Global Journal of Nursing & Forensic Studies
Open Access

Nursing ethics; Legal challenges; Artificial Intelligence in nursing; Professional liability; Informed consent; Patient confidentiality; Electronic Health Records; Disaster nursing; Advanced Practice Registered Nurses; Forensic nursing

Introduction

The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into clinical nursing practice introduces various ethical and legal challenges that demand careful consideration. Nurses need to deeply understand the implications of AI on patient safety, data privacy, the nuances of informed consent, and their professional accountability as these technologies become increasingly embedded in healthcare settings. Establishing clear guidelines and ensuring continuous education for practitioners are essential steps to ensure AI is utilized both ethically and legally, thereby protecting both the patients receiving care and the nurses providing it [1].

Nurses in Greece have shared their perceptions regarding professional liability, revealing specific areas of vulnerability. These include medication errors, critical omissions in documentation, and failing to adhere to established protocols. The findings highlight a clear need for improved legal education, the development of clearer professional standards, and the implementation of supportive organizational structures. These measures would empower nurses to better navigate complex care environments and mitigate the risks of litigation [2].

The implications of Advanced Practice Registered Nurse (APRN) prescriptive authority on both practice and policy warrant thorough examination. Expanding prescriptive rights for APRNs can significantly enhance patient access to care, particularly in regions that are underserved. However, this expansion also critically necessitates clear regulatory frameworks and robust interprofessional collaboration to ensure safe and effective advanced nursing practice. Understanding these intricate legal and policy dimensions is foundational for successful implementation [3].

Ethical and legal dilemmas frequently arise for nurses working in acute care settings. Common challenges encompass complex end-of-life decisions, difficult resource allocation choices, and the crucial task of maintaining patient autonomy. Observations suggest that nurses often confront these situations without adequate legal and ethical guidance. This underscores a significant need for enhanced training and readily accessible institutional support to help them effectively manage these profound challenges [4].

Electronic Health Records (EHRs) bring substantial legal implications for nurses, particularly illustrated by the context in Kenya. The emphasis is on maintaining proper documentation, ensuring robust data security, and upholding patient confidentiality within these digital systems. What this really means is that as healthcare systems digitize, nurses must not only acquire proficiency in technological skills but also deeply comprehend the complete legal framework surrounding EHRs. This understanding is vital for preventing potential liabilities and guaranteeing secure management of patient data [5].

Nursing practice during disaster scenarios involves distinct legal, ethical, and policy implications. Nurses, frequently on the front lines, face unique pressures such as severe resource scarcity, the necessity of altering standards of care, and making rapid decisions under extreme duress. Grasping the legal protections and inherent limitations within disaster settings is paramount. This knowledge enables nurses to provide effective care while concurrently safeguarding their professional standing [6].

Informed consent remains a cornerstone of patient care, and research explores nurses' knowledge and experiences with it in clinical practice. While nurses often play a central role in the consent process, their grasp of its legal intricacies and their precise responsibilities can vary significantly. What this truly means is that consistent education and clear institutional policies are indispensable. These are crucial for empowering nurses to expertly facilitate informed consent, thereby protecting patients' rights and ensuring all legal requirements are comprehensively met [7].

Patient confidentiality holds immense legal and ethical weight, a subject investigated through nurses' perceptions in Saudi Arabia. This area highlights the critical importance of safeguarding patient information, especially considering unique cultural factors influencing privacy. The findings generally suggest that nurses understand their obligations regarding confidentiality. However, continuous reinforcement and targeted education on specific legal frameworks for data protection are necessary to maintain patient trust and ensure full compliance with regulatory standards [8].

Forensic nursing represents a specialized field, and a scoping review provides insight into its diverse practice areas and the unique challenges forensic nurses encounter. These nurses serve as a crucial link between healthcare and the legal system, undertaking vital evidence collection and interpretation in cases involving trauma, violence, and abuse. This demanding role mandates a profound understanding of legal procedures, complex ethical considerations, and highly specialized clinical skills [9].

