breath sounds, dullness to percussion and jugular ingurgitation. Initial chest X-ray showed a massive left-sided pleural effusion with mediastinal compression and tracheal deviation to the opposite hemithorax (Figure 3). Emergency ultrasound-guided needle decompression revealed 3000 cc of an odorless serous-yellowish fluid under pressure. Post-thoracentesis chest X-ray showed a 25% pneumothorax secondary to needle decompression and the patient had a chest tube placed. Following drainage, the patient’s respiratory pattern and hemodynamics were quickly restored. Postchest tube X-ray showed tracheal and mediastinal realignment, and a low placed chest tube with persistent pleural air later placed on suction (Figure 4). Pleural fluid analysis revealed a malignant-exudate effusion with negative gram-stains.
Massive pleural effusions are defined as occupying >2/3 of the hemithorax and can be either malignant (67%) or non-malignant. 10% of pleural effusions present as massive and 10% of patients with pleural carcinomas have massive effusions with complete hemithorax opacification. Up to 65% of cancer patients will have pleural effusions at one point during their ailment and when present in the context of malignancy, life-expectancy is 4 months. Non-malignant causes include trauma, chylothorax, pancreatitis, cirrhosis, TBC, parapneumonic effusions and other autoimmune diseases. Physical exam will usually show reduced or absent breath sounds over the affected hemithorax along with dyspnea, simple chest X-rays are usually sufficient to confirm increased pleural fluid. Large pleural effusions may be evacuated either by thoracentesis or by tube thoracostomy depending on clinical presentation, suspected etiology and the attending physician’s preference.
The most common complication of thoracentesis is a pneumothorax which can occur in about 20%-39% of cases without the use of radiology; when performed using ultrasound-guidance, pneumothorax rates are reduced to 2.5%-13.9%; of which 30-50% require a chest tube. Chest tube complications have a rate of 3%-18%, the most common being malpositioning. Care must taken when draining the pleural cavity to avoid causing reexpansion lung edema, a rare complication (0.2%) which can appear when pleural fluid or air in a collapsed or trapped lung is evacuated too rapidly [20-24]. Although uncommon, it is recommended not to exceed a fluid drainage of more than 1000 cc at insertion or 1500 cc within the first 24 hours as a precaution. When performing thoracentesis, a more than 1100 cc immediate fluid evacuation increases the risk of developing a pneumothorax, therefore whether tube thoracostomy or thoracentesis is superior for decompressing a tension hydrothorax is still in debate since reestablishing proper cardiothoracic dynamics usually requires an initial drainage of at least 1500 cc. A chest tube therefore can both drain the fluid as well as address a pneumothorax, whereas thoracentesis may result in a patient requiring a second procedure.
Placement of chest tubes or thoracentesis, simple yet high-risk and sometimes lifesaving invasive techniques, are usually performed by surgeons (chest tube), pulmonologists (thoracentesis) and radiologists (image-guided thoracentesis), at teaching hospitals closed thoracostomies are performed mostly by surgery residents and to a minor degree by residents of other specialties. Although placing a chest tube is considered to be a simple procedure, with insufficient expertise and training it can become life threatening. The literature shows that general surgery residents have a lower chest tube complication percentage than residents in other residency programs (7%), family and internal medicine (13%) emergency medicine (40%). Being a non-surgical trainee is thus an independent risk factor for chest tube placement complications. Courses such as the Specialty Skills in Cardiothoracic Surgery Course offered by the Royal College of Surgeons, ATLS training and other similar courses may greatly benefit physicians exposed to chest tube requiring pathologies. One study showed faster tube thoracostomy performances when practiced on simulation-embalmed cadavers. In performances with image-guided thoracentesis; radiologists and radiology residents have the lowest pneumothorax rates of 0.5-1.8% in comparison to other specialties.
A Tension hydrothorax is a rare and potentially fatal medical emergency that can quickly lead to cardiac arrest, early suspicion and detection of this condition may prove lifesaving with the proper decompression with a chest tube or needle thoracentesis [23-33]. This condition continues to be a medical challenge and whether thoracentesis or tube thoracostomy is superior in decompressing a tension hydrothorax remains in debate and a clinical dilemma. The decision is made depending on the attending physician`s preference, equipment availability and the patient’s hemodynamic status. Both of our patients had a malignant tension hydrothorax and decompression technique was chosen according to their individual hemodynamic and respiratory needs.
- Chidambaram S, Sangareddi V, Ganesan G, Dhandapani VE, Ravi MS, et al. (2013) An echocardiographic assessment of cardiovascular hemodynamics in patients with large pleural effusion. Indian Heart J 65: 666-670.
- Kaplan LM, Epstein SK, Schwartz SL, Cao QL, Pandian NG (1995) Clinical, echocardiographic, and hemodynamic evidence of cardiac tamponade caused by large pleural effusions. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 151: 904-908.
- Kisanuki A, Shono H, Kiyonaga K (1992) Two-dimensional echocardiographic demonstration of left ventricular diastolic collapse due to compression by pleural effusion. Am Heart J 122: 1173-1175.
- Alam HB, Levitt A, Molyneaux R, Davidson P, Sample GA (1999) Can pleural effusions cause cardiac tamponade? Chest 116: 1820-1822.
- Vaska K, Wann LS, Sagar K, Klopfenstein HS (1992) Pleural effusion as a cause of right ventricular diastolic collapse. Circulation 86: 609-617.
