Department of Chemistry, University of Toronto, ON, Canada
Received date: July 17, 2016; Accepted date: July 28, 2017; Published date: August 04, 2017
Citation: Naugler DG, Prosser RS (2017) Notes on Synthesis of Perdeutero-5-13C,5,5,5-Trifluoroisoleucine VI56. J Chromatogr Sep Tech 8:375. doi: 10.4172/2157-7064.1000375
Copyright: © 2017 Naugler DG, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Chromatography & Separation Techniques
The 13CF3 group is a promising label for heteronuclear (19F,13C) NMR studies of proteins. Desirable locations for this NMR spin label include the branched chain amino acid methyl groups. It is known that replacement of CH3 by CF3 at such locations preserves protein structure and function and enhances stability. 13CF3 may be introduced at the δ position of isoleucine and incorporated biosynthetically in highly deuterated proteins. This paper reports our work in synthesis and purification of 5,5,5-trifluoroisoleucine, its perdeutero and 5-13C versions and of 2-13C-trifluoroacetate and its utility as a precursor for introduction of the 13CF3 group into proteins.
13C; 19F; Heteronuclear; Paramagnetic; NMR; Spin label; Methyl TROSY; Unnatural amino acid; Fluorous; Lipophilic; Protein expression
Fluorine NMR and labelling strategies in proteins
Fluorine NMR spectroscopy is a powerful method for the study of both structure and dynamics of proteins and their interactions with other proteins or ligands [1-4]. Because of the ability of the 19F lone-pair electrons to participate in non-bonded interactions with the local environment, 19F chemical shifts are sensitive to changes in van der Waals contacts, electrostatic fields and hydrogen bonding. As such, 19F chemical shifts (or changes in shifts) are often indicative of conformational changes [5-8] binding  and protein folding or unfolding events [10-12]. Fluorinated probes are also frequently used to assess solvent exposure, via chemical shift changes or relaxation effects resulting from: 1) substituting H2O for 2H2O  paramagnetic additives such as Gd3+: EDTA2 heteronuclear nuclear Over Hauser effects . In membranous systems, analogous paramagnetic effects are also observed upon addition of nitroxide spin-labels  or dissolved oxygen [15,16] facilitating the study of topology and immersion depth via fluorinated probes. Finally, associated 19F spin-spin and spin-lattice relaxation rates are useful for studying conformational dynamics over a wide range of timescales, due to the significant chemical shift dispersion, shift anisotropy, and large heteronuclear dipolar relaxation terms [17-20].
Fluorine labelling of proteins is achieved in many ways. Via biosynthetic means, monofluorinated versions of tyrosine, phenylalanine, and tryptophan may be substituted for their nonfluorinated equivalents, often with little effect on overall expression yields [2,4]. Fluorinated versions of methionine [7,21] proline , leucine  and isoleucine  have also been successfully incorporated into proteins. An alternative approach to 19F labelling of proteins is to make use of a thiol specific fluorinated probe, which frequently consists of a terminal trifluoromethyl group . In this way, a fluorine tag may be placed at virtually any site in the protein, using successive single cysteine mutations of the protein under study. Thus, the majority of 19F labels used in protein NMR fall under the category of isotopic fluoroaromatic or trifluoromethyl species. For very large proteins, spectral overlap may become problematic for biosynthetically labelled proteins. However, a doubly (13C, 19F) labeled amino acid should provide greater resolution in two-dimensional (19F,13C) NMR spectra, with further possibilities of assignment without mutational analysis. Moreover, such two-dimensional NMR schemes should benefit from the relatively large one bond (13C,19F) coupling which is between 265 and 285 Hz for both fluoroaromatics and trifluoromethyl groups. Finally, the possibilities for studying dynamics from a 13C,19F pair encompasses a much greater range, since various zero, single, and double quantum coherences in addition to Zeeman and two-spin longitudinal order, may be separately evolved and studied [25,26]. In this paper, we present a method for the preparation of perdeuterated isoleucine, in which the terminal trifluoromethyl group consists of a 13C-19F pair. The motivation for this work is to develop a useful doubly labelled species for subsequent nD NMR studies of proteins, whose isoleucine residues have been fluorinated.
