Bruno Chaves Fabrini, Weslley Fernandes Braga, Estefânia Souza Andrade, Daniela Aparecida de Jesus Paula, Renan Rosa Paulino, Adriano Carvalho Costa, Luciano Vilela Paiva, Fabrício Lelis da Silva and Luis David Solis Murgas*
Fish Physiology Research Center, Federal University of Lavras, Lavras-MG, Brazil
Received Date: December 14, 2016 Accepted Date: May 02, 2017 Published Date: May 04, 2017
Citation: Fabrini BC, Braga WF, Andrade ES, Paula DAD, Paulino RR, et al. (2017) Sulfated Polysaccharides in Diets for Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) in the Initial Growth Phase. J Aquac Res Development 8: 477. doi: 10.4172/2155- 9546.1000477
Copyright: ©2017 Fabrini BC, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Aquaculture Research & Development
This study had the objective of evaluating the performance of Nile tilapia, in initial growth phase, with the supplementation of fucoidan, extracted from brown algae, at 30 days of rearing. The experiment was conducted for a period of 30 days. We used 216 Nile tilapia fingerlings distributed in to twelve 60 liter tanks, in a completely randomized design, totalizing four treatments and tree replicates. The fingerlings were supplemented with powdered sulfated polysaccharide extract at the levels of 0%, 0.5%, 1.0% and 1.5%. During the experimental period, two samplings were performed (initial and final) to measure zootechnical performance, muscle histology and blood plasma chromatography. The data were submitted to analysis of variance at a level of significance of 5%. The performance variables muscle fiber diameter frequency and fucose plasmatic concentration were not significant among the treatments (P>0.05). It was possible to identify fucose in the blood plasma of the animals, proving its efficiency in breaking the α-(1-3) bonds of the polysaccharide, thus absorbing this component. The histological analysis showed that there was a higher percentage of hypertrophic growth of the muscle fibers, given that, in all treatments, the diameter class >50 μm prevailed (P<0.05). In conclusion, the sulfated polysaccharide fucoidan, used in diets for Oreochromis niloticus with 30 days of rearing, was not effective in increasing performance parameters and muscle growth.
Fish farming; Oreochromis niloticus; Performance; Fucoidan
According to the Food and Agriculture Organization, FAO , the consumption of fish has rapidly increased in recent years, especially in the last decades, going from 9.9 kg per individual in 1960s to 19.7 kg per individual in 2013. This increase in consumption leads to the demand, by the consumer, that management methods, breeding and nutrition be improved, thus increasing productivity.
In the fish production chain, the improvement of a few productive traits, such as specific growth, is essential for the success of the activity, given that, from the economic point-of-view, this trait is prominent for being intrinsically connected to productivity and production profitability. In this context, the use of economically feasible and natural nutritional compounds, capable of promoting such increment in animal growth, can be an important ally to the producer.
Muscle growth is positively and negatively controlled by a series of transcriptional and growth factors, which, in turn, control the proliferation and differentiation of the satellite cells. One of these factors is a protein of the transforming growth factor–B (TGF-B) family, known as myostatin or Growth/Differentiation Factor–8 (GDF-8), and has the main function of negatively regulating muscle growth, controlling the formation of new muscle fibers and inhibiting the hypertrophy of the existing fibers [2,3]. The knowledge and effect of this protein in the workings of the organism has led to the increase in researches, especially in the genetic level, to inhibit its action, thus, promoting greater muscle growth.
Recently, the use of a sulfated polysaccharide, extracted from brown algae, known as Fucoidan, has demonstrated positive results in this sense. Ramazanov et al. , after conducting an immuno-electrophoresis analysis, in Western Blot, using proteins extracted from human blood serum incubated with sulfated polysaccharide, showed a positive cross reactivity with the antibody of the myostatin. This reactivity increased with the increase in the concentration of polysaccharides in the sample, indicating that the sulfated polysaccharides bonded, preferentially, to the myostatin complex and, potentially, interfere with the bonding capacity of this protein in the cells, inhibiting its action. Tuller et al. , with the objective of obtaining the same result, tested the increment of this polysaccharide at increasing levels in the feed of barramundi (Lates calcarifer). With the increase in the levels of Fucoidan, there was increase in animal growth and size of the muscle fiber. Similar results were also found by Cruz-Suárez  and Traifalgar , who worked with shrimp species.
