Received Date: May 21, 2014; Accepted Date: June 25, 2014; Published Date: July 07, 2014
Citation: Johnbull OS, Uche AP, Kesiena AJ, Francis FA, Oyemocho A, et al. (2014) Prevalence and Risk Factors of Malaria in HIV-Infected Pregnant Women on Anti-Retroviral Therapy in Enugu, South East Nigeria. J AIDS Clin Res 5:321. doi:10.4172/2155-6113.1000321
Copyright: © 2014 Johnbull OS, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of AIDS & Clinical Research
Background and objective: Malaria and HIV co-infection pose significant health concerns in many regions of the world. Co-infection significantly increases the burden of these diseases in pregnancy, yet the interactions of these diseases in pregnant women are not well understood. The aim of the study was to determine the prevalence and examine the factors that could be associated with malaria in HIV positive infected pregnant women on antiretroviral therapy.
Methodology: Blood samples were collected from 301 confirmed HIV positive pregnant women in various trimesters and examined for malaria parasite presence and density with other laboratory indices. Baseline socio-demographic information, antenatal information, CD4 levels, and viral load were collected from clinical records. Information on type of treatment, such as intermittent malaria preventive treatment (IPT) and ART therapy/ prophylaxis, was extracted from care cards. Information on the prior use of antimalarial drugs and cotrimoxazole intake was obtained from direct interviews.
Results: The prevalence of malaria among HIV-positive pregnant women was 49.83% and the odds of having malaria doubledwith living in a rural community (AOR 2.04, CI [1.07-3.91] P<0.001). Also, being on ART therapy increased the odds of having malaria by 133% (AOR 2.33 CI [1.06-5.10] P<0.05). A higher level of CD4 counts reduced the odds of malaria parasitaemia though not significant. Those whose CD4 count was 200-350 and >350 had reduced odds of malaria parasitaemia (AOR 0.50, CI [0.81-1.44] P=0.202) and (AOR 0.65, CI [0.24-1.73] P=0.391), respectively, compared with those with lower CD4 counts. Malaria parasites were unlikely in those with normal haemoglobin levels (AOR 0.08 CI [0.04-0.16] P<0.001). Pregnant women who were not on treatment before coming to the hospital ANC were about nine times more likely to have malaria parasites than those who had it recently (AOR 9.30, CI [4.44-19.50] P<0.001).
Conclusion: The prevalence of malaria in HIV-positive pregnant women was influenced by the locality, level of haemoglobin and self-medication prior to coming to the hospital. Low haemoglobin, which serves as an index of malnutrition, was also a serious factor that should be evaluated to reduce the scourge and burden of malaria complications, and programs geared towards provision of mosquito and environmental barriers should be improved.
Rural HIV; ART therapy; CD4; Enugu, Nigeria
Malaria and HIV are among the principal causes of morbidity and mortality in resource-limited settings including sub-Saharan Africa . Despite the international community’s efforts to reduce the incidence and prevalence of these diseases, they remain serious health problems in tropical and sub-tropical regions throughout the world . According to the World Malaria Report 2011, there were 225 million cases of malaria and an estimated 781,000 deaths in 2010 . It is estimated that each year, about 24 million pregnant women are affected by Plasmodium falciparum, especially in sub-Saharan Africa , and about 1 million per year are co-infected with HIV . Together, malaria and HIV infection cause more than 4 million deaths per year [5,6].
The interactions of malaria parasites and HIV are serious health challengesas it causes complications including severity of clinical signs and other symptoms . Presentation of malaria in HIV-infected people is severe than non-infected individuals . In a review of HIV-1 infection in Africa, malaria was identified as the third cause of HIV-related morbidity . This is more evident in special populations such as HIV-infected pregnant women . Pregnant women living in malaria-endemic regions, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, have a high frequency and density of Plasmodium falciparum parasitaemia.
There are high rates of maternal morbidity including fever, severe anaemia, abortion, still birth, and placental malaria among these women.Consequently, babies can be born with low birth weight due to both prematurity and intrauterine growth retardation [3,10]. However, epidemiological studies of the prevalence and clinical manifestations of P. Falciparum malaria in HIV-infected pregnant women that consider factors such as residential location, CD4 level, viral load, and adherence to intermittent preventive treatment (IPT) and cotrimoxazole regimen, are limited.