Clinical Ethics Committees (CECs) play a significant role within the nursing environment, as highlighted by qualitative research. These committees provide valuable resources for nurses who are navigating complex ethical dilemmas, offering essential guidance, education, and unwavering support. The insights gained from this research indicate that robust CECs can significantly assist nurses in ensuring their practice adheres to both established ethical principles and legal requirements, thereby cultivating a strong culture of ethical awareness and patient-centered decision-making [10].

Description

The modern nursing landscape is continuously evolving, bringing forth a range of ethical and legal complexities that demand constant attention from practitioners. A critical area of development involves the integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into clinical practice. Nurses must therefore deeply understand the ethical and legal implications of AI, focusing on patient safety, data privacy, informed consent, and their own professional accountability. Establishing clear guidelines and ensuring ongoing education are vital for the ethical and legal use of AI, safeguarding both patients and the nursing profession [1]. Furthermore, professional liability is a pervasive concern, as evidenced by studies examining nurses’ perceptions in Greece. Key vulnerabilities identified include medication errors, oversights in documentation, and non-adherence to established protocols. These findings underscore the imperative for improved legal education, robust professional standards, and supportive organizational structures to help nurses navigate intricate care environments and mitigate litigation risks [2].

The scope of nursing practice is also expanding, exemplified by Advanced Practice Registered Nurse (APRN) prescriptive authority. This expansion holds significant potential to improve patient access to care, particularly in underserved communities. However, the successful implementation of such authority hinges on the establishment of clear regulatory frameworks and effective interprofessional collaboration. A thorough understanding of these legal and policy dimensions is paramount for ensuring safe and effective advanced nursing practice [3]. Beyond prescriptive authority, nurses in acute care settings frequently encounter profound ethical and legal dilemmas. These often involve challenging end-of-life decisions, the difficult allocation of scarce resources, and the fundamental responsibility of upholding patient autonomy. The reality is that nurses often face these complex situations without sufficient legal or ethical guidance, signaling a pronounced need for enhanced training and accessible institutional support to effectively manage such challenges [4].

The legal, ethical, and policy implications for nursing during disaster scenarios also highlight unique pressures. Nurses on the front lines confront resource scarcity, altered standards of care, and the need for rapid decision-making under extreme stress. Understanding legal protections and limitations in these scenarios is critical for providing effective care while preserving their professional standing [6].

The digitalization of healthcare introduces another layer of legal considerations, particularly concerning Electronic Health Records (EHRs). Studies, such as one focusing on Kenya, emphasize the importance of meticulous documentation, stringent data security, and unwavering patient confidentiality within digital systems. This means nurses must not only become adept with new technologies but also fully grasp the legal framework governing EHRs to prevent potential liabilities and ensure secure patient data management [5]. Central to patient rights is informed consent, where nurses often play a pivotal role. Research indicates that while nurses are frequently at the heart of this process, their understanding of its legal nuances and their precise responsibilities can vary. Consequently, consistent education and clear institutional policies are essential to empower nurses to effectively facilitate informed consent, ensuring patient rights are protected and legal requirements are met [7]. Relatedly, patient confidentiality carries significant legal and ethical weight. Research in Saudi Arabia, for example, highlights the critical importance of safeguarding patient information, acknowledging the unique cultural considerations surrounding privacy. While nurses generally understand their obligations, continuous reinforcement and specific education on data protection legal frameworks are necessary to uphold patient trust and ensure regulatory compliance [8].

