Satomu Morita*, Satoshi Furukawa, Akari Takaya, Ikuo Sakagushi, Hayato Okunaga, Tokiko Nakagawa, Lisa Wingenfeld and Katsuji Nishi
Department of Legal Medicine, Shiga University of Medical Science, Japan
Received date: May 01, 2013; Accepted date: May 21, 2013; Published date: May 27, 2013
Citation: Morita S, Furukawa S, Takaya A, Sakagushi I, Okunaga H, et al. (2013) Usability of Histological Assessment of Cerebellar Granule Cell Layer Regardless of Postmortem Interval. J Forensic Res 4:180. doi: 10.4172/2157-7145.1000180
Copyright: © 2013 Morita S, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Forensic Research
We often encounter many decomposed cases in the forensic science fields. Damage to organs by bacteria
complicates our diagnosis, examination and study. The central nerve system is one of the most hardly decomposed organs. The cerebellar granule cell layer (GCL) is useful for some investigation.
We histologically evaluated cerebellar GCL of decomposed and fresh cases using Photoshop™ application. No statistical difference was found between two groups. In addition, we grouped by agonal situation and histologically evaluated cerebellar GCL. We could only show the statistical difference between carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning and house fire because of shortage number of some groups, but the comparison of the box plots suggested some relations between GCL and agonal situation.
We suggest conservation of histological findings of cerebellar GCL regardless of postmortem interval and usability for detecting agonal situation.
Cerebellar granule cell layer; Decomposition; Photo shop; Agonal situation; CO poisoning
In the forensic science fields, we encounter many decomposed cases. Damage to organs by bacteria complicates diagnosis, examination and study. Decomposition by bacteria often begins colon, lung and mucous membrane of face that have bacterial flora, next widely spread to whole body in few days. The almost cardinal organs exist in cavity of chest and abdomen that are vulnerable to bacterial invasion. Central nerve system (CNS) is immersed in cerebrospinal fluid that is clearly aseptic except for meningitis cases, and there is no connection to chest and abdominal cavity. According to the report by Stan et al.  postmortem interval (PMI) range of 6 to 40 hours does not correlate with the RNA quality in brain . Therefore, we can say that CNS is one of the most hardly decomposed organs.
Cerebellar granule cell layer (CGL) is very useful for some investigations. GCL is noticed for showing unusual change after ischemia like CA1 and CA4 regions of hippocampus in the forensic science [2,3], and showing many neuronal death mechanisms especially for apoptosis in the neurology . And Stan et al. suggested the proportional connection between histological findings of cerebellar GCL and RNA quality .
We histologically evaluated GCL in decomposed cases PMI over 40h and quantified with Adobe Photoshop™. We also evaluated GCL in some cases, which were dead in different agonal situation, carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning, house fire and suicide by fire.
We chose all decomposed cases that died suddenly from 2009 through 2012; these were 12 cases (Table 1a). Moreover, more we chose fresh 12 cases that also died suddenly in 2012. The causes of death are hanging, drowning, choking, fatal acute myocardial infarction and brain contusion. It must be quite short time from outbreak to death in every case because there was no struggle appearance. We excluded murdered cases because it might not be quite short time to death. Due to bacterial damage, we could not evaluate any GCL of decomposed cases that died for brain contusion. The all autopsy of fresh cases started within 40 h after death (Table 1b).
|No.||Sex||Age||Cause of death||PMI||Percentage||Pixcel|
PMI: Postmortem Interval, AMI: Acute Myocardial Infarction, *: Estimated age
Table 1a: The list of decomposed cases.
|No.||Sex||Age||Cause of death||PMI||Percentage||Pixcel|
AMI: Acute Myocardial Infarction, H: Hours
Table1b: The list of fresh cases.
During 2012, we conducted surveys of five CO poisoning cases, three victims for house fire and two suicide cases by burning. All CO poisoning cases was suicide-using charcol, which is noticed one of the most famous suicide technique in Japan. From January to March in 2013, we treated four more CO poisoning cases. We excised brain from all the cases, and evaluated GCL.
The tissue sections of the cerebellum were obtained at autopsy. The tissue sections containing granular cell layer and dentate nucleus were fixed in 10% of formalin and embedded in paraffin within three days. The tissue sections with 3 microns were used for hematoxylin-eosin (HE) staining.
