Audit of Deaths in a Pediatric Oncology Unit in Sub-Saharan Africa
Received: 15-Jan-2019 / Accepted Date: 23-Feb-2019 / Published Date: 01-Mar-2019 DOI: 10.4172/2165-7386.1000353
Introduction: There are few data on the mortality of children hospitalized for cancer in Sub-Saharan Africa. Reported death rates are usually high. This study describes the causes of death from childhood cancer.
Methods: This is an observational and descriptive study of the clinical and therapeutic characteristics of children (0-14 years) who died in the pediatric oncology unit of the University Hospital Center of Treichville in Abidjan from January 2010 to December 2015. Identified causes of death are reported.
Results: During this six year period, 249 inpatient children out of 681 died, resulting in a mortality rate of 36.5%, the median age of the deceased children was 6 years 10 months. Of the 139 who died in hospital, 131 were solid tumors and 48 were metastatic or at advanced stages in the Toronto classification. Of the 71 cases treated, 14 had received first-line palliative treatment. Treatment-related deaths accounted for 29.5% of cases and non-treatmentrelated deaths for 70.5%. The main causes of death were: tumor progression (42.5%), febrile aplasia (15.1%) and metabolic disorders (7.9%).
Conclusion: Actions promoting/ early diagnosis and treatment as well as improved supportive care will reduce mortality.
Keywords: Pediatric oncology; Death; Sub-saharan Africa
In high-income countries, about 20% of children with cancer die, and cancer is the second leading cause of death in children [1,2]. This rate remains stable, paving the way for clinical research to identify new therapeutic alternatives. The reported death rates are in the order of 80% in low-income and middle-income countries [1,3]. African publications on the mortality of children with cancer are rare [4,5]. In the pediatric oncology unit of the University Hospital of Treichville in Abidjan, the overall survival of children with cancer reported in a population of 331 cases recruited from 1995 to 2004 was 9.4% and the death rate during the study period was 39,3% . We performed an audit to identify the causes of deaths of hospitalized children and to improve patient survival in the pediatric oncology unit.
Our center is a referral oncology center with medical and surgical oncology. All services regularly treat patients on inpatient basis. Approximately 200 new pediatric cancer patients are seen annually and common cancers are lymphomas, leukemia, retinoblastoma and Wilms tumor.
This observational and descriptive study concerned children aged 0 to 14 years diagnosed with cancer (treated or non-treated with specific treatment) and having died in the oncology unit of the pediatric ward of the University Hospital of Treichville from January 1, 2010 to December 31, 2015. This unit is member of the GFAOP network. The collection of information for each death was based on data from the hospital register and the patient's medical file.
Cancer stages were established using Toronto guidelines . Sociodemographic, clinical and therapeutic variables, delays (diagnosis, treatment) and causes of death were analyzed. The diagnostic delay was the time elapsed between the first symptoms and the diagnosis. The treatment delay was the time taken to initiate treatment after diagnosis. Deaths occurring within 90 days of anticancer therapy without tumor progression were considered as treatment-related mortality. Status of cancer at the time of death was recorded for all deaths.
Controlled cancer in solid tumors was defined as clinical and radiological absence of disease for at least 1 month; for hematological malignancies, besides clinical and radiological response, hematological response was also considered to document the same. Non-responders and partial responders were grouped into uncontrolled malignancies. The cause of death was determined from the source documents, and the immediate cause mentioned was taken into account for the analysis. The cause of death, when not mentioned, was deduced from the clinical and paraclinical data of the last two weeks of life.
Statistical analysis was performed using the SPSS 15.0 software (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA), and included a description of the demographic and clinical parameters. The confidentiality rules of the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC 2004/03) were applied. This work was done with the agreement of the scientific director of the hospital.
Six hundred and eighty-one patients were admitted during the study period, including 249 deaths, resulting in a mortality rate of 36.5%. This study included 139 files, 126 files had a diagnosis at the time of death.
Thirteen patients with clinical and radiological signs of cancer died before performing the histological examination. The basic characteristics of the study population are presented in Table 1.
|Median||6 years and 10 months|
|Extremes||(3 months-14 years and 4 months)|
|Type of malignancies||139|
|Solids tumors||131 (94.2)|
|Extremes||(15 days-720 days)|
Table1: Baseline characteristics of the 139 cases.