Nigeria has one of the highest malaria burdens in the world. In 2010, of the estimated total population of 130 million people, 489,000 severe malaria cases were reported, resulting in 200,000 deaths [2,11,12]. Nigeria is one of the countries in sub-Saharan Africa with a high HIV/ AIDS burden: in adults aged 15-49 years,a HIV prevalence rate of 4.4% (range 2.3-5.6%) is estimated andthe estimated total number of women aged 15years and older living with HIV is 1.6 million .
The aim of this study was to determine the prevalence of malaria parasitaemia among HIV-infected pregnant women on ART in Enugu, southeast Nigeria which will serve as a baseline data on the relationship between malaria and HIV infections in this region.
Enugu State is an inland State in South East Nigeria with a capital at Enugu. It shares boundaries with Anambrato the West, Abia State to the South, Kogi to the North and Benue to the North East and Ebonyito the East. It is also known as the Coal City State of Nigeria. In the 2006 Population and Housing Census, Enugu state was made up of 1,596,042 males and 1,671,795 females . Enugu Statehas rich agricultural land as a result of its location within the tropical forest and savannah belts. The humid climate and the distribution of rains almost all year round allow the breeding of mosquitoes throughout the year.
A cross sectional descriptive study design was used for the study.
Three hundred and one (301) confirmed HIV positive pregnant women in various trimesters who visited the antenatal clinic of the University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital (UNTH) Enugu, Nigeria were recruited for the study. Essentially, the Prevention of Mother-To-Child Transmission of HIV (PMTCT) clients were recruited through the routine HIV testing at the antenatal care (ANC) opt-out approach. Women who were sick and previously knew their HIV positive serostatus present by self-referral. About a third of the recruited PMTCT clients were referred from other public and private hospitals.
Sample size and sampling techniques
The sample size for the study was calculated by the standard methods. Considering the prevalence of malaria (23.7%) in pregnant women , an error margin of 5% and a power of 80%, a sample size of 278 was obtained. Taking into account a drop-out rate of 10%, a total of 305 pregnant women were recruited for the study.
Non-probability sampling technique was used. All pregnant women received the modified group pre-test counselling before HIV testing, and individual post-test counselling when the test result was ready. During the post-testsession, each patient was told her test result and offered additional counselling. If the rapid test result was reactive, she also underwent the "Western Blot" test for confirmation of the result. Those who were confirmed sero-positive were formally recruited into the PMTCT programme following their signing of the PMTCT consent forms. Once recruited, they were assigned a unique PMTCT number. Some HIV positive pregnant women who have been on adult ART programme or might have been referred from other PMTCT programmes did not undergo further testing but they were offered on-going counselling and enrolled into the PMTCT program. Also, confirmation of HIV infection and pregnancy were based on the hospital’s protocols. All the subjects were on ART or ARV prophylaxis in accordance with the Nigerian National Prevention of Mother-To- Child Prevention of HIV (PMTCT) guidelines .
The study was conducted between March and June, 2012. Consecutive eligible respondents seen over the study period were solicited to participate. Consenting subjects were counselled and their informed consent was duly obtained. Their socio-demographic characteristics (age, education, and occupation) as well as current CD4 counts, viral load, parity, antiretroviral duration were obtained from their clinic records while gestational age, body temperature, Intermittent Preventive Treatment (IPT), fever in the past weeks, drugs taken for treatment of fever and cotrimoxazole intake were obtained by direct interview.A finger prick was performed for the preparation of a blood film and for haemoglobin estimation. To ensure confidentiality, samples were labelled with coded numbers.
Microscopic examination of stained slides: Thin blood films were fixed with methanol and all films (thick and thin) were stained with 10% Giemsa at pH 7.2 for 30 min as recommended by WHO . Taking the number of leucocytes per micro litre of blood as 8,000, parasite density of blood using the thick film was expressed as: parasite count (x) 8,000 divided by number of white blood cells (WBCs) counted. Stained slides were examined under the light microscope using x100 objective lens (with immersion oil) . In the thin film, distinction was made to identify the different malarial species. Slides were examined and double checked by two experienced medical laboratory scientists/technicians and if there were differences, an additional assessment was made by another scientist and the average of two agreeing counts was recorded taking into consideration leukocytopenia.
CD4 cell counts and viral loads: CD4 cell counts were measured by FACS Count (Becton Dickson, Mountain View, California) at each sampling point after incubation at room temperature based on the manual’s information obtained from the hospital’s laboratory.