Despite the results obtained in the in vivo researches, no molecular analysis was conducted to analyze, first, if the animals were effective in breaking the polysaccharide, thus absorbing its components, since it is formed by α-(1-3) bonds; and, posteriorly, its interaction with the action of myostatin. In this sense, this study had the objective of evaluating the performance of Nile tilapia, in initial growth phase, with the supplementation of different levels of sulfated polysaccharide (Fucoidan), extracted from brown algae, at 30 days of rearing, as well as their efficiency in breaking and absorbing this dietary component.
Biological material and experimental conditions
used 216 reverted Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) fingerlings, with average initial weight of 2.73 ± 0.19 g. The fingerlings were maintained for observation, for two weeks, in two water recirculation tanks with capacity for 500 liters, at 26°C. During this period, the animals were fed ad libitum with commercial feed (45% CP), specific to this species and life phase, three times a day (08 h: 00 min, 12 h: 00 min and 17 h: 00 min).
After this period, the fish were randomly distributed in to the 12 experimental tanks, with capacity for 60 liters each. The groups were comprised of 18 animals, which were maintained in experimental conditions, with commercial ration, for a period of a week for adaptation, thus beginning the experiment with the initial sampling.
For a period of 30 days, the animals were daily fed ad libitum at the times of 08 h: 00 min, 12 h: 00 min and 17 h: 00 min, using two experimental diets. The light period adopted was of 12 hours of light and 12 hours of dark. The water quality parameters, such as temperature, pH and dissolved oxygen, were monitored and maintained at 26.5°C, 7.5e, 9.0 mg L-1, respectively, remaining within the normal values for the species . The tanks were maintained in water recirculation system, filtered with biological and physical filters. All tanks were maintained with constant water flow. During the morning (09 h: 00 min) an afternoon (16 h: 00 min) of every day, the tanks were cleaned of feces and, twice per week, the filters were cleaned.
Both experimental samplings (initial and final) were obtained after anesthesia, with clove oil at 80 mg/L , and posterior slaughter of nine animals per tank at each sampling. The slaughtered animals were used for obtaining the data for zootechnical indexes, fucose level in the blood plasma and muscle extraction for histological analysis.
All experimental procedures were carried out in accordance with the Ethics Commission on Animal Use (CEUA) of the Federal University of Lavras (UFLA)
The animals were weighed on precision scale, and the morphometric measures were assessed with the aid of ruler graduated in millimeters (mm). The measures taken were: Total Length (TL), consisted of the beginning of the mouth to the end of the caudal fin; Head Length (HL), consisted of the rear end of the head to the caudal edge of the operculum; Standard Length (SL), consisted of the rear extremity of the head to the smallest perimeter of the peduncle (insertion of the caudal fin); Body Height (BH), body height measured in front of the 1st radius of the dorsal fin.
By means of the weight, morphometric measures and mortality, we evaluated:
Survival rate (S%) = ( final number of fishes / initial number of fishes)×100
Final average weight gain(WG) = final weight – initial weight
Average ration consumption RC = final quantity of ration initial quantity of ration
Evaluation of the skeletal muscle fibers
For the histological analysis, fragments of white muscle were extracted from the left dorsal region of the fishes. These fragments were involved by neutral powder and, subsequently, the samples were frozen in liquid nitrogen and, posteriorly, stored in freezer at -80°C.
For the confection of the laminas, transversal sections of 10 μm of thickness were obtained in cryostat at -20°C (Leica, Germany) and the cuts were submitted to coloration with hematoxylin and eosin for morphological studies.