Advantages of a trifluoromethyl group
The trifluoromethyl group is expected to be a useful probe of molecular structure and dynamics, particularly in the hydrophobic core of proteins, at the interface between protein complexes, and in the membrane or detergent interior in studies of integral membrane proteins. Expressed within proteins, the CF3 group offers additional benefits of sensitivity and relatively long transverse relaxation times. However, the inherent slow rotational tumbling associated with large proteins or protein complexes, and membrane proteins, results in line broadening and reduced sensitivity. 19F spin labels also suffer extensively from dipolar relaxation with nearby proton spins of the protein , which may be largely avoided by extensive deuteration. Furthermore, in situations where 13C,19F two-dimensional NMR schemes are employed, the use of transverse relaxation optimized spectroscopy (TROSY) techniques [27,28], may be considered. The TROSY effect in methyl groups, results from interference between intramethyl dipolar interactions . As such, the effect is independent of field, to the extent that chemical shift anisotropy does not contribute to relaxation. Since the geometry of the trifluoromethyl group is like that of a CH3 group, while the gyromagnetic ratio of the 19F nucleus is 0.83 times that of 1H, the methyl TROSY effect would be expected to be preserved in appropriate (19F,13C) two-dimensional schemes. In particular, in the rigid limit, the maximum peak intensities in the (1H,13C) HMQC are predicted to depend on terms which are derived from relaxation via reorientation of either the CF or FF intramolecular bonds i.e., transverse rates proportional to and, to a lesser extent, . In this case, Saxis and τc represent the local order parameter of the methyl rotor and the global correlation time associated with rotational tumbling of the protein. Finally, γC and γF represent the magnetogyric ratios of 13C and 19F, respectively while rCF and rFF designate the intramolecular bond lengths. In the (19F,13C) HMQC, where we estimate the CF and FF intramolecular bond lengths in a trifluoromethyl group to be 1.33 Å and 2.12 Å respectively, the above transverse rates are predicted to be more than three times smaller than those for the CH3 groups, in the absence of external dipolar relaxation or relaxation due to chemical shift anisotropy.
The trifluoromethyl probe in isoleucine
Considering these anticipated advantages for 1D and 2D NMR, we have developed a protocol for the synthesis and purification of perdeuterated 5,5,5-trifluoroisoleucine, in which the carbon nucleus of the trifluoromethyl group is 13C enriched. Incorporation, using a cellfree protein expression technique, is reported . We also describe herein a synthesis strategy for 2-13C-trifluoroacetate and purification of the ammonium salt (or hypothetically CF3CO2H), to produce perdeutero 5-13C-5,5,5-trifluoroisoleucine. This report is intended to communicate some of the subtleties involved in these efforts.
Isoleucine has some additional features that make it attractive for (19F, 13C) double labelling. At neutral pH, isoleucine is the most hydrophobic of the aliphatic side chain amino acids and it is often highly conserved at positions involved in hydrophobic interactions. Consequently, isoleucine often functions at the hydrophobic binding cleft. For example, isoleucine residues 737 and 898 in the human androgen receptor ligand binding domain mediates interdomain communication with the NH2-terminal domain, which in turn mediates transcriptional activation . Calmodulin provides another example. 1H NMR studies of amide proton exchange rates of Ca2+-saturated calmodulin and a Ca2+-saturated calmodulin-mastoparan complex showed a reduction in solvent accessibility of Ile27 upon mastoparan binding . Genomic analysis of membrane protein families informs us of amino acid abundances and conserved motifs. The most abundant amino acids in transmembrane regions are leucine, isoleucine, valine, phenylalanine, alanine, glycine, serine, and threonine. Taken together, these amino acids account for 75% of the amino acids in transmembrane regions. In contrast, isoleucine (10% abundance versus 4% conserved), valine (8% versus 4%), methionine (4% versus 1%) and threonine (7% versus 4%) are less prevalent in conserved positions . Large hydrophobic (Phe, Leu, Ile, Val) residues show a clear preference for the protein surfaces facing the lipids for β-barrels, but in α-helical proteins, no such preference is seen, with these residues equally distributed between the interior and the surface of the protein .
The scheme shown below shows the route used to make 5,5,5-trifluoroisoleucine as a racemic mixture of diastereomers . This scheme is modified for perdeuteration by substitution with cyanoacetic acid-d3, acetone-d6, CF3CO2D, ammonium-d4 acetate-d3 and D2/Pd. Modification of this scheme for the 13CF3 amino acid requires electrochemical trifluoromethylation using 13CF3CO2-.
