Received date December 06, 2012; Accepted date December 08, 2012; Published date December 11, 2012
Citation: Castellani KC, Perry EA, Perry G, Castellani RJ (2013) Treating Alzheimer Disease: Is Diet and Exercise more Effective than Small Molecule Therapy? J Membra Sci Technol 3:e111. doi:10.4172/2155-9589.1000e111
Copyright: © 2013 Castellani KC, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Membrane Science & Technology
As Alzheimer’s disease (AD) therapeutic research continues to pursue small molecule targeting, disease modifying therapy remains elusive . Indeed, despite a wide array of pharmacologic agents at our disposal and the design and completion of dozens of clinical trials targeting Amyloid-beta (Aβ), no approach has shown any progress whatsoever in ameliorating the disease process, and affected patients continue to suffer and expire on the same cognitive trajectory as they have since the dawn of the species. One major defect in the so-called amyloid cascade hypothesis is that the hypothesis itself, as well as essentially all experimental modeling, is derived entirely from Mendelian conditions, i.e. familial autosomal dominant disease . Such conditions are not only exceedingly rare (total number of amyloid β protein precursor mutation kindreds in the world number less than 100, for example), but encompass lifelong defects in cellular physiology. The repeated failures in sporadic AD therapy may simply be due to the inapplicability of this small molecule construct to something as complex as age-related sporadic neurodegeneration. Indeed, an in depth analysis of clinicopathological correlations in sporadic disease reveals that the pathology of AD (and a spectrum of chronic diseases), is indicative of a response to the aging environment, possibly even a productive response, in which case targeting such a response would be ineffective at best, and deleterious at worst. This is to say nothing of the empirical problem with targeting a single small molecule within the scope of the neuronal proteome, comprised of many thousands of protein transcripts at any give time.
It may be time to embrace an aggressively holistic approach to such a disease process that is intimately intertwined with age and the simple passage of time. The many risk factors for sporadic AD, comprised for example of cerebrovascular disease, diabetes mellitus, head trauma and neuroinflammation, neuroendocrinology, and transition metals, suggest that AD is a whole organism disorder that cannot be addressed by any singular construct, least of all lesion targeting. The role of a healthy multi-nutrient diet , as both a direct (e.g. antioxidants) and indirect (e.g. reducing obesity and atherosclerosis related risk factors) means of prevention and treatment is already as effective as the most sophisticated of clinical trials to date, and probably more so. Moreover, as the hormesis concept becomes better developed, a judicious exercise program may similarly be of measurable, whole organism benefit, just as hormetic kinetics of Aβ may be operant as a potential factor in the physiology-pathology continuum . Such processes may further underlie the concept of mental “activity,” and the influence of brain usage in the form of educational attainment, as a means of defense against cognitive decline, associated with a given pathological load. At present, it appears that effective therapy for AD associated neurodegeneration is in the distant future and may well take a number of generations, as well as a paradigm shift for measurable progress to occur. Nevertheless, the benefits of something as simple as a healthy diet, mental activity, and a regular exercise program, in combating oxidative stress, neuroinflammation, and the aging process has already proven beneficial to both the quality and quantity of life. Small molecule therapy based on the amyloid cascade model has achieved neither, and unless a different paradigm is pursued, likely never will.