Benign Mucosal Fold Lesion as a Cause of Hoarseness of Voice - A Clinical Study
Received Date: Aug 04, 2012 / Accepted Date: Aug 22, 2012 / Published Date: Aug 26, 2012
Hoarseness of voice is a common disorder seen in day to day practice of Otorhinolaryngologist. Although,
occasionally it can be a symptom of underlying malignancy, there are a variety of benign lesions causing the same. We analyzed a total number of 100 patients with history of hoarseness of voice for at least six months in whom the cause of hoarseness was the presence of a benign vocal fold lesion. Malignancies, vocal cord paralysis and Neurological lesions were excluded from the study. We found that vocal nodules were the commonest benign mucosal vocal fold lesion, (37% patients); followed by vocal polyps in 26%, LPR 23%, Reinke’s edema in 4%, intracordal cyst in 4%, contact ulcer in 3%, saccular cyst in 2% and papillomatosis in 1% of the patients.
Hoarseness is a vague term that patients often use to describe a change in voice quality ranging from voice hoarseness to voice weakness. However the term can reflect abnormalities anywhere along the vocal tract from the oral cavity to lungs. Ideally the term “Hoarseness” refers to laryngeal dysfunction caused by abnormal vocal cord vibration . Bernoulli’s principle explains that when air passes from one large space to another i.e. from lungs to Pharynx, a vibratory pattern is developed at the vocal cords and the resultant sound produced is appreciated as voice . When the regularity of vibratory pattern is lost, i.e. becomes random, the resulting vocal sound is heard as a hoarse. There are a variety of causative factors leading to hoarseness of voice which include acute or chronic infections, benign mucosal fold disorders, systemic diseases, gastro esophageal reflux disorders, malignancies etc.
Benign mucosal fold disorders are common. More than 50% patients with voice complaints have a benign mucosal disorder . Brodnitz  reported 45% of nodules, polyps or polypoidal thickenings where as Kleinsasser  reported that more than 50% of 2618 patients had one of these benign entitles. Benign mucosal fold lesions like vocal nodules, polyps, intracordal cysts, contact ulcers etc., seem to be caused primarily by vibratory trauma (excessive voice use). An expressive talkative personality correlates most consistently with most of these disorders. Cigarette smoking, infections, allergy and acid reflux increases the mucosa’s vulnerability to vibratory trauma leading to injury . The anatomy most relevant to benign vocal fold mucosal disorders is the micro-architecture of the vocal folds. Starting medially towards lateral direction, the membranous vocal fold is made up of squamous epithelium, Reinke’s potential space, the vocal ligament and the thyroarytenoid muscle. Perichondrium and thyroid cartilage provide the lateral boundary of the vocal fold.
Materials and Methods
The present prospective study was conducted in the ENT Department of SKIMS Medical College, Bemina, Srinagar. The patients with the history of hoarseness of voice as a predominant symptom or associated a symptoms of other complainants like cough, pain, foreign body sensation, dryness of throat etc. were taken up for the study. The patients with Hoarseness of voice for at least six months were included in the study. The patients with acute infections, carcinomas, vocal cord palsy or other neurological diseases were excluded from the study. A detailed history of general physical examination, routine investigations and indirect laryngoscopy were done and findings recorded. Fiber optic laryngoscopy was done in patient with difficult indirect larynogoscopy because of one or other reasons. All the patients with structural lesions were subjected to microlaryngeal surgery and specimen were sent for histopathological examinations.
The males comprised 61% of patients in the study and the commonest age group involved was 30-40 years. The average duration of the symptoms was 11 months. The history of vocal abuse or excessive use of voice was seen in 45% patients, 47 patients were smokers and 7% were alcoholics. The Hoarseness of voice was a predominant symptom in 73% patients followed by cough in 20% foreign body sensation in 19%, heart burn in 17%, frequent attempts at clearing the throat in 13% and low grade pain in 9% patients. The structural anomalies found are listed in Table 1. The vocal nodules were the commonest lesion seen and were present in 37% patients. Vocal polyps, laryngopharyngeal reflux, Reinkes odema, intra-cordal cysts, contact ulcer, saccular cyst and papillomatosis were found respectively in 26%, 23%, 4%, 4%, 3%, 2% and 1% patients. The sex distribution of individual lesions is also listed in Table 1. The lesions were on right side in 44% and on left side in 37% patients where as patients the lesions were bilateral.
Table 1: Showing male preponderence in our study.