- Roberts ME, Neville E, Berrisford RG, Antunes G, Ali NJ (2010) Management of a malignant pleural effusion: British thoracic society pleural disease guideline 2010. Thorax 65: ii32-40.
- Okonta KE, Ocheli EO, Okoh PD (2016) Massive pleural fluid collection in adult Nigerians. Ad Med 29: 6946459.
- Jimenez D, Diaz G, Gil D, Cicero A, Perez-Rodríguez E, et al. (2005) Etiology and prognostic significance of massive pleural effusions. Resp Med 99: 1183-1187.
- Porter E, Finley D, Millington T, Phillips J (2017) Small cell lung cancer presenting as tension hydrothorax: A case report. Chest 152: A673.
- Pineda GV (1997) Tension hydrothorax. Acad Emerg Med 4: 836.
- Negus RA, Chachkes JS, Wrenn K (1990) Tension hydrothorax and shock in a patient with a malignant pleural effusion. Am J EmergMed 8: 205-207.
- Vakil E, Faiz SA, Iliescu C, Balachandran DD, Ong P, et al. (2017) Managing post-pneumonectomy tension hydrothorax. Annal Am Thoracic Society 14: 28570153.
- Rabinov KE, Stein MY, Frank H (1966) Tension hydrothorax-an unrecognized danger. Thorax 5: 465-467.
- Chattranukulchai P, Satitthummanid S, Puwanant S, Boonyaratavej S (2013) A rare cause of pulsus paradoxus: Acute tension hydrothorax. BMJ case rep: 1-2
- Yaylali Y, Nassar N, Manthous C (1197) Tension hydrothorax. South Med J 90: 1156-1157.
- DeSouza R, Lipsett N, Spagnolo SV (1977) Mediastinal compression due to tension hydrothorax. Chest 72: 782-783.
- Deal A, Evans D, Counselman FL (2016) Tension hydrothorax from disseminated endometriosis. West J Emerg Med 17: 88-90.
- Dagrosa RL, Martin JF, Bebarta VS (2009) Tension hydrothorax. J Emerg Med 36: 78-79.
- Dev SP, NascimientoJr B, Simone C, Chien V (2007) Chest-tube insertion. New Eng J Med 357: e15.
- Iribhogbe PE, Uwuigbe O (2011) Complications of tube thoracostomy using advanced trauma life support technique in chest trauma. West African J Med 30: 369-372.
- Patel N (2008) Targeted training for tube thoracostomy. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 90: 627.
- Venuta F, Diso D, Anile M, Rendina EA, Onorati I (2017) Chest tubes: Generalities. Thoracic Surg Clinic 27: 1-5.
- McElnay PJ, Lim E (2017) Modern techniques to insert chest drains. Thoracic Surg Clinic 27: 29-34.
- Aylwin CJ, Brohi K, Davies GD, Walsh MS (2008) Pre-hospital and in-hospital thoracostomy: Indications and complications. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 90: 54-57.
- Kesieme EB, Olusoji O, Inuwa IM, Ngene CI, Aigbe E (2015) Management of chest drains: A national survey on surgeonsintraining experience and practice. Niger J Surg 21: 91-95.
- Ball CG, Lord J, Laupland KB, Gmora S, Mulloy RH, et al. (2007) Chest tube complications: How well are we training our residents? Can J Surg 50: 450-458.
- Chung TN, Kim SW, You JS, Chung HS (2016) Tube thoracostomy training with a medical simulator is associated with faster, more successful performance of the procedure. Clin Exp Emerg Med 3: 16.
- Jones PW, Moyers JP, Rogers JT, Rodriguez RM, Lee YG, et al. (2003) Ultrasound-guided thoracentesis: Is it a safer method? Chest 123: 418-423.
- Feller-Kopman D (2006) Ultrasound-guided thoracentesis. Chest 129: 1709-1714.
- Havelock T, Teoh R, Laws D, Gleeson F (2010) Pleural procedures and thoracic ultrasound: British thoracic society pleural disease guideline 2010. Thorax 65: i61-76.
- Wang L, Cherng J, Wang J (2007) Improved lung function after thoracocentesis in patients with paradoxical movement of a hemidiaphragm secondary to a large pleural effusion. Respirol 12: 719-723.
- Fellerkopman D, Berkowitz D, Boiselle P, Ernst A (2007) Large-volume thoracentesis and the risk of reexpansion pulmonary edema. Ann Thoracic Surg 84: 1656-1661.
- Pihlajamaa K, Bode MK, Puumalainen T (2004) Pneumothorax and the value of chest radiography after ultrasound-guided thoracocentesis. Acta Radiol 45: 828-832.
Citation: Vinck E, Peterson T, Villarreal R, Cabrera L, Van den Eijnden L (2018) Malignant Tension Hydrothorax with Mediastinal Shifting: Emergency Decompression of a Rare and Potentially Lethal Respiratory Condition. J Pulm Respir Med 8: 452. Doi: 10.4172/2161-105X.1000452
Copyright: © 2018 Vinck E, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language
Share This Article
Annual Congress on Research and Innovations in Medicine
July 02-03, 2018 Bangkok, Thailand
August 22-23, 2018 Tokyo, Japan
- Total views: 210
- [From(publication date): 0-2018 - Jun 23, 2018]
- Breakdown by view type
- HTML page views: 192
- PDF downloads: 18