The median age of the children who died was 6 years 10 months and the sex ratio was 1.6. The majority of deaths were in the 5-9 year age group (60=43.2%).
Metastatic or advanced-stage patients at diagnosis accounted for 38.1% of causes, and those with regional extension for 9.5% of cases (Table 2).
|Main cancers||N (%)||Stages at death according to the Toronto classification (n)|
|Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma||70 (55.5)||Limited 46|
|Retinoblastoma||17 (13.5)||Localized 1|
|Acute Leukemia||8 (6.4)||CNS-4|
|CNS + 1|
|Sarcoma||10 (7.9)||Localized 3|
|Wilms Tumor||7 (5.5)||Localized 4|
|Neuroblastoma||6 (4.8)||Locoregional 1|
|Germ cell tumors||3 (2.4)||Metastatic 3|
|Hodgkin's Lymphoma||2 (1.6)||3A 1|
|Others1||3 (2,4)||Localized 1|
|Total||126 (100)||Localized/Limited/3A/CNS: 60 (47.6%)|
|Regional/Locoregional: 12 (9.5%)|
|Metastatic/Advanced/4A/CNS +: 48 (38.1%)|
|Unknown: 6 (4.8%)|
Note: 1. Glioma (1), hepatoblastoma (1), melanoma (1)
Table 2: Distribution of cancers and stratification (n=126).
Thirty-seven out of the 46 stage-limited lymphomas in the Toronto classification were diffuse abdominal forms. Several deaths occurred before or in less than 30 days after initiation of treatment (98 cases).
Sixty-eight deaths occurred in patients not treated. Of these, 13 died before performing the histological examination, 19 during nutritional rehabilitation and treatment of associated infections.
Twelve children had died just before the initiation of cancer treatment. Seventeen patients waiting for a blood transfusion died in an acute anemia chart. The circumstances of death were not specific for the remaining eight cases.
The number of children treated was 71 (Table 3).
|Treatment of Patients||139|
|Treated patients||71 (51)|
|Untreated patients||68 (49)|
|For patients treated||71|
|Intent of therapy|
|Extreme||1 Day-130 Days|
|Deaths during the first 30 days of chemotherapy|
|Time of onset of deaths compared with the start of chemotherapy|
|Extreme||1 day-600 days|
|Status of patient at death|
|Controlled disease||08 (11.3%)|
|Uncontrolled disease||63 (88.7%)|
Table 3: Therapeutic characteristics of treated patients.
The average time to death from admission was 78 days and the median was 28 days (range: 1 day to 630 days). For patients who received treatment for curative purposes, the rhythm of administration of chemotherapy was irregular in 41 cases out of 57, with an average delay of 11 days during the inter-cure period (range: 3 days-51 days) and a median 7 days. The status of malignancy was controlled in 8/139 (5.7%) including 1 case of leukemia and 7 solid tumors. The one case of leukemia in complete remission died of severe anemia following a digestive hemorrhage.
Of 139 deaths, 41 (29.5%) occurred within 90 days of anticancer treatment of which 38 occurred after chemotherapy. Non-treatmentrelated deaths accounted for 70.5% (98 deaths).The main causes of death identified were tumor progression (42, 5%), febrile aplasia (15,1%) and metabolic disorders (7,9%) (Table 4).
|Causes of death||Lymphomas||Neuroblastoma||Wilms tumor||Retinoblastoma||Acute Leukemia||Sarcomas||Others*||Undiagnosed cancers||Total|
|Organ failure 1||3||4.2||-||-||-||1||12.5||1||10||1||14.3||-||6||4.3|
|Metabolic disorders 2||10||13.9||-||-||-||-||-||1||14.3||-||11||7.9|
|No treatment-related death||38||52.8||4||66.7||6||100||16||94.1||5||62.5||9||90||7||100||13||100||98||70.5|
Note: * Gliomas (1), teratoma (1), germ cell tumor (3), hepatoblastoma (1), melanoma (1); 1. Acute renal failure (4), hepatic failure (1), respiratory failure (1); 2. Tumorlysis syndrome (6), dehydration (3), hypoglycemia (2)
Table 4: Distribution of causes of death with various malignancies.