The evaluation of alteration of the granular cells was performed using Photoshop™ application. After taking photograph of the GCL stained by HE at microscopy level using Nikon H550S™ system at magnification ×400. Color of nucleuses of the granular cells was changed into gray and then the ratio of the number of pixels with gray color and other color was counted with Adobe Photoshop CS5™ (Adobe Systems™). The frequency of the remaining cells was indicated as percentage of the total number of pixel with gray color in the GCL. The area of remaining granular cells was indicated as the percentage of the GCL. When we counted number of pixels, we chose five visual fields of GCL, which looked equable and calculated average. In every case, whole pixels of one fields was 327,680 pixels (Figure 1).
Statistical analysis was performed with the R program, version 3.0.0 (the R project). To compare percentage between groups, the non-parametric Mann-Whitney U test was used. A value of p<0.05 was considered statistically significant. To compare three groups, Bonferroni correction and Holm correction were performed.
We could confirm granular cells in severe decomposed cases, and that look no obvious postmortem change in H.E. staining. For example the case, No.1251, was discovered by a fisherman, which floated in Lake Biwa, Shiga prefecture, in August that season was summer in Japan. The cause of death emerged from autopsy, drowning. We investigated blood and urine, we did not detect any drugs, but we did only caffeine, which was no relation to death. Histological appearance showed paler staining of eosin staining than fresh cases but no obvious postmortem change of form (Figure 2). We could see the pale pink of eosin staining in the GCL of many decomposed cases that was only feature we could observe.
The percentage of GCL of cerebellum of decomposed cases range 33.2% to 50.0%, and the percentage of fresh cases 35.3% to 52.4%. When we compared with these, we found no significant (p=0.1408 >0.05) (Figure 3). We also compared about age and found no significant (p=0.55635 >0.05).
The percentage of GCL showed different tendency by agonal situation, CO poisoning cases (group1), house fire cases (group2) and burning suicide cases (group3) (Table 2a). When we compared group1 and 2, we found statistical difference in spite of correction. However, we could not find statistical difference between group 2 and 3, 1 and 3 (Table 2b).
|No.||Sex||Age||Cause of death||PMI||Percentage||Pixcel||CO|
|Group 1||1240||39||M||CO; charcoal||20H||29.7||97320||93.7|
|Group 2||1231||43||F||house fire||30H||45.7||149749||79.5|
|Group 3||1214||62||F||fire; suicide||24H||46||150732||0|
PMI: Postmortem Interval, CO: Saturation of COHb, H: Hours
Table 2a: List of different agonal phase cases.
|1 × 2||0.016 *||0.048 *||0.048*|
|1 × 3||0.0446||0.1338||0.0892|
|2 × 3||0.4||1.2 **||0.4|
*: p<0.05, **: p>1.0
Table 2b: Statistical evaluation.
GCL is very useful especially for apoptosis analysis. Some mechanisms of apoptosis were found in GCL . It is noticed that global ischemia induce DNA fragmentation indicative of apoptosis of GCL . In forensic science, it is noticed that apoptosis in CA1 and CA4 regions of hippocampus with regard to the causes of death, but some special immunostaining are needed for evaluation and it is difficult and uncertain to quantify . Sheedy D et al.  Using GCL performed histological analysis of cerebellar GCL with HE staining for a marker of brain tissue integrity in 2011, we may be able to evaluate brain damage during agonal phase and easily quantify with Photoshop™ application.
Appearance of apoptosis during PMI, that was less than 24 hours, was investigated in skin, testis, thyroid, spleen and adrenal gland with Tunel staining [6,7]. In these report, apoptosis, which occurred during PMI, was not found. Though it was reported that various endogenous genes appeared in human postmortem tissues with time , gene must not be able to evolve histological change in postmortem tissues. In our analysis, no statistical difference between decomposed and fresh cases supports the hypothesis that apoptosis of cerebellar granule cells does not occur during PMI over 40 hours, neither.
We also evaluated cerebellar GCL of some cases of which agonal phase were different. In the situation of CO poisoning suicide, group 1, the concentration of CO rise up slowly. On the other hand, in the situation of house fire, group 2, the victims inhale high concentration of CO or smoke including some kinds of chemical gas and died more quickly than group 1. In group 3, suicide by fire, the fire let them die in quite short time by the temperature of itself. We determined saturation of COHb in every case. It seems no relation between the percentage of GCL and saturation of COHb.
We could only find the statistical difference of GCL percentage between group 1 and 2 that was because number of group 2 and 3 were very shortage. The comparison of the box plots suggested tendency of inverse proportion between the time to death and the percentage of GCL (Figure 4). In the future, accumulation and evaluation of many and various cases are desirable.
We could show usability of GCL regardless of postmortem interval and suggest some relations between GCL and agonal situation.