Effect of Low Cost Locally Available Ingredients on the Growth Performance of Juveniles Freshwater Prawn Machrobrachium Rosenbergii in the Laboratory

Azam K^* and Koroi T

School of Marine Studies, Faculty of Science, Technology & Environment, The University of the South Pacific, Suva, Fiji

*Corresponding Author:

Azam K
School of Marine Studies
Faculty of Science
Technology & Environment
The University of the South Pacific
Suva, Fiji
E-mail: azam_k@usp.ac.fj

Received Date: July 01, 2013; Accepted Date: July 26, 2013; Published Date: August 01, 2013

Citation: Azam K, Koroi T (2013) Effect of Low Cost Locally Available Ingredients on the Growth Performance of Juveniles Freshwater Prawn Machrobrachium Rosenbergii in the Laboratory. J Fisheries Livest Prod 1:107. doi:10.4172/2332-2608.1000107

Copyright: © 2013 Azam K, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Visit for more related articles at Journal of Fisheries & Livestock Production

Abstract

Fiji has a strong demand for shrimp but farmers have hard time meeting the demand due to inadequate knowledge of local ingredients. A nutritional study was conducted to evaluate the growth performances of juveniles of the freshwater prawn species Macrobrachium rosenbergii. The prawns were fed with low cost formulated diets using locally available ingredients. Two experiments were conducted with six different diets in each of the experiment. In Experiment 1, diets were mainly based on carbohydrate ingredients ( fish meal+wheat, Fish meal+meat bone meal+wheat, Fish bone meal+fish meal+wheat, Meat bone meal+wheat, Meat fish meal+fish meal+wheat and Meat fish meal+wheat). While diets for Experiment 2 were based protein ingredients ( Fish meal+wheat, Fish meal+meat meal, Fish meal+meat meal+crest tilapia pellet, Fish meal+meat meal+copra meal, Fish meal+wheat+pea meal and Crest tilapia pellet). Each experiment (6 diets x 3 replicates) was carried out in the laboratory. Juveniles were fed twice a day for a period of three and four weeks in Experiment 1 and 2 respectively. Results indicated no significant (P>0.05) differences in water quality parameters. All nitrate, nitrite and ammonia concentrations were less than 0.2 mg/L. Fat and crude fiber contents were lowest and highest respectively in crest pellet tilapia (4.60% and 17.98%). Experiment 1 showed slight variations in growth performance. In Experiment 2, crest tilapia pellets indicated better result in weight gain (7.04 ± 2.96 mm), carapace, abdomen and body length (4.74 ± 1.94, 5.57 ± 0.62 and 5.57 ± 0.62), specific growth rate ( 2.38 ± 0.53) and feed intake (1.31 ± 1.19).However, no significant differences (P ≥ 0.05) were observed in either of the experiments. The costs of making each feed was almost same (0.53–0.58 Aus $/Kg). The findings indicate that the ingredient inclusion level for local ingredients available in Fiji could be quite flexible and used successfully for the growth of fresh water prawn juveniles (M .rosenbergii).

Keywords

Local diets; Juveniles prawn; Growth performance; Fiji

Introduction

Nutrient requirement and feed utilization can be estimated from intake (utilization) measurements, palatability and digestibility Gonzales [1]. An ingredient inclusion trial is probably the simplest way to examine effects on feed intake [1]. An ingredient can be incorporated into a reference diet to create a test diet. Significant differences in feed intakes between the reference diet and test diets indicate the clear palatability of the test ingredients Glencross [2].

In Fiji, there is a huge concern about the farmed M. rosenbergii usually maturing very early (3-5 months) from the PL stage and diets have been identified as one of the reasons for this common problem. Increasing costs have resulted in the increase in price of feed. Currently, a 25 kg bag of prawns and tilapia feed, sold at Crest Feed Mill costs FJ$ 40.20 and FJ$ 31.32 respectively. Pacific Feeds Ltd is also a producer of tilapia and prawn pellets selling at FJ$ 25.00 and FJ$ 37.00 respectively. As part of the Fiji Islands Freshwater Aquaculture Sector Plan 2005-2010, the Government has recognized the potential in freshwater prawn farming in Fiji, and thus has emphasized its development and production expansion in the coming years. In view of this initiative, a study was undertaken to evaluate feed intakes of M. rosenbergii for six diet formulations that all utilized local ingredients.