Gateways identified for febrile aplasia and non-neutropenic sepsis were pulmonary (5 cases) and gastrointestinal (7 cases).
This study revealed high death rate and high proportion of nontreatment related deaths. Cancers have a poor prognosis in Sub- Saharan Africa. Death rates in children in hospitals range from 39% to 59%, compared to populations of 690 and 88 cases respectively [5,8,9]. Most of the published studies on cancer mortality in middle and highincome countries are from clinical trials, or focus on specific cancer mortality rather than inpatient mortality as a useful epidemiological parameter . Marwaha, et al. reported a 24% mortality rate in a population of 532 children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia in a center in northern India .
Tsurusawa, et al. in Japan found 6 deaths among 321 children treated for non-Hodgkin's B lymphoma .
Delayed diagnosis and advanced stages may justify high mortality rates in Sub-Saharan Africa. Indeed Weaver et al showed that in Kenya, where the average diagnostic delay was 6.8 months, retinoblastoma mortality was 73%, more than 50 times higher than the reported death rate in Canada . Approximately 50-75% of children diagnosed with retinoblastoma in Africa die because of advanced stages, compared to less than 5% of deaths in developed countries where the diagnosis is early and the access to a competent team rapid . The median time to diagnosis was 90 days, and 38.1% of the patients were metastatic at diagnosis in this study. Eke and Akani found a median consultation time of 8 weeks and 60% of metastatic patients . 71.4% of children were metastatic at diagnosis in the Brown et al. study in the Department of Pediatrics, University College Hospital, and Ibadan, Nigeria .
Treatment-related deaths accounted for 29.5% and non-treatmentrelated for 70.5% including 42.5% due to tumor progression in this study. Concurrently O'Brien, et al. found 77% of non-treatment-related deaths, 57% of which were due to tumor progression . In contrast, Prakash, in India found 71% of treatment-related deaths and 25% of deaths due to tumor progression . These differences could be explained by different practices of patient care and registration of deaths, but also by the definition of death patterns used in the above studies. While tumor progression is the leading cause of death in our study, the high probability of underestimation of this cause must be emphasized. The causes identified were those mentioned in the medical file, but there was a similarity between the clinical elements considered as a tumor progression and the clinical presentations of the other non-treatment causes in several deaths. In another study conducted on a pediatric population, Brown, et al. found 27% of treatment-related deaths, and infections accounted for the leading cause of death with 39.6% .
Childhood studies of chemotherapy-related deaths in leukemia clinical trials in high-income countries yielded death rates ranging from 3% to 51%, and infections were the dominant causes ranging from 33% to 73% [15-19].
The weaknesses of this audit are that 44% of the deaths were not included in the study because they lacked sufficient information to be attributed to treatment-related deaths or not and to cause, most of which occurred at home. However, this work is a contribution to the study of childhood cancer mortality in Sub-Saharan Africa.
This study has made it possible to establish the mortality profile of childhood cancers in our department. Most deaths are due to cancer. Actions promoting early diagnosis and rapid access to treatment will reduce the mortality rate.
- Kellie SJ, Howard SC (2008) Global Child Health Priorities: What Role for Paediatric Oncologists? Eur J Cancer 44: 2388-2396.
- Desandes E, Clavel J, Berger C, Bernard JL, Blouin P, et al. (2004) Cancer Incidence among Children in France, 1990-1999. Pediatr Blood Cancer 43: 749-757.
- Smith MA, Altekruse SF, Adamson PC, Reaman GH, Seibel NL (2014) Declining Childhood and Adolescent Cancer Mortality. Cancer 120: 2497-2506.
- Brown BJ, Bamgboye EA, Sodeinde O (2008) Early Deaths and other Challenges to Childhood Cancer Survival in Ibadan, Nigeria. Cent Afr J Med 54: 32-39.
- Brown BJ, Bamgboye EA, Sodeinde O (2008) Causes of Death in Childhood Cancer at the Department Of Paediatrics, University College Hospital, Ibadan. Afr J Med Med Sci 37: 7-13.