The histological laminas were photographed using an Olympus CX31 microscope (Olympus, Japan), coupled to an Altra SC30 digital camera (Olympus, Japan) and, using the AxioVision program (Carl Zeiss, Germany), the diameter of 200 muscle fibers was measured per lamina (animal) .
The data regarding the diameters of the muscle fibers were distributed in diameter classes (<25 μm, 25-50 μm and >50 μm), according to methodology adopted by Almeida et al. , and the means were plotted in frequency histogram (%) for each treatment, at 30 days.
Plasmatic levels of fucose
After sampling blood and the posterior extraction of blood serum, the samples underwent readings of liquid chromatography coupled to mass chromatography, to identify and differentiate the levels of fucose.
The samples of plasma were prepared with the dilution in the proportion to 1:100 and filtering by PES membrane, with pore diameter of 0.22 μm. A volume of 10 μL of these samples was injected in to a UFLC system (Shimadzu, Kyoto, Japan) comprised of two pumps (LC- 20AD) and a gas relief (DGU-20A3), by an automatic injector (SIL-20A HT) equipped with a 100 μL loop. The system was operated by software Hystar (BrukerDaltonik, v. 188.8.131.52).
A pre-column of 5 mm and an analytical column of 150 mm × 75 μm, filled with stationary phase C18, 2.7 μm (Supelco, Bellefonte, Pennsylvania, United States) were used for separating the metabolites, which were analyzed in a mass spectrometer (microTOF Q-II, BrukerDaltonik, Bremen, Germany), equipped with an electrospray ionization interface. The samples were carried by flow of 200 μL. min-1 of acetonitrile solution at 20% (v/v) and 0.1% (v/v) AF in water (Fluka, Buchas, Switzerland).
The mobile phase used for separation was prepared with gradient between water containing 0.1% (v/v) AF LC-MS Chromaslov (Fluka) – solution A, and acetonitrile containing 0.1% (v/v) AF LC-MS Chromaslov (Fluka) – solution B. The program used for elution was configured with the following proportions: 0-2 min isocratic 2% B; 2-12 min linear gradient up to 10% B; 12-17 linear gradient up to 98% B; 17- 23 min isocratic 98% B; 23/25 min isocratic 2% B. The configurations used in the mass spectrometry were: mass interval: 50-1000 m/z; spray voltage: 3500 V; drying gas (N2) temperature: 190°C; flow: 9 L. min-1; funnel 1 RF 200.0 Vpp; funnel 2 RF 200.0 Vpp; Hexapole RF 96.0 Vpp; quadrupole energy -3.0 eV; smaller mass of the quadrupole 100.00 m/z; collision energy -8.0 eV; collision RF 150.0 Vpp; transfer time 70 us; storage pre-pulse 5.0 us.
The chromatographic data obtained via LC-MS were analyzed with software Bruker Data Analysis, version 4.0 (Build 253), generating the EIC for m/z 163.05, correspondent to fucose. We also collected the values for area under the spike for comparison between samples. A high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) method has been used previously for the determination of fucose .
The powdered fucoidan extract, derived from the brown algae species Undaria pinnatifida, with purity of 70%, was extracted from capsules of a commercial product and, posteriorly, added to the mixture of ingredients during the confection of the experimental diets.
The experimental diets (Table 1) were formulated and balanced according to the demands of the species and for the fingerling phase. The fucoidan extract was added to the base diet at the levels of 0 (T1), 5 (T2), 10 (T3) and 15 g/kg (T4). After homogenization of the product with the ration ingredients (dry), the diets received treatment with water at 60°C. The rations, agglutinated, underwent pelletizing and, the formed pellets underwent a drying process in oven (45°C) under forced ventilation, for a period of 24 hours.
|Ingredients (%)||Diet 1||Diet 2||Diet 3||Diet 4|
|Vit/ Min Premix1||0.5||0.5||0.5||0.5|
|Calculated Values (%)||0||0.5||1||1.5|
|Digestible Energy (kcal/kg)
1Vitamin and mineral mix provided the following (kg-1 of product): Fe 19621 mg, Cu 2800 mg, Zn 28000 mg, Mn 5200 mg, Se 119 mg, Co 40 mg, I 120 mg, vitamin A 1995 KUI, vitamin D3 798 KUI, vitamin E 19950 mg, vitamin K3 997 mg, thiamin 4987 mg, riboflavin 4987 mg, pyridoxin 4987 mg, cyanocobalamin 5985 mcg, niacin 19950 mg, pantothenic acid 9975 mg, folic acid 997 mg, biotin 159600 mcg, inositol 10000 mg, vitC 70000 mg, ethoxyquin 24775 mg.
