Received date: September 04, 2016; Accepted date: September 21, 2016; Published date: September 28, 2016
Citation: Yazdani A, Sivapragasam M, Levêque JM, Moniruzzaman M (2016) Microbial Biocompatibility and Biodegradability of Choline-Amino Acid Based Ionic Liquids. J Microb Biochem Technol 8:415-421. doi: 10.4172/1948-5948.1000318
Copyright: © 2016 Yazdani A, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Microbial & Biochemical Technology
Choline-Amino acid based ionic liquids (AAIL) have sparked recent interest throughout the scientific community due to their allegedly low cost and natural origin. They are considered as a potential “green” solvent to replace conventional volatile organic solvents. However, much is still scarce on their (AAILs) microbial toxicity and biodegradability. This study reports the synthesis of ten AAILs with cholinium cation and variable anions derived from amino acids. Their microbial biocompatibility to gram-positive (Bacillus licheniformis and Staphylococcus aureus) and gram-negative (Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Vibrio cholerae) bacteria and biodegradability by industrial sewage water were analyzed. All the tested AAILs were reported to have EC50 values in the range of 160-1120 mg/L which is deemed “practically harmless” based on hazard rankings. The toxicity trend was seen to reduce as the molecular weight of the anion decreased. The level of mineralization of AAILs through anaerobic microbial breakdown was found to be a factor of anion and its functional group in all the cases. They resulted to over 60% biodegradation in 28 days (readily biodegradable).
Ionic liquids (ILs) are commonly referred to as liquid salts, comprising of anions and cations. Since the past few decades, there has been growing attention towards these new “green” solvents and their applications due to their impressive physicochemical properties such as low boiling point, low vapor pressure, thermal and chemical stability or as reviewed by numerous authors [1-5]. ILs possesses a number of advantages over conventional solvents  and supercritical fluids . Hence, ILs has been used in different aspects of chemical engineering [8-11], nanotechnology , biotechnology [1,13-16] and in the pharmaceutical industry [17-22]. ILs is often characterized by their degree of biocompatibility and biodegradability, a measure which reveals the toxicity and environmental adaptability of ILs. Introducing new applications of ILs in large scale requires consideration not only on the process itself but also evaluation on their potential hazard to the environment. Biocompatibility and biodegradability are characteristics of ILs that tie them up with their practicality in actual chemical and pharmaceutical processes. Thus an ideal IL would be defined as possessing both the aforementioned characteristics while maintaining their unique properties.
The role of amino acids in synthesizing ILs can be found by recognizing their biodegradability and bioactivity features . They are known to possess an improved biodegradability [24,25] and enhanced biocompatibility [24,26]. The other advantages of amino acids are that they are available at relatively low costs  and can be obtained in large quantities with high purity . Nevertheless, many factors still affect properties of ILs such as types of cations and anions [29,30] and also the alkyl-chain length . Since amino acid molecules consist of two functional groups- carboxylic acid and an amino group, they can be used as a cation or an anion in forming unique IL molecules . It is well-known that using different amino acids as cation or anion would change the physicochemical and biological properties of ILs [33-35]. The toxicity mechanism of ILs on microorganism is still a vague process, but it has been suggested that the cation of the ILs permeates the cell structure, subsequently disrupting the microbial membrane . As one of the approaches to find a trend in property changes with altering molecular structure of ILs, molecular engineering can be employed in order to improve toxicity and environmental acceptability (with appropriate choice of cation and anion) . Choline is an essential micronutrient in living organisms involved in many physiological processes such as metabolism and transport of lipids  and it is proven to increase the biodegradability  and lower the toxicity to an acceptable range . Recent studies have shown that cholinium based ionic liquids significantly improved the cytotoxicity , biodegradability and biocompatibility [24,41] towards microorganisms.
This work aims to synthesize AAILs and investigate their biocompatibility using an eco-toxicity test on two types of gram- positive (Bacillus licheniformis and Staphylococcus aureus) and gram- negative (Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Vibrio cholerae) bacteria; then to assess their biodegradability by industrial sewage water microorganisms. In order to evaluate the AAILs’ toxicity, minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) and effective concentration (EC50) are measured.