The viral load of each sample was determined by the Versant HIV RNA 3.0 Assay (bDNA, Siemens, IL) as recommended by the manufacturerbased on the manual’s information obtained from the hospital’s laboratory.
Data was analyzed using the STATA 10 software (Stata Corporation, College Station, Texas) statistical analysis package. A descriptive analysis was performed on each variable and bi-variate analysis to assess relationships between the variables: independent student t-test was used to assess significant mean difference of haemoglobin seen in malaria infestation; one-way ANOVA analysis was used to compare the level of anaemia and malaria density seen in the three trimesters of pregnancy. Chi square (χ2) was used to compare relationships between categorical variables. Associations and differences were considered statistically significant if p-value is less than 0.05. Anaemia in pregnancy was defined as haemoglobin concentrations less than 10 g/dl [3,21].
Ethical approval for the baseline study was obtained from the ethical committee of the PERFAR, University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital (UNTH) Enugu, Nigeria.
A total of 301 HIV positive pregnant women (response rate 98.7%) out of 305 that were recruited participated in the study. HIV-positive pregnant women in their first and second/third trimesters were 46.12% and 53.82%, respectively, and their mean weight was 63 kg (± 14.0). The average age was 30years (± 4.7) (Tables 1 and 2). Most of them were married (73.09%) and the majority were rural dwellers (61.13%). Each of them had at least three children (45.51%). The two most frequently reported occupations were trading (38.54%) and full term housewife (31.90%).Those withsecondary education were in the majority (53.16%) (Tables 1 and 2).
|Age (years)||Baseline CD4( cells/mm3 blood)|
|26-30||32.89(99)||200 - 350||36.88(111)|
|Median baseline CD4 (IQR)||350 (236-464)|
|Single||12.29(37)||25months and above||48.17(145)|
|Widow||9.97(30)||Median Duration on ART (IQR)||24(12-48)|
|Malaria Parasite in Blood|
|Educational Level||No Parasite||50.17(151)|
|Housewife not working||30.90(93)||Intermittent Preventive Treatment|
Table 1: Baseline socio - demographic characteristics of study population
|Viral Load (/ml blood)||17968.0||71993.01||0 – 461720||0(0-800)|
|Body Temperature (°C)||37.0||3.0||33-83||36.7(36.3-37.5)|
|Pf parasite density (/µl blood)||1302.9||1860.8||0-6200||0(0-2400)|
|ART treatment duration (months)||30.8||22.7||1-96||24(12-48)|
|Hemoglobin Level (g/dl)||10.0||1.0||6.6 -12.7||10(9.5-10.2)|
Table 2: Summary Statistics of Selected characteristics of Respondents.
Prevalence of malaria
About half (49.83%)of the study population, had Plasmodium falciparum positive slides at the time of recruitment; over one third reported having fever (Table 1) and one quarter of the women examined had a temperature ≥ 37.5°C. A significantly higher proportion of women with body temperatures ≥ 37.5°C had detectable malaria parasitaemia compared with 36.8%with negative slides. Anaemia was significantly associated with the presence of malaria parasites as 76.35% of pregnant women who havepositive slides have haemoglobin levels <10 g/dl. Likewise, more pregnant women who reported having fever (74.76%) had malaria parasites. Furthermore, more of those who were on ART therapy (52.97%) had malaria parasites (Table 3). A higher proportion of pregnant women whose CD4 was above 350 cells/mm3 had negative parasitaemia. Also, more of those who were multiparous presented with malaria parasites.
|Respondent has Parasitaemia||Respondent has no Parasitaemia||P-Value of Chi-square (X2) Test|
|Presence of Fever||74.76(77)||25.24(26)||0.000|
|Absence of Fever||36.87(73)||63.13(125)|
|Body Temperature (°C)|
|Type of ART|
|Anti-malaria Drug Before Coming|
|CD4 Level(/ml blood)|
ART- anti-retroviral therapy; ITP- Intermittent preventive treatment.
Table 3: Distribution of detectable parasitaemia in pregnant women with HIV/AIDS.
Only 35.24% of pregnant women were on intermittent preventive treatment (IPT) for malaria prevention and 8.0% had taken cotrimoxazole therapy. One third of women reported taking an antimalarial drug on self-medication within 2-5 days before going to the hospital. Seventythree percent were on antiretroviral therapy compared with 27.0% on antiretroviral prophylactic therapy. The median duration of ART was 24 months (IQR [12-48 months]) (Table 2). About half the population (49.17%) had CD4 counts >350. The median viral load was zero (IQR [0-800]), while 49.0% of pregnant women had haemoglobin less than 10 g/dl, the mean haemoglobin concentration was 1.0 g/dl.