2Antioxidant: butylated hydroxytoluene.
Table 1: Diet composition with the levels of fucoidan.
With the fundamental hypothesis for analysis of variance met, the data for zootechnical performance and chromatography were submitted to analysis of variance with a level of significance of 5%. The diameter frequencies were submitted to analysis by the Goodman test. All analyses were performed with the aid of the R computer program, version 3.0.1 .
Regarding the performance variables, final weight (FW), average ration consumption (RC), final average weight gain (FWG), apparent food conversion (AFC), survival (S) and morphometric measures – standard length (SL), head length (HL) and body height (BH), there was no significant difference between the treatments (P>0.05) (Tables 2 and 3).
|Levels of Fucoidan (g/kg)||FW1||RC2||WG3||AFC4||S5|
|0.0||14.25 ± 0.72||12.66 ± 0.76||11.36 ± 0.75||1.12 ± 0.06||86 ± 0.09|
|0.5||12.56 ± 0.10||12.94 ± 0.68||10.01 ± 0.22||1.29 ± 0.09||93 ± 0.06|
|1.0||11.38 ± 1.25||12.90 ± 0.46||8.57 ± 1.24||1.58 ± 0.27||96 ± 0.03|
|1.5||13.29 ± 1.63||12.72 ± 0.32||10.62 ± 1.60||1.25 ± 0.19||96 ± 0.03|
1Fw=Final Average Weight (g); 2RC=Average Ration Consumption/Animal (g); 3WG=Final Average Weight Gain (g); 4AFC=Aparente Food Conversion; 5S=Survival (%)
Table 2: Average values of the performance variables of Oreochromis niloticus supplemented with powdered fucoidan extract during 30 rearing days.
|Levels of Fucoidan (g/kg)||CP1||CC2||AT3|
|0.0||7.22 ± 0.11||2.40 ± 0.02||2.88 ± 0.07|
|0.5||6.84 ± 0.04||2.34 ± 0.03||2.63 ± 0.03|
|1.0||6.68 ± 0.28||2.31 ± 0.13||2.53 ± 0.09|
|1.5||7.01 ± 0.34||2.46 ± 0.11||2.68 ± 0.13|
1SL=Standard Length (cm); 2HL=Head Length (cm); 3BH=Body Height (cm)
Table 3: Average values for the morphometric measures of Oreochromis niloticus supplemented with powdered fucoidan extract during 30 rearing days.
Plasma levels of fucose
Chromatography was incapable of identifying the presence of monosaccharide fucose in the blood plasma of the animals during initial sampling. At the end of the experiment, its presence was identified in all treatments (Figure 1), however, there was no significant difference between the evaluated treatments (P>0.05). We verified the tendency of increase in the levels of fucose with the increase of the levels of fucoidan provided. The average values of the fucose spike areas, in arbitrary units, were of: 841.87 ± 420.99 (T1), 2533.60 ± 189.32 (T2), 4606.23 ± 2202.63 (T3) and 2176.85 ± 833.89 (T4).
Evaluation of skeletal muscle fibers
Table 4 demonstrated data regarding the distribution of the muscle fibers for the studied classes, at 30 days of rearing. There was no significant difference between treatments, since, in all treatments, the fiber frequency in the class >50 μm was the highest, followed by classes 20-50 μm and <20 μm (P<0.05). This result shows that there was a higher percentage of hypertrophic growth of the muscle fibers (Figure 2).
|Levels of Fucoidan (g/kg)||< 20||20 - 50||> 50|
|0.5||4 c||33 b||63ª|
|1.0||6 c||34 b||60ª|
|1.5||5 c||32 b||63ª|
*Means followed by the same letters do not differ statistically by the Goodman test at 5% of probability.
