Received Date: May 16, 2012; Accepted Date: June 30, 2012; Published Date: July 05, 2012
Citation: Turan A, Sarwar S, Sandwell S, Homolya K, Govinda R, et al. (2012) Retrospective Analysis of Single-Dose Extended-Release Epidural Morphine Usage. J Anesth Clin Res 3:221 doi: 10.4172/2155-6148.1000221
Copyright: © 2012 Turan A, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Anesthesia & Clinical Research
Objective: Moderate to severe postoperative pain is commonly experienced by surgical patients. A new advance in epidural anesthesia permits use of a 48 hour, extended release formulation of morphine (DepoDurTM). This retrospective study examines efficacy and side effects of this drug used in two different doses.
Methods: 90 surgical patients were given Epidural analgesia, of which 31 and 59 patients were given single doses of 10 mg or 15 mg extended release formulations of morphine respectively. Following IRB approval, retrospective chart review focusing on supplemental pain medication needs of patients up to the first 48 hours after surgery was carried out. Pain medication doses were converted to morphine equianalgesic values using established equivalence formulas. Verbal analog pain scale records from postoperative recovery units were reviewed; side effects of patients were noted.
Results: During the first 48 hours after surgery, patients given 10 mg dosage of DepoDurTM required 27.3 ± 32.8 mg while those given 15 mg of DepoDurTM required 19.6 ± 18.2 mg of morphine (P = 0.23). Pain levels reported on a 0-10 scale at discharge after surgery were 1.6 ± 2.6 and 0.9 ± 1.5 for the 10 mg and 15 mg groups respectively (P = 0.52). Postoperative side effects were experienced in 77% and 68% of patients receiving a 10 mg and 15 mg dose of DepoDurTMrespectively (P = 0.46). Postoperative nausea was reported with greater frequency at 65% and 46% in both 10 mg and 15 mg groups respectively (P = 0.12).
Conclusion: Comparing usage of 10 mg and 15 mg doses of DepoDurTM for extended release epidural analgesia, no significant difference was found in pain control, total pain medicine consumption during the first 48 hours after surgery and or incidence of any side effect.
Despite ongoing efforts to curb postoperative pain, moderate to severe pain is experienced by as many as 88% of surgical patients within the first 24 hours after surgery of which 41% describe their pain as unbearable. 81% of postoperative patients in general report moderate to severe pain, with 29% of these patients also describing their pain as unbearable . Uncontrolled pain adversely affects patient health causing delay in hospital recovery and ambulation , increased chronic pain development  and postoperative complications .
Commonly, postoperative pain may be treated using regional anesthesia, such as epidural and intravenous (IV) opiate administration . Advantages of epidural anesthesia are early ambulation and related decrease in pulmonary complications [6,7], nausea and sedation compared to systemic opiate pain control [8-10]. Pain control is often better achieved using epidural anesthesia than with IV narcotics [12-15]. Patients show less of a stress response determined by lower circulating levels of epinephrine, norepinephrine, cortisol and serum glucose . The drug of choice using epidural analgesia is local anesthetics but in the interest of improving efficacy of pain control, opioids are usually added. However epidural opioids may cause pruritis and urinary retention [10,12,14] and the risks associated with placing epidural catheters are low but may include epidural hematomas, infections and catheter migration into the thecal sac area .
Recent advances in epidural anesthesia allow use of a 48-hour extended release form of morphine, brand named DepoDurTM [16-18]. DepoDurTM uses DepoFoamTM technology delivering morphine as part of a multi-vesicular liposomal structure resembling foam . As the structure is broken down, embedded morphine is released providing longer periods of analgesia compared to regular epidural morphine dosages which provide 8 hours of pain relief [19,20]. Using extended release morphine, the need for supplemental opiates is decreased . Similar to regular epidural morphine, pain control is better achieved than that with IV opiates although causing side effects such as nausea, pruritis, and hypotension [18,22]. However one study comparing 10 mg DepoDurTM doses to regular epidural morphine showed no significant difference in incidence of side effects . Currently there are two available preparations of DepoDurTM, 10 mg and 15 mg, and there is no clear consensus on which dose should be preferred. Furthermore, there is no study available comparing the two doses, not only for pain but also for side effects.
This retrospective study sets out to evaluate the effectiveness and side effects of two doses of epidural DepoDurTM assessing and comparing pain medicine consumption.
Following IRB approval and partial waiver from the IRB and Hospital Ethics Committee, charts from patients having received epidural DepoDurTM prior to operative procedures were retrospectively reviewed. The selected charts extended from December of 2006 through December of 2008.
Information obtained from the charts includes patient age, procedure, DepoDurTM dose, intra and postoperative analgesics, and postoperative verbal analog pain scores (VAPS). Adverse effects were also sought in chart review including incidence of respiratory depression, oxygen desaturation, nausea, vomiting, pruritis, urinary retention, constipation, pyrexia, and sensory or motor disturbances.