- Yao JJ, Couitchere L, Atimere Y, D Kone, Stefan DC, et al. (2012) Childhood Cancer in Côte d'Ivoire, 1995 - 2004: Challenges and Hopes. S Afr Med J 103: 113-115.
- Gupta S, Aitken JF, Bartels U, Brierly J, Dolendo M, et al. (2016) Paediatric Cancer Stage in Population-Based Cancer Registries: The Toronto Consensus Principles nd Guidelines. Lancet Oncol 17: e168-172.
- Togo B, Traore F, Togo AP, Togo P, Diakite AA, et al. (2014) Epidemiology and Prognosis of Childhood Cancers at Gabriel-Touré Teaching Hospital (Bamako, Mali). Med Sante Trop 24: 73-77.
- Eke GK, Akani NA (2016) Outcome of Childhood Malignancies at the University of Port Harcourt Teaching Hospital : A Call for Implementation of Palliative Care. Afr Health Sci 16: 75-82.
- Prakash G, Bakhshi S, Raina V, Bhatnagar S, Sharma A, et al. (2010) Characteristics and Pattern of Mortality in Cancer Patients at a Tertiary Care Oncology Center : Report of 259 Cases. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev 11: 1755-1759.
- Marwaha RK, Kulkarni KP, Bansal D, Trehan A (2010) Pattern of Mortality in Childhood Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia: Experience from a Single Center in Northern India. J Pediatr Hematol Oncol 32: 366-369.
- Tsurusawa M, Mori T, Kikuchi A, Mitsui T, Sunami S, et al. (2014) Improved Treatment Results of Children with B-Cell Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma: A Report from the Japanese Pediatric Leukemia/Lymphoma Study Group B-NHL03 Study. Pediatr Blood Cancer 61: 1215-1221.
- Weaver MS, Heminger CL, Lam CG (2014) Integrating Stages of Change Models to Cast New Vision on Interventions to Improve Global Retinoblastoma and Childhood Cancer Outcomes. BMC Public Health 14: 944.
- O'Brien ME, Borthwick A, Rigg A, Leary A, Last K, et al. (2006) Mortality within 30 Days of Chemotherapy: A Clinical Governance Benchmarking Issue for Oncology Patients. Br J Cancer 95: 1632-1636.
- Alexander S, Pole JD, Gibson P, Lee M, Hesser T, et al. (2015) Classification of Treatment-Related Mortality in Children with Cancer: A Systematic Assessment. Lancet Oncol 16: e604-610.
- Christensen MS, Heyman M, Möttönen M, Zellar B, Jonmundsson G, et al. (2005) Treatment-Related Death in Childhood Acute Lymphoblastic Leukaemia in the Nordic Countries: 1992-2001. Br J Haematol 131: 50-58.
- Oskarsson T, Söderhäll S, Arvidson J, Forestier E, Frandsen TL, et al. (2017) Treatment-Related Mortality in Relapsed Childhood Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia. Pediatr Blood Cancer 65(4).
- Gupta S, Bonilla M, Valverde P, Fu L, Howard SC, et al. (2012) Treatment-Related Mortality in Children with Acute Myeloid Leukaemia in Central America: Incidence, Timing and Predictors. Eur J Cancer 48: 1363-1369.
- Gupta S, Bonilla M, Fuentes SL, Caniza M, Howard SC, et al. (2009) Incidence and Predictors of Treatment-Related Mortality in Paediatric Acute Leukaemia in El Salvador. Br J Cancer 100: 1026-1031.
Citation: Couitchere LGS, Kouakou EKV, Ouattara J, Egesi M, Zaho L, et al. (2019) Audit of Deaths in a Pediatric Oncology Unit in Sub-Saharan Africa. J Palliat Care Med 1:354. DOI: 10.4172/2165-7386.1000353
Copyright: © 2019 Couitchere LGS, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language
Share This Article
Open Access Journals
- Total views: 1625
- [From(publication date): 0-0 - Jun 25, 2022]
- Breakdown by view type
- HTML page views: 1164
- PDF downloads: 461