Table 4: Frequency distribution (%) of the diameter of white muscle fiber in classes: < 20 µm, 20-50 µm and > 50 µm of Oreochromis niloticus supplemented with powdered fucoidan extract during 30 rearing days.
The first evidences that the polysaccharides presented the effective capacity of inhibiting the action of myostatin, thus promoting an elevated hyperplasia and hypertrophy rate in the muscle cells, were demonstrated by Ramazanov et al. . In their work, an immuneelectrophoresis analysis, in Western Blot, on proteins extracted from human blood serum and incubated with sulfated polysaccharide. The results showed a positive cross reactivity with the antibody of the myostatin. This reactivity increased with the increase of the concentration of polysaccharides in the sample, indicating that the sulfated polysaccharides bond, preferentially, to the myostatin complex and, potentially, interfere with the bonding capacity of this protein in the cells, inhibiting its action. From this study emerged the idea of testing this polysaccharide as part of a feeding program, in order to obtain the same results.
In this study, the sulfated polysaccharide, Fucoidan, was incapable of increasing performance rates and muscle growth, both hyperplastic and hypertrophic, between the treatments, since none of the variables presented significant differences (P>0.05) with the increase in the levels of the product. Similar performance results, regarding the levels of sulfated polysaccharides, were found by Lima , who tested the effect of administering sulfated polysaccharides at the levels of 0.0, 0.5, 1.0 and 2.0 mg L-1, over survival and growth of juvenile shrimp, species Litopenaeus vannamei, submitted to conditions of stress by hypoxia.
In counterpart, Tuller et al. , who tested levels of inclusion of 0%, 0.5% and 1% in diets for barramundi (Lates calcarifer) (76.1 ± 1.1 g) for 52 days, found significant results. With the increase in the level of Fucoidan, there was an increase in animal growth and size of the muscle fiber. Similar results were found by Cruz-Suárez  and Traifalgar , who worked with shrimp species, L. vannamei (white shrimp) and Marsupenaeus japonicas (kuruma), respectively.
Due to the scarcity of papers with this product, for performance purposes, especially with fish species, its demands and the behavior of this polysaccharide within the animal organism are unknown. Thus, the levels used may not have been enough to meet the demands of the Nile tilapia regarding the effect of the product, since, when compared to the barramundi , for example, in addition to refer to a different species, presents different feeding habits and distinguishes itself from the Nile tilapia regarding its region of origin. The barramundi is an animal of carnivorous habit, of cold water and Asian origin , while the Nile tilapia is an omnivorous species, of tropical climate and African origin .
In addition, we must consider the time spent in this study, which may not have been enough to obtain a response to the product, as well as the manner in which the product was incorporated to the experimental diets, given that, distinct from Ramazanov et al., , who used the intact polysaccharide molecule in direct contact with the blood cells, in this study, the animals would have no capacity of absorbing the molecule in this form in the gastrointestinal tract, due to the size of the molecule. This knowledge, added to the positive results obtained from the different authors, suggest that the effect of the polysaccharide can be caused not by the interaction of its integral structure with the cell, but by a specific monosaccharide present in the structure, such as fucose, which corresponds to more than 90% of its structure.
Since this concerns a polysaccharide with α-(1-3) bonds, another hypothesis for a possible positive performance was raised, since the animals may not have been capable of producing specific enzymes to break these bonds and thus absorb the fucose. In this sense, chromatography analysis were conducted, given that, for detecting the presence of fucose in the blood plasma, prove that the animals are capable of degrading the molecule and absorbing this component.