Melting points are uncorrected. 1H, 19F and 13C NMR spectra were recorded on Varian Gemini 200 MHz and Unity Inova 600 MHz spectrometers. 2H NMR spectra were recorded on the Varian Unity Inova 600 MHz spectrometer. UV spectra were recorded using a Biochrom Libra S22 UV/Visible spectrophotometer. IR spectra were recorded using a Nicolet Avatar 360 E.S.P. FT-IR spectrometer. GC/MS was done using a Shimadzu GCMS-QP5050 system. LC/MS was performed using a system comprised of a Waters/Alliance 2690 liquid chromatography module and a Waters Micromass ZQ ESI mass spectrometer. Hydrogenation was performed with a Parr high-pressure hydrogenation apparatus. Electrochemical trifluoromethylation was performed with a Sargent Slomin analyzer with (one spinning) platinum mesh electrodes.
Synthesis of methallylcyanide and methallylcyanide-d7
Synthesis of methallylcyanide and methallylcyanide-d7 relies on ‘active hydrogen’ chemistry, i.e., exchangeable protons/deuterons. Wang et al. cite a synthesis reported by Marson et al. . Cyanoacetic acid (e.g., 50.0 g, 0.59 mol), acetone (34.2 g, 0.59 mol), and ammonium acetate (4.0 g, 0.05 mol) (or their perdeutero counterparts) in dry benzene (100 mL) were refluxed with a Dean-Stark trap. Reflux was performed until one equivalent of water (or D2O) was collected in the trap. Due to the cost of perdeuteroammonium acetate, a minimal amount of this catalyst was used. The quantity was observed not to be critical to yield. One gram of ammonium-d4 acetate-d3 will suffice for the synthesis of methallylcyanide-d7. The Dean-Stark unit was replaced with a distillation head and the fraction collected between 110°C and 115°C.
Compton et al. reports the existence of both 3-methyl-2-butenenitrile and 3-methyl-3-butenenitrile in a sample of methallylcyanide. This is consistent with an equilibrium arising from ‘active hydrogen’ chemistry as evidenced by the 2H NMR spectrum in Figure 1, below. The predicted boiling points for these isomers are within 2°C, so they cannot be separated by fractional distillation. Accordingly, this product is properly called methallylcyanide  rather than 3-methyl-but- 3-enenitrile . Appreciation of the active hydrogen nature of this product is required to make methallylcyanide-d7.
Synthesis of methallylcyanide-d7 requires the preparation of cyanoacetic acid-d3, first and then its condensation with acetone-d6, catalyzed by ammonium-d4 acetate-d3. 50 grams of cyanoacetic acid was dissolved with warming in a minimum quantity of D2O, then left overnight to affect exchange. Excess H2O/D2O was subsequently removed with a rotary-evaporator, and the wet crystals further dried overnight in a vacuum desiccator. Because not all H2O/D2O can be removed by this procedure, subsequent steps require less D2O to affect dissolution. The proton/deuteron exchange procedure was executed three times and the product submitted for mass spectral analysis. Three more H/D exchange steps were performed. The resulting cyanoacetic acid-d3 was condensed with a molar excess of actetone-d6 in the presence of ammonium-d4 acetate-d3 and the water of condensation was analyzed by 1H NMR. The trace aqueous solubility of benzene is known. Comparison of integrated peak intensities showed that the water of condensation contained 0.6% H2O and 99.4% D2O. Given that all H/D sites are exchangeable, it is concluded that methallylcyanide-d7 obtained after decarboxylation and distillation of the condensation product was 99.4% isotopically pure. This isotopic purity is consistent with that of the reagents used. See the 2H NMR spectrum in Figures 1 and 2.
Electrochemical trifluoromethylation of methallylcyanide-d7
Muller chose to perform electrochemical trifluoromethylation of methallylcyanide in aqueous 90% methanol between platinum electrodes whereas we chose a later system of CH3CN and H2O (8:1) . An electrochemical solvent system of acetonitrile and water necessitates further use of acetonitrile and D2O for methallylcyanide-d7.
Because of hydrogen exchange chemistry of methallylcyanide-d7, special care needs to be applied to the adaptation of this reaction to a perdeuterated substrate. H2O needs to be replaced by D2O. Both MeOD and CH3CN methyls ought to be resistant to H/D exchange under the conditions of the reaction but CH3CN is cheaper than MeOD and so is a better choice. Muller chose to use a 73% molar excess of CF3CO2H relative to methallylcyanide and to use a slight coulombic excess . Dmowski chose to use a 20 times molar excess of TFA relative to substrate and 1.5 Faradays per mole of TFA. Because both methallylcyanide-d7 and 2-13C-trifluoracetate are very expensive these should be used in 1:1 molar ratio and with 50% excess current. Both authors achieved mild basic condition with 10% Na.