The site of lesion was divided into anterior, middle and posterior one thirds. In 47% patient’s involvement was in anterior one third areas. The middle one third and posterior one third areas was the site of lesion in 11% and 22% patients respectively. In 20% patients, area of involvement was either diffusing or more than one area was involved as illustrated in the Table 1.
Hoarseness of voice is a common ailment for which consultation of and Otorhinolaryngologist is sought. It may be intital or only symptom of an underlying malignancy and thus merits at detailed ENT examination. However a variety of benign lesions also cause Hoarseness of voice and are sources of concern and worry as it can affect the self esteem of a person, besides it can be a cause of job threat to professionals like singers, teachers and preachers. However a proper diagnosis and management can be rewarding in most of these benign lesions.
In the present study the commonest pathology was the presence of vocal nodules in 37% patients. Vocal nodules are defined as bilateral symmetrical epithelial nodular swelling of interior middle third of true vocal folds. Mahesh Chandra et al.  reported an incidence of 28.57% of vocal nodules in their study.
Vocal polyps were seen in 26% patients and in all cases were unilateral. Vocal polyps are pedunculated masses encountered on true vocal cords. They are more common in males, often intense intermittent voice abuse, history of aspirin or anticoagulant use or other vocal trauma such as endotracheal intubation  (Table 2). Kotby et al.  in a series of 19 patients with polyps had a male percentage of 84%. In our study, out of 26 patients with polyps 18 (69.23%) patients were males, in other studies in literature the incidence of the incidence of vocal polyps varies from 68.3 to 16% [9,10].
|Age-group(commonly affected)||30-40 years|
Table 2: Showing the most common age- group among selected cases.
In the present study, 23% patients were diagnosed as having features of laryngo pharyngeal reflux and the same was labeled as the cause for Hoarseness of voice. The patients were diagnosed as being suffering from LPR if they were having associated symptoms like excessive cough especially at night, frequent attempts at clearing throat, difficulty in swallowing food or liquids, sensation of something sticking in throat or lump in throat and presence of heart burn, chest pain or indigestion. Besides this positive history, the patients on examination were having some or all of the findings like vocal cord odema, subglotic odema, ventricular obliteration esthema/Hyperemia, diffuse laryngeal odema, posterior commissure hypertrophy and granuloma or granulomatous lesions etc. (Table 6).
|Site of lesion||Percentage (%) (of cases)|
|Anterior 1/3 of vocal cord||47%|
|Middle 1/3 of vocal cord||11 %|
|Posterior 1/3 of Vocal cord||22%|
Table 6: Showing percentage of cases with respect to site of lesion of vocal cord.
It is currently estimated that 4-10% of patients evaluated by otolaryngologist have reflux related disease and that patients who have oesophagitis are twice as likely to have laryngitis as those who do not have . The symptoms are most likely to be the result of intermittent nocturnal gastroesophageal reflux and contact of upper airway structures with refluxate. Classical symptoms of GERD are present in fewer than half of the patients with GERD induced Otolarynologic manifestations [12,13]. In the present study Hoarseness of voice, chronic cough and foreign body sensation both were the commonest presenting symptoms of LPR group Harding and Richter  estimated the prevalence of GERD associated cough and found it in the range of 10-40%, depending on whether symptoms or pH monitoring was used as diagnostic criterion for GERD (Table 7).
|Lesion||Males (Total No. 61)||Female (Total No. 39)||Total No. 100|
|No. of Patients||%||No. of Patients||%||No. of Patients||%|
Table 7: Shows various vocal cord lesions observed (in our study) with percentage of male/female cases in each lesion.
In the present study Reinke’s edema was seen in 4% patients. Reinke’s edema or polpoidal cordites are terms that refer to proliferation or redundancy of superficial lamina propria (Reinke’s space). It is often seen in patients who have chronic irritant exposure such as tobacco smoke, LPR and sometimes occupational exposures . In our study, all four patients were smokers. In the present study intracordal cysts were seen in 4% patients. These cysts are sub epidermal epithelial lined sacs located within laminar propria and may be mucus retention or epidermoid in origin . The history of a patient with a vocal cyst is similar to those of patients who have nodules or polyps but with a less vocal limitation than expected from its size (Table 3). Shohet et al. compared stroboscopic findings between cysts and polyps and determination that mucosal wave was the most important parameter in differentiating such cysts from polyps . They found the mucosal wave to be diminished or absent in 100% of vocal fold cysts and the wave to be present in 80% polyps.
|Positive history||Number of cases|
|History of vocal abuse||45%|
|History of Smoking||47%|
|History of alcoholism||7%|
Table 3: Showing Cases with Past History.
