alexa
Reach Us +447460731551
Socio-Demographic Determinants of Satisfaction with Training Process among Final Year Nursing Students at Kenya Medical Training College | OMICS International
ISSN 2573-0347
Advanced Practices in Nursing

Like us on:

Make the best use of Scientific Research and information from our 700+ peer reviewed, Open Access Journals that operates with the help of 50,000+ Editorial Board Members and esteemed reviewers and 1000+ Scientific associations in Medical, Clinical, Pharmaceutical, Engineering, Technology and Management Fields.
Meet Inspiring Speakers and Experts at our 3000+ Global Conferenceseries Events with over 600+ Conferences, 1200+ Symposiums and 1200+ Workshops on Medical, Pharma, Engineering, Science, Technology and Business
All submissions of the EM system will be redirected to Online Manuscript Submission System. Authors are requested to submit articles directly to Online Manuscript Submission System of respective journal.

Socio-Demographic Determinants of Satisfaction with Training Process among Final Year Nursing Students at Kenya Medical Training College

Kabanya CN*, Karani AK and Mirie W

Kenya Medical Training College, University of Nairobi, Embu, Kenya

*Corresponding Author:
Kabanya CN
Kenya Medical Training College, University of Nairobi, Embu, Kenya
Tel: 2540722432372
E-mail: [email protected]

Received date: November 03, 2016; Accepted date: January 06, 2017; Published date: January 13, 2017

Citation: Kabanya CN, Karani AK, Mirie W (2017) Socio-Demographic Determinants of Satisfaction with Training Process among Final Year Nursing Students at Kenya Medical Training College. Adv Practice Nurs 2:128. doi:10.4172/2573-0347.1000128

Copyright: © 2017 Kabanya CN, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Visit for more related articles at Advanced Practices in Nursing

Abstract

Student satisfaction is an important means of assessing the institution’s capacity in meeting the students’ learning needs. The degree of student’s satisfaction with their educational experience is an important dimension in the assessment of institutional effectiveness. Understanding students’ perceptions and satisfaction is important in efforts to enrich the students’ learning experiences. This study aimed at identifying the student’s socio-demographic factors that influenced satisfaction with the nursing training among the final year nursing students in Kenya Medical Training College. This was a mixed method design where both quantitative and qualitative data was collected using the following; a self-administered questionnaire comprising of both closed and open ended questions and a Likert’s rating scale which scored the levels of satisfaction on various themes. Data was collected from final year nursing students in the six selected campuses. Quantitative data was analyzed using Statistical Package for Social Scientists (SPSS) program version 20.0. Chi-square tests were used to test relationships between perceived level of satisfaction and the selected independent variables. The results showed that gender of student did not influence students overall satisfaction. However, students who had positive college experience were satisfied with overall teaching and learning process. Student’s information sources regarding the nursing career had a significant association with their satisfaction with teaching and learning process.

Keywords

Satisfaction; Teaching and learning; Extra-curricular activities; Nursing training

Introduction

Satisfaction is the good feeling that one has when she/he achieves something or when something she/he wanted to happen does happen. Jaradeen et al. [1] defined satisfaction as a psychological state which results from confirmation of expectations with reality. Studies point out that certain factors exert positive and significant influences on student satisfaction. These factors include, student background characteristics, participation in the community, access to and use of college facilities and services, faculty style of instruction, academic and social integration, learning activities, courses, quality and usefulness of education [2,3]. A study done by Rognstad [4], found that Norwegian nursing students were motivated to join a nursing career by the need for human contact and need for helping others. They viewed nursing as a vocation and felt compelled to do it. They felt a strong desire to care for people and make a difference. Zysberg and Berry [5] argued that there is a deep and rewarding joy in caring for people.

Student’s satisfaction contributes to intellectual, social, affective growth, classroom and college retention, academic performance, motivation and college persistence [2]. Satisfied students are more successful and dedicated to accomplish their goals than unsatisfied students [2,6]. A study done by Jaradeen et al. [1] found out that students were satisfied with the syllabus and grading method. They were also satisfied that nursing courses were helping them on how to care for their families, and how to communicate effectively. However, they were dissatisfied with college facilities, acquiring writing, critical thinking and problem solving skills. Studies done found a significant relationship between the clinical placement setting and overall satisfaction where students who completed their clinical placement in a community setting expressed higher levels of satisfaction than their counterparts from bed based services [7,8]. The study by Happel [8] further showed that there was overall sense of satisfaction by student nurses with their clinical experience where eighty-eight percent of students enjoyed their clinical placement. They indicated that they felt welcomed, well supported and orientated, involved in patients care and regarded the nursing staff as highly skilled and respectful to patients [8]. Their relationship with the clinical supervisors increased their motivation to learn more.