Materials and Methods

Experimental set up

The experimental system was conducted at the Sea Water Wet Laboratory of the University of the South Pacific (USP) between September and December, 2010. Eighteen 100 L aquaria (58.5 x 38.5 x 44.5 cm) were connected to a temperature controlled recirculation system. All of the aquaria were kept on wooden benches to assist better observation and accessibility. Water was supplied from a 300 L sump tank with a constant water flow rate (0.3 L/min) into each aquarium. Water was circulated through a common biological filter system.

The water parameters were checked daily and maintained within the following limits:

Temperature 29.0 ± 0.5°C, pH 6.5-7.5, DO>6.0 mg/L, ammonia<0.2 mg/L, nitrate<1.0 mg/L and nitrite<0.1 mg/L. A natural photoperiod of 12 h light and 12 h darkness was maintained throughout the experimental period.

Local ingredients

The local ingredients available in Fiji including their costs and sources are shown in Table 1. The feed ingredients were purchased in 35 kg bags and stored in the freezer at the Wet-lab. Feed stuff was analyzed at the QDPI laboratory in Brisbane, Australia. Not all of the ingredients were used in the formulations, as some were not available in supply at the time of the experiment and obtaining those ingredients were not economical due to shipment expenditures.

Table 1: Raw ingredients and suppliers in Fiji.

Formulation and feed preparation

Six experimental diets were formulated to be isoenergetic, isoproteic and isolipidic. Diets for both experiments were prepared at the Physicochemical Laboratory facilities at the School of Marine Studies (USP). Before weighing out the quantities required, all of the dry ingredients (except the Premix) were sieved on 1.0 & 0.5 mm diameter mesh dies to remove any irregular sizes of impurities, such as small pieces of scales, hairs, grains, husk and large fragments. The dry ingredients were weighed out as per formulae (Tables 2 and 3), mixed manually and fish oil was added until a homogeneous mixture was obtained.

Table 2: Formulation (%) of the diets based on different inclusion levels (fish meal, meat bone meal and meat fish meal) tested on M. rosenbergii juveniles (Experiment 1).

Table 3: Formulation (%) of the diets based on different inclusion levels (wheat, mill mix, copra meal, and pea meal) tested on M. rosenbergii juveniles (Experiment 2).

Water was sufficiently added in order to get a wet enough consistency to obtain dough. The mixture was then pressed through an electrical meat mincer which had die pellets of 2 mm diameter. The pellets were then dried in an electrical oven at 50°C for 24 h. The resulting pellets were then stored in labeled polyethylene plastic bags at a temperature of -10°C.

The same above procedure was done for the preparation of Experiment 2 diets. However, fish oil was not used in the second experiment in order to keep lipid levels homogenous. A few ingredients in Experiment 2, like pea meal and wheat, had to be finely grinded using an electric blender due to the coarse nature of the ingredients. The commercial tilapia pellet of Experiment 2 was obtained from Crest Feed Mill in pellet form and used as a reference diet, because it is widely used by Fijian farmers (Table 4).

Table 4: Formulation of Crest Tilapia Pellet (Experiment 2).

Every ingredient and experimental diet was analyzed at the Queensland Department of Primary Industry in Brisbane (Australia). The proximate compositions of ingredients and the formulated diets were analyzed according to AOAC (2005) procedures. Nitrogenfree extract was determined on a dry weight basis by subtracting the percentage of crude protein, lipids, fibre and ash from 100 %. Gross energy content was determined by using a bomb calorimeter.