In the present study contact ulcers were seen in 3% patients. Contact ulcer is made up of thickened epithelium with a central indentation. These are appreciated as saucer like lesions on the medial edge of vocal cords. These can be bilateral and symmetrical often with a small projection of one cord which fits the saucer of other side  (Table 5).
Table 5: Showing the side involvement with percentage of cases.
In the present study one patient aged 3 years had laryngeal papillomatosis . Respiratory papillomatosis is an infection caused by human papillomavirus (HPL) which is also known to more commonly cause of cervical, vaginal, penile and anal warts. Although it is relatively uncommon in larynx, it is still considered to be one of the commonest laryngeal neoplasms [7,15]. In the present study, in 2% patients, Hoarseness of voice was due to huge secular cysts encroaching corresponding mucosal folds (Table 4). Largngeal cysts and largngoceles are actually disorders of saccule and were included in the present study because of big enough size to have impact on vocal folds.
|Predominant symptom||Percentage of cases|
|Foreign body sensation||19%|
|Low grade pain||9%|
Table 4: Showing cases with predominant symptomatology.
- Thomas Carroll, Mona Abaza (2005) The Hoarseness patient, in ENT secerts. (3rdedn) 179.
- Maran AGD (1982) voice problems, in logan turners disease of ENT. Laryngol 372.
- Robert W. Bastian (2005) Benign vocal fold mucosal disorders. Cummings Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery (4thedn) 3: 2150.
- Brodnitz FS (1963) Goals, results and limitations of vocal rehabilation. Arch otolaryngol 77: 148-156.
- Kleinsasser O (1982) Pathogenesis of vocal cord polyps. An Otol Rhinol Laryngol 91: 378-381.
- Mahesh Chandra, Panduranga KM, kiran B, Ranjith P, Ravi Babu P (2012) Benign lesions of larynx-A Clinical study. Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 57: 35-38.
- Altman KW (2007) Vocal fold masses. Otolaryngol Clin North Am 40: 1091-1108.
- Kotby MN, Nassar AM, Seif EI, Helal EH, Saleh MM (1988) Ultrastructural features of vocal fold nodules and polyps. Acta Otolaryngol 105: 477-482.
- Kambic V, Radsel Z, Zarqi M, Acko M (1981) Vocal cord polyps: incidence, histology and pathogenesis. J Laryngol Otol 95: 609-618.
- Chopra H, kapoor M (1997) Study of benign glottic lesions undergoing microlaryngeal surgery. Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 49: 276-279.
- Ormseth EJ, Wong RK (1999) Reflux laryngitis: Pathophysiology, diagnosis, and management. Am J Gastroentrol 94: 2812-2817.
- Gupta R, Sataloff RT (2009) Laryngopharyngeal reflux: current concepts and questions. Curr Opin Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 17: 143-148.
- Barry DW, Vaezi MF (2010) Laryngopharyngeal reflux: More questions than answers. Cleve clin J Med 77: 327-334.
- Harding SM, Richter JE (1997) The role of gastroesophageal reflux in chronic cough and asthama. Chest 111: 1389-1402.
- Shohet JA, Courey MS, Scott MA, Ossoff RH (1996) Value of videostroboscopic parameters in differentiating true vocal fold cysts from polyps. Laryngoscope 106: 19-26.
- Paul van dem Brock (2010) Acute and chronic laryngitis. In: Scott-Brownâ€™s Otolaryngology. (6thedn), 5/5/10.
- Ndiaye Malick, Ndiaye Issa Cheikh, Itiere Odzili F Arnaud, Tall Abdourahnane, Diallo Bay Karim (2008) Laryngeal papillomatosis in children. ORL; 94: 379-381.
Citation: Wani AA, Rehman A, Hamid S, Akhter M, Baseena S (2012) Benign Mucosal Fold Lesion as a Cause of Hoarseness of Voice - A Clinical Study. Otolaryngology 2:120. Doi: 10.4172/2161-119X.1000120
Copyright: © 201 2 Wani AA, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language
Share This Article
- Total views: 13430
- [From(publication date): 8-2012 - May 30, 2020]
- Breakdown by view type
- HTML page views: 9557
- PDF downloads: 3873