GET THE APP
Received date December 30, 2013; Accepted date January 05, 2014; Published date January 10, 2014
Citation: Silbermann M, Jaloudi MA (2014) Setting a Higher Standard in Cancer Care: Isn’t it Time to Bring about a Change in Cancer Palliation? J Palliat Care Med 4:e128. doi:10.4172/2165-7386.1000e128
Copyright: © 2014 Silbermann M. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Palliative Care & Medicine
For most cancer patients in the Middle East, “palliative” is a vague term, a medical approach they have hardly heard of let alone understand. The focus of palliative care is to prevent patients from suffering with the aim to provide relief. It’s about providing the best possible quality of life by minimizing the burden of a chronic, life-threatening disease . It is, therefore, important to correct the misunderstanding of the role of palliative care in treating cancer patients. To date, regrettably, many still view palliative care as “giving up”. Yet, by complying with the patient’s desire for self-dignity, we fulfill his/her basic human and constitutional right .
Unfortunately, we still face barriers to the effective integration of palliative care in cancer care, including gaps in education and research and a cultural stigma that equates palliative care with end-of-life care. It is our obligation, therefore, to address these obstacles in order to achieve the seamless integration of palliative care across the continuum of cancer care for all patients and their families . Let’s remember that for most cancer patients, one of the most noticeable benefits of palliative care (which is also called supportive care) is the relief of physical pain, since if patients feel better physically, they are able to continue with their cancer treatment .
In the past two years, the Tawam Hospital in Al-Ain, Abu Dhabi, in the United Arab Emirates, in affiliation with Johns Hopkins Medicine, initiated, sponsored and supported annual conferences (the International Emirates Oncology Conference) to improve physician and nursing training in cancer care generally and palliative care in particular. This year’s conference, held at the Emirates Palace in Abu Dhabi on November 14-16, 2013, dedicated an entire session to pain assessment, as well as management and the use of opioids for cancer patients.
To date, most Middle Eastern countries are categorized as low- or middle-income countries suffering from limited treatment options for most cancers, while patients present late with advanced malignancies . For the most part, these patients suffer from moderate to severe pain, which, if unrelieved, may escalate suffering and functional impairment, and affect sleep and appetite, leading to emotional distress. Due to the reality that there are relatively few oncologists and palliative care specialists in many of the Middle Eastern countries, many cancer patients are treated by health professionals lacking the essential skills for pain management, as there was no provision for palliative care in their training. Several international declarations (Korean , Cape Town ) have stated that pain-relieving drugs should to be available and accessible at all levels, including the community. Regretfully, however, this is not the case in most Middle Eastern countries.
Opioids are key in the management of severe pain, with morphine consumption a proxy measure of the degree of pain control. In order to further elucidate the current situation as related to the availability and accessibility of opioids for the management of cancer pain, the European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO) partnered with the European Association for Palliative Care (EAPC) in launching a global survey: The Global Opioid Policy Initiative (GOPI) project. Its aims included evaluating the formulary availability and cost to the consumer of the seven opioid formulations deemed essential by the WHO and the International Association for Hospice and Palliative Care (IAHPC). In addition, the study aimed to evaluate the actual barriers that impede accessibility . The Middle East Cancer Consortium (MECC), which was invited to join this project as a collaborating partner organization, succeeded in bringing in 16 out of 24 Middle Eastern countries (representing 76% of the target countries) to actively participate in this project. On a population basis, the current Middle Eastern dataset is relevant to 329 million of the region’s 403 million people, representing 82% of the target population.
It became apparent that by and large the Middle East still has very low medical opioid consumption [10,11] (Figure 1). In contrast to the global consumption of opioids, which has increased significantly during the last 30 years, there has been very little increase in the Middle East (Figure 2).
The GOPI study is the first comprehensive study of opioid availability and the accessibility of opioid in the Middle East .
The main findings in this survey are as follows:
Formulary Availability and Cost of Opioids for Cancer Pain
Saudi Arabia, Israel and Qatar had all seven essential opioid formulations available: codeine; immediate-release per os morphine (tablet or liquid); controlled-release per os morphine; injectable morphine; oxycodone per os immediate release; fentanyl transdermal; and methadone per os immediate release. In the majority of countries (11 of 16), the cost of these medications was free, or <25% of the drug cost was charged to the patient.
Almost all countries have considerable restrictions on the accessibility of opioid analgesics.
Requirement for Permission/Registration of Patients to Render them Eligible to Receive an Opioid Prescription
Turkey, Morocco and Israel had no restriction on the eligibility of a patient to receive a prescription for opioid analgesics. In all other countries, patients required a permit or needed to be registered to receive opioids even in an inpatient setting.
Requirement for Physicians and Other Clinicians to Receive Special Authority/a License to Prescribe Opioids
In Morocco, Afghanistan and Israel, all physicians were permitted to prescribe opioids. In most other countries, special authorization was required for both surgeons and family doctors.
Eight countries allow physicians to prescribe an amount of opioid analgesics to a patient for more than 2 weeks.