We used a Sargent Slomin S-29460 electrolytic analyzer, for radical trifluoromethylation. Both rotating and stationary electrodes were platinum. The rotating platinum electrode was chosen to be the anode. At the anode, reactions CF3CO2 -→CF3CO2+e-→ CF3+CO2↑ and at the cathode 2H++2e- → H2↑, both yield gases. The spinning electrode helps stirring and shakes off gas bubbles. Upon entering the limiting current region increasing the applied voltage is counterproductive. Gas production observation aids adjustment.
Muller’s workup  was followed, as described below. For methallylcyanide-d7, H2O should be replaced by D2O, H2 by D2 and MeOH by MeOD or some other exchange resistant solvent such as CH3CN. An iron (steel) cathode would minimize loss of valuable substrate by electrolytic hydrogenation.
The mixture was poured into 700 mL of water, the dense oil collected, and the aqueous layer extracted with two 40 mL portions of dichloromethane. The combined organic layers from three identical runs were distilled to remove the solvent and then steam distilled. The nonaqueous layer was a mixture of 3-methyl-5,5,5-trifluoropentanonitrile, several isomeric 3-methyl-5,5,5-trifluoropentenonitriles, methallyl cyanide, and unidentified by-products. It was diluted with methanol and hydrogenated at low pressure over 5% Pd/C. Distillation afforded 66 g of nearly pure 3-methyl-5,5,5-trifluoropentanonitrile, b.p. 166- 171°C.
For the perdeutero route, once the various isomeric perdeutero- 3-methyl-5,5,5-trifluoropentenonitriles are reduced by D2, exchange is no longer possible. Subsequent steps closely follow the protocol outlined by Muller as does this exposition. Quantities were adjusted proportionately.
The distillation product, 3-methyl-5,5,5-trifluoropentanonitrile was stirred with sufficient concentrated aqueous hydrochloric acid to bring most of the organic material into solution, for several days, then diluted with water and refluxed overnight. The separated organic layer was isolated, dried over Na2SO4, and distilled at 6 torr, giving 58.3 g of 3-methyl-5,5,5-trifluoropentanoic acid, b.p. 76-81°C.
58.3 g (0.343 mol) of 3-methyl-5,5,5-trifluoropentanoic acid, 19.1 mL of bromine and 0.6 mL of phosphorus trichloride were refluxed with a trap to absorb gaseous hydrogen bromide until the colour of bromine had disappeared. On distilling at 6 torr, about 6 g of 3-methyl- 5,5,5-trifluoropentanoic acid were recovered. 60 g of distillate boiling at 100-106°C consisted mainly of nearly equal amounts of the two diastereomers of 2-bromo-3-methyl-5,5,5-trifluoropentanoic acid. This mixture was used for the preparation of 2-amino-3-methyl-5,5,5- trifluoropentanoic acid without further purification. 64.4 g (0.259 mol) of this nearly pure 2-bromo-3-methyl-5,5,5-trifluoropentanoic acid and 225 mL of concentrated aqueous ammonia were cautiously mixed and stored in a closed flask at 44-48°C for 5 days. The stopper was removed and the mixture gently heated with a water bath to drive off excess ammonia and reduce the volume to about 90 mL.
We observed the formation of polymeric materials and so we could not crystallize the product from our reaction mixture. Accordingly, we developed several purification methods discussed in the next section.
Purification of a reaction mixture containing 2-amino-3- methyl-5,5,5-trifluoropentanoic acid
Two factors are likely to alter the physical properties of 5,5,5-trifluoroisoleucine relative to native isoleucine. The inductive effect of the CF3 group will make the amino acid and amino groups more acidic and the greater hydrophobicity of the CF3 group will enhance the hydrolytic stability of its polymers [38,39].
In our hands, reaction of a mixture of diastereomers of 2-bromo-3- methyl-5,5,5-trifluoropentanoic acid with aqueous ammonia produced a product mixture that contained a significant quantity of polymeric material. Some of this material was readily soluble in diethyl ether and CDCl3. That fraction that was soluble in organic solvent could be hydrolysed by dissolution in TFA followed by gradual addition of water. We found that the reaction mixture could be stabilized by formation of the TFA salt.