Standard protocol in our institution for patients receiving DepoDurTM included administration of 10 mg each of Montelukast and Loratadine prior to the procedure or day of surgery, and 10 mg of Loratadine on the day after the procedure. Intra-operative anti-emetics were recorded from the intra-operative anesthesia charts. Morphine and equivalent narcotic medicine usage was compared among DepoDurTM dosage groups as mean values ± standard deviation (SD).
The student’s t-test and the Pearson Chi-square test were used comparing continuous outcome (i.e., pain medicine consumption) and binary outcome (i.e., PCA usage and adverse side effects) amongst DepoDurTM dosage groups, respectively. Adverse effects were presented as a percentage of incidences and demographic data was presented as mean ± SD.
The average age of patients considered was 48 ± 11 years with greater majority of patients having under gone a gynaecological procedure, as shown in Table 1.
|Age (yrs)||48 ± 11|
|Female / Male (No.)||80 / 10|
|Body mass index (kg/m2)||33 ± 16|
|Type of surgery (No.)|
Table 1: Demographics and type of surgery (N = 90).
Table 2 compares both groups of patients, one receiving a 10 mg mg (N = 59) DepoDur Groups. dose of epidural DepoDurTM (n=31) and the other 15 mg (n=59). Pain medication needs for both groups of patients were compared during three time periods; the intra-operative time period, the first two hours following surgery and lastly upto and including the first 48 post operative hours as shown in Table 2. A significantly higher average of morphine equivalent medication was given to the 15 mg group of patients during surgery (P = 0.02); although the group receiving 10 mg of DepoDurTM consistently required descriptively more pain medication during the first 48 hours post surgical period. The total 48 hour postoperative pain medication requirements were not different between the 10 and 15 mg groups (27.3 ± 32.8 and 19.6 ± 18.2 mg, respectively; P = 0.23) (Figure 1).
|Time||DepoDur Dose (mg)||Opioid consumption †
(mg; excluding DepoDur)
|Intra Operative||10||32.5 ± 13.5||0.02||N/A||N/A|
|15||40.2 ± 17.2||N/A|
|PACU (0-2 hrs)||10||12.3 ± 14.8||0.61||29||0.17|
|15||10.8 ± 11.6||15|
|10||15.0 ± 26.0||0.22||39||0.08|
|15||8.8 ± 12.4||20|
(total 48 hrs)
|10||27.3 ± 32.8||0.23||39||0.15|
|15||19.6 ± 18.2||24|
† Morphine Equivalent
PACU = Post-anesthesia care unit, PCA = Patient controlled anesthesia
Table 2: Postoperative (morphine equivalent) (N = 31 and 59 for the 10 and 15 mg groups respectively).
Further comparisons were made using data from patients with history of prior opiate use (n=10) vs. patients who were opioid naive (n=80) (Table 3). Patients with history of prior opiate use received lower dosages of epidural DepoDurTM (P = 0.01) and a lower amount of intra-operative pain medicine (P <0.001) on average when compared to the opiate naive group, 11.5 ± 2.4 and 25.5 ± 7.1 vs. 13.5 ± 2.3 and 39.1 ± 16.6 mg, respectively. However, no difference in the amounts of morphine required during the postoperative period between patients with prior opiate use and opioid naive patients, 28.9 ± 29.8 vs. 21.4 ± 23.7 mg respectively (P=0.47).
(N = 10)
(N = 80)
|DepoDur Dose (mg)||11.5 ± 2.4||13.5 ± 2.3||0.01|
|IntraOp pain medicine (mg) †||25.5 ± 7.1||39.1 ± 16.6||<0.001|
|Postop pain medicine (mg) †||28.9 ± 29.8||21.4 ± 23.7||0.47|
† Morphine Equivalent
Table 3: Compare patients with history of prior opiate use (n=10) and patients who were opioid naive (n=80).
Patient controlled anesthesia (PCA) devices were required significantly more (P = 0.03) for patients with prior opioid use (60%) than for opioid naive patients (25%) respectively. The observed frequencies of PCA usage were also doubled in the 10 mg dose group as compared to the 15 mg dose group; however the differences were not statistically significant (Table 2). During the PACU recovery period, pain scores were descriptively lower among the 15 mg dose group at all time periods compared to the 10 mg dose group, but the differences were not statistically significant (Table 4). Side effects occurred in both 10 mg and 15 mg dose groups with 77% and 68% of patients experiencing one or more side effects respectively (P=0.46, Table 5).
|PACU Pain Scores||DepoDur Dose
|1 hour||3.8 ± 2.9||2.6 ± 3.1||0.14|
|2 hours||2.7 ± 2.4||2.2 ± 2.6||0.54|
|Discharge||1.6 ± 2.6||0.9 ± 1.5||0.52|
Table 4: Pain score during PACU stay (N = 31 and 59 for the 10 and 15 mg groups respectively).
|Side effect (%)||DepoDur Dose
|One or More||77||68||0.46|
Table 5: Side effects occurred in both 10mg (N = 31) and 15 mg (N = 59) dose groups.