Ansari [9] found out that student’s socio-demographic characteristics affected their satisfaction where students with a higher average age were more satisfied than the younger ones. It was also determined that handicapped students were a little more satisfied than the others. Ansari [9] also found out that satisfaction varies from program to program and from one institution to another.

Objective of the Study

The aim of the study was to determine students’ socio-demographic factors that influence level of satisfaction with the training process among final year nursing students at the Kenya Medical Training College.

Research design

A mixed method was used which involved both quantitative and qualitative method.

Sampling

A sample size of 341 final year students was computed using the formula as used by Fischer et al. Three hundred (300) students who consented to be included in the study filled the questionnaire.

Data analysis

Data was processed stepwise and involved data validation, cleaning, coding and entry into Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 20.0 in order to generate quantitative and qualitative results. Descriptive statistics were computed to generate means, percentages, ranges and standard deviation and the results presented in form of frequency tables, bar graphs and narration.

Inferential statistics were generated using Pearson’s coefficient and Chi-square test in order to determine the relationship between student factors and level of satisfaction with training. The level of significance was set at P<0.05. Logistic regression model was also be used to analyze the predictors of satisfaction.

Results

Students’ gender, religion and marital status were established. Majority of the students were females (62.8%). Most of these students were protestants (53.7%), 36.3% were catholic faithful and 2.0% were Muslims. 84.7% of these students were single whereas 14.3% were married students (Table 1).

Demographic information Number of students (N=300) Percent
Gender    
Male 112 37.3
Female 188 62.8
Religion    
Catholic 109 36.3
Protestant 161 53.7
Muslims 6 2.0
Others 24 8.0
Marital status    
Married 43 14.3
Separated 1 0.3
Single 254 84.7
Widowed 2 0.7

Table 1: Demographic information of the students

Parents’ demographic information

The parents’ education levels and occupation established showed that, 41.7% of these students were from homes where the father had college education. 16.3% stated that their fathers had university education while 1.3% of the students had their fathers having vocational education. When asked to about their mothers’ education, 35.7% of the students stated their mothers had college education, 6.0% had the mothers having university education.

Occupation of the parents

Majority of the students 39.3% were from homes where the fathers were salaried, 32.75% were from homes where the fathers were farmers and 22.3% were from homes headed by business fathers. The mothers were mainly farmers (41.0%). 26.7% of the students had salaried mothers whereas 24.0% of the students had business mothers (Table 2).

Demographic information of parents Number of students (N=300) Percent (%)
Fathers’ education level    
Primary 49 16.3
Secondary 58 19.3
Vocational 4 1.3
College 125 41.7
University 49 16.3
Others 15 5.0
Mothers education level    
Primary 75 25.0
Secondary 81 27.0
Vocational 9 3.0
College 107 35.7
University 18 6.0
Others 10 3.3
Fathers’ occupation    
Farmer 98 32.7
Salaried employee 118 39.3
Business 67 22.3
Unskilled laborer 6 2.0
Others 11 3.7
Mothers occupation    
Farmer 123 41.0
Salaried employee 80 26.7
Business 72 24.0
Unskilled laborer 17 5.7
Others 8 2.7

Table 2: Parents education levels and occupation.

Student factors that influence levels of satisfaction with nursing training

Kenya certificate of secondary education (KCSE) grades obtained by the students: In their KCSE, majority of the students in the nursing colleges had obtained KCSE grade B- (minus). 47.7% obtained grade B-, 28.0% obtained KCSE grade C+, 10.3% had obtained grade B+ while the highest grade obtained was KCSE grade A- which was obtained by 3.7% of the students (Table 3).

KCSE grades obtained Number of students (N=300) Percent (%)
Grade A- 3 1
Grade B+ 31 10.3
Grade B 12 4
Grade B- 143 47.7
Grade C+ 84 28
Grade C 16 5.3
None committal 11 3.7

Table 3: KCSE grades obtained by the students.

Effect of the KCSE result on the students overall satisfaction with the teaching process of the nursing program

Chi square test for association was conducted on the students’ performance in KCSE and the levels of their satisfaction with the teaching and learning process of nursing. All the students who had obtained KCSE grade A- were somehow satisfied with the teaching and learning process of the nursing program. Majority of those who had B- (67.2%), grade B (66.7%), grade B+ (51.7%), grade C (50.0%), grade C + (75.9%) were satisfied with the teaching and learning process. The result showed that there was no significant variation in students satisfaction with the KCSE grades obtained (χ2=23.53, P=0.171) (Table 4).