In the study in question and that conducted by Traifalgar et al. , the knowledge of this compound in the animal organism has led to it being incorporated to the diets as fibrous element. However, with the exception of Lima et al. , who also found no significant differences between treatments, the authors made only the inclusion of the product, without considering the balance of the diets regarding the levels of fiber or even of energy, since it concerns a polysaccharide. In addition, in none of the works was conducted a molecular analysis with the objective of detecting any type of inhibition of the action of myostatin. Thus, the positive effect of the polysaccharide over growth, cannot be attributed only to this fact.
There are suppositions that can be made concerning the beneficial effect of the sulfated polysaccharides, or its constituents, over animal performance, discarding the hypothesis of its action over the myostatin molecule. A possible explanation is in the fact that fucose performes an important role in the maintenance of animal immune system and health of the intestinal flora.
Fucose, whether dietetic or of the organism, can be found as an important structural component of glucans. Specific terminal changes in glucans, including fucosylation, mediated by fucosyltransferases (FUT), can confer exclusive functional properties to a few oligosaccharides, and, are often regulated during ontogeny and cellular differentiation .
The discovery of thirteen genes capable of synthetizing fucosyltransferases in the human genome was describe . The expression of these genes is responsible for many functions in the organism, such as synthesis of the H blood group antigen [18,19]; synthesis of Lewisx and sialyl-Lewisx antigens [20,21]; addition of fucose to GlcNAc asparagine ; and the addition of fucose directly in to polypeptide chains . Thus, this functional property, within the composition of the oligosaccharides, confer to fucose an important role in the health of the immune system.
The expression of these fucosyltransferases can also be regulated by bacterial flora, as described by Hooper . Microbiologically sterilized mice, when colonized by bacteria, were capable of increasing the expression of FUT2. Consequently, there were changes in the carbohydrate chain present in the epithelial cells, which presented fucose as terminal component.
In this sense, the health of the intestinal flora can be seen as an important component of maintaining the normal development of the animal, with the providing of fucose via diet aiding in this. It was proven that the bacteria are capable of growing while using fucose as a single source of carbon structure and energy . The stages to this via include the entrance of free fucose to the cell by means of bacterial permease, fucose isomerization (aldose) to form fuculose (cetose), fuculose phosphorylation to form fuculose-1-phosphate, and an aldolase reaction to form lactadehyde and dihydroxyacetone phosphate [25-27]. It was proposed that fucose can also be synthetized from two units of tree carbons by a via operating in the inverse direction of its catabolic via [28,29], however, this synthesis would by unnecessary, if the fucose be provided by the diet, conserving the energetic expense with its biosynthesis.
Considering that this monosaccharide was absorbed, as shows the chromatographic data, in addition to its use as fundamental structure of specific glucans, as aforementioned, we can suppose that it can be used as energy source for the animal, as occurs with glucose. In a study involving the intravenous administration of fucose (1-14C) to human patients, it was reported that 39% of the radioactivity injected was excreted in the form of 14CO2 , suggesting that fucose could be metabolized to smaller metabolic units. In an in vitro work, a catabolic via was identified in swine hepatocyte extracts, which can convert 1 mol of fucose to 2 mols of L-lactate .
Despite these suppositions, there are not enough scientific knowledge to extrapolate to other species, and it is yet unclear its contributions to in vivo metabolism.
In conclusion, the Fucoidan sulfated polysaccharide, used for diets for Oreochromis niloticus with 30 days of rearing, was ineffective in increasing the performance parameters and muscle growth. The animals were efficient in breaking the α-(1-3) bonds of the polysaccharide, and thus absorb the main structural component of the molecule, the monosaccharide fucose. The study was capable of directing future researches for the use of fucoidan a functional food, not discarding, however, the hypothesis of its inhibitory action to the molecule of myostatin.
The authors would like to thank Rede Mineira de Bioterismo-FAPEMIG, CNPq, FUNDECC, CEMIG and CAPES for financial support. The authors wish to thank FN Monographic for English translation and revision of this manuscript. The authors would like to thank Piscicultura Projeto Tambacu and Piscicultura Aquaporto for the donation of the biological material.