Finally, specialized fields like forensic nursing bridge the gap between healthcare and the legal system. A scoping review on forensic nursing illustrates its diverse practice areas and the unique challenges these nurses face. They provide crucial evidence collection and interpretation in cases of trauma, violence, and abuse, a role demanding a deep understanding of legal procedures, ethical considerations, and specialized clinical skills [9]. Additionally, Clinical Ethics Committees (CECs) serve as invaluable resources within the nursing setting. Qualitative studies reveal that CECs offer guidance, education, and support for nurses navigating complex ethical dilemmas. Strong CECs assist nurses in ensuring their practice aligns with both ethical principles and legal mandates, fostering a culture of ethical awareness and patient-centered decision-making [10]. This comprehensive overview underscores the dynamic and multifaceted legal and ethical responsibilities inherent in nursing practice, emphasizing the continuous need for education, clear policies, and supportive frameworks.

Conclusion

Nurses consistently navigate complex ethical and legal landscapes in their daily practice. Integrating Artificial Intelligence (AI) presents new challenges, requiring nurses to understand patient safety, data privacy, informed consent, and professional accountability. This calls for clear guidelines and continuous education. Professional liability is a significant concern, with medication errors, documentation gaps, and protocol non-adherence being common vulnerabilities. Better legal education and organizational support are crucial to minimize litigation risks. The expanded prescriptive authority of Advanced Practice Registered Nurses (APRNs) can enhance patient access, particularly in underserved areas, but demands clear regulatory frameworks and interprofessional collaboration. In acute care, nurses face dilemmas like end-of-life decisions and resource allocation, often without adequate legal and ethical guidance, signaling a need for enhanced training. The rise of Electronic Health Records (EHRs) necessitates that nurses master data security and confidentiality within digital systems to avoid liabilities. During disasters, nurses confront unique pressures, including resource scarcity and altered standards of care, making legal protections essential for their professional standing. Ensuring proper informed consent and maintaining patient confidentiality, especially with cultural considerations, requires consistent education and robust policies. Forensic nursing bridges healthcare and the legal system, demanding specialized skills in evidence collection for cases of trauma and abuse. Clinical Ethics Committees (CECs) offer vital support, helping nurses align practice with ethical principles and legal requirements. Overall, the field emphasizes ongoing education, clear policies, and strong support systems to equip nurses for their multifaceted legal and ethical responsibilities.

References

1. Yung-Chia C, Yao-Hung L, Pei-Chin H (2024) Nurses' ethical and legal challenges when using artificial intelligence in clinical practice: A scoping review.J Clin Nurs 33:e671-e685.

   Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

2. Dimitrios KZ, Eleni K, Ioannis K (2023) Professional Liability in Nursing: A Qualitative Study on the Perceptions of Nurses in Greece.Int J Environ Res Public Health 20:2147.

   Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

3. Lusine P, Janet JN, Brittany K (2021) Advanced practice registered nurse prescriptive authority: Implications for practice and policy.Nurs Outlook 69:1058-1067.

   Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

4. Fahad A, Naif A, Abdulrahman A (2022) Ethical and legal issues in nursing: The views of nurses in an acute care setting.J Multidiscip Healthc 15:2419-2428.

   Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

5. Prisca NM, Mercy EN, Naomi AO (2020) Legal implications for nurses in relation to electronic health records in Kenya.Pan Afr Med J 37:137.

   Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

6. Deborah B, Denise MT, Andrea RJ (2020) Legal, ethical, and policy implications for nursing practice in a disaster.J Emerg Nurs 46:772-777.

   Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

7. Mashael AA, Khaled AA, Abdullah NA (2023) Nurses' knowledge and experiences of informed consent in clinical practice.J Patient Saf 19:e278-e284.

   Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

8. Mansour A, Laila A, Hamad A (2020) Perceptions of nurses regarding the legal and ethical aspects of confidentiality in Saudi Arabia.J Clin Nurs 29:3357-3363.

   Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

9. Maureen L, Diego DL, Denise K (2020) Forensic Nursing: A Scoping Review of the Literature.J Forensic Nurs 16:187-195.

   Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

10. Marit HK, Kristin H, Jorunn H (2019) The role of clinical ethics committees in the nursing setting: A qualitative study.Nurs Ethics 26:1493-1506.

    Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref