Received Date: July 30, 2012; Accepted Date: September 27, 2012; Published Date: September 29, 2012
Citation: Maillart E, Karmali R, Miendje Deyi VY, Mascart G, Cherifi S (2012) The Association between Time to Positivity and Staphylococcus Aureus Bacteremia in a Geriatric Population. J Med Microb Diagn 1:114. doi: 10.4172/2161-0703.1000114
Copyright: © 2012 Maillart E, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Medical Microbiology & Diagnosis
Background: Time to Positivity (TTP) of blood cultures is defined as the time elapsed between the start of incubation and the automated alert signal indicating growth in the culture bottle. This study evaluates the TTP of blood cultures in patients with Staphylococcus aureus Bacteremia (SAB) and assesses the relationship between TTP and mortality,
Methods: We performed a retrospective study involving adults who had SAB between May 2007 and May 2010 in a tertiary hospital. TTP was defined as the time between onset of incubation and growth detection using an automated blood culture system.
Results: A total of 167 SAB were evaluated. Patient’s median age was 72 years (range, 18-95 years). The median TTP was 13.6 h (range, 3.6-95.2 h). Attributable mortality rate (27.5%) was not related to the TTP (P=0.558) nor to the comorbidities. Age >60 years was the only independent predictor of attributable mortality (P<0.001). Univariate analysis revealed a significantly shorter TTP in persistent bacteremia, endovascular source of infection, catheter-related infection and in community-acquired SAB. A TTP >11.3 h had a negative predictive value of 96.4% for endocarditis. TTP was not related to methicillin susceptibility nor resistance of Staphylococcus aureus (P=0.934).
Conclusion: In our elderly population, shorter TTP was significantly associated with a central source of infection and a persistent SAB. In addition for the first time, community-acquired SAB was associated with a shorter TTP. TTP may contribute to a better management of SAB by facilitating clinical decisions, especially in endocarditis
Staphylococcus aureus; Bacteremia; Time to positivity; Endocarditis; Community-acquired
Time to Positivity (TTP) of blood cultures is defined as the time elapsed between the start of incubation and the automated alert signal indicating growth in the culture bottle. TTP is related to the number of micro-organisms initially present in blood and their metabolism . The higher the initial bacterial inoculum, the quicker the cut-off value for detection of positivity is reached [1,2]. TTP is an indirect marker of the bacterial load and is associated with a higher morbidity and mortality . Differential TTP is used for the diagnosis of catheterrelated bacteremia [2,4,5-7] and TTP is used for predicting the presence of Staphylococcus spp. bacteria in blood culture [8,9].
Staphylococcus aureus is a major cause of bloodstream infection and is associated with significant morbidity and mortality . Only a few studies have described the relationship between TTP and clinical outcome in S. aureus Bacteremia (SAB) [3,11-13].
Our aim was to describe the TTP in adult patients with SAB and to assess its relationship with different variables such as mortality, severity of SAB, source of infection and methicillin resistance in order to improve the management of SAB based on TTP.
This retrospective study included all adult patients admitted to Brugmann University Hospital between 15th May 2007 and 15th May 2010 who presented at least one episode of SAB. The following data where collected: demographic characteristics; acquisition of SAB (nosocomial or community-acquired); screening of nasal carriage for methicillin-resistant S. aureus (MRSA); sources of bacteremia (primary, catheter-related, secondary); predisposing conditions and Charlson weighted index of comorbidity (Charlson WIC); microbiological data (antimicrobial resistance and TTP); criteria of severity (complications of bacteremia, control blood cultures, intensive car admission, department of hospitalization and length of stay); outcome (cure, relapse, death).
The Brugmann University Hospital is an 854-bed hospital in Brussels with around 27 000 admissions per year. It has 32 intensive care unit beds, geriatric unit of 132 beds.
A set of blood culture was performed by inoculating 7-10 mL of blood into BACTEC/F blood culture aerobic and anaerobic bottles. All the bottles were sent immediately at room temperature to the microbiology laboratory and were loaded into the BACTEC 9240 system (Becton Dickinson, Cockeysville, Md). Incubation was performed until positive and for a maximum of seven days. Bottles with positive results were examined by Gram staining. In case of characteristics colonies of Gram-positive cocci on direct examination, the standard coagulase reaction was performed with human plasma and their content was subcultured in a gelose. The gelose was incubated overnight at 37°C in aerobic atmosphere. If S. aureus was isolated, routine antibiotic susceptibility testing was performed including methicillin susceptibility determined by two methods: the disk diffusion method using an oxacillin disk and a cefoxitin one (Neo-Sensitabs, Rosco, Taastrup, Denmark) and a dilution technique on the automate Vitek-2 (bioMérieux, Marcy l’Etoile, France). In case of discordance between both techniques, the strain was sent to the Belgian reference laboratory for Staphylococcus spp. for molecular detection of the mecA gene.
A set of blood culture was considered positive if at least one of both bottles was positive for S. aureus . An episode of SAB was defined as ≥ one positive blood culture. The time of the SAB episode was the time of inoculation of the first positive blood culture . Time to positivity of the blood culture was defined as the time between the start of incubation and the time that the automated alert signal indicating growth in the culture bottle sounded [11,12]. In case of multiple positive blood cultures inoculated within maximum two hours, the shortest TTP was taken into account [1,3]
Source of bacteremia was determined according to the definitions of the National Surveillance Program for Hospital Infections (NSIH). SAB was considered as primary, secondary or primary related to catheter . We pooled the following sources into one group named as “central source”: primary, primary related to catheter and secondary endovascular (endocarditis, arterio-venous fistula, vascular graft) . Infective endocarditis was defined according to the modified Duke criteria . Severity of underlying diseases present before the episode of SAB was assessed according to the Charlson WIC .
SAB was qualified as complicated if multiple clinical sources were identified simultaneously during the bacteremia or if there was metastatic infection . Persistent SAB was defined if blood culture remained positive beyond 48 h of appropriate antibiotic treatment. A prolonged hospitalization was defined as a length of stay ≥ 15 days, minimum time necessary to consider an uncomplicated SAB as optimally treated .
Cure was defined as a negative blood culture and/or absence of septic signs during seven days following the initiation of antibiotics . SAB occurring more than 8 days after the end of one episode was considered as a new episode . The attributable mortality was defined as death occurring with persistent bacteremia, with persistent signs of sepsis or occurring before the end of the episode of bacteremia without any other obvious cause .
Non-normally distributed quantitative variables were reported as median values with their range and their differences were evaluated with the Mann-Whitney test. Qualitative variables were assessed by Chi-square test or Fisher’s exact test where applicable. Logistic regression was used for multivariate analysis. Receiver Operating Characteristics (ROC) curve was used to determine the cut-off values of TTP when univariate analysis (Mann-Whitney) was significant. The positive predictive value and negative predictive value were calculated according to the prevalence of that parameter in our cohort. A P<0.05 was considered to be statistically significant.
A total of 205 episodes of SAB were identified. Among these, 18 were excluded from the study because of incomplete or missing data and 20 episodes were excluded because they had received previous antibiotic treatment. A total of 167 episodes in 154 patients were reviewed for TTP analysis. Among ten patients with multiple episodes, one patient had four episodes, one presented three episodes and eight had two episodes.
Characteristics of the study population
The median age was 72 years (18-95 years) and 100 episodes (59.9%) occurred in men. Among the 167 episodes of SAB, 112 (67.1%) were caused by methicillin-sensible S. aureus (MSSA) and 72 (43.1%) were classified as community-acquired. Screening of nasal carriage for MRSA was performed in 148 (88.6%) episodes and in 46 (31.1%) it was positive. Control blood cultures were performed in 34 (17.9%) of the episodes 24 h after the beginning of an adequate antibiotic and in another 32 (10.2%) after 48 h of adequate treatment. The overall median length of hospitalization was 30 days (0-237 days). The attributable mortality rate was 27.5% with a median age of 82 years at the time of death (31-94 years). Characteristics of the 154 patients with SAB are listed in table 1.
|Patient groups||Cardiac echography||98||(58.7)|
|Geriatric ≥ 75 years||76||(45.5)|
|Intensive care unit||22||(13.2)||Biological||2||(1.2)|
|Charlson score||Catheter-related Source||36||(21.6)|
|0-5||56||(33.5)||Short term central venous catheter||18||(10.8)|
|> 5-10||83||(49.7)||Long term central venous catheter||16||(9.6)|
|Long term catheter||20||(12.0)||Attributable mortality||46||(27.5)|
|Renal insufficiency||26||(15.6)||Non-attributable mortality||13||(7.8)|
|Peripheral arterial disease||18||(10.8)|
Table 1: Characteristics among 167 episodes of S. aureus bacteremia.
Time to positivity: Univariate analysis and predictive values
The median TTP was 13.6 h (3.6 to 95.2 h). Distribution of TTP is represented in figure 1.
There was no significant relationship between TTP and attributable mortality (P = 0.558). Age>60 years did not influence the TTP (P=0.256) but influenced the attributable mortality independently (OR: 8.93; 95% CI: 2.62-30.3; P<0.001). The logistic regression represented in table 2 showed that age was the only independent factor that influenced the attributable mortality (P<0.001). Attributable mortality was not related to any of the comorbidities studied.
|Total||OR||(95% CI)||P||Total||OR||(95% CI)||P|
|Age > 60 years||48||(29.4)||8.93||(2.62-30.3)||<0.001||115||(70.6)||9.09||(2.53-33.3)||<0.001|
|Charlson score ≥ 5||44||(27.0)||1.48||(0.66-3.30)||0.343||119||(73.0)||0.94||(0.38-2.35)||0.893|
Table 2: Characteristics among 167 episodes of S. aureus bacteremia.
Univariate analysis represented in table 3 revealed an association between a TTP ≤ 13.9 h and community-acquired SAB (P=0.032), a TTP ≤ 12.4 h and persistent bacteremia (P=0.010), a TTP ≤ 12.7 h and an endovascular source of infection (P=0.037) and a TTP ≤ 13.3 h and an intravascular catheter-related infection (P=0.019). TTP>11.3 h had a negative predictive value of 96.4% for endocarditis. The cut-off values of TTP are listed in table 4. Influence of different comorbidities on TTP was evaluated. Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD), drug user and stroke significantly increased the TTP.
|Total||Median TTP||Total||Median TTP|
|Age > 60 years||117||(71.3)||13.3||(3.6-95.2)||50||(29.9)||14.5||(7.3-65.1)||0.256|
|Charlson score ≥5||123||(73.7)||13.6||(3.6-95.2)||44||(26.3)||13.2||(7.9-52.6)||0.740|
|Peripheral arterial disease||18||(10.8)||13.2||(4.4-28.0)||149||(89.2)||13.6||(3.6-95.2)||0.541|
|Criteria of severity|
|Intensive care unit stay||51||(30.5)||13.0||(3.6-52.6)||116||(69.5)||13.6||(7.0-95.2)||0.074|
|Source of bacteremia|
|Primary related to catheter (b)||36||(21.6)||11.6||(3.6-95.2)||131||(78.4)||13.9||(4.4-81.9)||0.019|
|Secondary endovascular (c)||25||(15.0)||12.4||(7.2-32.7)||142||(85.0)||13.8||(3.6-95.2)||0.037|
Table 3: Univariate analysis of different variables and TTP among 167 episodes of S. aureus bacteremia.
|Variable||TTP cut-off||AUC (95%CI)||Sensibility||Specificity||PPV||NPV|
|Community-acquired bacteremia||13.9||0.60||(± 0.04)||66.7||56.8||38.4||80.9|
|Persistent bacteremia||12.4||0.70||(± 0.07)||66.7||61.8||10.0||96.7|
|Primary source related to catheter||13.3||0.63||(± 0.05)||66.7||58.3||21.1||91.3|
|Secondary endovascular source||12.7||0.63||(± 0.06)||60.0||57.7||12.1||93.5|
|Central source||15.4||0.68||(± 0.04)||53.6||73.5||47.6||77.9|
Table 4: Sensibility, Specificity and Predictives Values of TTP.
There was no relation between TTP and methicillin resistance: the median TTP was 13.55 h in MRSA bacteremias compared to 13.45 h in MSSA bacteremias (P=0.934).
In 1998, Blot et al. described that TTP of blood culture was related to the number of micro-organisms initially present in blood and their metabolism. They concluded that the higher the initial bacterial inoculum, the quicker the cut-off value for detection of positivity was reached . Hence differential TTP was used in the diagnosis of catheter-related bacteremia [2,7].
Further, studies showed that a TTP ≤ 14 h was correlated to attributable mortality in bacteremia varying from 11.9% to 18% [3,11,12]. In our study, attributable mortality (27.5%) was higher than those reported in the literature but there was no significant association between TTP and attributable mortality. Two hypotheses could explain these results. First, our elderly population presented an important rate of comorbidities (Charlson score ≥ 5 in 74% patients) that could have influenced mortality in SAB. However, we did not find a relation between attributable mortality and comorbidities as described in the literature [11,13,16]. The second hypothesis is the higher median age (72 years) in our cohort and the even higher age (82 years) among the deceased patients. In other studies, the population considered was heterogeneous including pediatric patients with a median age inferior to 62 years [3,11,12]. In fact, the only independent factor in our population that influenced the attributable mortality was age. Age has been described as correlated to attributable mortality in elderly patients with SAB [19,20]. It is possible that the mortality rate in our cohort was not only attributable to SAB but rather to age which might have annihilated the influence of TTP on mortality.
To our knowledge, our study is the first one to describe that a community-acquired bacteremia influences TTP with a cut-off TTP ≤ 13.9 h. It has been reported that community-acquired SAB is more severe and complicated because the diagnosis is delayed due to the absence of major symptoms [21-23]. We hypothesize that community-dwelling patient, presenting to the emergency unit after a delay of three to four days of fever, when the bacteremia is already established with a large inoculum explaining a shorter TTP. In contrast, nosocomial bacteremia is often secondary or related to catheter infection and therefore more easily recognized . Hospitalized patients are managed more promptly and this implies a smaller inoculum and hence a longer TTP.
Some comorbidities increased TTP (COPD, drug user and stroke). The reasons are not clear and warrant additional studies addressing specifically that question.
We observed also a relationship between TTP and one criteria of severity. In our study, 9% of the patients had persistent bacteremia, which was correlated to a TTP ≤ 12.4 h. These results are similar to those reported by Khatib et al. , but their rate of persistent bacteremia was higher (32.1%), probably because they used a different definition of persistent bacteremia.
As reported in the literature, we also found a relation between TTP and different sources of bacteremia such as endocarditis, endovascular, central and catheter-related infection [9,12]. Our cut-off values of TTP were in majority similar to those previously reported [3,11]. In our hospital, the knowledge of the negative predictive value in endocarditis and catheter-related bacteremia has a clinical impact on the medical approach of these situations.
Finally, TTP tended to be shorter, but not significantly in MSSA bacteremia when compared to MRSA bacteremia. Martinez et al.  described that median TTP in a MSSA bacteremia was significantly shorter than in MRSA bacteremia. In contrast, Ruimy et al.  reported a median TTP in MSSA longer than in MRSA bacteremia but it was not significant and without excluding pre-treated bacteremia. With these conflicting reports, one would think that TTP in MSSA and MRSA bacteremia is influenced by other factors than micro-organisms themselves such as the origin of bacteremia and prior antibiotic therapy . On the other side, the genetic diversity of MRSA between countries with dominant MRSA spa types forming distinctive geographical clusters could explain the fact that in our study, methicillin resistance was not associated with a short TTP. MRSA strains in Belgium may be less virulent as compared to other clusters in the literature [24,25].
Our study had several limitations. Firstly it was limited by the retrospective nature of our analysis, the small size of our cohort and the lack of complete clinical data during the SAB except admission into intensive care unit; secondly, the volume of blood drawn in the bottles remained uncontrolled and may have influenced the TTP. Finally, all patients had not systematic blood culture control after introduction of adequate antibiotic therapy and therefore the number of persistent bacteremia might have been under-estimated.
In conclusion, this study suggests that attention should be paid to a short TTP because it is associated with a persistent bacteremia, an endovascular source of infection, a catheter-related infection and very interestingly with a community-acquired SAB. Another important information concerns the negative predictive value of 96.4% for a TTP >11.3 h in endocarditis. In our population, the high age of the patients and their comorbidities influence the TTP and modify its classically reported relation with attributable mortality. TTP, already useful for catheter-related bloodstream infection diagnosis is a relatively simple and fairly reliable method that can optimize the management and treatment of SAB.
The authors disclose any financial and personal relationships with other people or organizations that could inappropriately influence their work.