We first chose a method of chemical purification that was appropriate for the partial fluorous character of the amino acid [40-42]. The use of a C8F17 BOC derivative  proved to be problematic because the only rational method for its hydrolysis was the use of TFA and we already had made the TFA salt. Exploitation of the C8F17 Cbz derivative  proved to be more fruitful. A product mixture was dissolved in THF and a minimal quantity of water and reacted with a small molar excess of N-[4-(1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorodecyl) benzyloxycarbonyloxy] succinimide. The resulting C8F17 Cbz derivative was purified by solid phase extraction on fluorous silica . This derivative was subjected to atmospheric pressure hydrogenolysis over 5%Pd/C and the subsequent product mixture subjected to fluorous SPE. Lyophilization yielded a soluble product that was white. Incorporation of this product in calmodulin  (M. Kainosho: private communication) using a cell free protein expression system proved that the product mixture contained ≤ 25% 5,5,5-trifluoro-L-isoleucine and proved the efficacy of the chemical purification.
During lyophilization, much of the product was lost due to sublimation. Sublimation has recently been revisited as a means for purification of amino acids . We found that our chemically purified product mixture could be sublimed at 150°C and 6 mm Hg, but that fractional sublimation would require better vacuum and temperature control.
Finally, we exploited ion exchange chromatography using cellulose phosphate to separate monomeric and polymeric fractions. Elution with distilled H2O yielded a microcrystalline fraction while elution with dilute aqueous ammonia yielded a waxy fraction identifiable as polymeric material. Refinement of ion exchange column purification should be developed using ion exchange TLC on cellulose phosphate paper.
We explored the use of analytical HPLC-MS first using an acetonitrile gradient in 0.1% aqueous TFA on a C18 column. 2-amino- 3-methyl-5,5,5-trifluoropentanoic acid has a molecular weight of 185. We identified two separated peaks corresponding to [M+] and [M+H+] on an ESI-MS instrument. We conclude that these are the diastereomers and that differential inductive effects due to CF3 cause differing acid/base properties of the diastereomers. These peaks were followed at longer time by peaks due to polymers. We wished to explore the possibility of preparative scale chromatography where TFA would be counterproductive. An isocratic method was developed using 5% acetonitrile in 0.2% aqueous formic acid on an analytical C18 column.
To embed the 13CF3 group into a synthetic scheme for 5,5,5-trifluoroisoleucine following the synthetic scheme above, a route to 2-13C-trifluoroacetate is required. Trifluoro acetic acid has been made via electrochemical fluorination . Since this electrolysis would entail use of anhydrous hydrogen fluoride within a customized Teflon reaction vessel, a refrigeration unit, a high current power supply and a process control system, we chose to explore an alternate route involving halogen exchange with 2-13C-tribromoacetic acid. We devised a new route to 2-13C-tribromoacetic acid starting with 2-13C-ethanol, discussed below.
Halogen exchange reaction design considerations
Preliminary experiments were performed following the halogen exchange reaction originated by Ref. . Mass spectral analysis of an early natural abundance test reaction showed that trifluoro acetic acid was formed by reaction of AgBF4 with CBr3CO2H in DCM. However, 13C NMR multiple analysis of a test reaction with 13CBr3CO2H showed a conversion to 13CF3CO2H of only 18% after stirring at for 10 days at room temperature. A longer reaction time in glassware was found to be counterproductive because of failure of containment. AgBF4 releases highly aggressive BF3 during the reaction. The reaction between BF3 and silica gel [46,47], is useful at the purification stage, however, reaction with ground glass joints may give rise to leakage.
A procedure for making 2-13C-trifluoroacetic acid
The following procedure was designed to avoid the necessity of handling hydrogen fluoride, either as a solvent, reagent, or product. Synopsis: 2-13C-ethanol is converted to the tribromoacetaldehyde, 2-13C-bromal (hydrate) using a molar excess of bromine, Br2. One equivalent of water converts the product mixture to bromal hydrate. Reaction with excess nitric acid at a temperature less than 50°C converted bromal hydrate to 2-13C-bromoacetic acid. This product is isolated and converted to 2-13C-trifluoroacetic acid using AgBF4 under pressure in dichloromethane. The 2-13C-trifluoroacetate is extracted into ammonia. Impure ammonium 2-13C-trifluoroacetate can be enhanced in purity by sublimation at 85°C and with a vacuum less than 10 microns Hg. The yields were very low.