This retrospective study sets out to evaluate the effectiveness and side effects of epidural DepoDurTM, assessing and comparing pain medicine consumption amongst patients receiving the very same, using both 10 mg and 15 mg dosages. Although not statistically significant, this study does descriptively demonstrate greater efficacy with use of 15 mg preparations compared to 10 mg preparations of DepoDurTM. These findings are descriptively supported in the results which show lower consumption of opiate medications (Morphine Equivalent mg), lower usage of PCA and lower relevant Pain Scores at 1 and 2 hour intervals and discharge.
During the 48 hours following surgery, our results showed that no difference in supplemental pain medicine between patients randomized and receiving 10 and 15 mg dose of epidural extended release morphine, DepoDurTM. At two separate time intervals, PACU (0-2 hrs) and Post- Operatively (total 48 hrs), patients receiving 10 mg of DepoDurTM required descriptively greater supplemental pain medication versus those patients receiving 15 mg DepoDurTM; 12.3 ± 14.8 vs. 10.8 ± 11.6 (p = 0.61) morphine equivalent dosage for the initial PACU (0-2 hrs) period for 10 mg and 15 mg groups respectively, and 27.3 ± 32.8 vs. 19.6 ± 18.2 (p = 0.23) morphine equivalent dosage for the Post-Operative (total 48 hrs) period for both 10 and 15 mg groups respectively. The larger dose of epidural morphine was expected to provide better pain control and as anticipated this trend continued for the full 48 hours for which the product is reported to last. This finding may be partly attributed to the larger epidural dose and also because patients in the 15 mg group received a greater amount of systemic pain medication during the Intra-Operative period as opposed to patients in the 10 mg group, 40.2 ± 17.2 vs. 32.5 ± 13.5 (p = 0.02) respectively. The greater use of Intra-Operative systemic narcotics may have had a continued analgesic effect and extended into the PACU period thus contributing to reduced systemic pain medication requirements seen in the 15 mg dose group. In light of the aforementioned, several studies have also previously shown a reduction in the consumption of supplemental analgesics with the use of extended release formulations of morphine, DepoDurTM, such as that seen in post-caesarean deliveries or after total hip/knee arthroplasties and lower abdominal surgeries [17,18,21,23].
Furthermore a second comparison, established between patients with previous history of opiate use prior to surgery (n=10) and those who were opiate naive (n=80), showed the former group received a smaller dose of epidural DepoDurTM initially and also a lower amount of Intra-Operative pain medication compared to the opiate naive group. Interestingly enough greater amounts of supplemental pain medication was however required in the 48 hour Post-Operative time period for patients with history of prior opiate use versus the opiate naive patient population, 28.9 ± 29.8 vs. 21.4 ± 23.7 mg respectively (p = 0.47). With the standard deviation being large this was not unfortunately statistically significant. The sample size of the patient group presenting with histories of prior opiate use was only 10 and thus further study would be deemed necessary to establish a greater definitive observation. Side effect occurrence was also not different among these groups, 80% among those with a history of prior opiate use and 70% among the opiate naive group (P = 0.72).
Patient controlled anesthesia (PCA) devices were required for patients with prior opioid use at double the frequency of opioid naive patients, 60% (6/10) and 25% (20/80) respectively. They were also required more in the 10 mg dose group at also double the frequency (Table 2).
Results from the study also revealed usage of PCA was required in obtaining adequate pain control descriptively less frequently among the 15 mg dose group, 29% vs. 15% during the PACU (0-2hrs) period for both 10 mg and 15 mg groups respectively, and 39% vs. 24% during the Post-Operative (total 48 hrs) period also for both 10 mg and 15 mg groups respectively. These findings, as before, may also be attributed to the initially larger dose of DepoDurTM administered during the Intra-Operative time period and also a greater amount of supplemental morphine equivalent (mg) medication being given to the 15 mg dose group leading us to believe its lasting effects may have led patients to be less dependent on PCA. Interestingly, the larger dose was tolerated without a significant increase in side effects. In fact, overall incidence of one or more side effects was 77% and 68% amongst the 10 mg and 15 mg groups respectively. The most frequent side effect was nausea. Occurring with greater frequency in the 10 mg dose group when compared to the 15 mg group, 65% vs. 46% respectively, nausea may have been caused as a result of the systemic supplemental pain medications rather than the actual extended release epidural morphine. It is possible that because the 10 mg group required more supplemental systemic opioid medication, they may have experienced more nausea which is why we believe the 10 mg dose group also suffered greater respiratory depression, 10%, when compared to the 15 mg dose group, 5% (not significant P = 0.41).
Therefore we may conclude using a 15 mg dose of extended release epidural morphine might provide superior pain relief with less need for supplemental pain medicine during the 48 hour postoperative period when compared with a 10 mg dose group. Descriptively it is suggested those patients receiving 15 mg DepoDurTM experienced fewer side effects, however these findings are suggestive considering our small sample size. In lieu of these findings, it is our suggestion that further study is required before the findings can be deemed clinically significant. Seeing this is a retrospective study we have already included all the available data from all patients. An important limitation of this study is the small sample size. This retrospective study was limited by the sample size and further review of a greater number of patient outcomes would help better determine the efficacy and side effect profiles of epidural DepoDurTM at both 10 mg and 15 mg dosages.
Make the best use of Scientific Research and information from our 700 + peer reviewed, Open Access Journals