Stocking in Aquaria

For Experiment 1, 250 M. rosenbergii juveniles were obtained from Dairy Farm Fiji Ltd., located in Navua. Juveniles were acclimated for 10 days. Mean total body weights and lengths were recorded with an initial weight of 3.45 ± 0.99 g using an analytical balance (A&D®, model EK 600H) and a length of 50.27 ± 1.34 mm using an electronic digital caliper (Lufkin®). The stocking density for Experiment 1 was 10 juvenile prawns for 18 aquaria (3 replicates x 6 treatments-diets). For Experiment 2, juveniles were obtained from NRS and the stocking density was lower at 8 juvenile prawns for each of 18 aquaria (3 replicates x 6 treatmentsdiets, initial weight 6.85 ± 0.65 g and length 64.33 ± 1.15 mm). Pieces of hollow PVC were placed in each aquarium as hide outs for prawns to reduce stress.

Feeding and data collection

Prawns were fed twice a day (8:00 am and 4:00 pm) for a period of three weeks in Experiment 1 and four weeks in Experiment 2. At each feeding, prawns were given one hour to consume their feed ration after which uneaten feed was removed by siphoning from each aquarium using a filtration apparatus. Water replacement was made by pumping water from a reserve tank to fill up the loss due to evaporation and to account for water loss during the daily siphoning of uneaten feed. This daily collection of uneaten feed was filtered onto a filter paper on which was then rolled into a foil and stored in the fridge until drying and re-weighing the next day. The difference in weight was interpreted as feed consumed. The water parameters such as temperature, dissolved oxygen (YSI® model 85) and pH (YSI® model pH 100) were measured daily. After each experiment, the animals were re-weighed and had their lengths measured. The ammonia, nitrate and nitrite concentrations were measured using a freshwater quality test kit.

Calculations

Weight gain (WG), total body length gain (BLG), specific growth rate (SGR; % per day) feed conversion ratio (FCR), protein energy ratio (PER) and survival (%) were all calculated as follows:

WG = Final body weight (g)-Initial body weight (g)

BLG = Final body length (g) - Initial body length (g)

SGR = (In FBW-In IBW) / t x 100; where FBW is final body weight; IBW is initial body weight;

In = natural logarithmic; t = time in days

FCR = Feed intake (g) / weight gain (g)

PER = live weight gain (g) / protein intake (g)

S (%) = (final number of prawns-initial number of prawns) x 100

Means and standard deviations were calculated and expressed as mean ± SD.

4.7. Production costs

The production costs were calculated as follows:

Initial Biomass = 0.08 g x initial number of prawns

Final Biomass = final weight (g) of prawns x final number of prawns

Product (g) = final biomass (g)-initial biomass (g)

Cost of feed (FJ$) = total feed (kg) x cost of diet (FJ$)

Cost of feed (AU$) = total feed (kg) x cost of diet (AU$)

Cost to produce 1kg prawn = FCR x cost of diet (FJ$)

Statistical analysis

The data obtained was statistically analyzed by performing analysis of variance (ANOVA). The effect of different diets on FBW, WG, SGR, FCR, PER and S (%) were carried out using one way ANOVA. Water parameters were also analyzed using one way ANOVA.

Results and Discussion

Experiment 1

Proximate analyses: The proximate analyses of the experimental ingredients are shown in Table 5. The crude proteins ranged from 13.91% to 57.69% (dry weight) with meat fish meal showing the highest crude protein content and wheat showing the lowest. The crude fat ranged from 4.40% to 26.50% with meat fish meal showing the highest crude fat content and wheat showing the lowest. The gross energy ranged from 19.12MJ/kg to 23.94 MJ/kg with meat bone meal showing the highest gross energy and wheat showing the lowest.

Table 5: Proximate composition of experimental ingredients (Winfeed Stochastic Formulation % DM basis) (Experiment 1).

The proximate analyses of the experimental diets are shown in Table 6. The crude protein content was 30 % and the crude fat content was 10% for all the diets. The crude fibre ranged from 6.16% to 7.81%; with MFM2 showing higher levels and MBM3 showing the lowest. The gross energy ranged from 19.09 Mj/kg to 19.59 MJ/kg with MBM3 showing highest t and MFM2 showing the lowest gross energy content.