Conversion of 2-13C-ethanol to 2-13C-bromal (hydrate)
The reaction proceeds according to:
2-13C-ethanol+4Br2 → 2-13C-bromal+5HBr
In a closed system, the above is an equilibrium reaction. To drive the reaction to completion, product HBr gas must be permitted to escape. This loss of mass results in a considerable reduction in the volume of the reaction mixture. We have tried sulphur and I2 as catalysts. TFA is probably a better catalyst for this reaction. The oxidation potential of Br2 is not sufficient to carry oxidation beyond the aldehyde. The aldehyde is required for tribromination, because each bromination step proceeds via the enol. To avoid loss of volatiles, 2-13C-ethanol and excess Br2 were combined at liquid nitrogen temperature and warmed very slowly to reflux temperature. When the reaction has been driven to completion, 13C NMR shows the presence of only 2-13C-bromal (~40 ppm) and its hydrate (~12 ppm). Prior to the next step, it may be desirable to isolate 2-13C-bromal via distillation, and its hydrate by crystallization but it is not essential. One equivalent of H2O is added to convert all to hydrate.
Conversion of 2-13C-bromal hydrate to 2-13C-tribromoacetic acid
13CBr3CH(OH)2+HNO3 → 13CBr3CO2H+½N2O4+H2O
The more stable hydrate of tribromoacetaldehyde is the species oxidized. Completion of this reaction can be determined by 13C NMR (~34 ppm). At completion of reaction, excess nitric acid is removed under vacuum. Purity can be determined by melting point, 128°C.
Conversion of 2-13C-tribromoacetic acid to 2-13C-trifluoroacetic acid
This reaction is conducted in dichloromethane. This three-step reaction is exceedingly slow. For practical synthesis, it is necessary to conduct this reaction in a sealed pressure reaction vessel at above 75°C. The completion of this reaction can be determined by 13C NMR (quartet at 116.6 ppm is dominant) or 19F NMR (doublet at -76.55 ppm is dominant). Under standard conditions BF3 is a gas, whereas BF3∙(C2H5)2O is liquid. A strong Lewis acid, BF3 forms a complex with diethyl ether. This reduces the pressure. At the completion of the reaction, the DCM reaction mixture is eluted through silica gel. SiO2 reacts with BF3. 2-13C-trifluoroacetate is extracted into aqueous ammonia and excess removed under vacuum. Ammonium 2-13C-trifluoroacetate was converted into a fine powder by lyophilization, to aid in sublimation. Ammonium 2-13C-trifluoroacetate was sublimed to improve purity by sublimation at 85°C and less than 10 microns Hg vacuum. Because initial purity was poor, yield was poor. Gram scale quantities of material could be processed in this way.
Manipulation of 13C haloacetates
The halogen exchange reaction between 2-13C-tribromoacetic acid and AgBF4 proceeds in a stepwise fashion and hence yields a mixture of haloacetates. The target compound, 2-13C-trifluoroacetic acid is too volatile and so the haloacetate mixture is best manipulated as a salt. The ammonium salts have volatilities that were exploited for purification by high vacuum sublimation and the progress of purification was monitored by 19F and 13C NMR. Whereas high vacuum sublimation has only one theoretical plate, the greater load capacity compared to chromatography affords it an advantage for the first stages of purification. Repeated stages of high vacuum sublimation yielded a product that gave three spots on silica gel TLC. Neutral alumina TLC gave streaks. One spot showed an Rf=0.78 on silica gel TLC that was identical to the Rf of natural abundance ammonium trifluoroacetate, eluted with 10% aqueous ammonia in methanol. Based on this observation, the ammonium 13C haloacetate mixture was subjected to preparative TLC under the same conditions. 19F and 13C NMR of the product from the preparative TLC target band showed that the mixture consisted of ammonium salts of 2-13C-trifluoroacetate, 2-13C-bromodifluoroacetate and 2-13C-dibromofluoroacetate (Table 1).
|δ (19F) ppm*||δ (2-13C) ppm||1JCF Hz|
*Relative to TFA, -76.55 ppm
Table 1: 19F and 13C NMR of the product from the preparative TLC target band showed the mixture consisted of ammonium salts of 2-13C-trifluoroacetate, 2-13C-bromodifluoroacetate and 2-13C- dibromofluoroacetate.