Risk factors associated with malaria infection
A number of risk factors were associated with malaria infection in pregnancy (Table 4). Age was an important risk factor; women aged 26-30years and >30years had reduced odds of having malaria by 18% and 6%, respectively. The odds of having malaria infection doubled when moving from urban to rural settlements (AOR 2.04, CI [1.07-3.91] P<0.001). Likewise, a high body temperature (>37.5°C) significantly increased the odds of having malaria infection by 90% (AOR 1.90, CI [0.94-3.86] P< 0.001). Pregnant women on ART therapy hadan increased odds ratio of having malaria parasites (AOR 2.33 CI [1.06- 5.10] P<0.05). Those whose CD4 count was 200-350 and >350 had reduced odds ratio of malaria parasitaemia (AOR 0.50, CI [0.18-1.44] P=0.202) and (AOR 0.65, CI [0.24-1.73] P=0.391) (Table 1). Malaria parasites were unlikely to be seen in those with normal haemoglobin levels (>10 g/dl) (AOR 0.08 CI [0.04-0.16] P<0.001). Pregnant women who had not recently been treated for an acute malaria attack were about nine times more likely to have presence of malaria parasites in blood than those treated recently (AOR 9.30, CI [4.44-19.50] P<0.001). Illiteracy or no education was a contributory factor as this group had the highest mean malaria density (>3000 parasites/μL). Among all the socio-demographic variables considered only educational levels were significant different (F=7.007 p<0.0001) with respect to malaria density (Figure 1).
|CD4 count (/ml blood)|
|200 - 350||36.88(111)||0.82(0.40-1.71)||0.611||0.50(0.18-1.44)||0.202|
|Anti malarial drug taken before coming to hospital|
|Haemoglobin level (g/dl)|
Table 4: Logistic regression for factors associated with malaria parasite in HIV pregnant women.
In this study, a high maternal malaria prevalence rate (49.83%) was found among HIV-infected pregnant women during their ANC visit. This rate is close to reports from similar studies in Ekpoma, Nigeria (53%)  and Malawi (56%) , but higher than 21% reported amongst pregnant women in Jos, Nigeria . The prevalence of P. falciparum malaria in these HIV-infected pregnant women is a reflection of the high prevalence of this species of malaria in the Nigerian population because over 98% of malaria infection is caused by this species. Also in the study, no other type of species was detected except P.falciparum.
A number of risk factors were found to be associated with malaria infection. Women above 30 years of age had a higher risk of infection (AOR 0.94, CI (0.34-2.61) P=0.900. Age is a co-factor in disease progression, and the immunity to malaria and HIV infection has been shown to be age-dependent [25,26]. It is possible that older HIV-infected individuals may be more prone to developing infections including malaria than the younger HIV-infected individuals. This association needs to be verified in subsequent studies. Living in rural areas was also identified as a risk factor. The significantly higher parasitaemia found among the rural dwellers can be explained from the fact that they are more exposed to mosquito bites, due to thick vegetations and poorer drainage systems which encourage mosquito breeding in stagnant water around their homes. More so, they are less likely to use insecticide treated nets than the urban dwellers though not investigated in our study. The higher proportion of HIV and malaria co-infection among the rural dwellers (61%) suggests that rural communities now bear the greater burden of HIV/AIDS , thus overstretching rural health systems.
HIV-positive infected pregnant women require special attention and follow-up to reduce the risk of maternal death and adverse pregnancy outcomes resulting from the effects of anemia, especially among these special populations of HIV-infected women. Infection with P. falciparum was strongly associated with anaemia in 75% of cases, which is consistent with findings from other studies of pregnant women . In practice, most hospitals in Nigeria use a lower level of haemoglobin (<10 g/dl) as an indication of anaemia. This is justified on the basis of work of Lawsonet al, which showed that serious harm to the mother and foetus did not occur until the haemoglobin value was below 10 g/dl . The risk of anaemia secondary to malaria could be reduced through prompt and effective treatment during pregnancy to optimize the chances of an HIV-infected pregnant woman delivering a healthy infant. In a review of studies of Plasmodium falciparum–related anaemia in pregnant women, it was suggested that up to 400,000 pregnant women develop moderate or severe anaemia (hemoglobin level <8.0 g/dL or haematocrit<25%) each year in sub-Saharan Africa as a result of malaria infection . The HIV-associated risk of malaria affects all parities and is consistently higher in multiparous women, as observed in the study presented here.In turn, this increases the risk of still birth, preterm delivery, low birth and fetal growth restriction which agrees with some studies from Uganda [12,30]. The odds ratio or relative risk of parasitaemia and risk of malarial fever increase with decreasing CD4 count and increasing viral load. But usually, ART treatment could increase CD4 counts and decrease viral load but in our study, it is not like this which may be due to non-adherence of ART drugs.