KCSE grade obtained     Overall satisfaction with the teaching and learning process of the nursing program Total
Not satisfied Somehow satisfied Satisfied Extremely satisfied  
A- Count 0 2 0 0 2
% 0.00% 100.00% 0.00% 0.00% 100.00%
B- Count 2 32 90 10 134
% 1.50% 23.90% 67.20% 7.50% 100.00%
B Count 0 4 8 0 12
% 0.00% 33.30% 66.70% 0.00% 100.00%
B+ Count 0 12 15 2 29
% 0.00% 41.40% 51.70% 6.90% 100.00%
C Count 0 5 8 3 16
% 0.00% 31.30% 50.00% 18.80% 100.00%
C+ Count 0 16 60 3 79
% 0.00% 20.30% 75.90% 3.80% 100.00%
Total Count 2 72 191 18 283
% 0.70% 25.40% 67.50% 6.40% 100.00%

Table 4: Students’ KCSE performance and the level of satisfaction with the teaching process of nursing program.

Students’ gender and satisfaction with teaching and learning program

The gender of the students did not affect their overall satisfaction with the teaching and learning process of nursing program (χ2=2.110, P=0.550). Among the male students, 65.4% of the students were satisfied with the teaching and learning program whereas 68.7% of the female students were satisfied (Table 5).

    Overall satisfaction with the teaching and learning process of the nursing program Total
    Not satisfied Somehow satisfied Satisfied Extremely satisfied  
Gender Male Count 0 30 68 6 104
    % 0.0% 28.8% 65.4% 5.8% 100.0%
  Female Count 2 42 123 12 179
    % 1.1% 23.5% 68.7% 6.7% 100.0%
Total   Count 2 72 191 18 283
    % 0.7% 25.4% 67.5% 6.4% 100.0%

Table 5: Students’ gender and the level of satisfaction with the teaching process of nursing program.

Sources of information about nursing career

The students were asked to mention their sources of information about nursing career. The main source of the information as stated by 36.3% of the students was from personal interaction with the nurses, 35.7% of the students had gotten information from their parents and relatives while 4.7% of the students obtained information from books and pamphlets (Table 6).

Sources Number of students (N=300) Percent (%)
Book and pamphlets 14 4.7
Media (TV, radio/newspaper) 48 16.0
Personal interaction with nurses 109 36.3
Career guidance teacher 11 3.7
Parents and relatives 107 35.7
Other sources 11 3.7

Table 6: Student sources of information about nursing career.

Source of influence to join nursing training

To join nursing career, majority of the students (42.3%) were influenced by a Nurse role model, 36.0% of the students were influenced by parents and relatives, 9.3% were influenced by peers and friends, 4.3% were influenced by teachers and school counselors while 4.0% were influenced by other factors (Table 7).

Sources influencing Number of students Percent (%)
Peers and friends 28 9.3
Parents and relatives 108 36.0
Teachers and school counselors 13 4.3
Nurse role models 127 42.3
Personal influence 12 4.0
Others 12 4.0

Table 7: Sources that influenced the students to join nursing training.

Effect of the sources about nursing career and the students overall satisfaction with the teaching process of the nursing program

The students’ information sources of the nursing career had a significant association on the students’ satisfaction with the teaching and learning process of the nursing program (χ2=63.31, P=0.000). Most of the students, 45.5% who had learnt about nursing from career guidance teachers were extremely satisfied with the teaching and learning program. 74.5% of those who had gotten information about nursing career from personal interaction with nurses were satisfied with the nursing teaching and learning program while 58.3% of the students who got to learn about nursing career from books and pamphlets were satisfied with the teaching and learning program (Table 8).

     Overall satisfaction with the teaching and
learning process of the nursing program
Total
Source about nursing career   Not Satisfied Somehow satisfied Satisfied Extremely satisfied  
Books and pamphlets Count 0 4 7 1 12
  % 0.00% 33.30% 58.30% 8.30% 100%
Media (TV, radio/newspapers) Count 0 15 29 2 46
  % 0.00% 32.60% 63.00% 4.30% 100%
Personal interaction with nurses Count 0 22 76 4 102
  % 0.00% 21.60% 74.50% 3.90% 100%
Career guidance teachers Count 0 2 4 5 11
  % 0.00% 18.20% 36.40% 45.50% 100%
Parents and relatives Count 0 27 69 6 102
  % 0.00% 26.50% 67.60% 5.90% 100%
Others Count 1 2 6 0 9
  % 11.10% 22.20% 66.70% 0.00% 100%
Total Count 1 72 191 18 282
  % 0.40% 25.50% 67.70% 6.40% 100%

Table 8: Students’ sources of information on nursing career and the level of satisfaction with the teaching process of nursing program.