Synthesis of AAILs
In this experiment, 10 ILs were synthesized by acid-base neutralization. The cation was cholinium based and the anion derived from amino acids [AA] or as depicted in Figure 1. The choline component of the ILs were obtained from choline hydroxide 45% in methanol and reacted with 15% excess amino acid dissolved in methanol via neutralization process for 2 days. The solvents and produced water were separated from IL ([Cho][AA]) by rotary evaporator and moisture vacuum. Ten amino acids namely L-Alanine, L-Arginine, L-Asparagine, L-Glutamine, L-Histidine, L-Methionine, L-Phenylalanine, L-Serine, L-Tryptophan and L-Tyrosine were used to synthesize AAILs. These AAILs were analyzed by 1H-NMR spectra at frequency of 500 MHz using deuterium oxide (D2O) as solvent.
Minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC)
The AAILs were assayed for anti-microbial activity against 4 microbial isolates obtained from the Institute of Medical Research (IMR), Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia and American Type Culture Collection (ATCC). They were Bacillus licheniformis (ATCC 14580), Staphylococcus aureus S38, Vibrio cholerae V 148 and Pseudomonas aeruginosa P20. MIC was determined using the broth microdilution method (CLSIM07- A9, 2008) , developed by the Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute (CLSI), Pennsylavania, USA. Two-fold, seriallydiluted AAILs were dispensed into each of the 96 wells of a standard microdilution plate. The direct colony suspension method was used for inoculum preparation. Bacterial suspension was prepared by direct transfer of colonies from 24 h Mueller Hinton (MH) agar plates to MH broth. Bacterial suspensions were adjusted using bacterial counting chamber to contain approximately 1 × 108 CFU/mL. A 100 μL volume of each bacterial suspension was mixed with 100 μL serially diluted tested compound in 96 microdilution plate according to the microdilution method. Uninoculated wells were prepared as control samples. Plates were incubated at 37°C for 24 h for Staphylococcus aureus S38, Vibrio cholerae V 148, Pseudomonas aeruginosa P20 and 30°C for Bacillus licheniformis (ATCC 14580). The minimum (inhibitory) bacteriocidal concentration was defined as the lowest concentration of test compound producing no visible growth. Confirmation for MIC was achieved by transfer of aliquots from wells containing no growth on to nutrient agar plates and tested for colony formation upon sub culturing. Given values of obtained MIC values are means of three independent experiments.
Biodegradability test was performed according to procedures described by Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) 301 for Closed Bottle Test  using a BOD measurement system (OxiTop-C thermostatically controlled BOD meter from WTW GmbH, Weilheim, Germany). Seeding water sample as the source of biodegradation was taken from an industrial sewage pond in Seri Iskandar, Perak, Malaysia. The dilution water was prepared and mineral medium were added according to the standard procedure and mixed with appropriate amounts of AAILs. Three replicates were prepared for each substance of test, and since it was expected to have a high degree of biodegradation, the samples were introduced with a dilution factor of 10 and oxygen demand limit of 2000 mg/L, manipulated in the settings of OxiTop apparatus. A set of blank test was prepared by adding 5 mL of seed in a fresh medium. Biodegradability is assessed by calculating the percentage oxygen uptake of the theoretical oxygen uptake (ThOD) after 28 days. The results were compared with the ThOD in order to determine the biodegradability of the ILs.
Synthesis of AAILs
AAILs were synthesized in acceptable yields and1H-NMR analysis was performed to verify their structure.