It is interesting to note that CF3I has been enriched to 86% in 13C by selective multiphoton dissociation of 12CF3I at pressures less than 1.0 torr . A more practical method would rely on enrichment in the condensed phase. An isotope effect is often observed on melting points . In recent work, boron has been enriched to 93.21% in 10B and 99.01% in 11B by zone refining . It is known that isotope effects on heat capacity and crystal transition temperature can be detected by differential scanning calorimetry . Zone refining of low melting ammonium trifluoroacetate (M.P 123°C) would be more energy efficient than that of high melting boron (M.P 2079°C). In future, we plan to develop an analytical HPLC method and to use preparative HPLC for the purification of ammonium 2-13C-trifluoroacetate. Infrared difference spectroscopy may be able to resolve the carbon isotope effect for ammonium 2-13C-trifluoroacetate in the condensed phase. Differential scanning calorimetry of ammonium 2-13C-trifluoroacetate will provide the thermodynamic information needed to plan and develop a zone refining method for the extraction of ammonium 2-13C-trifluoroacetate from an inexpensive natural abundance melt.
Another promising route to 13C enriched TFA that we may explore is that of fluorodeoxygenation , starting with glycine. Recently a new and better synthesis of arylsulfur trifluorides has been reported for reagents that may provide a convenient route to fluorodeoxygenation of carboxylic acids .
We have presented a critical scientific narrative of a promising technology. The advantage of the 13CF3 NMR spin label in protein NMR has been explained. Progress in incorporation of this spin label in a perdeuterated amino acid and in an important protein is reported. We comment on some of the synthetic subtleties encountered.
Whereas incorporation of monofluorinated aromatic amino acids in proteins using in vivo or in vitro expression systems is now routine, incorporation of trifluoromethyl analogs of branched chain amino acids is at present a challenging technology. A biochemical hurdle is the specificity of an aminoacyl tRNA synthetase. Wang et al. determined that the specificity constant, kcat/KM of 5,5,5-trifluoroisoleucine is only 1/134 that of isoleucine for E. coli isoleucyl tRNA synthetase . Considerations of enzyme kinetics and competitive inhibition dictate that the background concentration of isoleucine needs to be effectively zero for tRNAIle to be charged with 5,5,5-trifluoroisoleucine by isoleucyl tRNA synthetase. In addition to the catalytic domain, where the amino acid and tRNAaa are specifically ligated, aminoacyl tRNA synthetase also has an editing domain for the hydrolysis of mischarged tRNA. In the case of isoleucyl tRNA synthetase, the editing domain has been evolved most specifically for the hydrolysis of val∙ tRNAIle. The successful incorporation of 5,5,5-trifluoroisoleucine in mDHFR, mIL II (27) and in calmodulin  (Kainosho M: private communication) implies that 5TFI∙ tRNAIle is too large for the editing site. Practical questions remain. Is an expression system based upon E. coli more advantageous than one based upon a eukaryotic organism? Is a cell free lysate system preferable to in vivo expression system?
This paper covers many areas of synthetic chemistry, organic, fluoro, isotopic, and biochemical. We have identified ammonium 2-13C-trifluoroacetate as an important synthon for introduction of the 13CF3 group into amino acids. Completed synthesis of methallylcyanide-d7 and conceptual synthesis of 5-13C-5,5,5- trifluoroisoleucine-d7, provide an important building block for the exploitation of 13CF3 in protein NMR.
5,5,5-TFI is an unnatural AA, more so than monofluorinated amino acids. Either as uniform, or site specific isotopic labels, deuterium and 13C amino acids are readily synthesized and incorporated. Fluorine is the 13th most abundant isotope in the earth's crust, yet even after 3.5 billion years of biology only about a dozen fluorinated natural products have been evolved, attributed to fluorine's chemistry as a "superhalogen" . Organofluorine compounds as polymers or as drugs have proven useful in material science and pharmacology. The target spin 13CF3 label should prove useful in multidimensional heteronuclear NMR structure dynamics studies of proteins . Synthesis of 5,5,5-TFI has been proven by its incorporation in the calcium binding protein calmodulin. Methallylcyanide-d7 has been produced with military grade deuterium isotope purity, 99.4%. Trace quantities of 2-13C-trifluoroacetate have been characterized by 13C-19F NMR coupling. This contribution may pave the way to future study [57-59].
This work is part of a project in heteronuclear multidimensional NMR.