Table 6: Proximate composition of experimental diets (Winfeed Stochastic Formulation % DM basis) (Experiment 1).

Growth performance, survival rate and feed intake: There was no difference (P ≥ 0.05) with regard to animal performance. Weight gain ranged from 0.55 ± 0.43 to 1.27 ± 0.48 g. In terms of value, highest weight gain was achieved by prawns fed with control diet. Total body length gain ranged from 7.06 mm ± 1.18 mm to 10.30 mm ± 2.03 mm (the highest value was observed for MFM1diet). Survival ranged from 63.33% ± 3.33 to 86.66 ± 13.33 % with highest value of survival seen in prawns fed with MBM3 diet. The feed intake, among all treatments, presented no significant differences (P ≥ 0.05).

Generally, the protein quality of dietary ingredients affects growth performance. Protein quality of dietary protein sources depends on the amino acid compositions and their digestibility. Deficiency of an essential amino acid leads to poor utilization of the dietary protein and thus reduces growth and decreases feed efficiency Hardy [3]. Hossain [4] found out that PL’s of M. rosenbergii raised in a recirculation system for 60 days and fed a commercial shrimp nursery diet (30 %) achieved survival rate of 76 % and SGR of 3.28 %/day. The use of different protein sources in various combinations has been found to be more effective than that of a single source in the substitution of fishmeal in feeds because it prevents the high inclusion level of any single anti-nutrient in the diet Hossain [5]. Yang [6] on Macrobrachium nipponense and Zhu [7] on Liptopenaeus vannamei juveniles reported no significant differences in growth with diets having varying inclusion levels (0-60%) of two protein sources e.g. fish and meat-bone meal. Growth rate was negatively affected by meat-bone meal when the fish meal replacement levels were above 14% and 17% respectively in M. rosenbergii and red drum fish [8-9]. Similarly, Forster [10] reported that replacement of fish meals by meat-bone meals above 25% reduced the growth performance of Liptopenaeus vannamei.

The specific growth rate (SGR) for prawns with different treatments ranged from 0.81 ± 0.36 to 1.45 ± 0.08%/day. Hari [11] obtained the highest SGR (3.72 %/ day) of M. rosenbergii with diets containing 30% protein and varying amounts of trash fishmeal and groundnut oilcake (Table 7).

Table 7: Mean growth performance, survival and feed intake of M. rosenbergii fed six different diets of varying inclusion levels of meat bone meal and meat fish meal for 21 d (n = 10). Values (Mean ± SE) (Experiment 1).

Water quality parameters: There were no significant (P ≥ 0.05) differences in temperature and D.O among treatments in Experiment 1. The water temperature ranged from 27.80 ± 0.09°C to 28.07± 0.03°C, D.O from 7.14 ± 0.04 to 7.24 ± 0.01 mg/L and pH from 7.4 to 7.5. All nitrate, nitrite and ammonia levels were <0.2 mg/L (Table 8). M. rosenbergii can tolerate a wide range of temperature (14- 35°C) and a wide range of salinity levels (0-25 ppt). For growth, the optimal temperature is 29-31°C, the optimal pH is 7.0-8.5, and the optimal salinity is 0-10 ppt New [12]. The effects of pH, temperature and salinity on the oxygen consumption and nitrogen excretion on M. rosenbergii have been studied by Nelson [13] and Chen [14]. Enterococcus infection in M. rosenbergii is exacerbated by high pH (8.8-9.5) and high temperature (33-34º C), but reduced by low salinity (5-10ppt) Cheng [15].

Table 8: Average water temperature and dissolved oxygen different diets for 21 d (Experiment 1).