[Cho][Ala]: 1H-NMR (500 MHz, D2O) δ 3.92 (2H, sep), 3.37 (2H, quin), 3.21–3.16 (1H, m), 3.07 (9H, s), 1.08 (3H, d)
[Cho][Arg]: 1H-NMR (500 MHz, D2O) δ 3.79 (2H, sep), 3.42 (1H, q), 3.19 (2H, t), 3.12 (1H, s), 3.02 (13H, s), 0.97(1H, t)
[Cho][Asp]: 1H-NMR (500 MHz, D2O) δ 3.89 (2H, sep), 3.41 (1H, q), 3.35 (2H, t), 3.04 (9H, s), 2.52-2.48 (1H, m), 2.28–2.23 (1H, m)
[Cho][Glu]: 1H-NMR (500 MHz, D2O) δ 3.75 (2H, sep), 3.38 (1H, q), 3.32 (2H,t), 2.94 (9H, s), 2.32 (2H,t), 1.93-1.79 (1H,m), 1.47-1.44 (1H,m)
[Cho][His]: 1H-NMR (500 MHz, D2O) δ 7.45 (1H, s), 6.70 (1H, s), 3.82 (2H, sep), 3.28 (3H, quin), 2.96 (9H, s), 2.77–2.73 (1H, m), 2.28–2.23 (1H, m)
[Cho][Met]: 1H-NMR (500 MHz, D2O) δ 3.93 (2H, sep), 3.39 (2H, quin), 3.20 (1H, q), 3.07 (9H, s), 2.43 (2H, t), 1.99 (3H, s), 1.86-1.76(1H, m), 1.71-1.65(1H, m)
[Cho][Phe]: 1H-NMR (500MHz, D2O) δ 7.26–7.16 (5H, m), 3.89 (2H, sep), 3.38 (2H, quin), 3.20 (1H, d), 3.07 (9H, s), 2.89–2.83 (1H, m), 2.74–2.70 (1H, m)
[Cho][Ser]: 1H-NMR (500 MHz, D2O) δ 3.85(2H, sep), 3.65 (1H,q), 3.52 (2H,t), 3.28 (9H,s), 1.76-1.72(1H, m), 1.67-1.64(1H, m)
[Cho][Trp]: 1H-NMR (500 MHz, D2O) δ 7.58 (1H, d), 7.35 (1H, d), 7.08 (2H, t), 7.03 (1H, t), 3.80 (2H, sep), 3.42 (1H, q), 3.20 (2H, quin), 3.06–3.03 (1H, m), 2.91–2.84 (10H, m)
[Cho][Tyr]: 1H-NMR (500 MHz, D2O) δ 6.90 (2H, d), 6.54 (2H, d), 3.89 (1H, d), 3.35 (2H, quin), 3.17 (2H, d), 3.04 (9H, s), 2.80–2.76 (1H, m), 2.63–2.51 (1H, m)
Minimum inhibitory concentration
We have examined the potential ecotoxicity of the ten ILs towards 4 different microorganisms. Two of the bacteria being gram positive (Staphylococcus aureus and Bacillus licheniformis) and another two being gram negative (Vibrio chlorae and Pseudomonas aeruginosa). It is interesting to note that B. licheniformis and P. aeruginosa are bacterium that produces biosurfactants. For all ILs tested, dose response curves were obtained and EC50 values were calculated in mg/L. In this study, viability of microorganism (in %) after 24 h were used as a measure of the EC50 values. Table 1 shows the EC50 values with respective 95 percent confidence level obtained in the fit of data. The effective concentrations as well as the upper and lower limit of analyzed data are illustrated in the Table 1 with indications being, the higher the EC50 value, the least toxic the AAILs. The highest EC50 value obtained was for Cho[Ala] which showed a toxicity value of 1120 mg/L (50% inhibition) against V. cholerae. Cho[Tyr], on the other hand, was seen to be the most toxic towards B. licheniformis with EC50 values of 160 mg/L.
The evaluation of the biodegradability potential of the studied AAILs was given in Table 2. The values represent the mineralization efficiency of a given AAILs. The biodegradation was carried out over the span of 28 days. The AAILs were inferred to be “readily biodegradable” as all the ILs achieved more than 60% biodegradation against the Theoretical Oxygen Demand (ThOD). The highest overall biodegradation (%) value of AAILs were given in the order of; Cho[Trp]>Cho[Glu]>Cho[A rg]>Cho[Asp]>Cho[Phe]>Cho[Tyr]>Cho[His]>Cho[Ser]>Cho[Met]> Cho[Ala]. The highest and lowest level of biodegradation of 85.8% and 64.1% was observed with Cho[Trp] and Cho[Ala], respectively.