Prophylactic treatment with IPT is an important approach to reduce the burden of malaria in pregnancy. Despite recommendation by the World Health Organization of at least three prophylactic doses of IPT during the second and third trimesters of pregnancy for HIV-infected pregnant women to prevent malaria , 65% of the subjects studied in all trimesters had never taken IPT. This might increase the severity of the consequences of malaria without intervention, which may lead to transmission of infections to the fetus during the intrauterine and intra-partum periods. Many of the HIV-infected pregnant women with malaria never had any knowledge of IPT and this may be due to lack of personal and institutional updates on new interventions in preventing malaria during pregnancy in the country. It may also be as a result of a lack of budgetary support in making available copies of the national IPT guidelines and strategic documents available within health facilities.In our study, it is important to note that those women who were not on IPT had a significantly reduced odds ratio for malaria parasitaemia (AOR 0.38, CI [0.18-0.77] P<0.01).
Prophylaxis with cotrimoxazole is also reported to be beneficial in malaria endemic areas . However, 92.36% of the HIV-infected pregnant women in this study were not on cotrimoxazole. The expanded use of cotrimoxazole as a prophylactic agent in HIV-infected people might have an added benefit of malaria prevention, the efficacy of cotrimoxazole for malaria prevention is not yet known among these special groups (HIV-infected pregnant women). Prophylactic treatment with IPT is an important approach to reduce the burden of malaria in pregnancy. Despite recommendation by the World Health Organization of at least three prophylactic doses of IPT during the second and third trimesters of pregnancy for HIV-infected pregnant women to prevent malaria , 65% of the subjects studied in all trimesters had never taken IPT. This might increase the severity of the consequences of malaria without intervention, which may lead to transmission of infections to the fetus during the intrauterine and intra-partum periods. Many of the HIV-infected pregnant women with malaria never had any knowledge of IPT and this may be due to lack of personal and institutional updates on new interventions in preventing malaria during pregnancy in the country. It may also be as a result of a lack of budgetary support in making available copies of the national IPT guidelines and strategic documents available within health facilities
Prophylaxis with cotrimoxazole is also reported to be beneficial in malaria endemic areas . However, 92.36% of the HIV-infected pregnant women in this study were not on cotrimoxazole. The expanded use of cotrimoxazole as a prophylactic agent in HIV-infected people might have an added benefit of malaria prevention, the efficacy of cotrimoxazole for malaria prevention is not yet known among these special groups (HIV-infected pregnant women).
Despite the high prevalence of malaria and HIV in many parts of the tropics, knowledge of how these two important diseases interact is still hampered by lack of knowledge in many key areas. Public health policies aimed at increasing hemoglobin levels should continue to support programs, particularly in rural areas, that provide iron supplementation, appropriate antiretroviral regimens to HIV-infected women and a system to support provision of insecticide treated bed nets (ITNs) & intermittent preventive antimalarial treatment during pregnancy according to the newly adopted national policy. Also, as more countries adopt policies of antiretroviral and antimalarial interventions in pregnancy, the interrelationship and ultimate benefit of these two interventions requires continued evaluation. The observed increased level of malaria parasites with IPT is surprising and requires further investigation.
Limitations of the Study
One of the greatest limitations was not being able to do follow-up to check the adherence of their ART medication and also to know why there was increased level of parasitaemia in patients on IPT.
We thank Prof Stephanie K. Yanow, Alberta Health Services, Canada for critical reading of the manuscript. We sincerely want to thank all other people who were available and provided advices during the study and also thank ChizobaEzeagu for assistance with data arrangement.
Make the best use of Scientific Research and information from our 700 + peer reviewed, Open Access Journals