Morocco and Afghanistan reported opioids as being available from any pharmacy, and that they were usually available. Most other countries reported that opioids were available only in hospital pharmacies.
Provision for Opioid Prescribtion in Emergency Situations
Only in Afghanistan were pharmacies allowed to prescribe in emergency situations. Few countries allowed for telephone or faxed prescriptions or nurse-generated prescriptions.
Eight countries had negative language in drug laws: Afghanistan, Iraq, Israel, Lebanon, Morocco, Palestine, Syria and Turkey.
Cancer continues to be a growing problem throughout the world, with a substantial increase in cancer incidence in developing countries (predicted at 70% by the year 2020). Significantly, inadequate treatment of acute and chronic pain is an enormous problem the world over, but especially in resource-poor countries: 80% of the world population lacks adequate access to pain treatment [13-17], especially as most cancer patients in the Middle East present with advanced disease [18,19]. The issue of very low opioid consumption in Middle Eastern countries is well known [20-24], with all surveyed countries, except Israel, indicating <10% of the anticipated Adequacy of Consumption Measure (ACM) for opioids (Table 1).
|S-DDD||%ACM 2006||S-DDD||%ACM 2010|
Note: %ACM, percentage of Adequacy of Consumption Measure; S-DDD, defined daily dose per million persons per day. Published by permission of the publisher: Oxford University Press.
Table 1: Comparison of DDD and %ACM [12-14] aCountries that did not respond to GOPI survey.
One of the important lessons to be learned from this study is that education in palliative care is paramount in ensuring a change in culture and practice. Addressing the barrier of health professionals’ lack of knowledge and skill in pain management is crucial and timely, as is advocacy of the need for palliative care practices , since inadequate training of health care workers in the use of opioids contributes to the absence of badly needed advocacy for the availability of these drugs. In a survey of final- year medical students in Saudi Arabia, half of the respondents considered cancer pain as untreatable, 40% considered it a minor problem, and almost 60% considered the risk of substance developing syndrome to be high even with a legitimate opioid prescription . In a survey of 122 physicians in six university hospitals in Teheran, inadequate education and training in this aspect of care was highlighted as a significant barrier to pain management . The problem of lack of training is critical among non-oncology specialists in hospitals, and more specifically in the community. Almost 70% of oncologists at the National Center for Cancer Care and Research in Qatar reported an awareness of guidelines for pain relief, but only 60% indicated that they applied them in their practice .
In a recent letter to the editor of the Journal of Clinical Oncology, Charalambous H and Silbermann M called for all oncology trainees, as well as oncology specialists, to obtain palliative care training , as did Jazieh in Saudi Arabia . At the same time, the public at large should be informed and educated, as most patients and their families are concerned about the use of opioids for the management of cancer pain [14,30,31].
The palliative care session in this year’s Emirates Oncology Conference served as an additional link in the chain of ongoing educational activities in the region, whereby Tawam Hospital together with international and national organizations – i.e., the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO), the Oncology Nursing Society (ONS), the National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN), the Arab Medical Association Against Cancer (AMAAC), Euro-Arab School of Oncology (EASO), Breast- Gynecological International Cancer Society (BGICS), and the Middle East Cancer Consortium (MECC) together with the United Arab Emirates University (UAEU) and the Abu Dhabi Health Services (SEHA) – have taken steps to improve physicians’ and nurses’ training in cancer pain control through the use of opioids. The data and findings of the recent ESMO & EAPC survey served as an important basis for fruitful discussions for future training programs in the region. Such collaboration between a regional referring hospital and education -oriented organizations will eventually make better use of existing resources and promote a better future for cancer patients, their families and the caregivers themselves. The ultimate goal would be to create a nucleus of local advocates who will further disseminate knowledge and firsthand experience associated with care generally and pain management in particular.
Further, we hope that such a collaborative effort will produce tailormade recommendations for individual countries in the region through local governments, health care professionals, other key decisionmaking bodies, and the general public. Such efforts will eventually pay dividends via advocacy, education and regulatory reforms. We must bear in mind that although such progress is incremental, it is real, embedding the potential for practical regulatory and clinical changes through concerted and sustained efforts.
The WHO Secretariat has been requested by member states to submit a resolution to the 2014 World Health Assembly laying out the importance of palliative care and appropriate access to opioids in public health. We hope that the recent findings regionally and globally in this area will strengthen such a resolution, setting out a road map for the international community to improve availability and access to better cancer care services . While each country in our region will be responsible for improving cancer care services for its residents, there is a growing potential for the impact of global and regional organizations, which can provide powerful support for advocacy with national regulatory authorities.
In the past, it has often been easier for individual associations, societies and NGOs to work independently within their country. Yet, a collaborative and coordinated approach, which we hope will emanate from the Emirates Oncology Conferences, harnessing the expertise of professional leaders across the field of cancer care, can create a united voice and reach the tipping point for real change and sustained impact . We believe that through the collaboration and efforts of the leading oncology services and organizations in the region who participate in the EOCs, several regulatory issues related to pain control can be overcome.
Make the best use of Scientific Research and information from our 700 + peer reviewed, Open Access Journals