Learners’ involvement in extra-curriculum activities in the college

When they are in college, 48.3% of the learners were involved in extra-curriculum activities. These activities include; Sports like football, rugby, volleyball, handball, basketball, hockey, lawn tennis, table tennis, scrabble, badminton. Games like Athletics. Other activities like charitable work for example, visiting prisoners and children homes, participating in outreach services organized by the hospitals, participating in hospital meetings and also setting the immunization group. They were also involved in clubs like counseling.

Regarding the extent to which the learners participation in extracurriculum activities contributed to their overall satisfaction with college experience, 13.0% of the learners felt that the activities extremely contributed to their overall satisfaction, 14.3% stated that it slightly contributed, 32.75 stated participation in the activities moderately contributed to their satisfaction while 40% of the learners felt that it did not contribute to their overall satisfaction at all (Figure 1).

advanced-practices-nursing-overall-satisfaction

Figure 1: Extent to which learners’ participation in extracurriculum activities contributed to overall satisfaction with college experience.

The extent to which the learners participated in the extracurriculum activities had significant influence (r=0.143, P=0.026) on their satisfaction in with the teaching and learning process of the nursing program. Students who felt that their participation in the extra-curriculum activities had contributed to their satisfaction with college experience were satisfied with the overall teaching and learning process (Table 9).

    Extent to which participation in these activities contributed to overall satisfaction with college experience Overall satisfaction with the teaching and learning process of the nursing program
To what extent has your participation in these activities contributed to your overall satisfaction with college experience r-value 1 0.143*
  P-value   0.026
  N 252 242
What is your overall satisfaction with the teaching and learning process of the r-value 0.143* 1
  P-value 0.026  
  N 242 283

Table 9: Correlation result showing relationship between participation in extra-curriculum. *Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed).

Discussion

The student factors that influenced satisfaction with teaching and learning in nursing training were identified from the study. In the study, 90% of the students were Christians who were satisfied with their training in nursing. Religion is closely associated with helping relationships. This concurs with a study by Pollard et al. [10] which indicated that helping individuals was found to provide nurses with great satisfaction. According to Dal et al. [11] nursing is a sacred profession where the need to help others emerged as the main motive of some students aspiring to join nursing. The gender of the students did not affect their overall satisfaction with teaching and learning program. These findings are consistent with other studies (Robins et al. [12], Ziae et al. [13], Tessema et al. [14], Ansari [9], Espeland et al. [15]). However, even with absence of significant differences in satisfaction according to gender, the trend of males and females reporting satisfaction was not stable. This could be due to the fact that women are more lenient in their ratings than male students Tessema et al [14].

Information sources regarding the nursing career had a significant association with student’s satisfaction with the teaching and learning process p=0.000. Students who entered into the training with adequate information about the career and what to expect during the training were extremely satisfied with the teaching and learning process. The students who got the information from the career guidance teachers were more satisfied than those who got the information from nurses or parents and relatives. Career guidance teachers are likely to give unbiased information about a career hence leaving the student to make an informed career choice.

The involvement of learners in the extra curriculum activities influenced the student’s satisfaction positively where 60% of the learners were satisfied with overall teaching and learning process. Students who felt that their participation in the extra-curriculum activities had contributed to their satisfaction with college experience were satisfied with the overall teaching and learning process. These findings are consistent with a study Deshields et al. [16] who argued that students who have a positive college experience will be more satisfied than those students who do not have a positive experience.

The entry grades into the training of nurses were found to have some influence on the satisfaction of the students while in training. The students who had the highest scores in KCSE (A-) were somehow satisfied with the teaching and learning process while those who scored lower were satisfied with the teaching and learning process in the nursing training. These findings are consistent with the findings of a study by Robinson et al [12]. A probable explanation to this could be that the expectations of those with higher entry grades may not have been met in the teaching and learning process of nursing, or they did not have adequate information on the careers that existed to help them make informed choices.

Conclusion

The student related factors that influenced their satisfaction with the teaching and learning process included; student’s information sources regarding the nursing career, the student’s prior knowledge on nursing career roles and responsibilities and what to expect during training and involvement of learners in extra-curricular activities while in the college. However, there appears to be an inverse relationship between student’s entry grades and level of satisfaction. Higher entry grades were associated with lower levels of satisfaction.

Recommendations

Career guidance in schools should be strengthened to help students in making informed career choices which are not influenced by the parents, relatives or peer pressure.

Extra-curricular activities including sports should be encouraged in the schools and training colleges to help the students exercise and relax.

References

Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language
Post your comment

Share This Article

Recommended Journals

Article Usage

  • Total views: 1540
  • [From(publication date):
    March-2017 - Nov 19, 2019]
  • Breakdown by view type
  • HTML page views : 1397
  • PDF downloads : 143
Top