Experiment 2

Proximate analysis: The proximate analyses of the experimental ingredients are shown in Table 9. The crude protein and crude fat ranged from 16.47% to 23.19 % (dry weight) and 4.10% to 13.20% respectively. Highest and lowest crude protein was observed in Copra meal and wheat while highest and lowest crude fat was found in copra meal and mill mix. The gross energy ranged from 18.52 MJ/kg to 19.95 MJ/kg with copra meal showing the highest gross energy and wheat showing the lowest.

Table 9: Proximate composition of ingredients (Winfeed Stochastic Formulation % DM basis. (Experiment 2).

The proximate analyses of the experimental diets are shown in Table 10. The crude protein and fat content was 30% and 10% for all of the diets. The crude fibre ranged from 3.49% to 17.98% with Crest Tilapia Pellet (CTP) and Copra (CP) showing the highest and lowest amount. The gross energy ranged from 17.13 MJ/kg to 18.30 MJ/kg. CTP indicated highest gross energy while CP content showed the lowest gross energy.

Table 10: Proximate composition of experimental diets (Winfeed Stochastic Formulation % DM basis (Experiment 2).

Growth performance, survival rate and feed intake: There were no significant differences (P ≥ 0.05) with regards to growth performance, survival rate and feed intake among the treatments. Weight gain ranged from 2.16 ± 0.54 g to 7.04 ± 2.96 g. Total body length increased between 3.04 ± 1.21 mm to 10.25 ± 2.47 mm. Survival rate ranged from 54.16 ± 18.16% to 79.16 ± 8.33 %. Increasing carbohydrate in the diet enhanced growth rate to a point. This is attributed to the protein sparing effect of carbohydrate in which the higher levels of carbohydrate in the diet provided more energy for metabolic activities of the animal, while sparing more protein for growth. The protein sparing effect of carbohydrate in diets occurs at 30% in Penaeus aztecus Andrews [16]. Sick and Andrews [17] found that 40% corn starch in casein-based diets produced faster growth in P.duorarum. Furthermore, at lower protein levels, energy may be partly derived from protein, thus accounting for lower growth rate even if protein and lip

The feed intake (Table 11) among all treatments did not show significant differences (p ≥ 0.05). Although, in terms of value, higher feed intake was seen for prawns fed with CP diet. The specific growth rate (SGR) for prawns in the different treatments ranged from 1.09 ± 0.03% to 2.38 ± 0.53 %/day.

Table 11: Mean growth performance, survival and feed intake of M. rosenbergii fed four different diets of copra meal, mill mix and pea meal for 28 d.

Water quality parameters: In Experiment 2, all water parameters showed no significant differences (P ≥ 0.05) for temperature and dissolved oxygen among the treatments. The water temperature ranged from 27.88 ± 0.04°C to 27.99 ± 0.03°C; D.O. from 7.15 ± 0.03 mg/L to 7.22 ± 0.01 mg/L and pH from 7.3 to 7.5. All nitrate, nitrite and ammonia levels were <0.2 mg/L (Table 12).

Table 12: Average temperature and dissolved oxygen for the M. rosenbergii fed six diets for 28 d (Experiment 2).

Therefore, the findings of these two experiments indicated that the ingredient inclusion level for selected local ingredients available in Fiji showed no significant differences in the intake levels for the two batches of selected local ingredients. The omnivore nature of freshwater prawns permits the use of a wide variety of locally available ingredients including commercial by-products, as ingredients in formulated feeds. This suggests that inclusion levels for formulation of diets for freshwater prawn M .rosenbergii could be quite flexible.