Measure of ILs’ toxicity was based on the parameters by Passino and Smith in  who rank toxicity to be; 100-1000 mg/L-1 as being practically harmless, 10-100 mg/L as being moderately toxic, 1-10 mg/L; slightly toxic and 0.1-1 mg/L being highly toxic. The data in Table 1 show the measured EC50 values vary between 160 mg/L (toxic) and 1120 mg/L (least toxic). As it was expected from using biomaterials (amino acid) derived cations and choline anion, biocompatibility of ILs were in acceptable ranges labelling them as “readily biodegradable” and “practically harmless”. These results were indeed supported by many research groups [36,29,44] in the past. The amino acid based anion in the structure of ILs highly improved the toxicity of the ILs- making it less toxic; although the individual data were dependent on the type of bacteria as another factor. The specific mechanism of toxicity are not well understood however there are several explanations that unravel microbial response in the presence of ILs, such as the modifications of membrane permeability, increase in osmotic pressure, enzyme detoxification or the synthesis of metabolites (allowing the entrapment of the contaminant, both extracellular and intracellular) [36,45,46]. Biological membranes, such as bacterial surfaces (being non-polar interfaces), has the ability to be disrupted by a hydrophobic/ionic adsorption phenomenon at the cell-membrane interface which then generates various responses towards ILs. As the nature of the gram negative bacteria supposes, V. cholerae was more viable towards the tested AAILs in comparison with S. aureus and B. licheniformis. This can be clearly seen in the respective EC50 value of every tested AAIL. Cho[Tyr] which has a comparably larger anion molecule shows a higher toxicity with an EC50 value of 160 mg/L towards B. licheniformis compared to other AAILs, then followed by Cho[Trp] and Cho[Phe] with EC50 value of 194 and 217 mg/L respectively. The least toxic IL to this type of bacteria is found to be Cho[Asp] with EC50 value of 588 mg/L followed by Cho[Ala] (474 mg/L) and Cho[Met] (417 mg/L). It is necessary to mention that not all of the tested AAILs are “harmless” but they can be considered as “practically harmless” (>100 mg/L)  to B. licheniformis which is the most sensitive bacterium in this study. Also noteworthy, B. licheniformis and P. aeruginosa were chosen as bacteriasubclass producing surfactants. They represent the class of bacteria that produce biofilms and have widely used in the past [47-49].
The results of AAILs’ EC50 value in contact with V. cholerae are considerably higher in many cases compared to P. aeruginosa, even though both of them are gram-negative bacteria. By observing the obtained results for P. aeruginosa and V. cholerae, Cho[Trp] and Cho[Tyr] are demonstrating the least biocompatibility compared to others based on their EC50 value. The remaining AAILs show acceptable range of biocompatibility and to be categorized as practically harmless; furthermore, Cho[Ser] and Cho[Ala] with an EC50 value of higher than 1000 mg/L are branded as harmless to P. aeruginosa and V. cholerae respectively. The toxicity effects of ILs towards microorganisms relates to a common cellular structural process. The interaction between the ILs and bacteria cells leads to cellular membrane disruption which then causes membrane-bound protein disruption. The EC50 values show that the effect of AAILs on gram-negative bacterium is considerably lower than the gram-positive bacteria. By incubating the same AAILs with P. aeruginosa (gram-negative), majority of the tested AAILs show comparably high EC50 (less toxic) values unlike the gram-positive bacteria. The effect of Cho[Asp] (906 mg/L), Cho[Glu] (800 mg/L) and Cho[Met] (715 mg/L) on P. aeruginosa are very similar to their effect on V. cholerae. The EC50 values are relatively higher, meaning they are less toxic towards P. aeruginosa. This is due to the presence of an outer peptidoglycan layer adjutant to the cytoplasmic membrane of the cell. This scenario decreases permeability of the ILs into the cells, making it able to withstand the presence of ILs into its surroundings.
Figure 2 depicts a visual comparison of biocompatibility in terms of bubble size. From the figure it can be clearly observed that Cho[Trp] has the most toxic impact on the tested bacteria (based on the small size of the bubble). Results show that changing anion produces different biocompatibility characteristics for AAILs. Gram-positive bacteria are more sensitive to these changes compared to gram-negative types. Cho[Asp] revealed acceptable biocompatibility and on the other hand Cho[Trp] and Cho[Tyr] showed less biocompatibility towards all the tested bacteria. This is due to the presence of an aromatic ring in structure of the anion which leads to higher toxicity to the tested microorganism [50,51].
The molecular weight of the anion (g/mol) follows the order of Ala<Ser<Glu< Met< His<Phe<Arg<Tyr<Trp; with Cho[Trp] having the largest molecular weight. By comparing the EC50 values and the molecular weight of the anion molecules in the structure of AAILs, it can be seen that the smaller the value of the molecular weight, the lower the toxicity values which is also supported by . As the anion molecular size increases either by chain length or presence of functional groups, the EC50 value of those AAILs decreases [52,53] which is a similar trend observed in this study. Therefore, the smaller and lighter the anions are the more biocompatible the AAILs are. However, according to some authors the anions of IL do not affect the ecotoxicity but instead determines their physical and chemical properties which include solubility, viscosity and melting temperatures [54,55]. Recent studies indicate that the anion effect has been overlooked for it possibility to contribute to the overall toxicity ; focusing on fluorine as the anion which collectively played role in the toxicity of the ILs. The OECD guideline mentions that the studied compound must exceed the threshold mineralization efficiency of 60% (within 28 days) in order to be considered as “readily” biodegradable. Taking this gage into consideration, it can be concluded that all the studied AAILs can referred to as “readily” biodegradable. “Readily biodegradable” substances go through biodegradation in wastewater treatment plants or in natural water reservoirs within short terms and they are not persistent.