Conclusions and Recommendations

The present commercially available feeds are inconsistent in supply and costly for farmers to purchase. The idea was to produce a diet using locally available ingredients which could be easily prepared by farmers as “on farm- feeds” and in the future, suggested to commercial feed companies to produce and supply. Locally available ingredients were identified as fish meal, meat bone meal, meat fish meal, copra meal, wheat, mill mix, rice meal and pea meal. The assessment of selected ingredients locally available in Fiji showed that the inclusion of feed ingredients for the formulation of diets for the giant freshwater prawn is flexible. Commercially, the use of ingredients in formulated feed should be cost-effective and should be available in large quantities in areas where culture operations occur. It is not always necessary that the best diet will be the cheapest one. However, it will produce better growth and lower FCR values which will be more economical in the long- term. A limited number of ingredients are used in the formulation of feeds in aquaculture in Fiji. When formulating a diet for freshwater prawns, it is recommended that ingredients be chosen based on nutritional value taking into account the potential anti-nutritional factors, rather than on the basis of cost per unit alone. There is also the need to further train farmers on how to formulate and produce nutritionally balanced feeds. In addition, Government should subsidize the cost of locally fabricated machines to make them affordable to farmers.

References

1. Gonzalez C, Allan G (2007) Preparing Farm- Made Fish Feed, New South Wales, Department of Primary Industries, Australia.
2. Glencross BD, Booth M, Allan G (2007) A Feed is only as good as its ingredients: A review ofingredient evaluation strategies for Aquaculture Feeds. Aquaculture. Nutrition 13: 17–24.
3. Halver JE, Hardy RW (2002) Fish nutrition (3rd Edn.). Academic Press, New York.
4. Hossain MA, Islam SF (2007) Meat and bone meal as partial substitute for fishmeal in nursery diet for giant freshwater prawn, Macrobrachium rosenbergii (de Man). J World Aqua Soc 38: 272-280.
5. Hossain MA, Jauncey K (1990) Substitution of fishmeal by oilseed meals in various combinations in the diet of common carp (Cyprinus carpio). Malaysian Applied Biology 9: 1-12.
6. Yang Y, Xie S, Lei W, Zhu X (2004) Effect of replacement of fish meal by meat and bone meal and poultry by-product meal in diets on the growth and immune response of Macrobrachium nipponense. Fish Shellfish Immunol 17: 105-114.
7. Zhu YZ, Yang GH (1995) Preliminary studies on suitable dietary protein level and soybean meal as dietary protein source of the freshwater prawn Macrobrachium rosenbergii. Fish Sci Tech Info 22: 125-128.
8. Hossain MA, Siddique MA, Miaje MA (2000) Development of low cost feed for culture of giant freshwater prawn (Macrobrachium rosenbergii de Man) in ponds. Bangladesh J Fish Res 4: 127 – 134.
9. Kaushik SJ (2000)Feed formulation, diet development and feed technology, CIHEAM-IAMZ, Options Méditerranéennes 47: 43–51.
10. Forster LP, Dominy W, Obaldo L, Tacon AG (2003) Rendered meat and bone meals as ingredients of diets for shrimp Litopenaseus vanamei (Boone, 1931). Aquaculture 219: 655-670.
11. Hari B, Kurup BM (2003) Vitamin C ascorbyl 2 polyphosphate requirement of freshwater prawn Macrobrachium rosenbergii (de Man). Asian Fisheries Science15: 145–54.
12. New MB (1995) Status of freshwater prawn farming; a review. Aqua Res26: 1-54.
13. Nelson SG, Armstrong DA, Knight AW, Li HW (1977) The effect of temperature on salinity on the metabolic rate of juvenile Macrobrachium rosenbergii (Crustacea: Palaemonidae). Comp Biochem Physiol 56: 533-537.
14. Chen JC, Kuo TT (1996) Effects of temperature on oxygen consumption and nitrogenous excretion of juvenile Macrobrachium rosenbergii. Aquaculture 145: 295-303.
15. Cheng W, Chen JC (1998) Enterococcus-like infection in Macrobrachium rosenbergii are exacerbated by high pH and temperature but reduced by low salinity. Dis aquat organ 34: 103-108.
16. Andrews JW, Sick V, Baptist GJ (1972) The influence of dietary protein and energy levels on growth and survival of penaeid shrimp. Aquaculture1: 341-347.
17. Sick LV, Andrews JW (1973) The effect of selected dietary lipids, carbohydrates and proteins on the growth, survival and body composition of Penaeus duorarum. World Mariculture. Society 4: 263 – 276.

--