|Ionic Liquid||S. aureus||B. licheniormis||P. aeruginosa||V. cholerae|
|24 h EC50 (mg/L) (low-high)||24 h EC50 (mg/L) (low-high)||24 h EC50 (mg/L) (low-high)||24 h EC50 (mg/L)
Table 1: Mean effective concentration (EC50) of the AAILs towards different bacteria.
|Entry||Ionic Liquid||Biodegradability (%) 28 days|
|1||[Cho][Ala]||64.1 Â± 2.2|
|2||[Cho][Met]||65.1 Â± 3.9|
|3||[Cho][Ser]||71.1 Â± 3.2|
|4||[Cho][His]||72.5 Â± 3.0|
|5||[Cho][Tyr]||72.8 Â± 2.6|
|6||[Cho][Phe]||73.8 Â± 1.8|
|7||[Cho][Asp]||77.0 Â± 5.5|
|8||[Cho][Arg]||77.3 Â± 4.5|
|9||[Cho][Glu]||83.5 Â± 2.0|
|10||[Cho][Trp]||85.8 Â± 9.4|
Table 2: Biodegradability (%) of the AAILs.
It is generally known that the incorporation of choline cation as well as carboxyl and amino groups in the anion highly improves the biodegradability of ILs [24,37]. However, a variation to biodegradability values indicate that the type of anion incorporated in the structure of AAILs has a vital effect in determining the quality of biodegradation. Also observed, the biodegradability of the AAILs improved as the size of the anion molecule increased. For AAILs with bigger anion molecules such as L-Tryptophan (containing an indole ring functional group) the biodegradability was as high as 85.8%. Heterocyclic indole functional group is known as an environmental pollutant which goes through biodegradation under sulfate reduction at high rates . L-Histidine is also a relatively big molecule incorporated by an imidazole functional group but the biodegradability value of Cho[His] was about 72.5% since the imidazole functional group does not favor high biodegradation . L-Phenylalanine incorporates a benzene ring and L-Tyrosine incorporates phenol as a functional group in their molecules. This has resulted in a difference in biodegradability values of Cho[Phe] (72.8%) and Cho[Tyr] (73.8%). This can be explained through an extra oxygen atom that phenol functional group possesses .
Another relationship can be derived between biodegradability and the alkyl side chain length of anion is by comparing Cho[Asp] and Cho[Glu] (77% and 83.5% biodegradation respectively). Longer alkyl side chain length of anion structure also helped with a higher biodegradability range. Since L-Glutamine has a longer side chain compared to L-Asparagine, the biodegradability values obtained for these AAILs suggest that the longer side chain length improves biodegradability; this is because the amount of oxygen required by the microbial consortia to degrade the larger compounds is higher. Cho[Met] and Cho[Arg] are another examples of this case. However presence of thioether functional group in L-Methionine is the reason for lower biodegradability of Cho[Met]. Also, L-Arginine has a guanidine functional group in its molecule that is proved to be susceptible to biodegradation . Therefore, biodegradation is influenced by both size and side chain length of the anion molecule and is a strong factor of functional groups present in the molecular structure of anion. There is a rising concern on the link between biodegradability; stating that ILs with long alkyl chain are toxic but easily biodegradable [24,52]. However, this conflict can be put to rest when employing choline based amino acid ILs since the low toxicity correlates with high biodegradability values.
Eco-toxicity results of AAILs reveal that different anions impose different effects on microorganisms. The molecular structure of anion can be taken into analysis to justify their effect. It was found that bigger anion molecules were more toxic and smaller anion sizes improved the biocompatibility. It is necessary to mention that the type of microorganism is also an important factor in analyzing and concluding the toxicity of AAILs since each of the gram-negative and gram-positive bacteria showed different reactions to an individual IL. As it was expected from choline based AAILs to improve the toxicity, the obtained results met this expectation confirming that these ILs are at least “practically harmless” to various bacteria. The effect of anion molecule sizes in biodegradability concluded to have a direct effectlarger the anion molecule, greater the biodegradability.
Authors would like to thank the Centre of Research in Ionic Liquids (CORIL), Universiti Teknologi PETRONAS for their financial support.